A New Normal

Contemporary Fiction

This story contains sensitive content

Written in response to: "Set your story at an event (a party, séance, funeral, etc.) where something goes wrong." as part of A Fright to Remember.

CW: Themes of and/or references to gun violence, sexual assault, and abortion

A New Normal

They giggle and touch up their makeup in the smudged mirror of the crowded restroom. Too young for their low-cut shirts and glossy red lipstick, but old enough that their parents trust them to attend the concert unchaperoned. The girls have attended all four of the pop star's previous performances in their small town. By now, it's practically a tradition.

They emerge from the restroom holding hands and make their way through hordes of screaming fans. They take dozens of selfies, laughing at their own exaggerated poses. When the lights go dark, the audience erupts, and the stage comes alive with their idol strutting under the spotlights, strumming a guitar and singing into a microphone glittering with rhinestones. The girls wave their arms, mesmerized. They've memorized every word of every song since her first single was released.

The noise is deafening. All faces are turned toward the stage, thousands of voices singing the same familiar lyrics. At the rear of the concert hall, the doors open slowly, and a man walks in with a gun.

*

It's a hot and sticky Sunday morning, but the congregation sits remarkably still, as though any unnecessary movement might invite admonishment from God himself. The women bow their heads in prayer, their bare shoulders covered by scarves. The men face forward, stiff as boards, occasionally receiving a discreet nudge from a wife whenever their eyelids begin to droop. Children fidget in the pews, and the occasional baby's cry is quickly silenced by a pacifier or a hurried retreat to the vestibule.

Sacraments and guilt are sprinkled about like holy water. The priest delivers a lengthy homily on forgiveness, and the congregation nods along, some listening intently, others calculating how much longer until lunch. When it's time for the final hymn, everyone stands with renewed enthusiasm. The familiar words pour from them, their voices rising toward the vaulted ceiling in a weekly release of worries, obligations, and sins.

An elderly woman near the back closes her eyes, swaying gently as she sings. Beside her, her grandson studies the colored sunlight spilling through the stained-glass windows, wondering why the saints always look so unhappy. She squeezes his hand, and he smiles up at her.

The congregation sings louder as the organ swells. No one notices when the heavy doors at the back of the church push open, and a man enters with a gun.

*

They show up at the Dragon Diner on the strip around one in the morning, just as the dance club up the street closes. The waitress loves these regulars, with the sparkle of strobe lights and freedom still dancing in their eyes. Excellent tippers and hilarious company, they shed boa feathers on the vinyl booths and leave glitter everywhere, like a busted fairy. When they flounce in wearing size ten heels and makeup the waitress couldn't dream of pulling off, she welcomes them as though they are royalty.

She's married with children, but these night birds have become like family. She doesn’t mind when they take over the diner, helping with the cooking and cleaning. They dance to Cyndi Lauper's Girls Just Want to Have Fun on the jukebox and have enough gossip to sustain a podcast for years. Occasionally, they pull the waitress onto their makeshift dance floor between the counter and the booths, and she laughs until her sides ache.

By two in the morning, it's closing time. Some are beginning to sport five o'clock shadows, which they mock mercilessly. The waitress thinks fondly of her husband, sound asleep at home.

Someone drops more coins into the jukebox for one last song, and Queen's We Are the Champions fills the diner. The waitress joins in the chorus from behind the counter, waving a dish towel like a freedom flag. They're laughing so joyously that no one hears the bell above the door. Nor do they see the man who enters with a gun.

*

At sixteen, she is raped.

When she discovers she's pregnant, she tells no one. She's earned a college scholarship, and her acceptance letter remains tucked beneath her mattress, where she takes it out sometimes just to reassure herself that another life is waiting.

She finds an underfunded clinic that's perpetually on the verge of closing its doors. The building is old, the waiting room crowded with women of different ages, and the magazines are several years out of date. Some sit alone, staring at their hands. Others whisper to companions or scroll through their phones. She wonders about their lives, the circumstances that brought them here, the stories they'll tell afterward, or perhaps never tell at all.

When her name is called, she follows a nurse down a narrow hallway, frightened by how quickly everything is happening. The medical professionals are kind and patient. They explain the procedure, answer her questions, and reassure her when her voice begins to break. It's much more invasive than she imagined, and she finds herself staring at the ceiling, counting the tiny cracks in the plaster.

Afterward, she's told to remain in the waiting area for thirty minutes before leaving.

Her eyes settle on a black-and-white photograph hanging on the far wall. A mother cradles her baby, whose tiny hand is wrapped around her ring finger. The tenderness of the image makes her throat tighten. She hopes that will be her someday. Just not today.

Still a little woozy, she leans back in her chair and shuts her eyes. Behind her, a man walks in with a gun.

*

The Pledge of Allegiance is followed by morning announcements. The kindergartners and first graders are preparing for their holiday assembly, an annual celebration involving paper snowflakes, off-key singing, and an enthusiastic interpretation of Jingle Bells performed on plastic instruments.

The seasoned teachers have spent months teaching their students to move quietly through the hallways. They've even developed a simple system of hand signals that the children have learned with remarkable ease. Little brains are like sponges, and these teachers, wonderful educators in every sense, know how to make even the smallest child feel capable of something important.

Today, the children are dressed in their holiday finest. There are red velvet dresses, crooked bow ties, Santa hats, and enough light-up sneakers to illuminate the hallway whenever someone takes a step. One little girl wears a reindeer antler headband that keep sliding over her eyes. The boy beside her holds her hand.

The teachers smile as they shepherd their charges toward the auditorium; the children's excitement is contagious. As someone in the main office begins calling the older grades to the assembly, popping sounds come over the intercom, accompanied by screams. The intercom goes silent. From somewhere near the front entrance comes the unmistakable sound of pounding footsteps.

The teachers exchange glances. Their expressions change so quickly that the children barely notice. One reaches for the nearest classroom door while another quietly directs the children to sit against the wall. Another teacher raises her hand, fingers pressed together in the familiar signal for silence.

The children don't understand what's happening. They know only that their teachers have asked them to be quiet, and they are trying their very best. The teachers understand all too well what is happening.

At this idyllic little elementary school, a man has entered with a gun.

*

The courtroom buzzes with anticipation. Every seat is occupied, and people stand shoulder to shoulder along the back wall. Another courtroom, another active shooter on trial, another group of grieving loved ones whose lives have been irrevocably changed. They clutch photographs, tissues, and one another's hands. Reporters crowd the designated benches, their notebooks open, their cameras ready.

The defendant sits beside his attorney, staring at the polished surface of the table. He's young and handsome, with neatly combed hair and a face that might once have appeared on a college ID or a driver's license. Nothing about his appearance suggests the horror that has brought so many people into this room. The jury has already delivered its verdict. The judge is now prepared to pronounce the sentence.

Life in prison. Not the death penalty. The gallery erupts. The judge pounds his gavel, its sharp cracks swallowed by the pandemonium. Reporters scribble furiously. Cameras flash. Families in the gallery cling to each other, devastated that the punishment will never feel sufficient.

The defendant remains seated, his hands folded in his lap as if in relief. His attorney whispers something, but he just shrugs. The courtroom is so loud that no one notices the rear doors opening.

There is shock, but certainly no surprise, when a mother pushes through the crowd with a gun.

Posted Oct 29, 2026
Share:

You must sign up or log in to submit a comment.

45 likes 39 comments

Graham Kinross
November 04, 2026 00:52

No one anywhere should ever experience anything like this. And it should never be normal. Great story about such a grim subject.

Reply

Elizabeth Hoban
November 04, 2026 00:54

A sad commentary indeed - thank you for the read and support! Always appreciated. x

Reply

Graham Kinross
November 04, 2026 05:15

You're welcome.

Reply

Antonio Briseno
October 29, 2026 20:35

My one critique of your past few stories was that you don't take enough risks with your writing. BUT MAN was I wrong! Not only is this a risk, but you pulled it off with ease. SO so good. The flip at the end where the mother is the one with a gun, caught me off guard, great writing.

Every week I write something, and I legitimately think, "this is the week I out-write Elizabeth," then I come read your story.

Haha, well earned. Powerful message. Please keep taking risks, more of this!

Reply

Elizabeth Hoban
October 29, 2026 21:06

What a huge compliment, Antonio! Risky writing is something I will definitely consider going forward, and I appreciate the constructive criticism. x

Reply

Hazel Swiger
November 04, 2026 03:59

This was just insane, Elizabeth. I - honestly - have read very few stories that leave such a lingering impact on me as this one did. This genuinely, literally left me without words. This was such a wonderfully crafted story about a very hard, gruesome subject, but I just applaud you for bringing light to it. This needs to be read by every single person, ever. And I don't mean that in a superficial way. This story just genuinely left that great of a lasting impact. This one will be staying in my head for a while, I am sure of it. Just amazing, and it took guts to write about something like this, well, unfortunately normal, yet it is of absolute disgust that it is normal. Just stunning work, Elizabeth. Truly stunning.

Reply

Elizabeth Hoban
November 04, 2026 13:48

Wow - thank you so much, Helen! Means so much coming from you. I appreciate the read and thoughtful comments. x

Reply

James Brandt
November 03, 2026 19:15

I always love reading your stories. I can see that as always you meticulously present elements in a well-thought out manner.

Reply

Elizabeth Hoban
November 03, 2026 23:02

Thank you so much, James! I appreciate your support and kind words, as always. x

Reply

Ron Sewell
November 03, 2026 13:26

From having fun or enjoying life to a man with a gun intent on destruction.

I want to ask why but I doubt if anyone including the shrinks actually know the answer.

The mother with the gun is out for retribution/revenge/ payment. I understand her and wish her well but the killing still goes on. why?. An interesting but disturbing well written tale of horror.

Reply

Elizabeth Hoban
November 03, 2026 14:36

Thank you so much for the read and comment - I was almost tempted to tag it as creative nonfiction but then changed my mind. I appreciate your thoughtful review. x

Reply

Maxwell Pacilio
November 02, 2026 14:13

Incredible. After reading this I have literal chills. The title itself takes on a haunting meaning. A New Normal, but not a good normalm. The sheer amount of different scenarios you present that should be moments of peace at the very least, joyful for some, contrasted by this new normal of shopters is genius. It really is unfortunate that many real situations happen like this all over the world, but particularly in America where our gun violence is the new normal. Well written!

Reply

Elizabeth Hoban
November 02, 2026 14:25

Thank you so much! I appreciate the support. x

Reply

Luke Hopkins
November 01, 2026 17:22

Wow. This is intense in the best and most devastating way possible. The pacing of it is so well done; the building dread as the reader knows what's about to happen at the end of every part, but can't stop is particularly powerful.
I think the way you pieced this together with the ending is what seals this as a great story to me. The mother walking in with a gun makes me split. It feels like justice, even though it perpetuates what's been happening. It feels wrong, even though it brings a twisted satisfaction.

This was a painful read, but I think you did a masterful job. Thank you for your story, I'll be thinking about this one for a long time.

Reply

Elizabeth Hoban
November 01, 2026 23:25

Thank you so much, Luke - means a lot coming from you!! x

Reply

November 05, 2026 01:12

I found this story to be very interesting since we had a school shooting in Bend, Oregon about two weeks ago. As a retired teacher this shooting really got to me since I was a special education teacher in a classroom like the teacher who was killed. I found your story cut close to the horrible reality. This type of thing needs a voice that you provided very effectively. Thank you, Elizabeth.

Reply

Dakota Snow
October 31, 2026 23:31

Devastating. The sequence of different settings and scenarios is such an effective way to demonstrate the senselessness of the violence. And I love the choice to leave out any description of the violence that is implied by the gunman entering the scene. Really impactful, and unfortunately relevant. Painful to read, but powerfully written.

Reply

Elizabeth Hoban
October 31, 2026 23:34

Thank you so much! I appreciate your lovely comments albeit a sad topic. x

Reply

Tania Bardsley
October 31, 2026 21:11

Wow, such innocent scenes then death walks in unnoticed.
Powerful writing - lovely and wholesome contrasting with sinister monstrosity.
Well done!

Reply

Elizabeth Hoban
October 31, 2026 21:28

Thank you so much! I appreciate your support. x

Reply

Michael Breton
October 31, 2026 19:24

I think the key to the effectiveness of this story is how you captured the day-to-day plainness of most people's lives. We don't live continual moments of high drama and tension, but, rather, are like "the little boy in church who wonders why all the saints looked so sad". A genius line if ever there was one. The final sentence hit with enough power to light a small town. A story that needs to be read, then read again. -M

Reply

Elizabeth Hoban
October 31, 2026 19:56

Wow - such a heartfelt review. Thank you so much, Michael. x

Reply

Scott Speck
October 31, 2026 15:02

What a tragic tale. Happy event after event ends with mass violence and death. The school scene was the most terrifying. Unnervingly true to life. The mother with a gun wasn't scary for me. She was an avenging angel. Great work!

Reply

Elizabeth Hoban
October 31, 2026 15:46

Thank you so much, Scott! x

Reply

Marjolein Greebe
October 30, 2026 14:10

“They know only that their teachers have asked them to be quiet, and they are trying their very best.”

That sentence broke my heart, Elizabeth. The children's innocence makes the horror almost unbearable. And what a clever, devastating use of repetition: we know exactly what's coming, yet somehow keep hoping it won't. Then you change just one word in the final scene, and suddenly the victim becomes the perpetrator. No graphic violence needed. You've made the reader supply all of it. Powerful writing.

Reply

Elizabeth Hoban
October 30, 2026 14:29

Thank you so much Marjolein! I appreciate the read and comment! x

Reply

Rebecca Lewis
October 30, 2026 13:39

I think this is a powerful piece. What got me wasn't just the gun violence, but how you made me care about the people before anything happened to them. They're just living their lives, having fun, going to church, spending time with friends, or trying to make it through the day. Then everything changes. I loved the little details. The waitress waving her dish towel, the grandmother holding her grandson's hand, and those little kids trying so hard to be quiet because their teachers told them to. That school scene got to me. You don't even have to describe what happens next because the reader already knows what could happen, and that's heartbreaking enough. I also thought the repetition worked well. After the first couple of scenes, I knew what was coming, but I still dreaded it every time. I think that's part of what makes this so effective. It shows how something horrific can happen anywhere, to anyone, when they least expect it. I liked the courtroom ending, too. Having a mother walk in with a gun instead of another man was an interesting twist. It made me think about how grief and anger can push someone toward the very violence that destroyed their own life. I think this is well done. It's emotional without being dramatic, and the fact that you never show the violence makes it even more disturbing. You make us see these people as human beings first, not just potential victims. And I think that's what makes the whole thing hit so hard.

Reply

Elizabeth Hoban
October 30, 2026 13:45

What an awesome review! Thank you so very much and I believe you got what I was aiming for in the end - forcing someone to do the same thing that destroyed their own life. I very much appreciate this thoughtful comment! x

Reply

October 30, 2026 08:05

I really liked how you captured the beauty of ordinary life. Through small details and carefully observed moments, you made each scene feel real and relatable. The surprising twist at the end of each scene was beautifully executed. By capturing everyday moments and building a sense of safety and normalcy, you made the sudden intrusions of violence all the more powerful. Ending the story with “mother” instead of the expected man with a gun was especially striking, letting us reconsider the story’s themes on a more intimate, personal level. Great work!

Reply

Elizabeth Hoban
October 30, 2026 13:48

Thank you so very much, Veronika! Always love your comments. x

Reply

October 31, 2026 10:56

You're welcome.

Reply

Alex Merola
October 29, 2026 16:50

Elizabeth, WOW! I don't know how to compliment you any more than WOW! You write about the horror of the human condition using the reality of its existence. The last line of each section, "...with a gun" is mesmerizing. I love your style of writing and all of your stories but for me "A New Normal" is unsurpassed. As always thank you for an excellent read.

Reply

Elizabeth Hoban
October 29, 2026 17:00

Wow right back at you, Alex! Thank you so much for such a wonderful review! x

Reply

Lois Edwards
October 29, 2026 11:57

Wow. This is a sombre symphony of the horror that hides beneath the ordinary. Even though I knew what was coming it still managed to shock me everytime - much like the unfortunate feeling you get when you read the news nowadays. This is such a beautiful yet devasting piece, well done.

Reply

Elizabeth Hoban
October 29, 2026 12:22

Thank you so much, Lois! x

Reply

Jim LaFleur
October 29, 2026 07:14

The warmth you build in every ordinary moment makes that haunting shift hit all the harder. Unforgettable work, Elizabeth.

Reply

Elizabeth Hoban
October 29, 2026 09:43

Thank you, Jim! x

Reply

Isabella Street
October 29, 2026 00:15

Once again, you have blown this prompt out of the water! Everyday occurrences without describing any real violence - but we all know this has become par for the course around the world. Love it and hate it for all the right reasons!

Reply

Elizabeth Hoban
October 29, 2026 00:21

Thank you as always, my friend! x

Reply

RBE | Illustrated Short Stories | 2024-06

Bring your short stories to life

Fuse character, story, and conflict with tools in Reedsy Studio. All for free.