Normalcy is for Losers

Contemporary Sad Teens & Young Adult

This story contains themes or mentions of mental health issues.

Written in response to: "Write a story in which a character's true self or identity is revealed." as part of Comic Relief.

I remember Jonah’s red car.

The same red car that always appeared out of nowhere.

In the middle of parking lots, outside of parties.

The same red car that held everybody looking to escape.

“Escape what?” he’d ask anyone who knocked on his window. It didn’t matter if it was the middle of 5th period or 2 a.m.—he was always there.

Parents getting a divorce? Go to Jonah.

OD’d on something strong? Go to Jonah.

Bullied? Go to Jonah.

Eating disorder? Go to Jonah.

Depression? Go to Jonah.

Heartbreak? Go to Jonah.

I went to Jonah’s red car once.

I knocked on his window once, as I’d been told to do, and he rolled it down slowly, looking at me with those sage green eyes. Those eyes enchanted me.

“Problem?” He asked me, handing me a piece of mint gum. I took the gum, placed it in my mouth, not thinking if it was laced in drugs or anything.

I took a deep breath.

“Crippling anxiety.” I stated, bluntly, as if it weren’t a medical thing. As if it were something boring, or annoying, or something minor. Not something that kept me up at night, even with melatonin. Not something that has me crying in the bathroom after a mistake, or a wrong word. No, not that.

“Crippling anxiety… yeah, hop on in,” Jonah said, all calm, like he’d dealt with this before. He probably had. Multiple times.

My heart pounded inside of my head, ringing with every breath.

I walked over to the passenger door, and opened it with shaky hands.

“So, how are you feeling today?” He asked me, like a trained professional. A therapist. I swallowed the spit forming in my mouth, and wiped my sweaty palms against my dark blue jeans with an accidental hole in the right knee.

Jonah looked at me, sunlight peeking through the visors, lighting up his hair.

“I don’t know,” I said, my voice shaking a little. God, was I about to cry? No, big girls don’t cry. Even when they get hurt.

Jonah stayed silent for a little while. I thought of something somebody had said to me a little earlier, when I brought up Jonah.

Don’t be afraid of silence.

I looked at him, and then looked down, my eyes darting between the air freshener attached nimbly on the dash, and my half picked off blue nail polish.

“I… I want to feel normal.” I spoke finally, breaking the silence. He wouldn’t take ‘I don’t know’ as an answer. We all knew, we just had to find the right way to put it.

“Normalcy is for losers, but I see where your head is,” he said, and I sucked in a little breath.

“What are you here to escape?” He asked me, the question I’d been preparing myself for, but you can’t prepare for everything.

“Myself,” I whispered, barely audible. He nodded, so I know he heard.

“That’s the most often thing that I hear, believe it or not. I know,” he said, clearing his throat at the end. He wanted to go somewhere, but he didn’t. I accepted the silence. I wasn’t afraid of it. Or was I?

I stared out of the window, as if this was a common thing I did. Something that I was used to.

He started cracking his knuckles, which made my eyes twitch. He noticed, said sorry, and stopped. I smiled a little.

“So, what do you want to come out of this? Advice? Something stronger?” He asked, reaching over and pulling out a notebook out of the glove compartment.

“Advice. My parents would kill me if I did anything they didn’t want, e.g., smoking, drinking, being sad, throwing parties, gaining weight, having fun. I can’t even have sleepovers.” I said, staring out into space, losing sight of the world around me. It was just me and Jonah now.

“I see. Well, no offense, but your parents sound like asses,” he said, cracking a grin.

“They are, to be honest,” I replied. Something about the car made me feel grounded. I could confide in something other than myself.

“So, my advice is to have a mantra or something. Maybe like, daily affirmations. Tried that?”

“Yeah. A lot, actually. Even went to small group in middle school, for managing anxiety.”

“Cool, I guess. Have you tried anything else?”

“Nah, not really. I can swallow pills, but everything scares me. I’ve only ever taken one shot, and that was a dare, and I threw up five times afterwards. I’m super prone to pain, so I can’t do anything to myself,”

“Those things don’t actually help, trust me. We’ll find something else, okay?”

“Okay,”

He smiled at me, and I smiled back. I picked at a loose hangnail, wincing when I pulled it out. My breathing became shallower as the silence progressed.

Nobody really knew Jonah. It was all vague when it came to his story. He never missed an actual day of school, but if you ever needed any help, he was there. It didn’t add up. His eyes would shine, but they looked tired. He wore the same superman shirt everyday, and had the same eager, but worn out, smile on his face, that highlighted the dimples on his cheeks.

“Jonah, why do you do what you do?” I asked him. I mustered up all of my courage to ask him that, and it was met with silence. Silence for a little, then a sigh.

“I just want to help, okay? Help as much as I possibly can,” he said, smiling a little.

I looked at him, looked into his sage green eyes. They were hungry eyes.

He writhed his hands together, a trick I used. To stop my hands from shaking.

This boy was beautiful. Could he not see it himself?

Suddenly, the bell rang. Shit, I thought, had I really been in this car for two whole periods?

Jonah’s face drooped a little, and then he looked back into the backseat, and let out a sigh of relief. I looked at him funny, and he smiled.

“So, uh, do you want me to go?” I asked him, wiggling around in my seat a little.

“Nah, you’re all good. Wanna talk more? Go somewhere else?” he asked, turning the keys into ignition.

“Sure. But like, no offense, but I don’t wanna hookup or anything,” I said. He tensed, but kept calm as always.

“Heard that before. I wasn’t planning on it,”

“Okay. Sorry, I sounded really stuck up when I said that. Disregard.”

“Don’t be sorry. It’s okay, really.”

“O-okay. Don’t you have like, somewhere to be? Home?” I asked. His face made me regret ever asking. “Sorry,” I said, silently pinching myself for saying sorry again, “I shouldn’t have asked,”

He stayed quiet for a little bit, and then turned on the radio. R.E.M’s “Everybody Hurts”.

I winced at the song, and so did he, turning it to a different station, with some sort of pop song on. It was better than depressing music.

Music that we both knew the names of.

After a little while, he turned off the radio, which was really starting to piss me off, with all the fake good vibes and happy love songs. Now was not the time for “Lover” by Taylor Swift.

“You ever wonder why I drive around all day?” Jonah asked me, and for a second, my mind flashed to a scenario. Kids, piling up around his car, trapping him in. What was it like? You could always reach him, right? How did it work?

“Everybody does, man,” I replied.

“Figured. Anyway, I drive because I don’t have anything else to do. I could go home, but my mom is the equivalent of all Disney stereotypical evil stepmothers mashed together into a giant homewrecker, and my stepdad, well, I don’t wanna go into him. I won’t waste another breath with his name.”

I didn’t know what to say. Jonah was confiding in me, now. I sighed, and then he started tapping furiously on the wheel. My eye twitched, he noticed it, said sorry, and stopped.

“Sorry. I don’t know why I kinda said that, sorry. So, anyway, let’s talk about you, now, okay?”

“Okay. You’re good, by the way. I can listen if you need me to,”

“Nah, it’s alright. I’m good.”

He said he was good, but he gripped the steering wheel like it was the only thing keeping him from floating away.

We stayed quiet for a little while, not daring to turn on the radio again. I pulled down the visor, and noticed the backseat. There weren’t blankets or fast food trash or anything like that. I expected that, for some reason, but the seat was clean. He cleared his throat, and then I turned up the visor, the dim lit sun peeking into the car.

“Remember when I said normalcy is for losers?” He asked me, breaking the silence.

“Yeah…” I said, as he started making more turns. Like he wanted to go somewhere now.

“I had a sister. Her name was Kay. She would’ve loved being a loser. She would’ve loved being boring.” I looked at Jonah. The red car almost began to fall apart, but somehow, it stayed together.

Suddenly, I recognized where we were. The cemetery.

He looked around, making sure nobody else was there, and then he yanked the keys out of the ignition. He was silent as he opened his door, and I followed him.

He stood in front of the gates, not going in. “I can’t bring myself to look. It just yells at me that I couldn’t save her.” he spoke, softly. I stayed still, feeling the calm rush of the wind.

“She always wore this shirt,” he said, pointing to the superman logo, “She said it made her really feel like a hero.” He smiled, laughed a little, and then sighed. I grinned.

He shoved his hands into his pockets, and then turned, facing the sunset. His eyes went all glassy for a second, and then returned to normal.

He walked back to the car, and I followed him.

He stared at the old red car for a second, and then hopped onto the hood. He patted the space next to him, offering for me to sit.

“You sure?” I asked, reluctant.

“Hell yeah,” he said, pumping his fist in the air. I smiled, laughing a little.

“I mean, I do have a reason to be resistant,” I said as I made my way towards the front of the car, “The last time I was on one of these bad boys, somebody was actually in the car and started driving. One of my psycho friends, I’m sure. So I have a reason to be scared, okay, Jonah?” I said, enunciating all of my words with a bang.

He chuckled, and then I hopped up next to him. We stared at the rusted gates together, a raven calling in the distance.

“Did you know that a group of ravens is called an unkindness?” I asked him, as the raven flew down, perching on a tree.

"No. But it fits, I guess," he said. I smiled and sighed.

"Who's been unkind to you?" I asked, and he stared off into space. He cracked his knuckles, suddenly stopping when he remembered I hated that sound. Instead, he dug his fingernails into his shoulder. I looked at him, and gently grabbed the fingers off of his shoulder, where I could see imprints of nails.

He stayed quiet for a solid five minutes, then spoke.

"A lot of people have been unkind to me. But I try to be kind to as many people as I can. You know, Jonah's red car and all of that," he said.

"Huh. Well, you've helped a whole, whole lot of people. Like, seriously. You're famous at this point, Jonah." I said.

"I don't want to be famous," he whispered, wiping under his eyes.

His walls were falling down.

"I just want to help." he said.

I took a deep breath, and picked at the loose hangnail, my eyes still focused on Jonah.

"Here. When I first started doing the whole car thing, I bought a little notebook. I keep track of all the people who come. I know, it sounds a little psychopathic, but hey, a boy's gotta do what a boy's gotta do. Wanna see it?" he asked.

"Sure, if that's okay," I said.

"It is. Here," Jonah said, reaching into his back pocket and pulling out this tattered black moleskin notebook. I took it from him, our fingers brushing together, and opened it to the first page.

01-24 (January Twenty-Fourth)

Name: Jonah

Age: 16-

Phone: haha nice one sucker no chance here.

I looked at him, and he started blushing, mumbling something about sixteen-year-old Jonah.

The rest of the notebook was basically the whole school. Even the principal, which I gasped at. He chuckled at my audible surprise.

It had their problems, advice for the problems, and then something else. A check mark, or an X mark.

"What're they for?" I asked him.

"It sounds stupid, but it meant if I struggled with it or whatever." He replied. I looked at his sage green eyes, and how they glistened in the sunset, the pink and orange hues reflecting off of his face.

I flipped through, not trying to be nosy, and then got to the last page, with only a few pages left in the notebook.

04-11 (April Eleventh)

Her name is Abby. Crippling anxiety. Oof, been there before. Maybe she's a little like me. Oh well, it's whatever. Maybe, though. But who knows? Not me, that's for sure. Note to self: get a new notebook soon. Also, maybe try to go home for once. Maybe. Who knows? Wherever the road takes me, I'll be here. ~Jonah

I looked at Jonah, and Jonah looked at me.

He hopped off the hood, getting in the car. He smirked at me.

I shrieked playfully, and got off, stumbling into the old red car.

We laughed until our stomachs hurt, and then he turned the keys in the car.

"You know, Jonah, I think it's time to go home." I said, his sage green eyes looking into mine.

"Yeah, it's time to go home."

Posted Apr 12, 2026
Share:

You must sign up or log in to submit a comment.

12 likes 22 comments

Katherine Howell
02:06 Apr 20, 2026

I really thought this story was a nice take on the “guy who wants to help everyone else but ends up carrying everything on his own” trope. Jonah comes across as genuinely caring, and I liked how the story gradually reveals the weight he’s holding.

One moment that stood out to me was when he reacted to the hook-up comment like he’d heard it many times before—it made me wonder what kind of vibe he might be giving off to others. He seems sincere, so I found that detail really interesting. I also found myself wanting to know more about Jonah. The notebook mentions him at 16, but he feels older—so I was curious about where he is now. Is he still in school? If not, what keeps him coming back? He says he doesn’t want to be famous, yet he continues to show up for everyone.

It was a really sweet story overall, and these questions come from being invested in it rather than any criticism. Well done!

Reply

Hazel Swiger
02:22 Apr 20, 2026

Thank you so much, Katherine! For your question (which is a good one), for me personally, when I was creating his character, I was thinking he was a little off-putting (he's there all the time, so what in the world is his actual life), and for me, the car setting was just yeah. Jonah *now*, I was picturing senior year, and he will eventually leave, but for now, he's always there. I also thought while writing this that there was going to be a more supernatural note to it. Thank you for such a thoughtful read! This story was a bit of a midnight rush, so it might have had some holes in it, lol.

Reply

Pascale Marie
15:56 Apr 19, 2026

Hi Hazel. I enjoyed this one, and the first line is immediately intriguing. The idea of a fellow student providing a safe space for his peers is strong, and the red car is a unique touch. Your story did remind me of the series ‘S*x education’, which I loved.
My only critique would be the repetition of ‘his sage green eyes’, could be used more sparingly so as to not lose its effect.

Reply

Hazel Swiger
16:53 Apr 19, 2026

Thank you so much, Pascale! Such a thoughtful read. I'll have to look into that series.
Your critique is a fair one; I did sorta intentionally repeat it, but thank you for bringing that up. :)

Reply

Helen A Howard
07:51 Apr 19, 2026

Hi Hazel,
I really like the way you keep the reader guessing about Jonah. I did wonder if it might descend into creepy type territory with him exploiting his “victims”, but instead it was a beautiful exploration of how debilitating struggles with mental health can be and how widespread they are. Also, Jonah seems to be permanently stuck in the friend zone while giving his services to others. I like the way more is revealed about him and we discover who the real Jonah is. I also felt there was a chance for something more to develop between the two characters.
My only question mark and this isn’t a big one is whether he would show the notebook as it contains private material. It serves well as a plot device and he might well do. Not sure. I hope you don’t mind me raising this as I think the piece overall is awesome. Also love the red car 🚘 🤩

Reply

Hazel Swiger
13:22 Apr 19, 2026

Thank you so much for this comment, Helen! I don't mind at all, ha! For as far as that question about the notebook goes, in my mind, I was thinking that Jonah was finally letting his guard down, and showing something so precious as that. When writing a story, I *was* thinking about having a more-than-friends moment between Abby and Jonah, but for now, he's definitely friend zoned. Thank you so much for such a thoughtful read!

Reply

Helen A Howard
13:25 Apr 19, 2026

I see your point. I now want a sequel where he gets out of the dreaded friend zone. Surely she’s going to be impressed by that car. Anyway, an enjoyable read. Keep writing.

Reply

Hazel Swiger
13:26 Apr 19, 2026

Ha! I might think about it... now after I write what I'm cooking up for this week, maybe you'll see the desired red car again! Who knows?

Reply

Helen A Howard
13:30 Apr 19, 2026

I find I get drawn into writing sequels even when I don’t want to. Then people ask if it’s going to turn into a novel which is a problem as I don’t have the time. I have been thinking lately that maybe nearly all short stories have the potential to turn into something bigger.

Reply

Hazel Swiger
13:31 Apr 19, 2026

Yeah, I've gotten that feeling too, lol. We'll see where this one ends up, though!

Reply

Chris Dreyfus
02:33 Apr 17, 2026

This story has a ring of authenticity about it. The sadness is evoked without doubling down on sentimentality. The teen voice is perfectly captured. A clever piece of writing, Hazel. Can I suggest thinking of alternatives to the words "little" and "suddenly." Their overuse can weaken a story. Also, you might consider shortening and rephrasing to make it more active. E.g: "Our fingers brushed when I took it and opened the first page."
"He shoved his hands into his pockets, turned to face the sunset, and his eyes went all glassy for a second." This becomes more dynamic while excising anything unnecessary to carry the story forward. The old less is more trope. Anyway, some thoughts and good luck with your writing.

Reply

Hazel Swiger
10:58 Apr 17, 2026

Thank you so much, Chris! Comments like this really help me sharpen my writing, and it means a lot to me that you read so closely. Thanks.

Reply

Elizabeth Hoban
22:13 Apr 16, 2026

First off - I love the REM song! And this story is so genuinely lovely. Jonah is such a well-developed character. That he even helped the principal is very telling. Abby is so like many adolescents and how wonderful that she took a chance and got int that famous red car when she did. I get the sense that there is more to come between Abby and Jonah. An exceptional piece you've written here. I must read your other stories!

Reply

Hazel Swiger
00:39 Apr 17, 2026

Thank you so much, Elizabeth! It means so much to me! I went the gloomier path as I usually do, but I liked it! Thanks!

Reply

Atlas Gray
14:35 Apr 16, 2026

This is an amazing story. It was handled with the perfect level of tenderness, and the use of something as simple as a red car to introduce the story is genius. I really enjoyed this story, thank you for sharing it!

Reply

Hazel Swiger
16:30 Apr 16, 2026

Thank you so much! This means more than you know :) I'm glad you enjoyed it!

Reply

Fiona Selman
18:41 Apr 15, 2026

This is amazing. I don't even have words. But- as I've said before- everything you write is amazing. Sorry for not saying much today. 🙉

Reply

Hazel Swiger
00:00 Apr 16, 2026

Thank you so much, Fiona! You're good, lol. Thanks!

Reply

Fiona Selman
12:32 Apr 17, 2026

I checked your bio again, it's 2065 words now. lol

Reply

Hazel Swiger
13:33 Apr 17, 2026

Yeah, it just keeps growing, lol.

Reply

Marjolein Greebe
13:49 Apr 15, 2026

This is… genuinely beautiful. You captured something incredibly tender here without ever forcing it, and that’s not easy—especially with a subject like this.
Jonah’s red car is such a strong, simple image, but what really makes it work is how you slowly reveal the cost of being “the one everyone goes to.” That notebook moment? That’s the heart of the story. Quiet, honest, and it hits hard without trying to.
I also love how Abby grows alongside him, she doesn’t just receive help, she sees him. That shift, especially in the cemetery scene, feels very real and very earned.

Hazel, this one stays with you. 💛

Reply

Hazel Swiger
15:17 Apr 15, 2026

Thank you so much, Marjolein! I'm so glad you enjoyed this one. It means more than you think. Thank you! 💛

Reply

Reedsy | Default — Editors with Marker | 2024-05

Bring your publishing dreams to life

The world's best editors, designers, and marketers are on Reedsy. Come meet them.