Cataloged Under Nothing

Horror

Written in response to: "Write a story where the line between myth and reality begins to blur." as part of Ancient Futures with Erin Young.

The first time Henry noticed it, he blamed exhaustion.

He’d been cataloging artifacts in the basement archive of the university museum for weeks, breathing in dust and handling objects no one had touched in decades. Most of it was routine. Clay shards, dull coins, fragments labeled with guesses more than facts.

Then there was the mask.

It was carved from dark wood, smooth in some places, splintered in others, as if it had been both carefully shaped and violently broken at the same time. The tag tied to it read simply- Origin unknown.

That wasn’t unusual. What was unusual was that Henry didn’t remember unpacking it.

He checked the log. No entry. No accession number. No paperwork.

“Someone must’ve missed it,” he muttered, though the system was tight. Things didn’t just appear.

He placed the mask on the long table under a soft overhead light and leaned in. The face carved into it wasn’t exaggerated or stylized like most ritual pieces. It looked… human. Not idealized. Not symbolic. Just human.

Too human.

Its eyes weren’t hollowed out evenly. One was slightly higher than the other. The mouth was parted just enough to suggest breath.

Henry stepped back.

“Okay,” he said quietly, as if the room were listening. “That’s enough for today.”

That night, he dreamed of a forest.

Not the kind you hike through on marked trails, but something older. Dense. Tangled. The air thick with the smell of damp earth and rot. He moved through it without knowing why, brushing past branches that seemed to lean toward him.

Somewhere ahead, something was watching.

He woke with the taste of dirt in his mouth.

The next day, the mask had changed.

Henry noticed it immediately, even before he turned on the lights fully. The angle was wrong. He was certain he’d left it facing the door, but now it was turned slightly toward the wall.

He stood still for a long moment.

“Very funny,” he said, though no one else had access to the archive at night.

He approached slowly, as if expecting it to react.

Up close, he saw something else.

The wood looked… damp.

He touched it.

It was warm.

Henry jerked his hand back.

“That’s not possible.”

Wood doesn’t hold warmth like that. Not in a cold basement. Not overnight.

He grabbed a thermometer from his kit and pressed it gently against the surface. The reading climbed. Thirty-two degrees Celsius. Human body temperature.

He laughed once, sharp and hollow.

“Okay. Equipment’s broken.”

He checked it against the table. Cold. Normal.

Against his own skin. Accurate.

Back to the mask.

Thirty-two.

By the end of the week, Henry stopped telling himself it was nothing.

The dreams came every night. The same forest, but deeper each time. The same feeling of being led somewhere, or drawn. And always, just out of sight, something moving parallel to him.

Watching.

Waiting.

During the day, small things shifted.

Objects not where he left them. Labels rewritten in handwriting that almost matched his own. Records in the system referencing artifacts he’d never seen, each tied to a single vague description. Wooden figure, origin unknown.

He printed one of the records and stared at it.

The acquisition date was listed as twenty years ago.

The signature approving it was his.

“Hey,” he said to Kim in the main office, trying to sound casual. “Quick question. That mask in storage — dark wood, kind of… unsettling?”

She frowned. “We’ve got hundreds of masks.”

“No, this one’s different. No origin listed.”

Kim shrugged. “If there’s no origin, it’s probably a replica or misfiled. Why?”

“You’ve never seen it?”

“Nope.”

Henry studied her face, looking for any hint she was joking.

There was none.

That night, the dream changed.

He reached a clearing.

At its center stood a figure.

It was wearing the mask.

Henry tried to move closer, but his feet wouldn’t cooperate. The ground felt soft, like it might give way beneath him.

The figure tilted its head.

Not mimicking him. Studying him.

Then, slowly, it lifted a hand and touched the mask.

And Henry felt fingers brush his own face.

He woke up gasping, clutching his cheeks.

His skin was warm. Too warm.

He didn’t go to work the next day.

Or the day after.

He stayed in his apartment, curtains drawn, trying to convince himself it would pass. Stress. Sleep deprivation. A mind filling in gaps.

But the mask followed him.

Not physically. He knew that.

But every reflective surface seemed just slightly off. Mirrors showed his face a fraction of a second too late. Windows reflected expressions he hadn’t made yet.

Once, he swore he saw wood grain beneath his skin.

On the fourth day, he went back.

The archive felt different.

Quieter.

He walked straight to the table.

The mask was gone.

In its place was a small card, neatly typed.

On display.

The exhibit hall was empty.

Henry's footsteps echoed as he moved through rows of artifacts, each carefully lit, each labeled and explained.

At the far end of the room, under a single spotlight, was the mask.

Mounted upright.

Facing outward.

Waiting.

He approached slowly, heart hammering.

The label beneath it read-

Wooden mask. Origin unknown.

Believed to represent a transitional entity — something that exists between states.

Material- organic composite.

Henry leaned closer.

There was a second line, smaller, almost an afterthought.

Current condition- active.

He swallowed.

“That’s not funny,” he whispered, though he didn’t know who he was speaking to.

The air around him felt thick.

He looked up at the mask.

Its mouth was open wider now.

He was sure of it.

“Okay,” Henry said, backing away. “Okay. I’m done. This isn’t—”

The lights flickered.

Just once.

But in that brief moment of darkness, Henry felt it.

Hands.

Not on his shoulders.

On his face.

Pressing.

Fitting.

When the lights steadied, the hall was empty.

The mask remained on display.

Unchanged.

Still.

But if someone had been there — if anyone had looked closely — they might have noticed something new.

A faint warmth in the wood.

A subtle asymmetry in the eyes.

And the smallest suggestion that the mouth was trying to form words.

Somewhere else, in a forest no map could find, something walked for the first time in a very long while.

It moved uncertainly, as if learning how to exist.

Its hands brushed against its face.

Tracing unfamiliar features.

Human features.

And in the distance, something watched from between the trees.

Waiting its turn.

Posted May 03, 2026
Share:

You must sign up or log in to submit a comment.

6 likes 4 comments

Katherine Howell
21:42 May 07, 2026

This was wonderfully unsettling in such a controlled and effective way. I really loved how the horror escalated through small details at first: the mask slightly changing position, the warmth of the wood, the rewritten labels, the delayed reflections, until reality itself began to feel unreliable. Those little moments built tension so well without needing anything overtly graphic or traditionally “scary.”

What I especially appreciated was that the horror felt deeply psychological. The story never rushed to explain everything, which made it far more unnerving. It created that creeping feeling that something was wrong long before the full implications became clear. The descriptions of the mask itself were fantastic too. The details about the uneven eyes, the mouth seeming to suggest breath, and the warmth of the wood immediately pulled me in from the first paragraph. The atmosphere throughout felt immersive and claustrophobic in the best way.

And the ending was genuinely chilling. I actually had to reread those final sections once everything clicked into place and I realized the implication that Henry was now trapped within the mask while something else had taken his place. That ambiguity especially with “something watched from between the trees, waiting its turn” was terrifying and really left that impression after finishing the story. Really well written and a perfectly unnerving premise and story!

Reply

Marjolein Greebe
16:00 May 07, 2026

Thanks for liking JUCHE, Rebecca—I really appreciate it. I always look forward to what you submit each week. It’s getting surprisingly close at the top, so I’m curious where it lands by the end of the week. :-)))))

Reply

Aaron Luke
14:58 May 05, 2026

Hey Rebecca,
This was another nice story that you made. You captured the weight of the prompt really well by blending the aesthetic of myth and reality, it is done very nice.
There's not much I can say since Marjolein has said it all.
Just continue writing

Reply

Marjolein Greebe
07:09 May 04, 2026

This one plays a longer game—and it pays off. The tension isn’t in what the mask is, but in how quietly it rewrites Henry’s reality until there’s nothing solid left to push against.

The strongest thread for me is the administrative decay: missing logs, altered labels, his own signature appearing where it shouldn’t. That’s where the story really sharpens—less horror as intrusion, more horror as replacement. By the time the exhibit card shows up, it feels earned rather than staged.

There are a few moments where the prose leans into naming the unease instead of letting it surface on its own. You don’t need that safety net. The warmth of the wood, the delayed reflections, the physicality of the dreams—those details already carry the weight.

And that final shift—Henry no longer in the room, but implied inside the object—is handled with restraint. No spectacle, just a quiet handover. That’s what makes it stick.

Reply

Reedsy | Default — Editors with Marker | 2024-05

Bring your publishing dreams to life

The world's best editors, designers, and marketers are on Reedsy. Come meet them.