“A person will have to give account for everything his eye saw yet he did not eat.”
Talmud (Yerushalmi), Kiddushin 4:12
Don’t stand outside knocking! Come in!
Welcome to “The Almost Emporium” where I sell the finest in “could have been.” Shake off your umbrella (my, the rain is coming down, isn’t it?) and put it right there in the corner. There, that’s better. Your hands are free now to pick up, peruse, and, hopefully, purchase all the amazing artifacts we have in store!
I am J. Idleman, proprietor. My family has run this store for hundreds of years (or so it feels sometimes). We have a wide array of “almost” to choose from. Did you have something in particular you were looking for?
You asking for my recommendations? Of course! Follow me. I have something that might pique your interest. Fortuitous for you, I received this item only a few hours ago. It should be in this back row of shelves (haven’t had a chance to properly index it yet, ha!). Where is it again? Ah! Here it is.
A plane ticket. Never used.
Anxious fellow who brought it in. Very jumpy. Had scrimped and saved to in order to buy it. One way ticket to the Philippines. Said he had family there. Had not seen them in decades.
He told me he was excited for the trip. The day of his departure, this gentleman arrived at the airport in time. Made it through security. Sat waiting at the gate. Watched as people stood in line to get on the plane. His plane. Heard his name announced by the attendants. But it didn’t get up from his seat.
Only after seeing his plane take off did he finally leave the airport. Came straight here and pawned his ticket. I got a great deal on it — which I can pass off to you. Want to go to the Philippines? I heard it’s beautiful. Plus, there is a worried family waiting in the Manila airport for someone to come through the gate. Might as well be you, right?
No? Okay. Maybe travel isn’t your thing.
Let’s see, let’s see, let’s see. You seem fairly put together. Maybe fashion is your flavor?
Come this way. I have just the thing for you! I hung it up in a closet, waiting for the right customer to come along. Stand back as I open this door. I have a bit of a moth problem. Cover your face. They like to go for the eyes. Ready? One … two … THREE!
Out, out, out you damn insects! Whew. That was a bigger swarm than last week. They are reproducing at an alarming rate. What was I getting in this closet? Oh yes… the dress. Let me reach back in here and find it.
Here it is. What do think?
I just love the color! Red as warm blood. Feel this fabric. Satin straight from the looms of heaven. Don’t you just want to rub it all over your face? I have. Many times. But don’t worry — I always dry clean the dress after.
I know this gown would look great on you.
It’s never been worn. Look… the tags are still there. The lady who brought it in told me that she had purchased this particular piece of attire for a special occasion. She had tried on a lot of dresses with varying degrees of enthusiasm. None of them made her feel a certain way. Until she put this red dress on. She told me that once the dress slipped over her shoulders and down her body, she stared at the person in the mirror for five minutes. Had never had seen this attractive stranger before. She was looking at a woman brimming with confidence and curves. A person at home in a body that felt foreign in the last few years.
I had to clean off the spots where her tears soaked through the material.
When she finally took it off, she felt like a superhero stepping out of the costume. The dress was bought for a spectacular night. But then the night was canceled. And never rescheduled. She had opportunities to wear the dress. Weddings. Funerals. Trivia night at the local tavern. She would stare at the dress, hanging there in her closet like a wanted poster for a night that never was. But she always reached for the bulky sweatshirt and leggings instead. They were the familiar she could hide in.
Eventually, she brought the dress here. No point in getting dressed up if you have nowhere to go?
But her loss is your gain! As you can see from the tag, this is an expensive piece of clothing. But for you, I am willing to take 5 percent off the sale price. No?
Hmm… has anyone told you that you are hard to please?
Wait! A thought has zapped my brain.
Do you need a name?
Come over here. Perhaps this item will whet your appetite. I keep it in my lockbox with the broken lock. This is where I put all my most valuable objects.
Here. Take a gander at this. A list of names! All are available and ready for adoption. Every cognomen delicately written on a rosy pink slip of paper. If you ever thought “I need a new identity” then this is exactly what you need.
How regal would you feel if you were named “Magnus”? Oh… look at this one. “Claire.” A coquettish moniker. Perfect for a golden-haired ingénue sipping a dusky espresso in a Parisian café. Hey! I am also favorable to “Otto.” In fact, the name “Otto” would define you nicely. It’s right here on the list, along with many other appellations to choose from.
I remember I purchased this particular item from a couple from the city. It was raining (just like it is now) the day they came into shop. They were young. But harsh lines cut deep ravines in the corners of their eyes and mouth. Those canyons contained universes.
“How much for this?” the gentleman asked me. I took the crumbled paper from his calloused hand and unfolded it. Once I saw the list of names, I knew I had a treasure. But I did not want to overplay my hand.
“Well, I don’t know,” I said. “This type of note paper isn’t as popular as it once was. Don’t know if there is a market for pink pages anymore. Could I ask why you want to sell?”
The man looked at the lady. She stared down at the counter. Her hands were trembling.
“We thought we could use these names. But… it turns out we can’t.”
I made a show of thinking about the deal. Finally, I said “Okay, how about a hundred dollars?”
The man nodded his head. When I counted the crisp bills and placed them in his palm the man began to cry. Not loud. Not hard. But with the emotion reserved for a long-held dream crushed beneath the foot of inescapable reality. The couple turned and walked out the door. There was a wide space between them as they left.
Well, what do you think? That couple had a quite a list of names, didn’t they? How much is it worth to you? Wait… you don’t want this item either?
Well, what do you want then?
You’re selling the umbrella? The one you came in with? Why?
Oh, it was a gift from someone. Someone needed that umbrella. But you missed the chance to give it. I suppose it’s too late to present the umbrella now? I mean… it is raining still. This person could still avail themselves of such an instrument like an umbrella.
Oh. I am sorry to hear that. Yes, I suppose they don’t need an umbrella anymore.
In that case, yes, I will buy it from you. How does one dollar sound?
You must sign up or log in to submit a comment.
I like the concept, and the way you imply the situation with the umbrella at the end but never state it. You might want to look at the wording in the start of the last major paragraph, though -- if it's as gift *from* someone, as you wrote, then they gave it to the person selling it. But you imply a line or two later that the person selling it instead intended to give it *to* the other person, which would make it a gift for them, not a gift from them. Normally I don't comment on things that night be typos but this one looks pretty important so I figured it was a good idea to make sure you knew about it.
Reply
Great catch! Thank you. Yes, will need to fix that.
Reply
This is a great story about lost hopes, deferred dreams, and all the weight carried in “what may have been.” As I read it, I had a flash of Mr. Gold (Rumplestiltskin) from Once Upon a Time, along with echoes of the Sullivan Bros. Carnival and Samuel Sullivan from Heroes. That blend of myth, commerce, and quiet emotional reckoning really works here.
I agree with others that the piece feels like a beginning — in a good way. I found myself wanting to know more about the proprietor, J. Idleman (an especially apt name), and the lineage behind the shop. There’s an opportunity to deepen his character just a touch: even a fleeting hint of his personal stake in these “almosts” could add another layer of intrigue. Has he ever sold something of his own? Does he believe in second chances, or is he resigned to accumulation?
A few smaller craft notes that might strengthen an already compelling piece:
- Tightening some of the phrasing in the middle sections (particularly the dress vignette) could sharpen the emotional impact. The imagery is strong—trimming a line or two in places would let it land even harder.
- The repetition of structure across the items works thematically, but you might consider varying the rhythm slightly to keep the reader subtly off-balance, mirroring the unease of the shop itself.
- The ending is effective, but you could heighten it further by letting the final exchange breathe —perhaps one more beat of silence or interiority before the dollar amount lands.
Overall, this is imaginative, cohesive, and quietly haunting. The concept carries weight, and the execution invites reflection without forcing it. I’d absolutely read more if this world were expanded.
Reply
Great notes. Thank you for the strong suggestions.
Reply
Really dissapointing, was looking for a clever twist at the end but it just sputtered, stalled, and quit...Ugh
Reply
Great read, this was an intriguing story.
Reply
LOVE this. I chose it because 4:12 is a sign I receive from my best friend who has passed away. The story couldn't have fit better with the emotions I have felt from missed opportunities with her, nostalgia for past times, and just the true emotions of managing entropy in life. You connected me with my humanity on a lovely day. 10 stars
Reply
Thank you, Jessica. Your comment means a lot.
Reply
Started reading and was intrigued. Gave up after several mistakes that could easily have been rectified by a check through editing.
Surely that's the least a reader should expect when giving their time to read your work?
Reply
This is a good commercial for the value of editors. Thanks Paulene.
Reply
What an interesting idea for a story. Well written and intriguing. Congrats on the short listing - well done.
Reply
Thanks Stevie!
Reply
Very interesting and unusual. I, however, got lost wondering WHY the items were forfeited. Why didn't our traveller get on the plane? Why didn't our lady in red take herself somewhere exotic just for the hell of it? Curious about the name sellers and their story. I saw the piece more as a beginning than a conclusion.
Reply
Agreed. There is more to explore. This piece serves as an introduction to the Emporium. Perhaps there will be a moment to further build this world. Thanks for the suggestion!
Reply
Bravo!! Congrats on the shortlist.
Holy smokes this was good. Better than the winner in my opinion. Such a relatable feeling. Nothing like reading through an old journal or digging through the basement and finding the relics of a person you used to...could still...be.
Reply
Thanks Zack! You are SO right. We all feel this tension between what we are ... what we once were ... what we could be ... maybe could be again?
Reply
The concept here is immediately engaging, especially the idea of turning missed chances into physical objects you can hold and examine. One thing that might elevate it further is tightening a few of the longer item descriptions so the pacing doesn’t linger too long in any one story before moving on. I really liked the voice of the shopkeeper—it carries the piece and makes each example feel connected instead of fragmented. The umbrella at the end is a strong choice because it grounds everything in something smaller and more personal after all the larger “almosts.” There’s a quiet emotional weight underneath the whole piece that builds more than it announces itself.
Reply
Thanks Scott. Really good notes. Appreciate it.
Reply
Congrats
Reply
Thanks John!
Reply
The premise of a shop that sells "could have beens" is compelling. I find the prose polished and the narrator's voice very distinct. You turned regrets and lost potentials into physical artifacts, which is exceptional. Thanks for a good read.
Reply
Thanks Alex!
Reply
I really enjoyed this story. I could hear the voice of the salesman being overly eager, but I liked the subtext of the items that were being pawned. Fun piece!
Reply
Thanks Hayley!
Reply