Sasha waited on the concrete platform as two dull headlights cut through the fog. The wheels rasped along the rails toward him, growing louder as they neared, the wagons rattling, until a long, grinding hiss of air escaped as the train shuddered to a stop next to him. He breathed in the coal and fumes rising from beneath the wagons, then started down the platform, hammer in hand, tapping each wheel.
Tak.
Tak.
Tak.
Sasha was an odd man by everyone else’s estimation, though in his own mind the real problem was people. Always people.
Each wheel got the same two taps, and the sound told him everything he needed to know. Most days he spent more time at Leningradsky Station than in his own apartment. The never-ending arrivals and departures, the steady flow of work was what his sobriety needed. Unlike people, the station never changed.
After his inspection was completed, he spotted the notice taped crookedly to the wall of his closet-like office: “Train 09, Kirov to Perm — delayed for maintenance.” He stood reading it, actually relieved. It was well past noon; he was tired from the overnight work and decided to take the bus home.
The bus was already packed, no seats available, so he pushed his way to the far back window. A man several centimeters from his face yawned as he clumsily gripped the rail and the air hung thick with the weight of the man’s hangover, a smell that lived in the back of Sasha’s throat even after four sober years.
Without warning, he was somewhere else entirely.
Not the bus. The smell.
The nausea, his shaking hands and then the vomit.
Then the sound of his father’s voice.
The strange smell of his breath when he came home.
The swish of the whip and the crack of impact.
The key in the lock.
The bus closed in around him. Even the window offered no escape. Mud streaked the glass, leaving him with only a warped reflection of his own face.
His heart raced. His breaths came short and shallow. He counted slowly, trying to keep anyone from noticing. Sweat gathered on his brow. Then the brakes shrieked. The bus lurched to a stop, sending the standing passengers stumbling into one another.
Sasha was done. He pushed through the bodies and lunged toward the street before the conductor finished yelling about another bus coming shortly. Outside, he bent over with his hands on his knees and pulled in the air, grateful for it even with the diesel fumes.
“Breathe… breathe,” Sasha whispered.
He stayed there until his body began to settle.
Standing there on the curb, Sasha thought of his babushka Maria. She had sold sunflower seeds along one of these very streets. She knew everyone who passed her corner—the mechanic, the baker, the town drunk. Knowing people was her business.
She’d poke him in the side with her cane.
“Sasha, look up. Not everyone is your father. Life is passing.”
He was still turning the question over when he heard it: laughter with something cruel in its tone.
Near a wooden fence, two men stood over an elderly man, one of them grinding a muddy boot into his back, trying to force his face into a puddle.
“Take a sip, you homeless dog! Maybe there’s some dog piss to flavor it up!” The man ground his foot deeper into the old man.
“Drink it,” the other said, kicking water up into his face.
A woman with shopping bags slowed, glanced toward the men, then hurried on. A few meters away, a young couple stopped. They looked concerned but made no move to help. Sasha then stepped forward before he could think better of it, and the moment his presence registered, the two men left without a word; they continued yelling insults as they walked away.
Mud streaked down the old man’s face as he struggled upright. His wild black-and-gray beard had a matching set of eyebrows, both spattered with mud. There was a kindness in the man’s face Sasha couldn’t help but notice.
He helped him to his feet. He wobbled, then steadied, and brushed some of the grit off his coat.
“Thank you, my dear son. Thank you. Do you mind telling me the time?”
The question caught Sasha off guard. Why would he care, after what had just happened to him?
“It’s one minute to three. Are you… are you okay?”
A mischievous smirk spread across the old man’s face, and then his whole countenance shifted into something brighter.
“Well, you see, my son, it’s my three o’clock tradition. The best time of day for me. The time when we used to sing together.”
He then bowed, formally, as if acknowledging Sasha as his audience.
“Welcome to my daily ritual,” he continued, grinning as if he’d been waiting all day to say it.
The question rose: who had he sung with and where? Before Sasha was able to speak, the man raised a clear glass bottle, full to the brim with vodka, and began to hum, his eyes darting around as if playing to a much larger crowd than one. He swayed, rhythmically, holding the bottle above his head as he turned in a slow circle. Sasha bit his lip, fighting back laughter. Yet he could tell by the way the man hummed that a voice far grander must live inside this shabby old man.
The old man stopped moving, lowered the bottle to his side, and for a moment said nothing.
Then he began to sing. Sasha at once forgot the bottle, the filth, and the people walking past. His voice climbed with a richness and beauty that made Sasha’s heart ache.
One woman paused, leaned over, and whispered to Sasha. “Such talent,” she said, shaking her head at the man. “A voice like that, wasted on the streets. A disgrace!”
Only then did Sasha realize his face was wet, the warmth of tears sliding down. As he continued, others stopped to listen, a few tossed coins in his direction.
Sasha took two steps back, embarrassed at himself. He quickly placed a few rubles down and then backed away before the song finished, giving him only a polite nod.
That day, Sasha gave him a name of his own — the Opera Man — easier, somehow, than asking for the real one.
**
For the next few months, Sasha heard his voice, never failing, always rising at exactly three o’clock. He began to look forward to that hour and loved hearing the old man’s voice somehow rise above the city noise below. It didn’t matter that Sasha lived in a concrete high-rise on the tenth floor — that voice found its way to even those heights.
At times, a small circle of people gathered around him, laughing and cheering him on. On one occasion, he became a human statue, standing perfectly still while pigeons settled around him, even on his head. Then, without warning, he pulled out his bottle and let out his first note, sending the flock scurrying wildly in every direction. Some people clapped, while a few yelled at him for being a public nuisance.
There were days when no one gathered. He performed anyway to the pigeons, to the empty street, to whoever might be listening from a window above, even on a few occasions to a statue of Lenin.
“You had your revolution,” he whispered, patting the statue’s boot. “I have my three o’clock.”
He smiled and placed his empty bottle at its foot, and then gave his customary bow.
One babushka was not a fan. She shook her cane at him whenever she got the chance, her face scrunched in a scowl at the very sight of him. One day, he reached into his coat and produced a red rose, singing lowly a familiar song. A child passing with his mother immediately joined in, singing the next line before his mother shushed him. Her expression slowly softened, just this once, into a reluctant smile.As he extended it, his sleeve slipped back.
On the inside of his forearm was a cheap ink tattoo that looked self-made. Dates. “My beloved Dima.” Sasha opened his mouth to ask, but hesitated.
He looked away before he could read the years between them, distracted, not for the first time, by the way the Opera Man’s hands trembled.
Still every day at three o’clock his voice rose.
***
One day, anxious to get home after work, Sasha squeezed onto a packed bus, at once regretting it. Rush hour turned the bus into a living sardine can. He was pinned against a burly, red-headed man whose paint-splattered clothes marked him as a painter, one who looked like he wanted nothing more than to throw him out. Sweat gathered along Sasha’s spine.
Then he saw him — the Opera Man — sitting at the back of the bus, staring out the window.
Sasha checked his watch. His heart leaped.
Ten minutes to three. Would there be a performance? Would he dare?
On buses, silence was the general rule. Loud talking was reserved for teenagers or the occasional drunk. The conductor moved through the crowd collecting fares, her bulk sending ripples of discomfort through packed bodies, a collective groan following wherever she moved. Bodies pressed close enough that people could taste each other’s breath.
Sasha looked down. His watch hit three.
The Opera Man stood up, grinning. Sunlight caught his four front teeth. Passengers assumed he was getting off. Others thought he was possibly drunk.
They were wrong, or maybe not. He began to sway back and forth, eyes closed, drawing a few strange stares. Then he raised his hand, and let his voice flow, soft at first and then soaring, climbing to a pitch that made everyone go silent at once.
Beside Sasha, a woman's whispered argument with her husband trailed off.
The conductor forgot momentarily to collect money, and heads turned down the aisle until every face pointed toward him; even those pinned against the windows craned their necks to see.
He lifted his voice higher, singing in Italian. The conductor pushed through the crowd toward him, her face reddening.
“Quiet back there, you drunk fool!” she yelled.
The bus had become his rolling stage, and from the light in his eyes, he seemed to be enjoying every second of it. With a deft, mischievous switch from Italian to the local dialect, he launched into a playful serenade aimed squarely at the conductor:
To you, my love, my sweet dear little bunny,
It is for you that I have traveled;
oh, it is for you that my heart now sings—
Like stars in the night sky, your eyes shine so bright.
He dropped suddenly into his speaking voice, addressing the bus in a monotone, as if at a lectern: “As our great Pushkin once wrote —” then lifted back to a pitch the entire bus felt:
“A genius of pure beauty!”
Laughter erupted. Sides ached. Even the red-headed painter grinned. The whole bus rose in applause even as the conductor shoved toward him, cursing.
She seized him just as he lifted his bottle to his lips and hauled him toward the door by the collar of his oversized black coat. He went willingly enough, still smiling as the crowd applauded.
“You’re the genius of pure beauty!” one young lady shouted across the bus.
Before he could respond, the conductor, who was much sturdier than he was, shoved him out of the bus onto the curb, he stumbled forward, gathered his balance, turned and gave a long, theatrical bow, blew a kiss, and then drained his bottle. Sasha was still applauding long after he was no longer seen.
****
Winter had arrived at thirty-below, and still he came. It was the type of cold that burned everything it touched; his beard white with frost, vapor moving from his mouth in labored clouds, his face twitching against the bite of the cold. The entire ground was a solid rock of ice, and very few people were out at the moment.
He tried to sing, but his voice was hoarse; he kept having to stop, coughing, before he could gather himself again, each note a struggle. When he finished his ritual, he bowed to the empty street.
Then he reached for his bottle and held it to his lips. Finding it empty, he shook it several times, then hurled it against the concrete. It shattered, the sound echoing down the frozen street.
He stood among the pieces for a moment. The vapor from his mouth moved in the wind as he said things barely audible, pointing at the broken glass while moving his arm back and forth as if accusing it of something.
Then he walked away, beginning to talk loudly to himself, and sat at the bus stop, pulling something out of his pocket, placing it into the palm of his hand. Sasha watched him for a few minutes. The Opera man remained hunched beneath his coat, staring at whatever he’d taken from his pocket, and muttering to himself.
Sasha started toward him feeling the urge to buy him a warm meal, or perhaps finally ask his name. Then he stopped.
Another bottle by his side. The shaking hands. The talking to himself.
He checked his watch instead and walked to work.
*****
One morning, several days later, Sasha hurried toward the gazebo-style bus stop.
It was early enough that he was almost the only one venturing out beneath the streetlights. The wind was relentless and piercing. Snow moved in thin veils around him, lifting, turning, drifting in every direction possible.
As he drew closer he noticed a small figure curled on the old wooden bench, hands tucked into his pockets. He moved quickly, and found him. It was him. The Opera Man.
Sasha did not move. He did not want to look.
His skin had taken on a bluish tint.
His eyes were open, they looked vacant and haunted. Frost had gathered around his beard. Sasha could not stop staring at his eyes.
He crouched down, looking away as he closed them. Then he placed his hand on the man’s neck. His body was ice-cold. Still no pulse.
Sasha pulled off his own scarf and wrapped it around him, some part of him insisting this could still help.
He pressed his fingers to the man’s neck again, hoping again for a pulse. Tears forming. Was he breathing? He watched his chest for a long time. There was nothing: all the warmth of his body gone. Sasha sat on the bench for what felt like hours.
The ambulance finally pulled up. Two men got out, pulling an old stretcher between them.
“Another one, I bet… frozen stiff,” one said, chuckling under his breath.
“From the look of him… he won’t even need the fridge tonight.”
They caught the look on Sasha’s face and let the joke drop.
“Homeless?” one asked, as if bored.
Sasha stumbled over the words. “I… think so.”
“Death by hypothermia, more than likely.” The medic searched his pockets.
“No identification,” he said. “You knew him? His name? Where he lived?”
The question pained him, and he stood there in silence and did not answer at first. Sasha had stood close enough to hear him breathe, yet he didn’t even know his name.
“No,” he muttered. “No… I don’t know.”
Among his things, they found an empty bottle and a worn photograph. A medic held it out, and Sasha took it without thinking. In the picture, the Opera Man had his arms wrapped around a smiling woman, a small boy between them, grinning, bright-eyed, and almost entirely without hair.
On the back, in faded pencil: Ward #9, three o'clock.
“Are you Dima?” Sasha whispered.
His words came back to him: “Three o’clock is our time.”
He looked at the boy’s face. Then the woman’s. Then back at him, younger, whole, a man who belonged to others.
Then the old man’s body landed on the stretcher with a thud; loud enough that Sasha flinched.
“Could you not be more careful?” Sasha scolded them, tears freezing to his face.
Neither medic answered him at first, hoisting the stretcher into place.
“Sorry, he was a bit stiff,” one finally said. The other jabbed him in the side, and rolled his eyes.
They placed him in the ambulance, closed the door, and quickly departed. Sasha stood at the curb, watching the rear lights shrink into the distance until they were gone.
“Sasha, look up. Not everyone is your father. Life is passing.”
Maria’s voice, decades old, arrived without permission, and this time, he couldn’t argue with her.
The photograph snapped him from such thoughts, as he noticed the paper was soft at the edges, thinned by years of handling. He looked a long time at the happy faces. He slipped it into his pocket, tapped it a few times without knowing why.
He remained there well after the street emptied. His hands stung, his body numb.
The photograph was warm, at least, and Sasha missed work for the first time in years.
You must sign up or log in to submit a comment.
I marked this as fiction because Sasha, his backstory, and the ending are entirely invented.
This story was written in honor of a man who sang almost anywhere... a store, a bus, even a public paid bathroom ...to the great delight of his audience and the dread of the establishments around him. His voice made people laugh, it lifted spirits, and turned broken‑down rusty places into unexpected stages. I could have added so much more!
At its core, it is true: the Opera Man was a remarkable human being, full of mischief and light. The sad truth, as with so many others, is that his life ended on the brutal, bitter cold streets.
Through this story, I wanted the world to meet him so that he would not be forgotten. The bus scene actually did happen. He gave joy freely, carried music into places where it was least expected, and deserved to be remembered. Thank you for reading. I hope this story inspires others to care for those most vulnerable in their communities.
Reply
Many, many thanks for this context. Humans can be cruel to each other beyond the reach of our worst nightmares, but can also make the little sphere of existence around each of us a bit better. Here's to small kindnesses of all types: making strangers laugh, holding doors for those coming after us, picking up litter we didn't drop ourselves, being respectful, and all the rest. I raise my glass of undisclosed beverage!
Reply
I love your toast to those small gestures. A laugh shared with a stranger, a held door, a bit of respect offered freely… those tiny choices really are what keep communities human.
I know this was a rough story in many ways, and I was trying to capture both sides of what I witnessed: the ugliness society is capable of and the absolute brilliance it can show. Your comment touches exactly that tension. I’m glad the context helped deepen the reading, and I’d honestly be curious about your thoughts if you hadn’t known the background, whether the story alone would have carried the same weight. Where I lived, I saw many people who ended up dying on the streets or losing limbs to frost. It really burdened me. I was doing a lot of social work, trying to get people into shelters, trying to keep them alive through winters. When we do nothing, the consequences are devastatingly real. I raise my glass of undisclosed beverage to your toast!!
Reply
I think maybe I made part of my point somewhat inelegantly. In saying I appreciated the context, I meant only that I appreciated knowing the fact that this story had very personal roots for you.
I'd have still very, very much enjoyed the story even without your comment; in fact, I DID enjoy it without your comment, since I didn't read the comment until after I'd read the story. The suffering of a broken and discarded person is painful to witness; I've been lucky to have had pretty limited contact with such situations in my life. And yet, this person with virtually nothing does something each day to try to brighten the world around him.
Thanks again for this story--it made me smile, and I'll remember it at the times I can maybe make life a bit better for a few people...
Reply
I am glad I added the context for this story. Thank you so much for clarifying I really appreciate your words. It means a lot to know the story stood on its own for you, even before you knew it had personal roots. :)
You’re right ... the suffering of someone broken and discarded is painful to witness, seen too much of that in my lifetime. The Opera Man each day offered something beautiful. That tension between having almost nothing and still giving a gift was at the heart of why I wanted to write this. He was an amazing person.
Reply
I am glad I added the context for this story. Thank you for sharing with me your thoughts!
Reply
The image of the Opera Man's teeth was also so strong. I could see the golden light of the sun on them.
This is poignant.
Reply
Thanks !! Glad his teeth shining bright in the golden light worked for you :)
Reply
I didn't see as shining. I saw them as being few in his mouth, maybe crooked and probably deeply stained. What was beautiful is how you highlighted them with golden sunlight. That was an image that got burned in my memory. That's what I mean about your writing and how you did the ugly-beautiful so well. ❤️🩹
Reply
Thank you for sharing that. Your comments have been very encouraging!
Reply
Damn.
Reply
Hope in a good way :)
Reply
Yes. Excellent read.
Reply
Thank you very much for taking the time to read and comment ! Appreciate it.
Reply
As always with your writing -- I was greatly moved. There is emotional depth and importance here, of finding joy in life and loving those who bring that joy to us. The descriptions put me "right there", in that ice cold environment, especially near the end. I felt the coldness of the Opera Man in my own fingertips as I saw he was blue from having frozen. Beautiful writing. Thank you for sharing it with us!
Reply
Thank you! I'm so glad the emotional depth reached you. That is very kind thing to say! He did find joy in life, even with such hardships. Thank you for sharing your thoughts and for taking the time to read this story. I'll check out your latest one soon!
Reply
Oh, Gosh. This is so real. Your scenes are spectacular, the way they capture the struggle, the ugliness. So raw yet so beautiful. Sad and descriptive. Oh my gosh. This reads like Dostoevsky, but I'm practically watching a movie before my eyes because the images are so powerful. It's so humble, and the images are crazy, the way I can only read them and not have the words to describe how they're written. Even your stars are gorgeous. It's heartbreaking, and that's even before Sasha finds the man dead. It is so sad, but so rich. It's poor and near-holy. The Opera Man is so proud in his humble state, standing with a pigeon on his head. That was powerful. The bus scene is outrageous --in the way you wrote it. It just keeps flowing greatness. This is just gorgeous. Someone famous said there's no reading, there's only re-reading, and this story exactly fits the saying. It's beautiful, and you are an exquisite writer. THIS is art.
Reply
Wow... your comment genuinely stopped me in my tracks... thank you! The Dostoevsky comparison especially... I don't know that I'll ever read a kinder comment. He's my favorite author by far. :)
I love that you picked out the pigeon moment!! The Opera Man was an amazing individual who loved to transform anything into his stage. So happy the bus scene and all of it landed, he actually did that, one day, for real. The bus was crowded, packed Russian "rush-hour", where you could barely move your arms. The man stood up... and delivered a performance of a lifetime. Then sang his heart out to the angry conductor. I've never seen anything so spontaneous... pure genius. Thank you for reading this so closely, and for re-reading it... that really is the best compliment a story can get! I am so glad this was a story that mattered.
Reply
Are you kidding? If I could do any one thing as well as you can write...
Do you not know? Your story is so rich that it seems to make more of the 3000-word count we're allowed, as if you multiplied it by the depth of your storytelling!
Reply
Thanks so much for the kind words and encouragement!!
Reply
A wheel tapper,a s vanishing skill. Those men coulld tell by the sound if a wheel had a flaw or not. There isedtobea program The WheelTappers and Shunters Club.
The street singer and drunk. Fora few moments he was back in his opera house until reality returned. Such a waste. To die alone is bad enough but on the street.
As always well written and as the reader I could see it clearly. Lovelybutsadstory.
Reply
I’m really glad the wheel tapper detail stood out! During every stop on the Trans-Siberian, you would always see them come out and tap the wheels. Only once did I hear one make a sound that caused them to hold the train for repairs. It is a vanishing skill.
I’ve seen too many people die on the streets… it’s brutal in the winter. The Opera Man was a remarkable talent, a genius, sharing beauty on the streets for those who would appreciate it.
Thanks so much for your comment! It means a lot. I’m really glad this story mattered to people.
Reply
I enjoyed this story because it felt so realistic. While tragic, I think Sasha’s reactions were very human and probably what a lot of people would do in this situation. Even as he slowly began to care more about the Opera Man, he still kept his distance, and by the time he finally learned something about who the man really was, it was too late. That made the ending especially heartbreaking. Really well done! I saw in one of your comments that this was originally your Literary Prize piece, and I can only imagine what the full version of the story woulld have looked like.
Reply
Thank you so much! You put your finger on exactly what I was hoping would come through... that Sasha's distance isn't cruelty, just something very human, and that's what makes it hurt the way it does. It's great that you saw that. Any one of us could be Sasha.
And yes... the full version does go further with Sasha afterward, into his "change/transformation," as the prompt called for. It was interesting cutting it back to end here, at the rawest point. Thank you again for reading so thoughtfully!! :)
Reply
What a great story!
Even it involved tragic elements and human cruelty, one did not feel the man who sang saw himself as a tragic figure. He had a past that meant something and a talent that was appreciated by many of those who were lucky enough to hear him sing. The beauty of this story is it highlights the fullness of a life that bubbles beneath the surface. You honoured the man by writing about him.
Reply
Thank you so much!! I am glad you felt it honoured him. He for sure did not look at himself with eyes of self‑pity, but seemed to embrace life with his own unique twist. THank you for taking the time to read and comment!
Reply
This is simply a beautiful beautiful story. Not much I can add that hasn't already been said but Sasha is such a rounded character, you captured the pure horror of anxiety attack so well on the first bus scene and the chaos of the singing Opera Man to the delight and surprise of the passengers perfectly on the second. Just fabulous (and heartbreaking) writing.
Reply
Thank you so much! I’m really glad Sasha felt rounded to you and tanks for commenting on his panic attack.... I hoped it would feel real. And glad you liked the chaotic joy of the Opera Man. I truly appreciate you taking the time to read and leave such an encouraging comment.
Reply
What a great story. I enjoyed so many details, especially Maria's words telling Sasha to "look up..." both near the beginning and again at the end. What a good callback. Thanks for a fun, meaningful read!
Reply
Thank you so much!! I am glad Babushka Maria’s wisdom to “look up…” stood out to you! How many times, in life we need to take her advice Appreciate your comment and glad this story felt meaningful to you :)
Reply
Wow T.O.I,
I always love the perspectives of all your stories, how we get to travel the world. but this... this was beautiful. The fact that Sasha is one looking for connection some sort of warmth, he desperately wants to stretch and reach it but everytime he tries, the distance increases. The fact that Opera man was able to touch his heart and inspire him, made his life feel it had much more worth and warmth despite what Babushka Maria said about it. I felt I connected with Sasha the most when he tried his best to talk and just reach out. I understand how humans, when touched, just wanna do their best and meet their heroes but something holds them back. And when an eventuality embarks on them, it hurts the most. I feel that pain and I am so glad we, the small number of human beings you were able to tell could see his story unfold as you could have wished. Thank you so much for this T.O.I.
This is based on Russia yes?
Reply
Thank you so much, Aaron!! Yes, this is based in Russia, where I spent a good bit of my life, and this was a story I carried around in my mind for a long time before finally putting it on the page. I am glad I finally did. I really love how you described Sasha... reaching for connection, stretching toward friendship, and somehow feeling the distance widen each time he tries. All his past stuff pulled him back at the very moment he gets near it. And then,,, it was too late.
Thank you for reading so closely!! It is very encouraging.
Reply
You're welcome. With how versed you are I always forget where you are actually from. But I believe you're a native Russian. Thank you so much for such beloved stories. I have learnt so much from them.
Reply
This whole thing is an absolute roller coaster. You took me to so many places that I think I might just be putting the phone down tonight ( like I’m sure Sasha did ) and going to find someone to hug. It’s all done with such a beautiful subtlety. You don’t have to point a thing out with exposition. I really hope you’re putting a collection together. I would absolutely buy a copy.
Reply
I know, Sasha did not have a phone. You get what I meant! Lol
Reply
Thank you... this genuinely means so much. "Rollercoaster" is exactly the word for what I was hoping the story would do. I wanted the joy and mischief of the Opera Man to be experienced, not just a setup for sadness, so that the ending would hit the way it does... not as a literary gimmick, but as something that catches you the way it caught Sasha. And the way it catches me, too, every time one of humanity's gems dies on the streets, unseen. The very harsh reality that claimed the Opera Man's life.
If this sends you to go find someone to hug tonight, that's the best possible outcome I could have hoped for.... to find one person, make a friend of them, and truly see them.
And I felt what you said about the phone, too. Our greatest distraction... the constant blur that keeps us from really seeing what's right in front of us. Thank you for reading with your whole heart, and for such a generous thing to say about a collection. That really does mean a lot.
Reply
Great story - Sasha is a wonderful character, fully developed. This is very grounded in reality and makes the reader think about what is right and wrong in this world. Well done as always.
Reply
Thank you so much for reading! I’m glad Sasha’s inner world felt real to you, and that his character came across as fully developed. This story, like most of mine, comes from real corners, and it’s encouraging to hear it worked! Too many lives are lost on the streets, and sometimes simply noticing someone... stepping outside of our comfort, can make all the difference. Thank you again for liking it and for sharing your thoughts. :).
Reply
I feel that care you have for the Opera Man, and his impact on his community.
Thanks for sharing!
Reply
Thank you so much!!
Reply
Yeah, I think this is strong. The biggest thing that works for me is Sasha’s arc. At the beginning, he’s built his whole life around avoiding people. The trains make sense to him. He can tap a wheel twice and know what’s wrong with it. People aren’t like that, and because of his father and everything that happened to him, he’d rather just keep his distance. That’s why the Opera Man works so well. Sasha starts caring about this guy without admitting it to himself. He listens to him every day, looks forward to three o’clock, watches all the weird stuff he does, but he still never gets close enough to even ask his name. Then at the end, when the medics ask Sasha who he is, Sasha has to admit that he doesn’t know. I think that’s one of the strongest parts of the whole story. I also like that the Opera Man isn’t just depressing. He’s funny and kind of ridiculous. The part where he sings to Lenin and says, “You had your revolution. I have my three o’clock,” is great. I’d keep that. Same with the bus scene. That might be my favorite scene because for a few minutes he changes the mood of this miserable packed bus and gets everybody laughing together. The photograph reveal is good too. “Ward #9, three o’clock” gives us enough to figure out what happened with Dima without spelling everything out. I wouldn’t explain much more than you already do. The fact that the kid has almost no hair, the tattoo says “My beloved Dima,” and the Opera Man always sings at three is enough for us to put it together. I like the moment before his death when Sasha almost goes over to him.
Sasha started toward him feeling the urge to buy him a warm meal, or perhaps finally ask his name. Then he stopped.
That’s the most important moment in the story. He almost does what his grandmother has been telling him to do his whole life. He almost looks up and lets somebody in. Then he sees the bottle and the shaking and decides to go to work instead. I wouldn’t make him think something obvious like, “He’s just another drunk.” Him walking away says enough. And I like the ending with Sasha missing work for the first time in years. Work has been his safe place this entire time, so him not going means something has changed in him. There’s also a cool connection I noticed that I don’t know if you did. At the beginning Sasha taps the train wheels to figure out what’s wrong with them. At the end, he puts the photograph in his pocket and taps it a few times. I’d keep that because it almost feels like he’s doing the same thing, except this time he’s trying to understand a person instead of a machine.
Reply
I’m honestly blown away by your attention to detail ... you read this and understood the heartbeat of everything I hoped the story would carry! Sasha’s arc, his distance from people, the way he almost lets someone in but pulls back... you captured it all so beautifully.
One thing I didn’t intentionally plan, but love that you noticed, was the tapping of the photo. This story was originally my literary prize piece, and I had to cut and reshape it to fit under 3k words. In the longer version, Sasha sees the photo blowing across the ground and feels pained that something so precious is going to waste. He reaches down, picks it up, and taps it for no apparent reason.. simply because I loved the image. But you’re right, it echoes the beginning perfectly, when he tapped the train wheels to diagnose what was wrong, his ear tuned to the vibrations. That parallel between trying to understand a machine and, at the end, trying to understand a person is something I hadn’t consciously built, but wow.... it fits so well!!!
I had to make many changes to bring this story into its final form, and your insight makes me feel those choices landed in the right place. Thank you for seeing both the Opera Man and Sasha with such care ... it means more than I can say.
Reply
What a beautiful tale, made even more so by the fact that is was written in someone's honor. I really wanted one of those medics to either slip on the ice or get punched in the nose. They were so disrespectful. I love how he slips the photo in his pocket and mentions that at least it is warm. It made me think of the fact that the moment in the photo itself was a warm moment and that the photo would be warm and protected in his pocket as opposed to the very cold body that had just been handled with cold regard. Well done.
Reply
Thank you for taking the time to read and leave such an encouraging note. Those medics were awful... I debated whether to include them, but I remembered seeing that same kind of calloused heart in real situations more than once, and it felt important to show. I’m glad the photo scene worked for you. I like to think he kept that photo safe, holding onto the warmth of that moment and keeping that photo from just being discarded like trash. The Opera Man was such an interesting character in real life .. someone who brought unexpected beauty to unlikely places. Thank you for reading!!!
Reply
I should not have read this at work, because now I'm trying not to cry at my keyboard.
You are so good at writing in a way that grounds us quickly to the setting and the characters, and by the end I was as invested in the Opera man and Sasha as I would have been in a full length book. It's incredible what you can pull off narratively in so few words (something I admire and am working hard to emulate haha)
This was such a tender story. I know you said that Sasha was fictitious, but his struggle and ark felt very real. It hearkens to feelings we've all had, of being a quiet bystander to something we admire but are too afraid to touch until it is too late. I loved the ending, with the callback to his babushka and her words to look up. Such an amazing piece, thank you for posting it!
Reply
Thank you so much for this warm response and I’m sorry my story brought you to tears at work! It means a great deal to know the Opera Man and Sasha felt so real to you, even within a short piece. I hoped the atmosphere would ground readers quickly, so hearing you were invested as if it were a full‑length book is incredibly encouraging!!!
You captured Sasha’s arc perfectly... his anxiety made him a bystander to something he admired but was too afraid to reach for until it was gone. That sense of missed connection is devastating and I’m glad the callback to his babushka’s words resonated too. The Opera Man in real life was incredible, and I’m grateful his story moved you today. If you have a chance to give the story a like, it would help it travel further, but truly, your thoughtful words are already the best encouragement I could ask for. Thank you again!
Reply
I just wanted to say how much I enjoyed this story. The Opera Man was written with so much care, and the whole thing had this gentle, thoughtful tone that I really appreciate in your writing. It’s one of those pieces that lingers a bit after you finish. Really well done :)
Reply
Thank you.... that means a great deal to me. I hoped the Opera Man’s story would matter in a world that, in many ways, let him freeze on the streets. The fact that it lingers with you is the best encouragement I could ask for. He truly was an amazing individual, and I’m grateful you took the time to read. I see you ahve a new story. I will check it out soon.
Reply
I really liked the Russian atmosphere in this. The crowded buses, the Lenin statue, the cold, and the dry humor all felt very familiar. Some of the Soviet imagery even reminded me of an old Mosfilm movie.
I also loved that Sasha doesn't know the Opera Man’s name. He’s watched him for so long and knows all these little things about him, but somehow never knew that. It made their whole relationship feel a little sadder to me, especially after the reveal.
Reply
Thank you!! I was really drawing on the city I lived in for a long time... Oh' those crowded buses, the bitter cold, the old brutalist Soviet landmarks. I sigh with nostalgia remembering them at times It means a lot that the atmosphere reminded you of old Mosfilm films.
And I appreciate your note about Sasha not knowing the Opera Man’s name. He was so close to the man, yet still far. The Opera Man was based on a real person who used to brighten my part of the city, and I really just wrote this story to share him. I see you have a new story... I’m looking forward to reading it! :).
Reply
Your stories are a highlight in my reading! Brings me back to a lot of my childhood and the stories my family tells about their life in the former USSR.
Reply
Thank you for the kind words.
Reply
Iz, this one really got to me. The fact that Sasha gives him a name of his own, watches him for months, cries when he sings, yet never actually asks his real name makes that final “You knew him? His name?” hit incredibly hard. I also loved the three o’clock ritual — funny and wonderfully eccentric at first, then heartbreaking once we understand what it meant. And Maria’s “Life is passing” coming back at the end ties Sasha’s own story into his failure to truly see the Opera Man until it’s too late. Beautifully done, my friend. This one will stay with me.
Reply
This was an emotional story to write, and I feel you saw it in its truest colors through the moments that struck you most. I really appreciate how you picked up on the weight of Sasha naming the Opera Man without ever knowing his real name ... that “You knew him? His name?” was meant to land hard, and I’m glad it did. All the what ifs and could I have dones will keep crashing over Sasha in wave after wave.
I’m glad the three o’clock ritual stood out to you as well. I wanted it to feel eccentric because it truly was and then, as more is revealed, to shift into something much deeper.
And you’re right about Maria’s line. “Life is passing” Tying Sasha’s own story into his failure to truly see the Opera Man until it was too late. Yet I believe for Sasha, this is the moment his eyes are unveiled... when he finally begins to notice the invisible people languishing on the streets. Thank you friend for sharing that this story lingers with you. That is the most encouraging thing a writer can ever hear. To know a story mattered. :).
Reply
Excellent work, Iz. I should add that I posted my comment and only afterwards — so actually a little too late — read the context you provided for the story. Knowing that background gave the story even more depth and impact. It really touched me.
Reply
Such a beautiful and poignant tale. Your added backstory to the piece gives it even more humanity, light and sadness. People often look away or cross the street to avoid confrontation, Sasha wasn’t one of them. It only takes a few minutes out of your day to smile or offer a few words. It can make a world of difference to someone. We were at the Eclipse earlier tonight and had a queue of people borrowing our safety glasses so they could get a glimpse. Glasses were sold out everywhere and unscrupulous people were selling them for extortionate amounts of money. The atmosphere was so amazing and as we shared our food with them, we made new friends! Your story reminded me of how we can rashly judge people by appearances and circumstances. You are a weaver of stories as always.
Reply
Thank you so much for this... what a lovely thing to read. And what a beautiful night you had at the eclipse, sharing your glasses and making new friends along the way... that's exactly the kind of small generosity I hoped this story might inspire in people. Sad how so many like hIM, pass away on the streets. Thank you for reading so warmly and for your encouragement.
Reply
You are most welcome. Please keep writing, we love your stories on here. Look how many likes and comments you receive! Superb!
Reply
I am honored very much you enjoy my stories. I was rea;ly surprised by how many comments came in on the last one... every read and every bit of engagement means a great deal!! Your encouragement has always been genuinely uplifting. I do hope to get another story out soon; it’s just been a very busy stretch. I might have to sit this week out, but I’m hoping to be back in the mix again soon. :)
Reply
Thank you for sharing this story. I have tears in my eyes as I am writing this comment.
It hit close to home. I grew up in a city where these events could easily have happened, except for a winter this cold.
Your writing is very vivid. Your stories describe struggles that we face ourselves or see other people facing, and that is why they are so relatable.
Reply
Thank you so much for sharing how the story touched you. It means a great deal to know that the Opera Man and this story stirred your heart. I wrote this piece to honor someone who brought joy in unexpected places, and your words remind me that his voice still reaches people even now. I added a comment about this story... this is fiction but the Opera man was a real guy. Your reflection about growing up in a city where this could have happened makes me appreciate your comment even more! Where I lived, the winters could be brutal, and many of our homeless suffered greatly during that time.
Thank you again for reading and for letting me know your thoughts. Responses like yours keep me writing. :).
Reply
What a deeply human, gorgeous piece of writing.
Reply
I am glad you liked it!
Reply
This story deserved so many reads,and comments. I read it when I noticed it was a favorite. Great story. Sad in a way, leaving unanswered questions. Loved it.
Reply
I am honored you felt that way about my story, and I’m very grateful for every read and comment! I hoped that sharing a story about a man who, in real life, could turn any unexpected place into his open-stage would help bring a little of his spirit back to life. I’m glad the feeling of the story worked for you. Thank you so much for taking the time to comment it’s always a wonderful thing to know a story mattered :)
Reply
This left me with chills. And not just because of your visceral descriptions of the cold, the warm tears, the smell of alcohol on a stranger’s breath… the packed bus. But it was also full of humanity and compassion. Really beautiful.
Reply
Thank you so much!! Glad you enjoyed the story and that you saw humanity and compassion within. Really appreciate your kind words.
Reply
So sad
Reply
Very true….
Reply