Reality Rewritten

Contemporary Sad Teens & Young Adult

Written in response to: "Write a story in which a character is betrayed by someone they trusted." as part of Two's a Crowd with Kirsiah Depp.

The afternoon light didn’t fade; it ran out of strength. Outside, a gray winter slush coated the neighborhood sidewalks. The winter holidays were supposed to mean freedom - two weeks of empty mornings and frozen air. But to Olivia, sitting in the back of the living room, the vacation felt like a sentence. The house was a quiet box, away from the world, yet entirely exposed.

Anyone who has ever watched the clock tick down to the hours of an empty afternoon knows the silence doesn't just exist; it has a weight. It presses against the collarbones, a physical mass that can feel like lifting wet concrete. She sat perfectly still on the cushions, her knees pulled slightly toward her chest.

She was looking at her wrists, her skin looked paper thin - a stark white that felt entirely detached from a living body. Her phone lay down on the table. It had stopped vibrating thirty minutes ago. Yet the sudden silence was worse than the ringing. One learns quickly, when the dark takes over, the absence of sound isn’t peaceful, it’s deafening. It is a low, throbbing static that vibrates in the back of one’s skull until they forget what a human voice sounds like. The air in the house smelled of old wool, dust, and the stale radiator that whistled through the pipes. It tasted gray.

Her hair fell forward like a dark curtain, completely obscuring her face. She didn’t move to brush it back. She didn’t have the energy to find her voice. She simply sat, staring blankly at an old cable outlet on the opposite wall. When someone is empty, their eyes latch on things like that - a speck of dust on the rug, a plastic socket, a scratch on the shelf. They find themselves staring at them for hours because processing anything larger requires a soul, and theirs has already gone offline.

The cage hadn’t been built overnight. It had been constructed so quietly; bar by bar, over months of shared sleepovers, movie nights, and late - night whispers. Chloe was a master architect.

Olivia didn’t want to think about the last time they hung out, but her mind dragged her backward anyway, sorting through the wreckage of last year. Chloe had always been her best friend. The person who knew her secrets like gold. But gold is currency, and Chloe knew exactly when to spend it. The cruelty had always been wrapped in velvet. Olivia remembered three weeks ago, sitting in Chloe’s brightly lit bedroom. Chloe had reached out, gently smoothing down the collar of Olivia’s sweater.

“I love that you don’t care what people think about how you look, Livvy,” Chloe had murmured, her smile sweet, her eyes dripping with an agonizing, maternal pity. “It’s so brave. Honestly, if I had your skin tone, I’d be terrified to wear gray - it makes you look so washed out. But on you … It’s just you.”

The words had left a cold, prickling sting behind Olivia’s ribs. When she went quiet after that, retreating into herself, Chloe had sighed loudly, dropping her phone on her unmade bed.

“Oh my gosh, Liv, you’re doing that thing again,” Chloe had groaned, shaking her head. “You’re so incredibly sensitive. I was obviously joking. I swear, I have to walk on eggshells around you lately. It completely ruins the holiday mood for everyone else when we all try to hang out.”

And Olivia had apologized. That was the most terrifying part of the memory. She had looked at Chloe’s annoyed face, felt a sickening wave of guilt, and begged for forgiveness.

She had been taught to doubt her own skin. She had been trained to believe that her hurt was a defect in her character. It is a pattern of guilt anyone who carries a silent weight knows too well - the heavy, cold shadow settling deep within, convincing someone that their own pain is nothing but a burden to the people they love.

The kitchen clock ticked, marking another hour of the winter break ticking away into nothing. Olivia pulled her eyes from the wall and reached for her phone. The screen cast a clinical, blue glare over her face. There was a single, long paragraph from Chloe, sent an hour ago.

“I don’t get why you’re acting like this,” the text read. “I have literally always been by your side. I’m your best friend, Liv. I’ve defended you to everyone. If you felt left out when I was hanging out with the others at the ice rink this weekend, that’s completely on you and your deep insecurities. I shouldn’t have to punish myself and stay home just because you chose to sit in the corner. You’re twisting reality again to make me the bad one, and it’s honestly exhausting.”

Olivia stared at the words until the letters blurred into black fractures. She had spent months feeling like a phantom at the edge of Chloe’s bright, loud circle. She watched them post photos together online, felt the deliberate, icy shift in the group chats, and then - just as Chloe had conditioned her to do - she had blamed herself.

“You’re my person, Livvy,” Chloe would text her after a night of completely ignoring her. “You know you’re the only one who truly gets me.”

And Olivia would feel a desperate wave of relief. She had been handing Chloe the matches while Chloe was pouring gasoline over her entire life.

If she felt sad, she was broken. If abandoned, she was crazy. When reality is rewritten for someone, the mind splits in two. A person begins to double - check their own memories, tracking back to every conversation like a detective investigating a crime that may have never happened. They become a stranger to their own mind.

***

The gray afternoon light outside finally died, replaced by the yellow glow of the streetlamps reflecting off the slush. Olivia didn’t move to turn on the lamps. She wanted to cry. She could feel the immense, crushing pressure behind her eyes, a heavy dam of salt and water waiting to burst. But nothing happened.

There is a common myth that sadness means crying until the chest aches, but those who have travelled to the bottom of the well know a different truth: the worst part is when the tears run out entirely. That depth of sorrow bypasses crying, solidifying into a cold, heavy sediment at the bottom of a soul. Crying requires a tiny, desperate shred of hope - that things can be washed clean, that the pain can be let out. Beyond that lies the stillness of a graveyard after the rain has already stopped, where the shadows simply become part of the landscape.

The front door clicked open at around 8:30 PM. Her mother’s tired footsteps echoed in the hallway, carrying groceries from her shift.

“Olivia? Why are the lights off?” her mother asked, flipping the switch.

The sudden glare was blinding. Her mother took one look at Olivia’s pale face and her chest tightened with fear.

“Sweetie, what’s wrong? What happened?” her mother walked over, her face twisted with a helpless, heavy worry, and reached over to embrace her daughter.

As her mother’s hands brushed Olivia’s shoulder a violent jolt shot through Olivia’s spine. She flinched away so sharply her back struck the wooden frame of the couch.

“ Don’t. Please, don’t touch me,” Olivia choked out, her voice a thin, raspy whisper.

The touch felt heavy, like wet wool. It was an intrusion into a room that had taken weeks to still. Closeness required a currency she no longer possessed; even a simple gesture felt like an unpaid debt. When one has spent too much time in the shadows, light ceases to be comforting - it becomes sharp, exposing the spaces they cannot fill. They learn that quietude becomes the only shield against a world that demands more than one can give.

To endure, the lamps are slowly dimmed. The edges of things blur into a soft, protective gray. When simply existing takes too much effort, sitting still in the darkness remains the only way to watch the hours tick by.

“ I’m just tired.” Olivia murmured, her eyes already locking onto the old outlet on the wall.

Her mother stood there, her hands hovering in the empty air, completely helpless against the invisible wall that had dropped between them. The house fell back into its suffocating silence. Olivia sat on the generic fabric, completely untethered from the seventeen year old girl she used to be. Her mind didn’t even race anymore; it had run out of tracks. The thoughts didn’t loop; they just stopped moving entirely, like water freezing over a dead pond.

Posted Jun 05, 2026
Share:

You must sign up or log in to submit a comment.

7 likes 2 comments

06:33 Jun 08, 2026

I love the imagery you're using in this story! You have a real knack for describing what the characters are feeling, you're very talented! :)))

Reply

Iva Ratiu
09:59 Jun 08, 2026

thank you:) I truly appreciate your support

Reply

RBE | Illustrated Short Stories | 2024-06

Bring your short stories to life

Fuse character, story, and conflict with tools in Reedsy Studio. All for free.