IN HER SKIN

58 likes 80 comments

Fiction Mystery Thriller

Written in response to: "Write a story that keeps a key detail hidden from the reader until the very end." as part of Illusion or Reality?.

I met Ethan on a cold, rainy evening in a dimly lit bar-a tall, brooding man whose eyes hinted at untold stories. His presence was magnetic-an irresistible gravity that pulled me in before I could second-guess my instincts. I had only intended to explore my new neighborhood, maybe nurse a glass of wine before heading home, but the moment our eyes met, something shifted. It was as though fate had tethered us together, bound by an invisible thread of inevitability.

We talked for hours. His voice was rich, his laughter rare but intoxicating. He asked about my life, my dreams, my fears, and each time I answered, he looked at me as if my words held the key to something he had long been searching for. It felt like love at first sight-a dangerous delusion, but one I was willing to entertain.

The next day, I started my new job at Ravenwood Psychiatric Institute. My excitement curdled into dread when I saw Ethan standing at the entrance, dressed in a crisp white coat, speaking with authority to a group of interns. My pulse thundered in my ears. Ethan wasn't just anyone-he was my boss. And worse, he was married.

I tried to avoid him, to bury the spark before it could ignite, but Ethan made it impossible. His glances lingered, his touches were accidental yet deliberate. The restraint between us was paper-thin, and it wasn't long before we tore through it. Late-night rendezvous became our escape. Every whispered promise, every stolen moment, deepened my obsession with him.

"She's kind but fragile," he told me one night, his voice thick with something I mistook for regret. "Lillian has always been... delicate. Heavily medicated, lost in her own world. I can't leave her, not without breaking her completely."

I told myself I was different. That I could be the one to save him from the prison of his marriage. That love could justify anything. But something about Ethan unsettled me. His knowledge of the human mind extended far beyond the ordinary. His office wasn't just filled with paperwork and patient files-it was cluttered with medical textbooks, neurological studies, and obscure journals on cognitive manipulation.

Then, one afternoon, Lillian walked into the clinic. She was warm, easy to talk to, and genuinely kind-so different from what Ethan had described. Lonely and new in town, I welcomed her friendship. After all, I was her husband's personal assistant. We went to the gym together, joined women's groups, and she introduced me to her circle of friends.

She did have moments-episodes, almost-where she'd completely zone out. But I never questioned it. Ethan had told me she wasn't always okay. She was fragile. I never wanted to raise suspicions about my relationship with him, so I played along.

Eventually, I made the hardest decision of my life: I quit my job, cutting off both Ethan and Lillian.

One afternoon, while sorting through my laundry, I found something she had given me-a small piece of paper with a note scrawled across it: "Read this. It will help you understand but find me if it will be difficult."

Curiosity and guilt pushed me to see her one last time. When I arrived, she greeted me with a soft smile.

"I was wondering when you'd come," she said.

I confessed my affair with Ethan, expecting anger. But she only nodded. "I've known about his infidelities for years," she admitted. "That's why I take all these medications. If I confront him, he increases the dosage to make me sound crazy."

Despite everything, she still valued our friendship.

"You're the first real friend I've ever had," she whispered.

As a form of reconciliation, she asked me to try one of her spiritual exercises. "To connect," she said. "To understand each other beyond this world."

The room dimmed as we sat on the floor, knees touching.

"Close your eyes," she instructed. "Breathe deeply. Feel your spirit loosen."

At first, it was nothing. A moment of quiet. Then-I felt it. A strange pull, like something was unraveling inside me. My heart pounded. Dizziness washed over me.

I opened my eyes-

And screamed.

I wasn't in my body anymore. I was in hers.

Lillian had taken my body, slipping into my life with practiced ease. She moved with confidence, mimicking my gestures, my habits, my very essence as if she had been born into my skin.

"You'll need these," she said, pointing at the medication on the table, her voice eerily calm. "You're not well."

She dialed a number and whispered, "It's time."

Ethan entered, his gaze sweeping over me with something close to pity.

"She's having another episode," Lillian-in my body-said.

He sighed, shaking his head slowly. "I'm sorry, Lillian," he murmured.

A few hours later, I woke up chained in an experimental room. Ethan stood over me in his white coat.

I begged him to believe me.

He only smiled as he placed divorce papers in front of me.

I didn't even know Lillian's signature, yet somehow, the papers were signed, and the process was completed.

I felt a sharp sting as the syringe pierced my arm. As the sedative seeped in, Ethan whispered the last thing I would hear before darkness took me:

"You never really knew me, did you?"

The last thing I saw before the world faded was his smile and the signed divorce papers.

Five years later, Lillian-wearing my body-came to visit me.

"You were just unlucky," she said with a smirk. "You see, I'm a doctor too. Ethan and I have been running these experiments for years. Swapping identities. Testing human consciousness. It's all medical research, really. You were just... a fascinating subject."

"You ruined my life," I whispered.

She laughed softly. "Oh, sweetheart," she murmured. "I didn't ruin it. I just... took it."

She turned to leave. "Take your meds. They help with the delusions."

I watched her go, my own face disappearing down the sterile hallway.

No one would ever believe me.

So now, I write.

It's the only thing they allow me, the only proof I can leave behind. Maybe someone will read my words and finally understand. Maybe someone will warn the next victim.

All this because of desire for a married man.

Men will leave you in the desert without water.

Poor next victim!

Posted Feb 22, 2025
Share:

You must sign up or log in to submit a comment.

58 likes 80 comments

Martin Ross
March 03, 2025 16:41

Great use of the prompt with a vivid setup and dark twist (love that ending metaphor), and with your bio, I just know you have SO many stories to tell. There are a few structural style things, and I think the ending might be even more effective taking off “Poor next victim!” and leaving it with that desert analogy, but your writing and voice are rock-solid. Welcome to Reedsy — I hope you have as much fun as I have!!

Reply

Waeni S
March 03, 2025 21:18

Thank you so much, Martin! I really appreciate your thoughtful feedback and kind words. I’m excited to share more stories and grow as a writer here on Reedsy. Looking forward to having as much fun as you do!

Reply

Martin Ross
March 03, 2025 21:22

It’s a difficult world here in the States, these days, and this takes me away for a bit. Enjoy!

Reply

Waeni S
March 03, 2025 21:24

Im from kenya trust me its not any easier😂

Reply

Martin Ross
March 03, 2025 21:44

My best wishes are with you!🙂

Reply

Waeni S
March 03, 2025 22:07

Gracias

Reply

Sophie Trevelean
March 03, 2025 12:07

Well I wasn’t expecting that. A great story with a great twist and I was really drawn in from the start. Well done!

Reply

Waeni S
March 03, 2025 12:41

Aaaawww truly greatful🙏🏾

Reply

March 10, 2025 06:32

Married man, a jigsaw puzzle. Whoever, trapped in it, was destroyed .

Reply

Waeni S
March 17, 2025 14:35

Scary right!

Reply

Shirley Medhurst
March 07, 2025 17:27

Wow! Amazing story with a hell of an unexpected twist! Well done 👏

Reply

Shirley Medhurst
March 07, 2025 17:30

BTW I agree with Martin’s comment about not needing the last line…. I think it would be a much stronger ending without 😁

Reply

Waeni S
March 07, 2025 18:56

Yes you are right hoping for the best next time💚

Reply

Waeni S
March 07, 2025 18:56

Thank you soo much 💚I really appreciate 💚💚

Reply

Kylie Wallis
March 06, 2025 04:31

Wow I did not see that coming, such an intriguing story. I'm looking forward to reading more of what you post. :)

Reply

Waeni S
March 06, 2025 05:05

Thank you soo much i well love your stories too!!

Reply

Bruno Mazuryszyn
March 05, 2025 06:46

Wow, this story had me hooked from start to finish! The suspense, the emotions, and the twists were all so well done. I could really feel the tension building, and the way you described everything made it so vivid. Amazing work—congrats on such a great piece!

Reply

Waeni S
March 05, 2025 06:54

What a beautiful morning to read this. Thank you Bruno.

Reply

Graham Kinross
March 05, 2025 00:26

This is twisted. It feels like something from X-files. There was a subplot in the Netflix version of Dirk Gently about a cult that was possessing people a bit like this. Fascinating.

Reply

Waeni S
March 05, 2025 01:07

Thanks for checking out my story! I’m so glad you found it intriguing. I love weaving in surreal, mind-bending elements, and it means a lot that you shared your thoughts 🫶🏾

Reply

Graham Kinross
March 05, 2025 01:32

You’re welcome Waeni. What inspired it?

Reply

Waeni S
March 05, 2025 04:01

I wholeheartedly recommend checking out “Behind Her Eyes” on Netflix. It’s a captivating psychological thriller that will have you questioning every twist and turn long after the credits roll. With its clever blend of suspense, mystery, and unexpected revelations, it’s a must-watch Graham tht’s my inspiration 😌

Reply

Graham Kinross
March 05, 2025 05:27

You should be paid for that review. I’ll have a look. What are your usual genres?

Reply

Waeni S
March 05, 2025 06:01

Im an actress, so I have commitment issues… with genres! One day I’m into mind-bending thrillers, the next I’m sobbing over a rom-com. I wear characters for a living, so I don’t discriminate—I’ll take them all😭😂I recently found out i could be a writer but I think its same category and im happy to be here

Reply

Patrick M
March 04, 2025 22:57

Very Impressive Wow For A first timer its definitely something great. Welcome to reedsy!

Reply

Waeni S
March 05, 2025 00:03

I do appreciate 🙏🏾

Reply

A Elizabeth
March 04, 2025 22:18

Wow that was spectacular storytelling! Did not see that coming!

Reply

Waeni S
March 05, 2025 04:08

Audrey, I truly appreciate you! Your stories captivated me, and your talent with the pen is nothing short of inspiring. Congratulations on all your incredible achievements!

Reply

A Elizabeth
March 05, 2025 14:18

Thank you Waeni! You are too kind!

Reply

Miles Gatling
March 04, 2025 18:07

I like it like Forest likes Jenny!

Reply

Waeni S
March 04, 2025 21:56

That is definitely the sweetest comparison🫶🏾

Reply

Gian Marco Oasi
March 04, 2025 17:30

A short but very intense story, sensual but like the touch of a gentle hand, masterfully written, fast , nervous, truly worthy of a grest pen.

Gian Marco

Reply

Waeni S
March 04, 2025 21:54

Thank you so much Marco🙏🏾

Reply

Kevin Keegan
March 04, 2025 14:54

I was caught off guard by the twist which was really clever and unexpected. Great story.

Reply

Waeni S
March 04, 2025 15:32

Aaaawww thank you so much Kevin🫶🏾

Reply

Jude Wandaka
March 04, 2025 14:32

I knew you were a talented writer, but this book blew me away! Your creativity and attention to detail are remarkable. I can’t wait to see what you write next!☺️🫡

Reply

Waeni S
March 04, 2025 14:44

Thank you, Jude! It means a lot that you took the time to check out my work😌

Reply

Bleu Barb
March 04, 2025 13:02

Well, I'm still awe from the plot twist. Pure talent if you ask me. So creative we all expected a different ending but events took a turn,I love it!!

Reply

Waeni S
March 04, 2025 13:44

Wow, that means so much to me! I love keeping readers on their toes, and I’m so glad the twist took you by surprise. Thank you for your kind words and for appreciating my creativity! ❤️

Reply

Beverly WK
March 04, 2025 10:09

I really like it when a writer shifts the genre out of nowhere.Like you thought you knew what was going to happen but it doesn't turn out how you expected it to be and for that,i'll give you a solid 10! The intensity of the final few paragraphs kept me at the edge of the chair wondering how the turn of events would unfold😅This is my first time reading a psychological thriller with a supernatural aspect but it definitely won't be my last! I really enjoyed this. All the best💗🇰🇪

Reply

Waeni S
March 04, 2025 13:43

Wow, thank you so much! I’m really glad you enjoyed the twist and that it kept you on edge! It means a lot that this was your first time reading a psychological thriller with a supernatural aspect, and I’m honored it left an impression on you.

Reply

Sari Lu
March 04, 2025 09:56

The twist was mind-blowing!", "I never saw that coming!", "Such a clever twist, completely changed my perspective on the story.i loved it fr

Reply

Waeni S
March 04, 2025 10:02

Im so glad honestly thank you so much🙏🏾

Reply

Pink Lotus
March 04, 2025 08:52

I enjoyed the whole book, the plot twist wasn't some cliché. You really captured the audience but I don't really care for the last three sentences, they take away the great vocabulary we saw through out the book

Reply

Waeni S
March 04, 2025 08:57

Haha so you’re saying my story had an elite vocabulary until the last three sentences? Not me running out of words at the finish line! But seriously, I appreciate your feedback—maybe I’ll add a plot twist right at the end just for you 🫶🏽

Reply

Whitney Weringa
March 04, 2025 08:49

The way you built suspense and then delivered that twist at the end!!!...Such an incredible read😍!!!

Reply

Waeni S
March 04, 2025 09:00

Im sooo glad you enjoyed it all this means alot 😭🫶🏽

Reply

Denzel T.
March 04, 2025 07:17

Just reminded me of Saltburn. The plot twist is jaw-dropping,you were given an inch, and you took a mile. For starters, you deserve your tens.

Reply

Waeni S
March 04, 2025 08:34

Wow, Saltburn-level plot twist?That’s such an amazing comparison—thank you! I really wanted the twist to leave an impact, so it means a lot that you found it jaw-dropping.

Reply

Seleyian Leison
March 04, 2025 06:45

It was a rather thrilling read. The plot twist was entirely new. It reminded me of the series behind her eyes to a point.

Reply

Waeni S
March 04, 2025 06:47

Thrilled that you found it thrilling! I wanted the twist to feel fresh—glad it worked!

Reply

Valeria Kerubo
March 04, 2025 03:48

I loved the psychological thriller element it had me hooked from the start. It reminds me of Freida McFadden, my favorite author. I won't lie, you completely got me with that plot twist. I thought it was heading toward some cliché love story, but wow, it was so much more. Overall, it was an amazing read.

Reply

Waeni S
March 04, 2025 05:07

Wow, thank you so much! That means a lot, especially coming from someone who loves Freida McFadden. I’m so glad the plot twist got you! I really wanted to break away from the usual love story tropes and surprise the reader. Your words truly made my day!

Reply

Ron Hollands
March 03, 2025 21:08

Incredible , gripping - high quality I couldn’t let it go!

Reply

Waeni S
March 03, 2025 21:21

Thank you I really appreciate your support🙏🏾

Reply

March 03, 2025 21:06

This story is incredibly gripping, blending psychological horror with elements of betrayal and identity theft in a way that feels both chilling and tragically plausible. One of its greatest strengths is how it builds tension—starting with an innocent act of trust, only to unravel into a nightmare of manipulation and deception. The protagonist's slow realization of their fate is executed masterfully, creating a sense of helplessness that lingers long after reading.

Reply

Waeni S
March 03, 2025 21:23

Thank you, Giovanni! I’m really glad you found it gripping—though I seriously hope this never happens in real life! 😂 Your detailed feedback means a lot!

Reply

Atlas Gray
March 03, 2025 13:31

I loved the turn the story took. Wonderfully written, I really enjoyed it. Welcome to Reedsy and thank you for sharing this story!

Reply

Waeni S
March 03, 2025 13:47

Grateful doesn’t even begin to cover it—thank you for all the love and support, Cedar. I truly appreciate you!

Reply

Ken Cartisano
March 02, 2025 22:40

Your writing is excellent. I really enjoyed this story and the way you wrote it. Great description of the chemistry and mechanics of seduction. In certain ways, it is very much like an invisible and inevitable force.

I have three (3) suggestions that are straightforward and would improve this story. Someone already mentioned number 1. If this were my story, I'd be pretty proud of it, but I would do the following:

1. When using a dash between words, use the m dash. It's the longer of the dashes. I just hit the dash key twice and it gets changed to a longer dash. Or, simply leave a space before and after the dash. You have to figure out how your software works and change a setting. It took me several abandoned attempts until I finally figured out how to make Word do this.

2. 'his touches were accidental but deliberate.' Accidental is the opposite of deliberate, therefore you need to change the word 'accidental.' His touches were subtle, but deliberate. As soon as I read that I thought, 'that's impossible.'

3. Delete the last three sentences. They're your favorite lines, right? Get rid of them, they suck. Don't sum up your stories at the end.

This is the end of your story right here:

So now I write. It's the only thing they allow me, the only proof I can leave behind. Maybe someone will read my words and finally understand. Maybe someone will warn the next victim.

It's the story's last paragraph. I like how you separated 'So now I write.' I would do that too, for emphasis. 'It's the only thing they allow me...' That's good too. Even the sentence with 'the only proof I have'. Not really accurate, but as soon as I read it I knew what you meant. I think it's just the last two sentences.

She wants someone to 'believe her'. and Instead of 'maybe someone will warn' it should be 'Maybe my words will serve as a warning to others.' You almost slipped out of first person P.O.V. in admittedly, what I think, should be your last two sentences.

That's it. There ain't another thing wrong with this story. It has no typos, none that I could find. (Except for the hyphen-thing, but that's not a typo.)

I noticed that you immediately followed about a hundred and twenty five people. Myself included. I don't know how long you've been writing, but this is a good first post. It's first-person, fast-paced, intriguing, and very well written until the last few paragraphs. In fact, there are a lot of great lines in this story that deserve mention:

I met Ethan on a cold, rainy evening in a dimly lit bar - a tall, brooding man whose eyes hinted at untold stories. (That is one hell of an opening sentence.')

The more I think about this story the more impressed I am. I hope you find my advice useful. I usually try to take my own advice as well, but I (as you can see) don't always succumb to my more noble instincts. I'll follow you though. I'm intrigued enough to see what you got.

Reply

Waeni S
March 03, 2025 00:02

I appreciate the feedback so much! This is my first submission, and I’m determined to keep learning for my future growth. Your honesty means a lot. I’ll keep pushing forward!

Reply

RBE | Illustrated Short Stories | 2024-06

Bring your short stories to life

Fuse character, story, and conflict with tools in Reedsy Studio. All for free.