Clara couldn’t for the life of her remember why she’d come to Greyfriars Kirkyard. She’d been excited to tour it when she first arrived in Edinburgh, enraptured by the chance to study history in a city with its eras stacked atop one another like the layers of a cake: stairs slicing through Georgian streets that had been cobbled atop medieval streets, who themselves had dug their foundations through Celtic ruins, with a gothic castle topper looming over them all.
After drinking her way through town during Fresher’s Week and beginning her studies, she had visited every museum in the city twice, written all her essays at a cafe with a large window overlooking both the Castle and Kirkyard, and even broken up with Toby from Bath on top of Arthur’s Seat.
By the start of her second year, she moved off campus into a dilapidated, but affordable, flat in the Old Town. It took persuading to get her friends Helen and Tirtha to choose it over the flat with the dishwasher in the New Town, and an agreement to take on the 50 pounds a week difference in rent herself, but the moment she moved in, she knew it was worth it. She chose the room with a window that, if she leaned out, just a bit, she could see the Kirkyard as she listened to bagpipe melodies duel throughout the city.
She even took a job giving historical walking tours, spending her weeknights telling tourists from as far as Mumbai and Buenos Aires, and even Minnesota, back home, about the loyal Greyfriars Bobby and murderous escapades of Burke and Hare.
It was during her third year that something flipped. The city that had once felt so large and endless, suddenly made Clara feel small and insignificant. Not only did she have to compete with the other half-a-million people living in the city, and the five million tourists wading in and out, but everywhere she went, the ghosts of the million more interesting people who’d called this city home over the past thousand years stood beside her as statues and headstones and faces on the covers of books in shop windows.
The life she had made for herself, the small space she’d carved out by paying two-hundred--and fifty--pounds a week, meant nothing to the city she loved. She was Edinburgh’s Toby from Bath. She was less than Edinburgh’s Toby from Bath. She would not be found in its histories or its footnotes, and when her studies ended and her visa expired, the city would not notice she’d gone.
She found a new job making coffee in the student union, wrote her essays in a vegan cafe in New Town, and broke up with Highlands Harry outside an Apple store.
Her one act of pertinacity was to keep the lease on her flat, even after Helen and Tirtha left and had to be replaced via residence hall flyers, and leave her bedside lamp on, at all hours of the day and night. Its light glimmered coral pink through the lampshade. It gleamed through her window, warming the brown-gray rubblestone of her building--her small mark on the city.
Her heart jumped each time she saw it, on the streets amongst the other Edinburghers, tourists, and ghosts alike. Evidence that she was here. Evidence that she affected the city in some minuscule way.
She looked for the light now, but couldn’t spot it amongst the darkening buildings to her left. The old Elm by the gate had grown fatter, its heavy green branches blocking it, perhaps. Or perhaps Bryony, one of her new flatmates, had turned it off again. No matter how many times Clara explained to her that the LED bulb couldn’t add more than two or three pence to their electric bill and that Clara would give her the pence directly, if it mattered to her so much, Bryony would still slink into her room and turn the bulb off a couple times a week.
They hadn’t exactly become the fastest of friends in the few months they lived together. Really, the only thing they seemed to have in common was their suspicion that their third flatmate, Pyotr was either a KGB agent in disguise or the Candlemaker Lane Killer, or, maybe, both, whispering over tea about his microwaved instant coffee each morning, his bacon flavored toothpaste, and the banging in his room at odd hours of the night.
Still, Clara knew they were just being mean. A cheap connection.
Clara headed down the steps and slid out the Kirkyard’s heavy iron gate into the city, unusually quiet in the purple gloaming. She’d go home and turn her lamp on and then maybe give Helen and Tirtha a text, to see how they were getting on with their third year modules. She could invite them over for pizza and Halloween movies before the half-term break.
Clara stuck her tongue out at the statue of Greyfriars Bobby, looking down at the city behind his polished bronze nose. He wasn’t even a real dog. The Victorians made him up, a precious furry companion, loyal through the veil of death; they were working tourists even then.
It was a mild evening for October, which made the empty streets even more suspicious. At a minimum, the other locals should have been out, taking advantage of the weather by huddling outside of pubs with pints in white-knuckled fists, telling themselves that “not as cold as expected” was close enough to “warm.”
Something in the pit of Clara’s stomach told her to avoid walking under the George the IVth bridge, the great archway bridging two of the city’s layers. The darkness beneath it was thick and menacing.
Clara kept on. She was just getting in her own head. The papers had spent the dying summer fearmongering about the Candlemaker Lane Killer, the possible perpetrator of the two people found stabbed near the Grassmarket, one week after another, just before the Fringe swept through the city in a hurricane of sophomanic one-man shows.
The sheer number of flyers alone should have been enough to scare away the killer.
Clara quickened her pace as she passed the stairs that led up to Victoria street which led, aptly, to the Victorian addition to the city overhead. She tensed as she hurried past the cavern-like entrance, but no killer leapt out of the shadows.
There really should have been more people around. Clara turned to look behind her, but she could only make out hazy movements of faraway tarryers. Tirtha was right, she needed glasses.
She stepped beneath the shadow of the bridge, heart thumping doggedly in her chest. Only a few more strides and she’d be within sight of her window again.
Her place. She’d be on her street, within the gaze of her own ghost, watching the world go by underneath her melon-hued light.
The scents of damp moss and iron filled her nose. The shadows deepened.
There was something in them, in the indentation of a boarded up doorway. Clara could feel it, demanding her attention.
She stumbled on the curb. The thud thud of her heart roaring over the silence of the street. Just a few strides.
The thing in the shadow pulled at her.
She forced her head to turn, to face the corner.
And sighed.
Just a small pile of wilting carnations, a framed photo sticking up from the back of them. A chill worked down Clara’s spine.
She stepped closer.
Her photo. From her first week in the city. Helen had taken it, of Clara standing at the entrance to Edinburgh Castle, her face bright with the rush of exploring the town. Clara had printed it at the school library and put it in a fake gold frame she found on discount at Primark.
This frame.
What was her picture doing in fron--
The memory came back to Clara in flashes.
The glint of a knife. Pyotr’s face. The blood warm and glimmering as it wet her coat. Her window, dark and quiet and far from her reach.
Far from reach.
She shut her eyes, shaking her head, shaking away the horrible thoughts.
She’d try again.
Clara couldn’t for the life of her remember why she’d come to Greyfriars Kirkyard. She’d been excited to tour it when she first arrived in Edinburgh, enraptured by the chance to study history in a city with its eras stacked atop one another like the layers of a cake: stairs slicing
You must sign up or log in to submit a comment.
Love a good loop. I'm honestly going to read this again word for word. It's truly amazing.
The way it's grounded in the setting and subtle features give it a grim but yet so light hearted warmth somewhat puts me in the atmosphere. It's exactly how'd act it I were there.
I knew she wasn't gonna make it at the end but didn't expect her to go like that. Good read.
Reply
Thank you so much! A reread is the highest honor.
Reply
This was wonderful! I enjoyed the loop back at the end. And you created a vivid and real setting! Wonderful writing!
Reply
Thank you!!
Reply
Edinburgh is the perfect City for a ghost story, they move behind every corner
Thanks!
Reply
It’s such an atmospheric city! I’ve only ever been in the fall and it’s honestly hard to imagine it in the spring!
Reply
I loved how Clara’s coral-pink bedside lamp becomes her little proof that she belongs in Edinburgh. Knowing what the flowers and framed photograph reveal makes that desire to leave a mark suddenly heartbreaking. The repeated opening also gives the ending an eerie, circular quality. Did you always plan for the story to return to its first sentence?
Reply
Thank you so much! And yes! I wanted it to be a bit of a sisyphean story, with Clara caught in a loop of trying and failing to reach her home, and so I wrote the first few sentences knowing I wanted them to be the last sentences too. I'm so glad it proved effective. I feel like taking a chance with structure like that is always a bit of a gamble; if it doesn't land emotionally, it can feel like a cheap gimmick.
Reply
I think it landed beautifully! The circular structure doesn't feel like a gimmick at all; it makes the reader experience a little of Clara's endless struggle alongside her. Very much a literary gamble that paid off! I especially love that you knew the ending before the journey was fully written.
I get the feeling you might have published a book, or maybe not yet... Is that correct?
Reply
This is wonderfully atmospheric storytelling. The descriptions of Edinburgh make the setting feel like a character in its own right, and the recurring image of Clara’s lamp is a beautiful, haunting touch. The final reveal is chilling and makes the opening hit differently. Was the idea of Clara reliving her final moments something you planned from the beginning?
Reply
Thank you so much! And yes! I wanted the story to be a sisyphean tale of Clara caught in a loop of trying and failing to make her way home. The story's title comes from the Scottish Ballad "Loch Lomond" a story about Jacobite soldier telling his friend that he'll take "the low road" home, which in Celtic mythology is the "fairy" road that spirits take home when killed abroad. Clara's both on the low road, literally, on the road that is lower in elevation, and on the low "fairy" road as a ghost.
Reply
Wow! this is great! Where do you get your inspiration from if I may humbly ask? haha:)
Reply
Lovely! "Stairs slicing" caught my eye at the beginning on the first read through. I thought it was an interestingly violent adjective nestled in a somewhat peaceful setting. A brilliant way to end it.
Reply
Thank you!
Reply
This is my first time learning about Reedsy. Your story is a great introduction. The buildup of suspense and the ability to create a connection with the character in such a short time is truly wonderful.
Reply
Thank you so much!
Reply
Ah, a macabre concept. Well done on the prompt!
Reply
Thank you!
Reply
Congratulations, Julia! You drew me in with this line (my favorite!): "...a city with its eras stacked atop one another like the layers of a cake: stairs slicing through Georgian streets that had been cobbled atop medieval streets, who themselves had dug their foundations through Celtic ruins, with a gothic castle topper looming over them all." Your power of description--here and throughout your story--is amazing! Even the small details are significant, especially the lamplight, a beacon of home and hope. As other readers mentioned, I, too, read your story a second time and was very glad I did. I missed a very important detail--your use of foreshadowing: Bryony and Clara's suspicion that "Pyotr was either a KGB agent in disguise or the Candlemaker Lane Killer, or, maybe, both." I was so caught up in your descriptions of Edinburgh (taking me back to Jamie and Clare in Edinburgh in the Outlander series) that I stood with Clara, dumb as a brick, puzzled with her about why her picture was there--still not putting two and two together. On my second reading, I connected the clue of the withered flowers with the picture. Aha! A memorial. Julia, I appreciate your wonderful imagination and writing ability to weave this captivating story. I also love that I received the story's meaning via two layers of reading. I was delighted when you revisited the cake metaphor in your final line: "...enraptured by the chance to study history in a city with its eras stacked atop one another like the layers of a cake: stairs slicing." Your metaphor of "stairs slicing" through physical eras of time compared to the celebratory slicing of cake, and finally "the glint of knife: a masterful multilayered use of metaphor. Well done!!!
Reply
Thank you so much for all of your kind words! I'm glad, too, that the details rewarded a second reading.
Reply
I love it, amazing read
Reply
Thank you!
Reply
Agree with everyone on all accounts and will add that your story reads very naturally, with wonderful pacing and rhythm. The increase in tension when she approaches the bridge was super effective for me and is something that can be hard to pull off in short form fiction. Well done!
Reply
Thank you so much!
Reply
AMAZING JOB! Win WELL deserved!
Reply
Thank you!!
Reply
Oh very good, very good. I enjoyed this ! Love the twist. Congratulations!
Reply
Thank you!
Reply
Nicely done. Congratulations on the win! Welcome to Reedsy!
Reply
Thank you!
Reply
Loved the story! As someone else said, I re-read it right away. I had caught the flip (I mean it actually said flip), but because of the underlying tone of the desire to matter, "the ghosts of the million more interesting people who’d called this city home over the past thousand years..." it didn't fully register even then. Well done!
Reply
Thank you so much!
Reply
Edinburgh is certainly an excellent setting for a ghost yarn, although I think NOLA would give it a run for its money! I loved the line about the locals outside the pubs with white-knuckled fists holding pints and equating "not as cold as expected" with "warm". Here in Maine you can tell when it's changed from the wind breaker/sweater weather of autumn to the hard cold of fall when people start remarking, "not bad, if you stay in the sun." Look forward to your next posting. -M
Reply
Thank you! This story felt like it needed a more ancient setting, but the idea of a ghost trying and failing to walk home is definitely a little Nola-inspired. Our tradition of funeral second line parades supposedly has its origins in taking a coffin on a winding route to the cemetery so when the spirit awakens, it can't find its way back home to haunt the living. The thought of some poor ghost wandering the French Quarter as they search for their home has always broken my heart!
Reply
LOVE THIS!
Reply
Thank you <3
Reply
What an engrossing tale! Your words pulled me into the story seamlessly. I felt as if I were walking beside Clara. Edinburgh was the perfect setting. Congratulations on your win.
Reply
Thank you!
Reply
What a great story! It is a little weird that the prompt telegraphs the twist. That being said, the story still works. It’s a really great read.
Some stories live and die on the rug pull, but yours still works because your protagonist feels very real, and the atmosphere makes me feel like I’m in Edenburrow, even though I’ve never been there.
Reply
Thank you! My philosophy is that a good twist should only enhance a narrative upon a second or "spoiled" reading (The Murder of Roger Ackroyd is a great example of this). I can only hope my story has managed to stand up to that ideal!
Reply
WONDERFUL!!! 😀
This is one of the best short story's I have ever read!
Reply
Thank you! <3
Reply
Awesome read. Vivid scene riveted me, compelling me to read on nonstop until the very end.
Reply
Thank you!
Reply
Tense, atmospheric, and an exceptionally clever take on the prompt.
Snapping the narrative shut the instant the memory surfaces locks Clara inside an inescapable loop of denial. Circling back to the opening exposes “couldn’t for the life of her” as the story’s most cutting, literal punch to the gut.
A well-earned win!
Reply
Thank you so much! I apologize for the gut punch, but I appreciate the compliment!
Reply
Congrats
Reply
Thank you!
Reply
A beautifully haunting read! Congratulations on the win!
Reply
Thank you!
Reply
What a brilliantly crafted, atmospheric story! The atmosphere of Edinburgh practically drips off the page—you captured that distinct feeling of Old Town so vividly, from the stacked layers of history down to the bagpipes dueling across the streets and the huddling outside pubs with pints in white-knuckled fists.
The character arc with Clara is so painfully relatable for anyone who has ever moved to a storied, historic city. That shift in her third year—moving from the starry-eyed tourist enraptured by the lore of Burke and Hare to feeling completely swallowed up and dwarfed by the weight of the millions who walked those streets before her—hits a raw emotional nerve. The detail about her being "Edinburgh’s Toby from Bath" is such a sharp, funny, and devastating turn of phrase. It grounds her existential dread in the awkward, clumsy reality of university romance.
The symbolism of her small coral-pink bedside lamp is genuine storytelling magic. It’s such a simple, poignant way to express that universal human ache: I am here, I exist, I am leaving a mark. The ongoing minor war with Bryony over those few extra pence on the electric bill adds just the right touch of student-flat humor to balance the deeper thematic weight.
And that twist! You laid the breadcrumbs so skillfully throughout the walk home. The heavy, unseasonal quiet, the dark under the George IV bridge, the blurred tarryers in the background, and the missing pink light in her window all build this subtle, creeping sense of wrongness without ever giving away the game prematurely. When she stumbles upon the carnations and that cheap fake-gold Primark frame, the realization lands with a genuine chill.
Ending on the loop—having her shut her eyes, shake away the nightmare, and reset right back to that opening line in Greyfriars Kirkyard—is absolute perfection. It’s devastatingly tragic: the very city she loved and feared being forgotten by has now swallowed her whole, turning her into one of the exact statues and headstones she used to pass by on her walking tours.
The pacing, the local flavor, the dark humor, and the spectral loop at the end work together seamlessly. Thank you so much for sharing this piece—it’s going to stick with me for a long time every time I think of Edinburgh!
Reply
Thank you so much! I’m so glad to hear all of the details landed so well and that this story will stick with you!
Reply