Subject Unkown

Mystery

Written in response to: "Hide something from your reader until the end of your story." as part of In the Dark.

PART ONE

Day 6,421. Today I almost escaped.

They always say the days get easier when you stop counting. That’s a lie people tell themselves when they run out of numbers.

I still count everything.

Steps to the wall. Seconds between guard rotations. The exact number of crumbs I can save without it looking suspicious.

The guard at the east corridor tossed my tray through the slot like he always does. It hit the floor, spun once, then stopped like it had given up.

“Morning,” he said.

He says that every morning.

I nodded like I always do.

He didn’t leave right away. Sometimes he doesn’t. Sometimes he talks.

“Same dream again?” he asked.

I looked at him for a second too long. That’s what people do when they’re trying to remember if they’re allowed to lie.

“Yeah,” I said. “But this time I almost tasted something.”

That got a small laugh out of him. Not cruel. Not kind either. Just… human.

When he turned away, I slid the tray closer.

There was a mouse under the bunk again.

It always comes back.

I broke the bread into smaller pieces than yesterday. The mouse hesitated, then came forward like it had made a decision it couldn’t undo.

I don’t know why I do it. Maybe because it reminds me something still chooses to live in here.

The guard knocked twice before leaving.

“Don’t get attached,” he said.

I didn’t answer.

I never do.

After he left, I sat back against the wall and closed my eyes.

Sometimes I try to remember rain. Not just the idea of it—but the feeling. Like the sky is touching you without asking permission.

I can’t hold onto it for long anymore.

Food here tastes like nothing, but I still imagine things. Cheeseburger mostly. Real one. The kind that drips when you bite it too hard.

I caught myself smiling at it once.

That scared me more than anything else.

Because people like me aren’t supposed to smile at things we can’t have.

PART TWO

There are nights when the lights don’t turn off.

Those are the worst ones.

Not because of sleep, but because everything looks the same whether your eyes are open or closed. The walls don’t change. The air doesn’t change. Even your thoughts start sounding like they’ve been repeated too many times.

That night, I started counting again.

Not days this time.

Sounds.

Drip from the pipe above my bunk. Three seconds apart. Then four. Then three again. Like something trying to decide if it should be consistent.

The mouse came out later than usual.

It always knows when I’m awake.

I broke off a piece of my bread and held it low. It didn’t rush this time. Just stared at me first, like it was checking if I was still the same person as yesterday.

“Still here,” I whispered.

The mouse took the crumb.

I don’t know why I whispered. There’s no rule about talking to it. There’s no rule about anything that matters in here. Only rules about things that don’t.

A loud metallic clank came from the hallway.

Footsteps.

The mouse froze and disappeared into the dark.

The guard didn’t come in right away. He stood outside the door for a few seconds longer than usual.

Then he opened the slot.

“You sleeping?” he asked.

“No.”

He leaned closer, like he was trying to see something past me. Not my face. Something behind it.

“You ever think about what you’d do if the walls weren’t here?”

I almost laughed.

But I stopped myself.

Because that question isn’t normal. Not in here.

“I don’t remember not being here,” I said.

That was true.

He nodded slowly, like that answer meant something.

“You say that a lot,” he replied.

Then he slid something across the floor.

Not food.

A small paper packet. Thin. Folded once.

My heart changed rhythm.

“What’s this?” I asked.

He didn’t answer right away.

“Don’t open it until shift change,” he said.

That was all.

Then he left.

No jokes. No small talk. No morning routine.

Just gone.

I waited longer than I should have.

Then I opened it anyway.

Inside was a simple map.

Not of the prison.

Of something beyond it.

A path.

A blind spot in the patrol schedule.

And one line written at the bottom:

If you still feel like yourself, run.

I didn’t sleep after that.

Not really.

For the first time in a long time, the walls didn’t feel permanent. They felt… placed. Like someone decided they should be here, and everyone else agreed not to question it.

That’s the kind of thought that gets you in trouble.

So I stopped thinking.

And started planning.

PART THREE

The map didn’t make sense at first.

It wasn’t drawn like something meant to be used. Too clean in some places, too incomplete in others. Like whoever made it didn’t want to admit they knew the full shape of what they were showing.

But the route was clear.

Down the east corridor. Past the storage wing that no one ever entered. Through the maintenance tunnel that “wasn’t safe.” Then up—somewhere I’d never been allowed to go.

I memorized it anyway.

Because there was nothing else to do.

The next two days felt different, even though nothing changed. That’s the strange part about hope. It doesn’t rearrange the world. It just makes you notice how wrong everything already was.

The guard didn’t come back to talk.

That bothered me more than it should’ve.

The mouse still came, though. Still waited. Still took crumbs like it trusted me not to stop existing.

On the third night, I moved.

The corridor outside my cell was quieter than usual. That wasn’t normal. Silence here always meant something was being hidden, not that nothing was happening.

I kept my steps slow.

Counted them.

Of course I counted them.

At the storage wing, the lock wasn’t really a lock. More like a suggestion. It clicked open after two tries.

Inside, everything smelled like metal and dust that had forgotten its purpose.

The tunnel entrance was there.

Just like the map said.

Too easy.

That should’ve been the warning.

But I went in anyway.

The tunnel was narrow at first. Then wider. Then narrow again, like the place couldn’t decide what it wanted to be. Pipes ran along the sides, humming softly like they were alive but tired.

Halfway through, I stopped.

Not because I was lost.

Because I heard footsteps behind me.

Slow.

Not rushing.

Not chasing.

Just following.

I turned.

Nothing.

Then I kept going.

The exit wasn’t a door. It was light. Real light. Not the artificial kind that never changes temperature or direction. This one felt… distant. Like it had weight.

When I stepped out, the air hit me first.

Cold.

Sharp.

Alive.

I almost forgot how to breathe for a second.

Above me—sky.

Not a ceiling. Not pipes. Not flickering panels pretending to be day.

Actual sky.

I didn’t run right away.

I just stood there.

Like my body didn’t trust it yet.

Then I ran.

For the first time, no one stopped me.

No alarms.

No shouting.

No doors locking.

Just wind.

Grass under my feet that I wasn’t allowed to notice before now.

And something worse than fear started growing in my chest.

Because freedom was supposed to feel like relief.

But it felt like being watched.

Still, I kept going until I saw it.

The fence.

Tall. Reinforced. Real.

But not guarded like I expected.

The guards were there.

Behind it.

Standing still.

Watching.

No weapons raised.

No movement forward.

Just waiting.

One of them spoke.

Quietly.

Not to me.

More like to himself.

“I’m sorry.”

I didn’t understand that.

Not yet.

Then I climbed.

The fence was harder than it should’ve been. Every step felt like the world resisting me in ways I couldn’t explain. Like I wasn’t supposed to cross, not physically—but something deeper than that.

Still, I reached the top.

For a moment, I was above it all.

And then I dropped down on the other side.

Freedom.

I smiled.

I actually smiled.

Then I saw the sign.

White background.

Bold black letters.

Like it had been waiting for me longer than anything else in my life.

WARNING

DO NOT APPROACH THE INDIVIDUAL BEYOND THIS POINT.

If containment has failed, leave immediately and contact Central Command.

Do not attempt communication.

My smile faded, but I didn’t move.

Because I didn’t understand what “containment” meant.

And I didn’t understand why they were still watching me like that.

Like I wasn’t supposed to exist outside of something.

That’s when I saw the puddle.

Still water, right at my feet.

I looked down.

And for the first time in 6,421 days…

I saw myself.

PART FOUR

The water didn’t ripple at first.

It just held me.

Like it was used to carrying things I didn’t understand.

I leaned closer.

Waiting for my face.

Waiting for something familiar.

But the longer I looked, the more wrong it became.

The shape wasn’t human in the way I expected it to be human. Not monstrous. Not dramatic. Just… off. Like a version of a person that had been reconstructed from memory instead of reality.

Too many details didn’t line up.

The eyes didn’t sit where they should’ve.

The skin didn’t reflect light the same way.

And the more I focused, the more I realized something even worse—

I couldn’t actually remember what I was supposed to look like.

Not clearly.

Not anymore.

Behind me, the guards still hadn’t moved.

Still watching.

Still waiting like they already knew what the reflection would do to me.

My hands came up slowly.

Not because I was scared of the water.

Because I was scared of what it meant that I didn’t recognize myself in it.

“I’m…” I started.

But the word didn’t finish.

It didn’t feel like it belonged in my mouth.

One of the guards lowered his head slightly.

Not in respect.

Not in shame.

In acceptance.

Like something had finally reached its inevitable moment.

I turned back toward the fence.

Toward them.

Toward everything I thought I had escaped.

“Why?” I asked.

My voice sounded strange outside the walls.

Like it didn’t belong in open air.

No one answered immediately.

Then the same guard—the one who said sorry—spoke again.

“You weren’t supposed to remember far enough to make it this far.”

That didn’t help.

It only made the silence heavier.

The wind moved through the grass behind me.

Soft.

Alive.

Indifferent.

I looked down again at the puddle.

Tried to force clarity.

Tried to force recognition.

And for a brief moment—just a flicker—I saw something else under the reflection.

Not a face.

A pattern.

Like my shape wasn’t the point.

Like I wasn’t built to be recognized the way people recognize each other.

My breath stopped.

The realization didn’t come all at once.

It came in pieces.

The counting.

The isolation.

The lack of explanation.

The careful way no one ever described me.

The way even kindness felt structured.

The map.

The silence outside the tunnel.

The guards who never chased.

It wasn’t escape.

It was transfer.

A controlled release.

A test.

A containment protocol with doors that were never really locked.

I stepped back slowly.

My heel hit something small in the grass.

The mouse.

It was there.

Looking up at me.

Still waiting.

Still choosing.

And for the first time, I understood why it never ran from me.

Because it wasn’t afraid of me.

It was just like me.

Contained.

Observed.

Kept close to something it could never fully understand.

The guards didn’t move.

The fence didn’t matter anymore.

Nothing mattered in the way I thought it did.

Because I finally understood what I was looking at in the water.

Not a man.

Not a prisoner.

Not even a mistake.

Just something that had been kept alive long enough to learn the shape of freedom…

without ever being meant to live inside it.

The wind shifted again.

One of the

guards spoke softly, almost gently, like reading from a report he had memorized long ago.

“Subject has reached external boundary.”

A pause.

Then—

“Visual confirmation required.”

I looked down at the puddle one last time.

And finally, I understood why they built the walls.

The End.

Posted Jun 13, 2026
Share:

You must sign up or log in to submit a comment.

3 likes 1 comment

J R Duncan
07:21 Jun 25, 2026

The story has a very cool sci-fi/existential twist at the end but the reveal completely loses its punch because the narrative is so monotonous. The "one-sentence, one-thought" structure becomes an absolute slog by Part Two. It reads less like literary tension and more like someone hitting the enter key after every breath. Because every single line is given the exact same weight, nothing feels important. Compress the story, vary the sentence structure and lean more into the psychological horror and you will have a gripping and clever story.

Reply

RBE | Illustrated Short Stories | 2024-06

Bring your short stories to life

Fuse character, story, and conflict with tools in Reedsy Studio. All for free.