The First Meal

Fiction Science Fiction Speculative

Written in response to: "Write a story with an unreliable narrator or character." as part of Not What It Seems.

The first thing they taught me was how to swallow. Not because I had forgotten. Because nobody could prove I remembered. Apparently there was a difference.

The woman across the table smiled with professional optimism — the kind that had survived too many disappointed people to belong to her anymore.

"Take your time."

Between us sat a porcelain bowl filled with clear broth. Steam drifted toward the ceiling. No garnish. No color. No ambition.

The first meal, I would later learn, was always forgettable.

I reached for the spoon. Three silhouettes behind the observation window leaned forward in perfect synchrony.

"They're subtle," I said.

The woman's smile widened by exactly half a centimeter. "They're observing."

"I assumed they were deciding whether I'd make it to dessert."

Humor apparently was measurable.

The brochure had promised a seamless transition. No trauma. No painful memories. No legal complications. That last promise bothered me more than the others. People only advertised the absence of legal complications when they expected questions about legality.

Useful things had survived. I knew how to tie a tie. How to recognize the smell of rain before it arrived. How to tell when someone was pretending to listen. I knew octopuses had three hearts. I knew the capital of Peru. I even remembered every word of the second verse of Bohemian Rhapsody.

Yet when I searched for my mother's face, there was only static — the same static, I noticed, that filled the half-second before the intercom crackled to life. As though whatever had been taken had left the same texture behind as whatever was watching me now.

The company called the procedure Selective Continuity. The protesters preferred identity laundering. Marketing departments almost always won those arguments.

I lifted the spoon. The broth tasted of chicken, pepper, and childhood — not childhood itself, just the outline of it. A hand. Warm fingers around mine. Someone blowing gently across a spoon before holding it beneath my lips. A laugh. Gone. It disappeared before I could decide whether it belonged to me.

I swallowed. Another note behind the glass.

"Congratulations," the woman said.

"For what?"

"You've completed Phase One."

"I've eaten soup."

"Most people don't see the distinction."

"I sincerely hope your promotion doesn't depend on that sentence."

She laughed. A real one this time. Small. Unexpected. The only unscripted thing that had happened all morning.

"How do you feel?" she asked.

"I suspect there's a preferred answer."

"There isn't."

"Then..." I considered it. "...underwhelmed."

She blinked. "I expected terror. An existential crisis. A dramatic confrontation with the meaning of life."

"And instead?"

"They served soup."

Room Fourteen contained one chair too many. Mine. Everything else had already been decided.

Six identical shirts. Six identical pairs of trousers. Shoes polished to a military shine. Fresh towels. An empty wardrobe. No books. No photographs. No watch. No telephone. Most noticeably — no mirrors.

On the bedside table lay a printed card.

Congratulations on your transition. Reflective surfaces remain unavailable for the initial seventy-two hours.

That was the one sentence all day that actually frightened me. Not because mirrors were forbidden. Because somebody already knew I would ask for one.

Dinner arrived at six. Exactly. Institutions loved exactness. It gave uncertainty somewhere to hide.

The nurse placed the tray on the table and wished me an enjoyable meal, with the detached kindness of someone who had repeated the sentence too many times to mean it. As she reached the door, I spoke.

"Has anyone ever refused?"

She didn't ask what I meant. "No."

"Never?"

"They start with different questions."

"And afterwards?"

"They usually conclude the alternative was worse."

"Worse than what?"

She looked directly at me then — the only time she had all day — and said nothing at all, as if the answer itself were one of the things they weren't yet permitted to give back to me.

Then she left.

The stew cooled untouched. Instead I opened cupboards. Drawers. Boxes. Whoever had prepared the room had been meticulous. Too meticulous. People always left traces behind — receipts, hair, dust, half-finished thoughts disguised as objects. This room had none.

Except a folded paper napkin. Nothing else. No logo. No handwriting. Just white paper folded into careful quarters.

Inside, a dried stain spread across the fibres. Dark red. Wine. Tomato. Blood. Impossible to tell. The shape reminded me of a bird, or perhaps I simply wanted it to. The mind is generous with patterns when facts refuse to cooperate.

I turned it over. Three faint words, barely visible.

Don't finish it.

I looked at the untouched tray. Then back at the napkin. Only then did it occur to me — nothing before it had raised the question — that the meal might not be feeding me at all. It might be measuring me.

I sat with the tray a long time, doing nothing in a room built for observation.

At half past six the intercom crackled — the same static, the same texture as whatever waited behind my mother's face — and the woman's voice arrived, pleasant as ever.

"You haven't eaten."

"I'm savouring it."

"Nobody savours stew for forty minutes."

"You'd be surprised what nobody does, right up until they do."

She waited longer than she had all the other times, long enough that I pictured the clipboard, the pen hovering, someone deciding whether hesitation counted as data or as noise.

"Is something wrong with the meal?"

"Should there be?"

"No."

"Then there isn't."

I turned the fork in my hands twice before setting it down again, then I asked the question I'd been saving since the napkin. "Who was in this room before me?"

She didn't answer, and the not-answering had a different weight than her usual pauses — like someone who had already decided what she wouldn't say.

"No one has stayed in Room Fourteen before you," she said finally.

"The paint disagrees with you. There's a rectangle by the window, lighter than the rest of the wall. Something hung there. Recently enough that the wall hasn't caught up."

She was quiet again, briefly, and something in the quiet had changed register — not caught out, exactly, but recalculating.

"Phase Two begins tomorrow," she said. "Get some rest."

The intercom died before I could answer. She'd chosen the moment for that, too.

I didn't eat the stew. I wrapped it in the napkin with the words on it, folded the whole thing into a square small enough to hide inside a shoe, and lay on top of the sheets rather than beneath them, the way you sleep in a house you don't yet trust.

Sometime after midnight, the door unlocked itself. Nobody walked through — the maglock just gave its particular mechanical sigh and released, then caught again after a handful of slow breaths.

I never decided whether it had been a test or a mistake. In this building, I wasn't convinced the two were kept in separate drawers.

In the morning the tray was gone, taken sometime while I slept by someone who hadn't needed to unlock the door to do it, which meant the door last night hadn't been for the tray at all.

The woman arrived at nine, same smile, half a centimeter wide.

"How did you sleep?"

"Badly. On purpose."

"Congratulations," she said, and I understood, finally, that the word had never been for the soup, or the sleep, or anything I had done. It was for the fact that I was still asking questions at all. Somewhere behind the glass, someone else had stopped.

"What happens to the ones who finish it?" I asked. "The meal, I mean."

She didn't answer right away, and when she did, she used the sentence I now recognised as the only honest one she owned.

"They usually conclude the alternative was worse."

She held the door for me. I noticed, walking past her, that she didn't ask for the napkin back.

Posted Aug 04, 2026
Share:

You must sign up or log in to submit a comment.

13 likes 11 comments

Aaron Luke
August 06, 2026 12:53

This was interesting as it was confusing (in a good way) as it was frightening. Introduced to the fact that the protagonist has lost some memories (related to his loved ones) and further on to how he observes things in detail, even knows when the person speaking is uttering at pause or is just buying time to not answer. What stayed with me was how well you took the prompt. This was so unreliable. The prose and the imagery are slow and take in normal paces and when you reach the point where you start questioning yourself, you wonder for a second, what's going on? I really loved what you had to give here as it was exactly to the point and it stood out in the prompt as it should. Thank you for sharing this piece.

Reply

Marjolein Greebe
August 06, 2026 19:32

What a thoughtful reading of the story. I love that you noticed those small pauses and observations, because that is where much of the unease hides. And the moment the reader starts doubting their own understanding is exactly what I hoped the unreliable narrator would achieve. Thank you for engaging with it so closely.

Reply

David Poslad
August 06, 2026 03:43

This is probably the best I read of you yet.
The atmosphere is so exceptionally eerie, it directly moved over onto me.
I really love how you used the narrator telling us about simple things like looking into the mirror or eating a meal, while making them sound slightly off. The haunting sensations stays long after.
Very well done!

Reply

Marjolein Greebe
August 06, 2026 19:17

Thank you so much! That's a wonderful compliment. I especially love that the ordinary moments felt unsettling to you—that quiet sense of something being just slightly wrong was exactly what I was aiming for. I'm really pleased the atmosphere stayed with you.

Reply

Mariyam G
August 05, 2026 15:21

Wow, this pulled me in right away. The tone is so calm and matter‑of‑fact, which somehow makes the creepy parts even creepier. The whole “Selective Continuity” idea is fascinating, and the napkin twist was perfect. Great work :)

Reply

Marjolein Greebe
August 05, 2026 21:02

Hi Mariyam,

I'm always very pleased with your comments. Thank you so much.

Reply

August 05, 2026 05:47

I really enjoyed the haunting atmosphere and the institutional setting. It felt authentic and unsettling. The clinical routines, impersonal staff, and constant monitoring created a powerful sense of unease that deepened the protagonist’s isolation.
The subtle tension you build throughout the story was very well done. I liked how you blended the persistent discomfort with the protagonist’s quiet skepticism. The mysterious note “Don’t finish it” was a brilliant touch; its cryptic warning added a layer of intrigue.
The protagonist’s internal conflict—clinging to fragments of the past, skepticism about institutional motives, and subtle acts of resistance—felt authentic and relatable.
I especially loved how you portrayed the loss of his personal memories. The distinction between retaining facts and skills while losing the emotional connections to loved ones was heartbreaking and thought-provoking. You captured the emptiness and disorientation that came with forgetting the most meaningful parts of his life, and you made his struggle feel deeply human. This aspect of the story added a powerful emotional layer and raised important questions about what truly defines our identity.
The ending was haunting and effective. It left me with a sense of uncertainty and unresolved tension, mirroring the protagonist’s own struggle. It made me reflect on the consequences of memory loss and institutional control. Great work, as always!

Reply

Marjolein Greebe
August 05, 2026 11:59

Thank you, Veronika. You picked up exactly what I hoped would sit beneath the surface: the strange divide between still knowing things and no longer knowing the people who once gave those things meaning.

I’m also glad the unease stayed with you without needing to be fully explained. That uncertainty mattered to me.

Your comments are always so attentive, and I genuinely appreciate that.

Reply

August 06, 2026 04:31

You're welcome. I always enjoy reading your stories.

Reply

August 04, 2026 19:43

I enjoyed the dry, controlled voice and the way ordinary details—the soup, the missing mirrors, the folded napkin—gradually become threatening.

The strongest idea for me is that the real test may not be whether the narrator remembers, but whether he still questions what he is being told. The final exchange leaves the mystery open without feeling unfinished.

Reply

Marjolein Greebe
August 05, 2026 12:00

Thank you! I'm really glad that was your takeaway. I wanted the ordinary things—the soup, the mirrors, even a folded napkin—to become unsettling without ever turning the story into outright horror.
I also love your interpretation of the real test. Whether that's what was actually being measured... I'll leave that to the reader. 😊

Reply

RBE | Illustrated Short Stories | 2024-06

Bring your short stories to life

Fuse character, story, and conflict with tools in Reedsy Studio. All for free.