How to Become a Captain?

Adventure Funny Kids

Written in response to: "Write a story that includes the lines “Why should I believe you?” or “Give me one good reason to trust you.”" as part of Two Sides to Every Story with Emily Martin.

“I pronounce myself the captain of this pirate ship.” My brother Leo raised a stick above his head in a victory pose as he stepped into the old wooden boat in front of the garage. Yesterday, my dad moved the boat out of the garage and promised to repair it so he could take us to the lake.

“I want to be captain, too!” I grabbed another stick from the ground and lunged at my brother. He dodged to the side, then returned the blow, knocking my stick from my hand.

“There’s room for only one captain, Arthur.” He pointed his stick at me, then grinned in triumph. “And that’s me.”

“That’s not fair!” I cried out. “You're stronger only because you're older!”

“Alright then.” My brother hopped off the boat, dropping the stick on the ground. “We can settle this without fighting.”

“Every pirate ship captain needs a hat, an eyepatch, and a parrot. Find those things, and then we compare them. The one with the better set becomes a captain,” he proposed, and I nodded.

“I accept the challenge. You can’t win this one,” I said enthusiastically.

“We'll see,” Leo grinned, walking away and leaving me with the boat.

“Just wait; you'll be mine.” I patted the boat, smiling at the thought of being captain, even though I had no idea where to find any of those things.

I was lost in my thoughts when a magpie that had just landed in our garden near me caught my attention. Since we didn’t have any parrots around, I thought the magpie would make a great replacement.

I approached quietly from behind, trying to move as stealthily as possible. It completely ignored me, pecking at something in the grass without a care. When I was close enough, I leaped toward it, trying to catch it. It dodged easily, without even looking at me, leaving me to land on the ground with a big thud. The magpie looked at me for the first time, then it flew away with a chattering noise.

“Don’t laugh at me; I’ll catch you next time!” I yelled, standing up, glancing at my slightly grazed arm and grass-stained T-shirt. I was holding back tears when a familiar honk sounded behind me.

I looked at the goose pen on the far side of our garden. Emily, my favorite goose, was staring at me with concern. I walked toward her and slipped into the goose pen.

“I’m alright, Emily,” I reassured her, then sat next to her. I hugged her tightly, and she gently draped her neck around my shoulder. She always comforted and protected me, especially from other geese who weren’t happy with me being in their pen.

“I wish you could be a parrot right now,” I said sadly as I petted her head and neck. She answered me with purring noises, hugging me closer. As she did that, I noticed a feather drifting down from her. I picked it up and looked at it. That was when an idea occurred to me.

“You’re the best!” I jumped back to my feet, enthusiastic, startling her a little. I started to collect all the feathers I could find while Emily watched me carefully, ready to protect me from other geese.

“The next time I visit you, I'll be a pirate captain,” I said happily to Emily as I finished gathering all the feathers. I gave Emily a quick kiss on the head and left the goose pen.

I started running toward the house when my dad suddenly appeared beside me, looking surprised. “What are you planning to do with all those feathers?”

“I’ll make a parrot from them. I’m competing with Leo to become the captain of the pirate ship. I have to make a parrot, a hat, and an eyepatch,” I explained to him, and he burst out laughing.

“Why can’t you both be captains?” he asked, and I looked at him, horrified by his words.

“There can’t be two captains on one ship.” I shook my head vigorously.

“Why not?” he asked, amused.

“Because…” I paused, unsure how to respond. Then I frowned. “Having two captains is just wrong.” Plus, I really wanted to beat Leo at this because he was always the best at everything.

“Aye, aye, captain,” he said with a respectful nod. “Your parrot awaits.” He stepped aside, allowing me to enter the house.

I ran into my room and spread all the feathers on the ground. Then I started looking for other supplies I would use. I collected papers, felt-tip pens, colored pencils, watercolors, scissors, and glue, and placed them on the floor beside the feathers.

***

Two hours later, I finally finished everything. I made a beautiful paper hat and drew a big skull and crossbones on it. I used the blue colored pencil for that because I didn’t have the white one, and to be honest, the blue was way cooler anyway.

For the eyepatch, I had to improvise a little more. First, I tried to make it from paper, but I accidentally tore it in half. I tried again, but the shape was terrible, and it kept falling off my eye, so I tore this one on purpose.

After crying for at least ten minutes, I decided to cut the eyepatch from one of my black T-shirts, which was a really great idea because it fit well. If Mom ever discovered this, she would be so angry with me.

The parrot was probably the hardest. Trying to make a parrot from feathers wasn’t as easy as I’d thought. First, I glued small feathers to my hands and even to the floor. I’d like to know what would make Mom angrier—the cut-off T-shirt or the feathers glued to the floor. But on the other hand, I hoped she would never find out about this.

I wasn’t able to model a parrot’s body, so I made a ball instead. I colored the white ball with watercolors, then drew eyes and a beak with felt-tip pens.

I put the hat on my head and the eyepatch over my eye. Then I took my parrot proudly in my hands and smiled at it. “Emily Junior, we are ready to meet my brother.”

As I ran from the house, I realized that wearing an eyepatch wasn’t very practical. I bumped into the door twice and then tripped over the toy car I had left right in front of the entrance door. Maybe I should have put it back in my room, as Mom had told me to do before.

When I returned to the boat, Leo was already there, lying in it and looking at the sky. I immediately noticed his big plush parrot, sitting beside him. It had almost lifelike blue and yellow plumage and a majestic black beak. I had never seen a plush parrot as beautiful as this one.

“Oh, you're back. Finally!” He rose from the boat, putting a big black hat with a picture of a white skull and crossed bones on his head. Then I noticed a precisely made eyepatch over his eye. Both were absolutely stunning. I clutched Emily Junior firmly in my hands.

“Where did you find those things?” I asked, angry.

“I borrowed them from Josh.” He pointed to our neighbors' house. “His parents bought him the pirate costume for Halloween, remember?”

“That’s why you proposed this competition!” The realization of his betrayal hit me hard. He had planned this from the beginning. I was never supposed to win. I felt a lump form in my throat as I tried to hold back my tears.

Leo walked toward me, wanting to say something, but Dad’s voice cut in and interrupted us.

“Ahoy, captains! How's the competition going?”

“I think we have a winner.” Leo grinned in triumph, tapping his hat.

“Really?” Dad raised an eyebrow, surprised. “Both of your pirate accessories are amazing. I’d say it’s a tie.”

“You can’t be serious. Look at his ugly feather ball,” Leo cried out, pointing at Emily Junior. “My things are way better!”

I lowered my head and hugged Emily Junior protectively.

“They are great, but Arthur’s are original, which makes them just as great as yours,” Dad explained. I looked surprised at him, then smiled proudly at Emily Junior. Leo frowned.

“If this is a tie, who will be captain then? We can’t both be captains!” Leo protested, and Dad started to laugh.

“I’ve heard that before.” He looked at me with a slight nod, then looked at both of us. “Well, if you think you can’t both be captains, I have other competition for you,” he said, pulling something from his pocket.

“What is it?” Leo and I asked almost in unison, excitedly.

“I hid a pirate treasure somewhere, and this is a map to find it.” He showed us two small plastic bags, each containing at least twenty small pieces of paper, then he smiled broadly.

“Of course, you have to put the map together first.” He handed each of us a bag. “Whoever finds the treasure becomes a captain.”

“That’s so cool! At least I’ll win fairly.” Leo sat down on the grass, pulling all the paper pieces from the bag. I did the same, determined to beat him at this.

“Have fun.” Dad smiled at us, then he left.

After a few minutes of struggling to put the pieces together, I looked desperately at Leo. He was frowning at the pieces, having the same problem I did. I felt immediately relieved.

“Some of the pieces are missing,” Leo said without even looking at me. “I think we have to put all the pieces together,” he added with a sigh.

“I won’t give you my pieces!” I cried out, hiding the pieces back in the bag.

“But you have to. Otherwise, we won’t be able to find the treasure or become the captain.” He shrugged resignedly, then continued. “Look, I hate it too, but we have to work together.”

“Why should I believe you? You’ve betrayed me once!” I reminded him, and he looked ashamed.

“I’m sorry about that. I didn’t mean to hurt you. I just wanted to be the captain of the ship,” he said apologetically. Then he stood up and walked toward me, taking his paper pieces with him.

“Do you want to switch our pirate accessories?” he asked, grabbing his parrot and taking off his hat and eyepatch. “The eyepatch is amazing because you can actually see through it.”

He handed me all his accessories. I took his hat and eyepatch hesitantly, then gave him mine. I looked at his parrot, but I shook my head.

“I’m good with Emily Junior,” I explained, and Leo smiled.

“Okay then, Emily Junior is cooler than my parrot, anyway.” He sat next to me, setting his bag with paper pieces in front of us.

“So, can we solve this together?” he asked, and I just nodded, placing my pieces next to his.

***

After a few minutes, we easily put the map together. We followed it and found the treasure behind the shed, under the rhododendron bush. It was well hidden beneath the rocks and leaves. We would probably never have found it without the map.

It was a small chest, and when we opened it, there were many chocolate coins inside. We brought the chest onto our boat and divided the coins equally.

Leo took one of his coins, unwrapped it from its golden foil, and tasted the chocolate.

“This treasure is the best, Captain,” he said with a mouthful of chocolate. I smiled at him and grabbed one of my coins, then put it in my mouth.

“It is, Captain, but I think we’ll find even better treasures...” I popped another coin into my mouth. “…together.”

Posted Jul 31, 2026
Share:

You must sign up or log in to submit a comment.

18 likes 22 comments

Ron Sewell
August 05, 2026 08:29

brotherly love as it is and always will be.

Reply

August 05, 2026 09:09

I agree. Thank you so much for reading and commenting.

Reply

Matthew Granger
August 04, 2026 00:28

I gotta call my brother. Another great story. I now realize blue is a superior skull and crossbones color. Thanks for sharing.

Reply

August 04, 2026 07:03

Thank you so much for reading and commenting. I'm glad you enjoyed the story and liked the blue color on the skull. I'm also happy that this story reminded you of your brother.

Reply

Graham Kinross
August 03, 2026 13:19

At least dad’s challenge meant they got on better than the crew of the Black Pearl. Chocolate coins are a great treasure though I think making your own costume with all of that effort deserves the win more than borrowing a costume. That’s as someone who likes crafting so would appreciate the work that went into it. That’s not a parent’s job though. I’m also a fan of maps so making one would be a cool bonding activity.

Reply

August 04, 2026 06:21

Thank you so much for reading and commenting, Graham. I'm glad you liked the treasure, the map, and dad's challenge. I completely agree that making the costume himself should have earned the win for the creativity and effort, but the goal was to make them work together. Thanks again; I always appreciate your comments.

Reply

Graham Kinross
August 04, 2026 23:20

You’re welcome Veronika.

Reply

Jim LaFleur
August 03, 2026 12:09

Emily Junior is easily the sweetest pirate companion ever created. Arthur’s chaotic creativity and that goose-feather ball completely stole my heart! Excellent work as always!

Reply

August 04, 2026 06:12

Thank you so much for reading and commenting, Jim. I'm glad you appreciated Emily Junior and Arthur's creativity.

Reply

Scott Speck
August 02, 2026 15:12

I love this touching tale! Full of childhood pirate mayhem, sibling rivalry, creativity in costuming, and, at least, working TOGETHER as co-captains!

Reply

August 03, 2026 04:41

Thank you so much for reading and commenting, Scott. I'm glad you enjoyed the story.

Reply

August 01, 2026 19:41

Lovely! So wholesome and hearty warming. This is a story I would hve read to my kids when they were young. Great message about sharing and healthy competition . Also how original creations beat store bought stuff! Thoroughly enjoyed!

Reply

August 02, 2026 12:13

Thank you so much for reading and commenting. I'm glad you enjoyed the competition and the message of sharing. I'm also honored that you find this story worthy of reading to kids. Thanks again; I appreciate it.

Reply

Richard Fahy
August 01, 2026 17:39

Veronika, thanks, this was a fun read! It brings back some childhood memories of competitions with my siblings...
I liked how you brought out Arthur's creativity in pulling together the costume more-or-less out of thin air. You captured the endless creativity of kiddos wonderfully.
You also captured the quick-changing dynamics between siblings, or any group of kids: enemies one minute, besties the next.
I have one small suggestion for your consideration: in dialogue, especially between kids, I think contractions ("you're" instead of "you are", e.g.) sound more natural. Maybe that's just me; and certainly a more formal speech pattern CAN be an important part of a character's behavior.
Thanks again!!

Reply

August 02, 2026 11:48

Thank you so much for reading and commenting. I'm happy to hear this story reminded you of your childhood memories. I'm also glad you liked Arthur's creativity and the quick-changing dynamics between siblings.
I really appreciate your recommendation about contractions. I've tried to fix that. Thanks again; it means a lot!

Reply

Mariyam G
August 01, 2026 14:40

This was such a lovely read. I really enjoyed how real the sibling rivalry felt, and Arthur’s determination to make his own pirate gear — even when he ends up with feathers glued everywhere. Emily comforting him after the magpie fiasco was such a sweet moment. The treasure‑map twist from their dad was brilliant and made their teamwork feel natural. . And the ending, with the two of them sharing chocolate coins and calling each other Captain, was just perfect. A really heart-warming story :)

Reply

August 02, 2026 11:36

Thank you so much for reading and commenting. I'm glad you enjoyed the sibling rivalry, Arthur's determination, and the scene with Emily. I'm also happy the map twist and the ending resonated with you. Thanks again. I appreciate your comment.

Reply

The Old Izbushka
August 01, 2026 13:06

Love how you captured childhood here. As a reader, it’s so nice to be swept into that world and there’s nothing quite like competing to become captain of an imaginary pirate ship! :)

I especially loved the final message of the story, and the father’s brilliance in creatively getting them to work together despite their rivalry and jealousy. The idea that the greatest treasure is learning to work together is beautiful. They didn’t have to decide who would be the one captain; they discovered that the adventure was better when they shared it. Great story!!

Reply

August 02, 2026 11:29

Thank you so much for reading and commenting. I'm glad you enjoyed the story and appreciated the final message. Thanks again. I appreciate your comment.

Reply

Marjolein Greebe
July 31, 2026 19:45

Hi Veronika,

This was such a warm and charming story. What impressed me most is how much genuine feeling you created from very ordinary childhood moments: sibling rivalry, a handmade toy, a supportive father, and a goose named Emily. Arthur’s voice feels completely convincing, not because his language is overly childlike, but because his reasoning is. His certainty that there can only be one captain, his determination to make everything himself, and his growing concern about what his mother might think of the cut T-shirt and glued feathers all felt wonderfully authentic.

Emily quietly becomes the emotional heart of the story. The scene in the goose pen is especially lovely because it never strains for sentiment. She simply comforts Arthur, and that moment naturally inspires Emily Junior. It develops Arthur, deepens the warmth of the story, and moves the plot forward all at once. I also loved that, when Leo later offers him the plush parrot, Arthur keeps his own imperfect creation. That small choice says a great deal about what Emily Junior has come to mean to him.

The father handles the rivalry beautifully without ever turning the story into a lecture. Rather than telling the boys that cooperation matters, he creates a situation in which they have to discover it themselves. The divided treasure map is a simple but very effective device. Leo’s apology also works well because it is followed by action: he offers Arthur his superior pirate accessories and is willing to work beside him. That keeps him from becoming merely the selfish older brother who exists to learn a lesson.

I also really enjoyed the humor throughout, especially because it remains so firmly rooted in Arthur’s perspective. His thoughts about whether his mother will be angrier about the ruined T-shirt or the feathers glued to the floor made me smile, as did the practical difficulties of running around in an eyepatch. These details give the story a lively, natural quality and make Arthur very easy to care about.

The ending is exactly right. It doesn’t reach for a grand speech or overstate its message. Two brothers sit in their boat, share chocolate coins, call each other Captain, and realize that the better adventures may be the ones they have together. Simple, satisfying, and fully earned.

A thoroughly enjoyable story with a wonderfully believable young protagonist, a warm family dynamic, and one exceptionally lovable goose.

Reply

August 01, 2026 09:01

Marjolein, thank you so much for taking the time to read and leave such a beautiful, extended comment. I'm really glad you found Artur's voice convincing and authentic, and that the ordinary moments resonated with you. It means a lot to hear that Emily’s role and the father’s approach felt natural and effective. I'm also happy you enjoyed the humor and that the ending felt satisfying and earned. I wanted those details to feel genuine and earned, so I’m delighted they came across that way. Thank you so much for your generous and insightful feedback. I really appreciate it!

Reply

Marjolein Greebe
August 01, 2026 10:09

You're welcome! I was so happy to see you'd published another story.

Reply

RBE | Illustrated Short Stories | 2024-06

Bring your short stories to life

Fuse character, story, and conflict with tools in Reedsy Studio. All for free.