Old MacDonald Arrested

⭐️ Contest #187 Shortlist!

American Funny Sad

This story contains themes or mentions of physical violence, gore, or abuse.

Written in response to: "Write about a human and a cat that come to some kind of mutual understanding." as part of Cat People.

Old MacDonald had a farm, and on that farm he was training animals to infiltrate the halls of power. Old MacDonald (72) was arrested dressed as a clown. He planned to snare the nation with delicious fast food laced with cocaine.

It was Furball Fluffington who infiltrated the despot’s network. That cat sure wears the hell out of those boots, this reporter must say. The hat isn’t a bad look either.

“I’ve been undercover on the farm for months now,” said Furball. “And on that farm he had a cow. The bovine was training for something involving the moon and cutlery. From what I saw. It would have killed millions.”

Vowing that his undercover days are behind him, Fluffington agreed to share his story on the condition of payment in catnip.

“I was under cover in a smuggling network before it was legalised. I’ve been addicted ever since.” The black and white feline broke down in tears as he was paid for the story. Problems with addiction have kept him from family, who grew tired of him stealing to feed his habit.

“People call me a hero today,” Furball says, “but tomorrow I’ll be on my own dealing with the problem that’s been dragging me down for years. I know I need rehab but like Amy said; no, no, no.”

Among the charges levelled against MacDonald are sedition, terrorism, grand conspiracy, corruption of minors, and breach of copyright. Many fast food chains are already preparing cases to sue the former farmer.

Animals from the facility where Old MacDonald brainwashed them are in protective custody. Authorities say they will be on watchlists as they undergo deprogramming and court mandated therapy. Some have been part of the conspiracy for years, spreading MacDonald’s message through catchy children’s music. The disgraced media tycoon was a known fan of Hitler’s phrase; He alone, who owns the youth, gains the future.

Despite warnings being spread among mothers everywhere, videos containing MacDonald’s messages are still available on many social media and streaming sites. Efforts to remove them have been stymied in the short term by free speech advocates and far right groups.

An associate of MacDonald, known only as Mary, left the compound in handcuffs. Lambs wailed, led away from their abusive master. The smallest broke hearts, struggling free to sit on Mary’s lap in the back of a police van before it was taken away.

Ewan Ramstein (29) and his wife Woolamina (31) claim the child in the now viral news clip is theirs. Snow-White Ramstein met Mary, who gave a talk at her preschool years before.

“Everything changed when she met Mary. Our Snow-White was charmed by the girl. Mary seemed very agreeable at first. That was just a facade, beneath she was quite a contrarian. Anything good in the world was a conspiracy. Our little lamb chopped off communication with us. That last time we saw her was on the news, getting escorted onto a bus two by two with the other animals.

Police have assured us that parents of the children will be contacted as soon as all of those rescued from the facility have been identified.

“Old MacDonald had a pig,” Fluffball told us, before breaking down into a sobbing series of vowel sounds. “He found out the big guy wore a wig. He knew there was a mole in his circle. He tortured the pig. No matter how much Chris P Bacon squealed, MacDonald didn’t believe he was part of the cause. I had to keep my mouth shut as I watched. You know what the worst thing was? He branded the pig with his mark. It smelled delicious.” Fluffington licked his lips, recalling the ordeal.

Minute by minute, the scale of MacDonald’s crimes is revealed. Five little ducks went out each day. One by one, the farmer lured them all away. Fluffington believes some of them may be buried in a field of graves marked only by leek plants.

“He had a thing for cruel and unusual punishment. He made five little monkeys jump on a bed until one fell off and one bumped his head really bad. Papa M, that’s what he liked us all to call him, called a doctor. I tried to alert the doctor to what was happening but he just said we shouldn’t be jumping on the bed.”

Social media is already abuzz that Old MacDonald should have been arrested earlier. Whistleblowers were ignored. Opportunities to end the ordeal of so many innocent animals were missed.

The first rumours of malicious activity emerged in 2017. Three mice reported MacDonald to police, accusing him of blinding them to set an example to others. One lost all of his hair during the ‘expulsion of sin’. Another was beaten around the head, causing swelling that never healed. The third mouse, Larry (25) has given a statement. “He was a monster. It was the same thing, every night. Trying to take over the world. He thought he was a genius. He was insane.”

MacDonald settled out of court with the mice, using a non disclosure agreement to keep them from telling their story.

“I know people will judge me now, but I needed the money,” said Larry. “He’d already ruined my life. At least I got some cash to keep me going. I’m sorry to everyone I might have helped. Non-disclosure agreements shouldn’t exist. They just help people like him hide their crimes.” Clearly haunted by his time on the farm, Larry said; “I can still hear his voice yelling ‘see how they run.’ He would laugh. He was singing one of his songs about a teapot when he burnt my friend. ‘I’m a little teapot, short and stout.’ His hair never grew back. MacDonald called him Pinkie.”

Sedition carries a sentence of up to 20 years and a fine of up to $10,000. Sedition will be the least of Old MacDonald’s problems if he is found guilty of terrorism, which can carry a life sentence and in rare cases, the death penalty. Lawyers for Old MacDonald have issued a statement admitting that he was responsible for several noise disturbances in the past but has learned from his mistakes. He claims the entire investigation is a witch hunt by those who don’t agree with his ahead-of-his-time thinking.

BREAKING NEWS: Old MacDonald has announced his intention to run for president. It is believed he hopes to use the presidential pardon.

Further allegations have come to light dating back to the 1990s, Old MacDonald was accused of failing to declare income for tax purposes in 1992-1998 but due to the statute of limitations cannot be prosecuted for tax evasion. A former girlfriend of MacDonald claims that she went to police in 2001 with claims of violence committed in the 1980s but was told too much time had passed since the offenses to secure a conviction. Once again the statute of limitations saw a criminal evading justice.

I’m Fawning Itin with the Six O’clock News, click on the link below to watch Bear Lee Seayew with the weather.

Posted Mar 01, 2023
Share:

You must sign up or log in to submit a comment.

54 likes 101 comments

Wendy Kaminski
March 01, 2023 16:12

This was really cute, Graham, taking whimsical stories and turning them into fodder! I enjoyed the outside-the-catbox thinking, and the news story style was really appealing for presenting the info. Some terrible things you should be ashamed of:

- something involving the moon and cutlery. - haha!

- An associate of MacDonald, known only as Mary (lambs wailed) - lol :)

- she was quite a contrarian - booo, I say! boooo!

- Bear Lee Seayew - terrible! :)

Reply

Graham Kinross
March 01, 2023 22:39

Pun names are cheap, but like the joke in a Christmas cracker, I bet you smiled at how bad they were. An Englishman, an Irishman, and a Scotsman walked into a bar. The barman had to ask them, is this a joke?

https://youtu.be/VorIn2ISK6w

Reply

Wendy Kaminski
March 01, 2023 23:55

Yes I did laugh, dang you! :P

Reply

Graham Kinross
March 02, 2023 02:50

A man goes into a bar and orders a pint of beer and a packet of crisps(potato chips). He drinks the pint in a single gulp and crushes the crisps on his head then leaves the bar without saying another word. The next day he does the same. For a week he drinks a pint and crushes potato chips on his head every day. One day, when the barman is sick of cleaning crisps off his floor after the man leaves he tells his patron that he’s all out of crisps. The man nods calmly and asks for a pie and a beer. The barman gives the man a beer and a pie. Thanking the barman, the man drinks the beer in a single long gulp and sighs with appreciation. He then smashes the pie over his head.
“Why did you do that?” asks the barman.
“Do what?” asks the man, looking confused.
“Why did you smash the pie over your head?”
“Because you didn’t have any crisps.”

Reply

Wendy Kaminski
March 02, 2023 15:12

So terrible. :P

Reply

Graham Kinross
March 02, 2023 21:53

A drama teacher at high school told me that one.

Reply

March 11, 2023 02:55

This was so good, you had me from the first line wondering what manic wordplay was coming next: i loved how the list of grave crimes ended with “copyright infringement” so much observational humor like that in this. There was a rhyming feeling to the way childrens fables were dropped in that was spot on. V happy to see your talented work finally make it to the shortlist.

Reply

Graham Kinross
March 11, 2023 13:31

Nothing is a more grievous crime in America than threatening profit. Thanks, Scott.

Reply

Gail Coleman
March 22, 2023 14:54

I really enjoyed reading this. I think my favorite part is when the farmer was yelling see how they run! That made me laugh!

Reply

Graham Kinross
March 22, 2023 22:19

Thanks, Gail. I’m glad you enjoyed it.

Reply

Philip Ebuluofor
March 15, 2023 11:41

Congrats Graham. So long this journey. But the central message is that you finally appeared here. Congrats once more. Persistence finally overcame.

Reply

Graham Kinross
March 15, 2023 13:33

Thanks Philip. Persistence is the key to all accomplishments.

Reply

Philip Ebuluofor
March 18, 2023 04:58

For sure. It opens the iron door. I have found that out in my writings.

Reply

Story Time
March 13, 2023 16:18

This was such a great way to merge a concept with satire using a story everyone is familiar with--and lots of wit. I really enjoyed it, Graham.

Reply

Graham Kinross
March 13, 2023 20:57

Thanks, Kevin.

Reply

Marty B
March 12, 2023 01:27

Never trusted that guy and what is an Eieio- anyway?

Reply

Graham Kinross
March 12, 2023 05:03

Every idiot enjoys ingesting oranges. Thanks Marty.

Reply

Kathryn Kahn
March 12, 2023 00:00

How clever! Very fun and humorous.

Reply

Graham Kinross
March 12, 2023 03:48

Thank you, Kathryn.

Reply

Michał Przywara
March 11, 2023 17:06

Ha! Very funny :) And a little sad, as all good satire might be :)

The number of references and how they're worked in is creative, and I'm digging the puns. Ewen Ramstein took me just a moment, as it's a believable name - and then Chris P Bacon is a delightful slap to the face :)

Congrats on the shortlist!

Reply

Graham Kinross
March 12, 2023 01:06

I don’t normally go for puns but this seemed like the perfect story. Thanks.

Reply

Congratulations on the shortlist, Graham! Story #189 did the trick! Amazing that this is also your Reedsy prompts anniversary.

This was nuts! What is in your head?!

My mother says this reminded her of Jonathan Swift's A Modest Proposal.

The reporter voice works really well for this piece. In some ways I'm reminded of George Orwell's Animal Farm, but this is crazier. It seems to dance on a tightrope between horror and political satire, wrapped up in nursery-rhyme themed jokes and puns. Good job!

Reply

Graham Kinross
March 11, 2023 13:40

Your mum read this? Thank you. I had to look up A Modest Proposal, sounds interesting. Sad as well that we have very similar problems today as back then. They’re are no exceptions to the rule that everyone thinks they’re an exception to the rules-Banksy.

Reply

I’ve shown my mother Romea and Julian, and several of Xander’s stories, including Xander Meets the In-Laws. My first experience of this one was reading it out loud to her. She likes your work.

“It is foolish, generally speaking, for a philosopher to set fire to another philosopher in Smithfield Market because they do not agree in their theory of the universe. That was done very frequently in the last decadence of the Middle Ages, and it failed altogether in its object. But there is one thing that is infinitely more absurd and unpractical than burning a man for his philosophy. That is the habit of saying that his philosophy does not matter, and this is done universally in the twentieth century, in the decadence of the great revolutionary period.”
—G.K. Chesterton

Reply

Graham Kinross
March 26, 2023 10:05

Don’t think I can out quote that one. Thank you for sharing my work.

Reply

V. S. Rose
March 11, 2023 01:35

Congrats Graham! Really glad to see you on here I always love your stories. This one was really well done, you deserve this!

Reply

Graham Kinross
March 11, 2023 13:31

Thank you. Everyone is so kind.

Reply

Zack Powell
March 10, 2023 17:35

I've been hoping for a long time to see your stories finally get their fair and just recognition, Graham. Couldn't be happier for you today. You earned it!

Reply

Graham Kinross
March 11, 2023 00:14

Thank you very much, Zack.

Reply

Helen A Howard
March 10, 2023 17:12

Congratulations Graham. Well deserved.

Reply

Graham Kinross
March 11, 2023 00:12

Thanks, Helen.

Reply

Aeris Walker
March 10, 2023 17:11

Congrats on the shortlist, Graham!

Reply

Graham Kinross
March 11, 2023 00:11

Thanks, Aeris.

Reply

March 10, 2023 17:03

Congratulations, Graham!
( ͡ᵔ ͜ʖ ͡ᵔ )

Reply

March 10, 2023 18:02

Maybe come on over to the Discord channel and chat -- lots of Graham Fans there :)
https://discord.gg/bxTWQw3HJR

Reply

Graham Kinross
March 11, 2023 00:12

Thanks, Deidra. I’ve joined, you got me!

Reply

Amanda Lieser
March 08, 2023 05:37

Hey Graham!
Oh wow! This was a thriller, I don’t think I was expecting this kind of story from you for this prompt but I should’ve known a little bit better after reading the content warning. I thought that you did a really good job of weaving and not a lot of the old names and ideas that we know into this world. I also thought some of those ethical questions that you were throwing in there were interesting – especially towards the end. I think that I appreciated the way that you characterize that everyone has not necessarily heroes, nor victims entirely on their own. This was a punchy, thrilling story. Nice work.

Reply

Graham Kinross
March 12, 2023 12:45

Yeah a lot of people are indoctrinated into lifestyles, it can be hard to pinpoint exactly when they take full responsibility for their actions instead of being victims of the system that raised them. Thank you for reading the story and commenting.

Reply

Ann Miller
March 07, 2023 19:41

Very cute! This was a fun read.

Reply

Graham Kinross
March 07, 2023 22:48

Thank you.

Reply

Mike Rush
March 05, 2023 20:17

Graham,

I'm so glad I came across this piece. It's laugh out loud funny in many places. I thought it was a bit of brilliance to weave those old children's songs into a coherent story. Too bad so much of this, which should just be playful nonsense, is close to reality in our world. Especially the bit at the end! A criminal running for president? That would never happen!

Reply

Graham Kinross
March 05, 2023 22:58

Yes, we’re at an interesting time when there’s someone who’s main goal running for president is to give themselves a get out of jail free card. Then again, the first one was just to launch themselves as a far right media mogul, and to bilk followers out of money. He might just be one of the most successful conmen in American history. Billing the secret service for their stay at his own resort is a cheeky way to make a mint.

Reply

Roger Scypion
March 05, 2023 00:45

A great piece of writing, the characters are wunderbar!

Reply

Graham Kinross
March 05, 2023 01:23

Thanks Roger. That’s very kind of you.

Reply

Martin Ross
March 03, 2023 00:02

Sociopolitical satire meets Mother Goose!!🤣🤣🤣 Brilliant, and with the surreal, horrifying situations here in the U.S. over the past six or seven years, very appropo.

Reply

Graham Kinross
March 03, 2023 01:41

Thanks. It seemed really easy at first but then it was harder and harder to throw in the references.

Reply

Martin Ross
March 03, 2023 05:28

Came out seamlessly!

Reply

Graham Kinross
March 03, 2023 07:15

Thanks, Martin.

Reply

Michelle Oliver
March 02, 2023 13:42

This was such an entertaining read. Your pun names are so cheap and nasty that they’re delightfully delicious. I really enjoyed them and had a chuckle.

I loved the way you took all the innocence of children’s nursery rhymes (which if you stop to think about it aren’t that innocent at all) and twisted them into something sinister and dark.

I like the dramatic media voice you have used to sensationalise the information and whip the reader into righteous indignation. If feels very authentic.

A great read, thanks for sharing.

Reply

Graham Kinross
March 02, 2023 21:52

Thank you, Michelle. I’m glad you enjoyed the cheap jokes.

Reply

Lily Finch
March 02, 2023 00:03

Graham, Ok, you clearly have written much like good ol' George Orwell with this one. I am not sure I got all of the innuendos but I tried. Different politics for me than you as I don't live in US.
Absolutely love this character's name. "It was Furball Fluffington who infiltrated the despot’s network." - I wonder, though, if this should be in quotes since the reporter is reporting this?
Bovine - cow jumped over the moon and the dish ran away with the spoon?
I know I need rehab, but like Amy said, no, no, no.” - Winehouse?
"sedition, terrorism, grand conspiracy, corruption of minors, and breach of copyright" - one of your former Presidents?
The disgraced media tycoon was a known fan of Hitler’s phrase; He alone, who owns the youth, gains the future. - Mary Miller? One of your former Presidents?
Ewan Ramstein (29) and his wife Woolamina (31) claim the child in the now viral news clip is theirs. Snow-White Ramstein met Mary, who gave a talk at her preschool years before. - Harry Weinstein?
"The first rumours of malicious activity emerged in 2017. ...He thought he was a genius. He was insane.” - One of your former Presidents?

Wowsy. LF6.

Reply

Graham Kinross
March 02, 2023 03:29

You’re right with most things. The last bit about being insane instead of a genius is a riff on the theme song for Pinky and the Brain and Larry, who were my three blind mice.

Ramstein is a German rock band. Amy Winehouse indeed, I feel like she had a long career ahead of her, such a shame.

I just made up charges inspired by the people getting in trouble for the Capitol riots.

Reply

Lily Finch
March 02, 2023 17:44

Pinky and the Brain crossed my mind but Larry fooled me. Shoot! LF6.

Reply

Graham Kinross
March 02, 2023 21:57

Larry was in one episode, with a modified opening credits sequence.

Reply

Lily Finch
March 02, 2023 22:37

You gotta at least give a gal a chance! LF6.

Reply

Graham Kinross
March 03, 2023 01:30

I know, I think he was only in one episode but I needed another mouse and I wanted the three blind mice to include Pinky and the Brain.

https://youtu.be/VorIn2ISK6w

Reply

Marisa Billions
March 01, 2023 23:02

I totally loved this story! It had a very Orwellian feel to it, but not dry and boring (sorry if anyone likes Orwell).

Reply

Graham Kinross
March 01, 2023 23:50

I like Animal Farm but I know what you mean, there’s not much fun to be had reading it. Thanks, Marisa.

Reply

Marisa Billions
March 02, 2023 16:28

It's an important story, for sure. But I like your version far better! :)

Reply

Graham Kinross
March 02, 2023 21:54

Very kind of you. It probably helps that mine is a lot shorter!

Reply

Mike Panasitti
March 01, 2023 18:42

What really struck me here, Graham, was the Hitler quote: "He alone, who owns the youth, gains the future." When the United States has a president who's rabidly pro rap and trap music, he, or she, will secure the future, and the country's founding principles will hear their death knell. As things currently are, they're already threatened.

Reply

Graham Kinross
March 01, 2023 22:34

But by design the president will always be older than the youth of the nation. I’m not old enough to be President but I’m already too old to quite understand half of the crap teenagers now bother with. TikTok can be amusing for a few minutes but the lack of narrative and the distracting nature of it pisses me off after a while because I don’t see what I’m getting from it. Also, in America at least where two parties dominate the political scene, a president wouldn’t appeal to the whole youth, just the kids who’d be up for voting for their party. Picking a fight with another nuclear armed nation seems like a more likely risk to America, unless someone manages to pull of a Julius Caesar style coup. America seems specifically designed to avoid that though.

Reply

Mike Panasitti
March 03, 2023 00:00

I always appreciate your thoughts, Graham. I hope life in Japan is not as alienating as I imagine it can be for a non-native. BTW, my girlfriend is half-Japanese. I hope to visit your shores with her some day. Seeing Scotland would also be a welcome reprieve from the cultural chaos that is the United States. Take care and cheers.

Reply

Graham Kinross
March 03, 2023 01:38

There’s cultural chaos everywhere I think. It can be alienating. I’m used to being an outsider so it doesn’t bother me as much. Here I know why people are looking at me. There are still things that bug me, some of it is my own fault for being here so long and not learning enough of the language. At times I can say things the same way someone Japanese would say them but people in shops aren’t expecting to understand me so they don’t listen and just do whatever. On the rare occasion when I know what they’ve asked and can respond that gets really frustrating and makes me want to give up. Sometimes not knowing basics just makes things awkward for me and people I’m trying to talk to.

Japan is a very cool place to visit though. Probably better to visit than to live here.

Reply

Saffron Roxanne
August 09, 2025 16:26

This is hilarious! I want to crack open this case and discover all the horrible details that Old MacDonald bestowed upon his victims 😆 Very clever piece.

Reply

Graham Kinross
August 10, 2025 07:21

Thank you. Someone else’s story about the Big Bad Wolf on trial inspired me.

Reply

Aeris Walker
June 14, 2025 19:47

Going back to read your shortlisted story! You've ruthlessly and cleverly ruined every nursery rhyme for us all. This was sharp-witted and fresh. Congratulations!

Reply

Graham Kinross
June 16, 2025 00:17

Someone put the big bad Wolf in court in their story so that gave me the idea. Thanks Aeris.

Reply

RBE | Illustrated Short Stories | 2024-06

Bring your short stories to life

Fuse character, story, and conflict with tools in Reedsy Studio. All for free.