I
Leona Dewulf climbed the hill for the fourth time on a Tuesday in March, in wet stockings, with a bag of pears she had no intention of eating.
The old mortuary stood where the road gave up and became a path. Verlegem had stopped bringing its dead there years ago; now they went to the city in white vans with tinted windows. The building had stayed behind: yellow brick, a chimney nobody lit, and above the door a sign that had lost two of its letters and now read C APEL OF EST.
He opened the door before she could knock. He always did. She had never got used to the size of him in the doorway, or the way he had to stand half turned, one shoulder hitched up almost to his ear.
"You've been told no," he said.
"Three times." She held up the bag. "I brought pears."
He let her in, because it was raining, and because he had let her in before. Inside it smelled of chalk and old formalin and the paraffin heater ticking beside the steel table. A wall of cold-room drawers faced her. On each one, someone had written a name in chalk. She had asked about them on her second visit. He had said they were nobody's, and wiped one clean with his sleeve before she could read it.
She sat on the table without being asked. The steel was cold through her coat.
"I set two cups," she said. "Every morning. Two years now. I put out two cups, and then I stand there, and then I put one back." She smoothed the bag of pears flat on her knee. "I haven't slept a full night since she was born. First because she might wake up. Then because she might not come home. Now because she won't. I'm seventy-eight. I'd like to sleep before I die."
"You'll want her back," he said. "They always tell me they won't."
"Then I'll want her back." Her chin came up. "At least I'll be rested."
For a while there was only the heater, ticking.
Then he took off his gloves. His hands surprised her, as they had the other times: long and careful and clean, the only part of him that looked like it belonged to an ordinary man. He held her face between them, lightly, the way you feel a child's forehead for fever.
She smelled lime-blossom soap, which was strange, because she had never bought it. She heard a girl shout Mam, look! and saw a bicycle flying down the dike road, two thin arms thrown out wide, no hands on the handlebars. She wanted to tell the girl to hold on.
Then the picture went thin, like breath fading off a window, and there was nothing to hold.
When she had gone, forgetting her pears on the table, he tried to sit down in his chair and found that he couldn't bend that far anymore. He lowered himself to the tiled floor instead, one joint at a time, and lay on his side with his cheek against the cold.
Close to his ear, a girl shouted Mam, look!
He closed his eyes and listened to her until morning.
In her house by the canal, Leona woke at nine with sunlight across the quilt. She went downstairs and set out one cup and didn't think about it. Later she opened the door to the back bedroom, looked at the posters on the wall and the bicycle pump on the windowsill, and couldn't think whose they were. It would make a good sewing room, she decided. The light was nice in there.
II
In Verlegem they called him the Collector when they were being polite, and the monster when they weren't.
They said Fons Lambrecht went up the hill a grieving man and came down a stranger. At Easter his brother Staf came into the bakery, and Fons sold him a currant loaf and counted out his change and asked, pleasantly, whether he was visiting from out of town. Staf stood on the pavement afterwards with the loaf under his arm for a long time. Then he went home and didn't come back.
They said the widow Moens went up the week her husband died. At his funeral, while the priest was still talking, she laughed. It wasn't a cruel laugh. It was bright and surprised, and it went on a little too long. At the coffee afterwards she sat alone.
On the first Saturday of every month he came down for bread. Mothers pulled their children in by the hood. The men at the café table by the window stopped talking until the bell over the bakery door had rung twice, once for in and once for out. He paid with exact coins and never explained anything.
And still, at night, from his window, he could see small lights moving on the path below. A torch. A phone screen. Someone who had stopped halfway to argue with themselves, then kept on climbing.
III
Jolien Debaene came at the start of November, the week everyone came home for All Saints to put chrysanthemums on their family graves.
She left her car at the bottom of the hill with the lights off and walked up in good boots. He knew who she was. Everyone in Verlegem knew the notary's daughter, the one who had gone to the city and done well. She was twenty-eight and very calm.
She didn't sit on the table. She stood with her gloves on and looked at the drawers.
"I saw someone die," she said. "Two winters ago, on the dike road. A woman on a bike. It was icy. I can't stop seeing it."
He took off his gloves. Looking was allowed. He always looked before he agreed to carry anything; he needed to know how heavy it was. He reached out, and after a moment she pulled off her own gloves and let him.
Black ice, shining under the headlights. A yellow rain jacket. The sound, which was smaller than he had expected, like a sack of flour dropped on a step.
The car stopping. The engine still running. The wipers going.
Down in the ditch, in the wash of the headlights, the yellow jacket moved. An arm lifted, and fell back.
He saw her hand go to the phone on the passenger seat. He saw it rest there. He felt her think about the interview on Monday, and the drink at the party, and her father reading about it in the newspaper over his morning coffee, his face going still.
He watched the hand come back to the steering wheel.
He watched the car drive on.
He let go of her face.
"You didn't see it," he said. "You were driving."
She didn't cry. She pulled her gloves back on, finger by finger.
"I know what I did," she said. "I'm not asking you to make me forget it. If I forget, I'll do something stupid again." She looked at the drawers, not at him. "It's only that I drive the long way round now. Every time. Twenty extra minutes, so I don't have to go past that ditch. And if I see a yellow coat in the city, I have to pull over." She almost smiled. "I'm fine during the day. I just want you to take the part of me that minds."
IV
He told her to come back in the morning.
That night he didn't lie down. He stood in front of the drawers with a stub of chalk in his hand, reading the names. He wrote one for each memory he carried, so they wouldn't run together in the dark. Some had faded so much that only he could read them. He didn't need to read them. He knew where everyone was.
Here was the father who had been drunk on the riverbank while his son went under. He had taken that without asking whether any of it had been earned. That had always been his rule: only what was given freely, and never a question after.
Third row, near the floor, was the kitchen. A policeman with his cap in his hands. A cake on the counter with forty candles, unlit. Leona saying, But she only went to get eggs.
And under that, closer, the girl on the bicycle with her arms out, the way Leona had seen her a hundred times from the kitchen window. Griet. The gap between her front teeth. How she was afraid of geese. How she called every Sunday at six and let it ring twice and hung up, so her mother would call back and pay.
He had been carrying Leona's memory of her since March.
He had watched her lift her arm in the ditch that evening.
His back hurt. He had been tall once, before the hill. He remembered lying in a bed, and sleeping. Nothing faded in him the way it faded in other people. Leona had slept until nine. Griet was still shouting Mam, look! inside him, and would go on shouting it for as long as he lived.
He could go down the hill and knock on Leona's door. One sentence would do it.
But he would have to give back the grief she had climbed up four times to be rid of. And he would have to say aloud what Jolien had shown him only because she believed he never said anything aloud. After that, no light would come up the path again.
He stood there until the window went grey.
V
She came back at eight, with her coffee in a paper cup from the station.
He was already in the doorway.
"No," he said.
She waited. When nothing more came, she put the cup down on the step, carefully, as if it mattered where it stood.
"You took everyone else's," she said. Her voice stayed level, but her hands didn't. "Why not mine?"
He looked at her for a long time.
"I don't know," he said.
She stepped forward and took his wrist, hard, and pressed his bare hand to her cheek. "Take it."
He pulled back. She held on. When his hand finally came free, his nails had raked three thin red lines down her jaw.
They both looked at them.
Then she picked up her coffee and walked down the hill without looking back.
VI
By the afternoon she had shown the marks to her father, and her father had shown them to the café, and the café had shown them to the rest of Verlegem. By the time the bakery closed, the story was that he had dragged her inside and tried to take something from her by force.
They came up at dusk. Flashlights, mostly, and whatever the men had picked up in their sheds on the way out. Fons Lambrecht was there, in his flour-white apron, because someone had told him to come. The widow Moens was there. Leona Dewulf was there too, near the back, because her neighbour had taken her by the arm and she hadn't liked to say no.
He opened the door before they reached it.
He didn't say anything. When the first blow came, he went down onto his knees, slowly, and then further, onto his side on the wet gravel. Several people said afterwards that he looked almost relieved.
It took less time than anyone had expected.
When his heart stopped, everything he had been carrying went back to where it came from.
Fons dropped what he was holding and turned around and looked for his brother in the crowd, and when he couldn't find him he started calling his name down the hill. The widow Moens sat down in the mud with both hands over her mouth. All along the path people swayed and caught at each other, and every one of them knew at the same moment where their pain had been all these years, and whose back had bent under it.
At the back, Leona Dewulf heard a girl shout Mam, look! She said her daughter's name out loud, and her legs went out from under her.
Jolien Debaene was standing right beside her. Her own memory was still there. Not the version she had kept, the one worn smooth from two years of careful handling. Now she saw it the way he had seen it. The wipers going. The arm lifting in the yellow sleeve.
Leona, blind with crying, reached out for the nearest hand.
Jolien let her take it.
You must sign up or log in to submit a comment.
What a wonderful story!! At first, I thought it would be a dark fairy tale or ghost story, only to reveal itself as a much deeper exploration of grief!!
The Collector was a very fascinating character. In some sense, he is almost Christ-like, bearing the suffering of others and taking it upon himself. Sad he is treated like a monster by the village, yet he is arguably the most selfless person in it.
The ending works well! The moment everyone realizes where their pain had been all those years is both tragic and also heartbreaking. What stayed with me most, though, is the question the story raises about grief itself. If you remove the pain, you may also lose part of the love and connection behind it. That moral complexity lingered with me long after I finished reading.
Reply
I agree, Mr. Iz--for better or worse, grief and regret are part of what makes us, us.
Reply
This is strange. I’m trying to reply to Iz, but I keep ending up in the reply box under Richard’s comment. So this comment is for both of you:
Thank you! I appreciated the Christ-like connection you made. Between your reading and the other comparisons people have offered, I now have several figures I’d quite like to put around a table together. Though perhaps we should let the Collector sit down first.
Your question about losing some of the love along with the pain is the part I keep coming back to. I’d like to say I would always choose to keep the memories, whatever they cost, but that’s an easy answer when nobody is actually offering to take the suffering away. I honestly don’t know what I’d say at Leona’s door.
Thank you for giving this so much thought, and for telling me what lingered afterwards. It means a great deal to have you reading, Iz.
Reply
Sounds like there might be an interesting conversation around that table you mentioned.
Regarding replying to Iz but having it end up as a reply to me...this has happened before. A couple years ago I went through a time when I somehow became the black hole of comment replies on YouTube. Every time someone would reply to a comment about a video having to do with a Monty Python movie, I would get the reply. And every time I would try to reply to the reply, it came out as either "now leave, you filthy English k-nig-huts" or "leave or I will taunt you a second time." Really weird. Don't know why it started, don't know why it stopped, but I'm glad it did.
Perhaps I should seek professional help...
Reply
Professional help seems excessive, Ri’tchirdh. Have you tried turning the Holy Grail off and on again? 😂
Reply
I really enjoyed the vivid imagery and atmospheric details. Sensory details, such as the persistent sound and feel of rain or the flicker of the paraffin heater, evoked a sense of melancholy and isolation that perfectly matched the story’s emotional tone.
The Collector was a fascinating and memorable character, and his mysterious presence added a sense of folklore and myth. His role in offering relief from pain gave the story emotional depth and raised ethical questions. You explored the complexities of grief and the human desire to escape suffering beautifully.
The ending, in which the villagers confronted the Collector, was powerful and moving. This moment served as a powerful culmination of the story’s central themes. The confrontation was not just with the Collector but with the pain, grief, and memories the villagers had tried to forget. Excellent work—this was a great take on the prompt!
Reply
Thank you, Veronika, for taking so much time with this story. I really appreciated your attention to the rain and the paraffin heater. It’s lovely to hear which details stayed with you, especially the small sounds and sensations that might otherwise go unmentioned.
Your thought about the villagers confronting their own grief made me pause. I find it difficult to judge the wish to escape suffering. It’s easy to say that we ought to keep our memories, however painful, when we’re not the person who desperately needs a night’s sleep. I honestly don’t know how I would answer an offer like his.
I was also touched that you felt both the folklore and the humanity in the Collector. Readers have pictured him in quite different ways, and I’ve enjoyed hearing those impressions without wanting to settle on one definitive version.
Thank you for such a generous response, Veronika. You’ve given me plenty to think about, and I’m very glad the story meant something to you. 😊
Reply
You're welcome, Marjolein. I completely agree—it's so much easier to judge the wish to escape suffering from the outside than to experience it ourselves. I don't know what I would choose in that situation either. You truly did a wonderful job capturing the complexities of grief and the longing for relief from pain. Thank you for sharing such a moving story.
Reply
I think this is a strong story. What I like most is that you don't overexplain things. You let the little details do the work, like the pears, the two cups, and Leona deciding her daughter's room would make a nice sewing room. That part got me because she doesn't even realize what she's lost. I also like the Collector. The fact that he carries everyone else's pain makes the whole idea feel real. And the way you bring back “Mam, look!” throughout the story works well. It means something different each time. Jolien is the most interesting part for me. She's not asking to forget what she did. She just doesn't want to feel bad about it anymore. That makes her worse in a way, because she knows what happened and still wants to get rid of the guilt. The ending is perfect. Leona reaching for Jolien's hand, and Jolien letting her take it, is such a good place to stop. You don't explain whether it's guilt, compassion, or something else, and I think that's why it works. I think the writing is good. It feels quiet and unsettling without trying too hard to be either. I like that the Collector isn't doing something good, even when he's helping people. Taking away someone's grief also means taking away part of the person they loved. And Jolien shows how dangerous that same idea becomes when someone wants to stop feeling guilty for something they did.
Reply
Rebecca, what a lovely comment to receive. Thank you for taking the time to tell me so specifically what reached you. The sewing room getting to you, and your noticing the changing meaning of “Mam, look!” — those are things I was especially grateful to read.
Your distinction between wanting to forget and wanting to stop feeling guilty gave me pause. I can understand the wish for relief, which makes it uncomfortable to consider where my sympathy would run out. I suspect I’d find that boundary much harder to draw in front of a real person than from the safety of my reading chair.
I also appreciated your reservations about the Collector himself. You felt for him without giving him a free pass, and I’m glad you included that thought.
And thank you for being willing to leave that last hand-holding unresolved. I love being able to discuss a character’s motives with someone who has read closely and still has questions. You’ve given me a great deal to think about. I’m very grateful for comments ❤️
Reply
Thank you for such a quietly devastating and unforgettable read.
Reply
“Unforgettable”—one of the greatest compliments a writer could hope for. Thank you.
Reply
In my humble opinion, this story takes an awfully long time to arrive at its central conflict. We have Leona's visit, the Collector's suffering, the townspeople's reactions, several examples of previous visitors, and only then Jolien's arrival. It emphasizes the same point repeatedly: the Collector absorbs suffering, the townspeople fear him, and people continue seeking his services. Once we understand that premise, do we really need so many illustrations of it? And the memories never actually become real objects, as the prompt states.
Reply
It's great you took the time and trouble to comment. I think you're very clear about what you didn't like about the story.
That said, I respectfully disagree. Seems like your main point is that the story took too long to "get to the point". For me, a short story (or a novel) isn't about making a point quickly; it's about building emotional impact. From that perspective, I think the story is a great success.
Regarding the point about the "memories never actually become real objects", I think the Mercy Collector actually IS the real object the memories have become.
I hope you keep reading and commenting - it's always helpful, for me at least, to see other viewpoints, even if I don't agree.
Reply
Thank you for sharing your thoughts. I truly appreciate constructive feedback.
For me, a memory that can be transferred from one person to another, acquired, held, and physically carried becomes a tangible asset. That was my interpretation of the prompt.
The gradual build-up was intentional, though I understand it felt repetitive to you. Thank you for reading.
Reply
Marjolein, I read you a minimalist in storytelling. Your prose is always perfect: "wet stockings," "a bag of pears she had no intention of eating," "lime-blossom soap," and the sound of a crash being "smaller than he had expected, like a sack of flour dropped on a step." Your story is true to life-the burden of grief, moral guilt, and the unintended consequences of trying to escape human suffering -this is the realism in person. It makes me wonder how many people agree that painful memory is worth carrying if the alternative is losing a part of your humanity? I hesitate to refer to the "Mercy Collector" as a Christ-like figure. The ending is brilliant-so "bitter sweet" as the Collector dies, the townspeople are forced to pick up their own cross again. Thank you as always for a great read.
Reply
Thank you for such a generous, attentive reading. Knowing those particular details stayed with you means a great deal to me.
Your question is a difficult one. From a comfortable distance, I’d like to say the memories would always be worth keeping. Faced with someone offering relief after years of suffering, I might be rather less certain. I don’t think I could judge anyone for being tempted.
I’d be interested to hear more about your hesitation over the Christ-like comparison. Readers have made several different connections, and I’ve enjoyed considering each of them. Thank you, as always, for bringing so much thought to the conversation.
Reply
Marjolein, about the 'Christ-like comparison': any time the word "Christ" is mentioned, people think of the 'sins' they believe they own and look for miracles to overcome the hardships and the pain/suffering they feel on a day to day basis. The reality of it is that it is called "life" so why look for an easy solution like believing in Christ and miracles? You might as well believe in Superman, which-by the way-I think is easier/safer to think of than traditional religious beliefs. "So called Miracles" are actually the consequences of human interaction. People need to believe more in themselves because 'they' have the power to bring about "miracles."...Oh boy, I better stop here before I offend other people. You asked to hear more on the subject and this probably isn't what you expected. Anyway, I still think your story is excellent.
Reply
Thank you for explaining, Alex — I did ask, and I appreciate your candour! I understand your hesitation better now, particularly your emphasis on what people can do for one another. You certainly haven’t offended me; there’s room for different beliefs and readings here.
Thank you again for giving the story so much attention and for such a generous response. It’s been a pleasure exchanging thoughts with you.
Reply
The Mercy Collector. I read and understood. Memories can be painful.
You handled this with care. Well done.
Reply
Thank you for your comment Ron.
Reply
The collector reminds me of the tragic healer(*John) from The Green Mile. His abilities are feared, misinterpreted, and taken for granted in Verlegem as well. You have vividly depicted the variations in grieving and coping among each mourning villager. When they do see the mercy collector in town, they are reminded of the old hurt and not wanting anything to do with him...
Unprocessed suffering and regret make the best of us project reactively in ways that are destructive. Perhaps the collector knew that he could no longer take other people's grief without suffering catastrophically. Perhaps he knew what would happen to him? Heartbreaking. A tragic empath.
Thank you for sharing yet another human experience with us, Marjolein! I am inspired!
Reply
Thank you, Akihiro! “A tragic empath” — that will stay with me. I hadn’t thought of John from The Green Mile, but I can see the connection. I’m so pleased this inspired you, and grateful for such a thoughtful reading.
Reply
Jolien’s request is the most disturbing part for me: she wants to remember what she did without having to care. That makes the final hand-holding deeply uncomfortable. Leona has no idea whose hand she’s holding, and I’m still wondering what it means that Jolien lets her.
Reply
Thank you! I wonder about that too. She could pull her hand away, but she doesn’t. Whether she stays for Leona’s sake or her own is another question.
Reply
He's a living miracle, I think. And the townsfolk felt the traumas all over again after they murdered him. This is a profoundly told tale that I could see as a movie. Great work...
Reply
Thank you! A living miracle treated as a monster — that’s what makes his fate so painful. And now you’ve got me wondering who would play him. 😊
Reply
A Sin Eater, or Mary Shelly's pitiful monster? For me the genius in your writing is how adept you are at picking out the little things that make the situations and characters so real. In this story it was when Leona said, "But she only went to get eggs." Grief needs an anchor and for my money this was what held Leona firmly. -M
Reply
You’re faster than light, M — I’d barely posted this and you were already here! Love it!
A Sin Eater, or Mary Shelly's pitiful monster? Perhaps a little of both — though I suspect either would have preferred a different village.
I’m glad you picked out the eggs. Such an ordinary errand, and then she never comes home. I love your thought that grief needs an anchor.
Reply
I was deeply caught in this story. A figure doing such a great deed, apparently out of free will and even without a needed payback, and a village seeming to exploit this in a very interesting way. I doubted the decisions of the different characters throughout the story, but the collector was who really fascinated me. His life seems to only consists of supporting other people in their grief, but what about his own wishes, memories or just his own life? He was such a complex character, I would love to know more about him,
Also do I question the whole system of giving up grieving in the sense of forgetting. Erasing your daughter’s room and turning it into a sewing room, sitting alone at your husband’s funeral or not recognising a family member, all these behaviours seem even more sad than the grieving itself. Still, the only reason to remember is presented by Jolien as not to do a mistake again. Without the caring, when for all the other characters it is the caring that matters. So why care, why grieve? This is something I have to think about more. Thank you for this thought.-provoking story.
Reply
Thank you for such a thoughtful response. Your concern for the Collector’s own wishes and memories touched me. Almost everyone approaches him because of something they need, and here you are asking what he might want for himself. I’m glad he found that consideration in a reader.
I can understand finding the sewing room sadder than the grief. There’s something particularly painful about witnessing a loss that the person herself can no longer recognise.
Your “why care, why grieve?” is a question I don’t have a tidy answer to. We don’t choose grief, but being offered a choice about keeping it would be terribly difficult. I’d hesitate to tell someone in pain what they ought to preserve, however much I feared what they might lose.
I really appreciate you sharing the questions you’re left with, including your doubts about the characters’ decisions. You’ve given me plenty to think about too.
Reply
This was haunting before you even realize what’s going on. Beautifully written. This builds a complex mythology with very little exposition. Really enjoyed it.
Reply
Thank you, Andrew! I’m especially pleased the atmosphere reached you before the explanation did. Thank you for reading and for your lovely words. 😊
Reply
This is such a fascinating and beautifully imaginative story! I found myself questioning how grief affects us, and how that grief shapes us as a person. The way everything came together at the end was brilliant. It's tragic and heartbreaking, but that's what makes it work. I was completely drawn in!
Reply
Thank you! Your thought about grief shaping who we are is something I keep coming back to. I’m not sure I’d know how much of myself I was giving up until it was gone. I really appreciate you reading and sharing what stayed with you. 😊
Reply
A thoughtful story about grief, suffering and pain. I loved the details of the pears, but wanted to know if they were Bartlett or Bosc pears?
Reply
Conference, naturally. She’d already been told no three times, so she brought something suitable for further discussion. 😊
Reply
Naturally. Please let me know what your thoughts are on my story 379. If you can. Thank you.
Reply
Wow what a great story, thank you sharing it with us. This definitely made me ponder on the nature of grief. Well done!
Reply
Thanks Micah.
Reply
Simply brilliant.
Reply
Thanks!
Josh told me about your collaboration and plans for the future. I’d love to come on board.
Reply
I’m very excited to hear that! Big things to come I hope 🙏
Reply
Dear Marjolein,
Thank you for this story. The themes of memory, mistakes, and conscience are very close to me.
What can really be corrected in life? Sometimes, nothing. And then we simply have to live with it. Still, the temptation to somehow forget can be very strong. Sometimes it is pain, sometimes guilt, sometimes disappointment.
Thank you for giving us the chance to feel for these characters, and for an ending that leaves so much room for different meanings — each of them, perhaps, able to help a reader understand something about their own path.
Reply
Thank you, Erian. There’s something painful about wanting relief from a memory and fearing what losing it might mean. I’m glad you found room in the ending for your own reading.
Could you please give it a like as well?
Thank you very much.
Reply
Thank you. I think I gave it a like a few days ago — on my side it shows that the like is there. I was just a bit late leaving a comment. Could you check whether you can see the like too?
Reply
You’re absolutely right. I missed that. Sorry. 🫣
Reply
It's a wonderfully,well written story!
Reply
Hi Kylie,
I'm so happy that you liked it.
Could you please also give the story a like?
Reply
Wow, I had to give the story a second read through to take everything in. I love how you tell a story about grief and guilt through a dark and gloomy lens.
My favorite line is when Leona said, "I haven't slept a full night since she was born. First because she might wake up. Then because she might not come home. Now because she won't. I'm seventy-eight. I'd like to sleep before I die," because I can see how it summarizes the struggle and sacrifice of a mother.
It's a very well written story. Great work, Marjolein!
Reply
Thank you for giving it a second read! Leona’s words are especially painful to me—after a lifetime of worrying about her daughter, even sleep has become something she has to ask for. I’m glad that moment stayed with you.
And if you haven’t already, I’d really appreciate a like on the story. Thank you! 😊
Reply
What a beautifully written story. Perfectly paced. The twists and resolution linger long after you finish reading. And I love your gentle, clean prose, the thoughtful details, the weight of every sentence. One of my favorite reads on this platform.
Reply
Thank you for such a generous comment. There’s something quite special about a story reaching someone you haven’t met before, and then getting a message like yours back. I’m very happy you found it.
Reply
The more I read this the more rewarding it becomes. I love the way he held her face like a child’s face - such a visual image, along with the pears. A unique take on the prompt. Interesting the way he took on the ultimate sacrifice and was viewed by some as a monster, yet takes on the suffering of the memories of others is how I read it. A rather beautiful piece.
Reply
I'm so happy to see/read you again!
Thank you for returning to it. There’s a particular loneliness in being feared by the very people whose suffering you carry. His gentleness makes that harder for me, especially in the moment you mention with her face. I’m touched that you found beauty in it.
Reply
Hi Marjolein,
There is beauty in it.
Things have been so hectic and challenging in recent weeks, I haven’t felt able to write much. Great that you appreciate me.
Reply
I really enjoyed this story! Thanks for sharing!
Reply
This feels like a grim metaphor for the lack of appreciation caregivers are shown in society. Fons provides a service people are incapable of appreciating when it works and when he refuses to offer it as a get out of guilt free card the mob turns on him. That reminds me of the way people have said that vaccines are dangerous because they don't know how dangerous the world was before vaccines were invented. People don't know what they have until they lose it, or in this case, until they get it back. Like other great fiction you have me thinking about many different issues in the real world. Well done.
Reply
Well said, Graham!
Reply
Thank you Graham. Your reading makes me wonder whether gratitude sometimes asks more of us than resentment: it means admitting how much we needed someone, and how little we could offer in return.
“Until they get it back” is a particularly sharp way of putting it. Thank you for such a thoughtful response.
Reply
Working with children at the start of life and looking after my dad at the end of his showed me how much work goes into caring for people with degenerative conditions at the end of their lives and that unlike working with children who become more independent with time, care workers who help the elderly don’t have the comfort of knowing their patients will get recover. Over the years despite the reward of companionship and knowing you’re making their lives better that must take a huge mental toll on the doctors and nurses and the porters and all of the other staff in that field. People have as much right to a dignified end to life as they do an education at the start. In a world as rich as ours, where we have enough food for everyone and access to disease prevention, we should all have healthcare from the cradle to the grave. That might be enough to prove employment for all of the people losing their jobs to automation and artificial intelligence.
Reply
Thank you for sharing that, Graham.
The distinction you make between helping someone towards independence and helping them through its loss is a sobering one.
Care doesn’t become less valuable because recovery is no longer possible, though we seem much better at celebrating recovery than the daily work of preserving someone’s dignity.
I’m sorry about your dad. Having experienced both ends of that journey, you bring something very personal to this conversation. I appreciate it.
Reply
I think people are more comfortable with care in the beginning because it has a limit and people move on but end of life care makes people feel guilt so they ignore it even though that makes it worse for people who need it most. We’re all going to need it but it’s difficult to think about so let’s not. Easier to bury our heads in the sand and pretend we’re immortal.
https://youtu.be/OQL5DiNVC9o?si=BhbGpg-YfzZYLoJd
Reply
Perhaps we also find it easier to care when we can tell ourselves someone will get better. When they won’t, we have to face what care can still mean—and our own helplessness. That’s much harder to sit with.
I like how these conversations with you keep going beyond the story. I’ll have a look at the clip—mortality might be easier to face with the Simpsons involved.
I’m very grateful for your insights. You often give me something I hadn’t considered.
Reply
Madam, I believe this is my favorite so far. As usual your story is layered and thought provoking. As usual you've captured some absolutely magical imagery: "...went thin, like breath fading off a window..." and "...like a sack of flour dropped on a step..." were especially mesmerizing.
You also have a terrific way of letting the details build, of letting bits of the picture develop over time. As someone who wrote expository documents for my job for decades, I'm still finding it hard to not rush right to the point, so to speak. Fiction isn't a memo about why accounting entries for vacation time are going to go whacko when a pandemic shuts everything down. (Shoot, now I'm gonna have PTSD dreams again...)
Bravo, and well done!
Reply
Your favourite so far? Thank you, Ri’tchirdh — I’m going to be quietly insufferable about that for a while.
I’m especially pleased you enjoyed letting the picture develop. After decades of writing documents where getting to the point was the whole point, I imagine allowing yourself to take the scenic route must feel almost professionally irresponsible.
Though I suspect “Accounting Entries for Vacation Time During a Pandemic” belongs in the horror category. Please don’t bring that one to our table. We’ve only just got everyone seated. 😂
Reply
Horror category indeed. And, you can be insufferable out loud if you wish; the people around me seem to have gotten used to it just fine.
And sorry for additional near-identical comments (which I've now deleted). I was having some trouble with my technology and it seemed like it wasn't posting, so I tried again, and again... Might be time for a new device; this one involves a stone tablet and chisels, which I'm told is not exactly the current gear.
Reply