The Last Roll Call

Drama Historical Fiction Sad

Written in response to: "Set your story in a place where something terrible once happened." as part of What Lingers.

The men had carried out the last of the tables, but they had left the numbers on the wall. Somebody had written them in carpenter’s pencil above the places where the bodies lay. I had been working in that room for eleven days in June, and still, when I came back in September, I found myself counting.

Mr. Evans was on his knees beside the stove, fitting a length of pipe into the collar.

“You’ll want to open those windows.”

“They are open.”

“The other ones.”

“They don’t open.”

He sat back on his heels and looked at them as if this were a recent development, something I might have done while he was away.

“I’ll fetch a hammer.”

“Please don’t break them. We’ll want them shut soon enough.”

Outside, a wagon struggled through the ruts, its wheels sinking where the new gravel gave way to mud. Across the street stood half a house. You could see the wallpaper in an upstairs bedroom, blue flowers climbing toward a ceiling that was no longer there. The family had hung a blanket across the opening. In the mornings, a woman shook it out as though she were making a bed.

I set my books on the desk. Someone had scrubbed it with something that had taken off the finish. There was a pale place where my hands used to rest.

***

Before the flood, Daniel Keane sat in the second row beside the window. I had moved him there because he talked, then moved the boy beside him because Daniel continued talking, and finally accepted that he would talk to an empty chair if nothing better presented itself.

His father worked at the mill. His mother took in washing. Daniel knew what everyone earned and considered most of it insufficient.

When I asked what he intended to do when he grew up, he said he would own the mill.

“What would you pay your father?”

“More.”

“How much more?”

He thought about that.

“Enough that he’d stop coming home cross.”

The other children laughed, and he laughed with them, although I had not thought he was making a joke.

His little sister Maggie would have started school that autumn. He brought her to the door once to show her where he sat. She stood behind him with two fingers hooked into his belt.

“She won’t talk,” he told me.

“She’s talking now.”

“That’s only to me.”

I bent down to hear her.

“She wants to know where we eat,” Daniel said.

***

Mr. Evans returned with a hammer, a chisel, and his dinner wrapped in newspaper. He put the dinner on my desk.

“Don’t let me leave that.”

“I shall try.”

“My wife says I’m getting forgetful.”

He worked the chisel beneath the window sash. When it came free, a little shower of dried mud fell onto the sill. He caught the window before it dropped.

“There. Air.”

I could smell the river, wet timber, and something burning farther down the street.

“Have you any sandpaper?” I asked.

“What for?”

I pointed at the numbers.

He looked along the wall. “Paint would do it.”

“Have we any?”

“Not today.”

He went back to the stove. I took a damp cloth from my bucket and rubbed at the nearest number. The plaster darkened around it, but the pencil remained.

“You’ll have the wall down before you get that out,” he said.

I kept rubbing.

After a while, he came over and took the cloth from me.

“Go have something to eat. I’ll see to it.”

“I’m not hungry.”

“Well, I am. And I can’t eat with you doing that.”

***

In June, there had been so little paper that we wrote descriptions on the backs of envelopes and the unused portions of letters. People arrived carrying scraps they had been told might lead them to a husband or a child. They unfolded them carefully, smoothing them on my desk.

Sometimes the number was wrong.

Sometimes the description was wrong.

A woman came looking for a little girl in a blue dress. The child we showed her wore blue, but the woman shook her head before she reached the table.

“The buttons,” she said.

I remember wanting her to look at the face. I remember being ashamed of wanting it.

She explained that she had replaced the buttons on her daughter’s dress the previous Sunday. White buttons, all alike except the bottom one.

Then she apologized for troubling us.

I had known people could be frightened of the dead. I had not understood how frightened they could be of leaving without them.

Daniel’s father came three times. On the third visit, he brought Maggie. She sat on the step with a piece of bread while he walked between the tables.

I stayed at my desk. I knew every cowlick on Daniel’s head, the scar beside his mouth, the crooked nail on the finger he had caught in a door. I had written those things down for his father. There was nothing more I could tell him.

***

Maggie arrived on Monday wearing boots too large for her. Her father had folded the tops of her stockings over them, but one had already slipped.

He stood in the doorway holding her dinner pail.

“She’ll want this.”

I took it from him.

“There’s bread and an apple. She says she doesn’t like apples, but she does.”

“Only the skin,” Maggie said.

“Then leave the skin.”

He straightened her collar. He had missed a button, and the two sides would not meet.

“Have you got her down?” he asked me.

“Yes. Margaret Keane.”

“Maggie,” she said.

“Your name’s Margaret.”

He looked past me into the room. The desks had been arranged as nearly as I could remember them. I had put fresh paper over the worst marks on the wall.

“That one was his.”

“Yes.”

Maggie pulled at his coat.

“Can I sit there?”

He rubbed his mouth. His knuckles were split, and there was a dark line beneath each nail that washing would not remove.

“You sit where she puts you.”

“I don’t mind,” I said.

He nodded without looking at me.

For a moment I thought he would ask about the register. Other parents had. They wanted to know which children were coming back, which families had gone to Pittsburgh, whether we had heard anything.

Instead, he bent to Maggie.

“You stay here until I come.”

“Even after?”

“After what?”

“After school.”

“I’ll be here.”

She watched him down the street until the wagon traffic hid him.

***

There were fourteen children that morning. I had expected seventeen. I waited until the church clock finished striking, then another few minutes, pretending to put my papers in order.

A boy in the back row was trying to open his dinner pail without making a sound. Every time I looked up, he stopped.

“You may eat something if you’re hungry, Joseph.”

“I’m not.”

“Then leave it.”

“I wanted to see what she put in.”

This seemed reasonable enough. I let him look.

The old register had swollen in the damp. Its pages lay unevenly beneath my hand, the ink spreading into little blue roots where the water had reached it. I had brought a new book, but I opened the old one to check the names.

Outside, Mr. Evans was moving something heavy across the yard. The scraping stopped.

“Clara Bell.”

“Here.”

“Thomas Dugan.”

A hand went up.

“You can say it, Thomas.”

“Here.”

I worked down the page, finding the children before I called them. Some sat where they always had. Others had taken places beside new companions.

Then I reached Daniel.

I saw the empty space beneath his name where I had never entered another day’s attendance. I saw Maggie at his desk, her feet resting on the rung because they did not reach the floor.

“Daniel Keane.”

My voice sounded quite ordinary.

Maggie raised her hand.

Nobody moved. Joseph put the lid back on his dinner pail.

“Your name is farther down, Maggie.”

“I know.”

“You needn’t answer for him.”

She lowered her hand and looked toward the window. I could see her trying to work out whether she had done something wrong.

I went on with the names.

***

At dinner, she remained at the desk while the others went outside. Her apple sat on a folded handkerchief.

“Shall I peel that?”

She nodded.

I took the little knife I used for sharpening pencils and wiped it. The skin came away in short pieces. My mother could peel an apple without breaking the strip. She used to give it to me to hang over my wrist like a bracelet.

“Daniel said you’d call him.”

I stopped cutting.

“When did he say that?”

“When he showed me.”

I put a piece of apple on the handkerchief.

“He said if he wasn’t here, I should put my hand up. Then you wouldn’t mark him away.”

“That sounds like Daniel.”

“He said you wouldn’t notice.”

I laughed. It came out badly, and I had to put the knife down.

Maggie waited until I could look at her.

“Did you?”

“Yes,” I said. “I noticed.”

***

That afternoon, I copied the children’s names into the new register. When I came to Daniel, I turned back to the old book and wrote missing beside his name. I left room after it.

His father arrived before the other children had gone. Maggie ran to him carrying her empty pail.

On his way out, he touched the paper covering the wall. He knew what was underneath. He had stood beside those numbers, waiting for someone to lift a sheet.

“Looks better,” he said.

After they left, I found one of Daniel’s old pencil marks on the underside of the desk. He had worked a small hole into the wood and drawn spokes around it, making a wheel.

I ran my thumb over it. Then I pushed Maggie’s chair back into place.

Posted Nov 07, 2026
Share:

You must sign up or log in to submit a comment.

14 likes 10 comments

Graham Kinross
November 13, 2026 02:50

The detail about the apple was great, reminds me of something similar at my old teaching job so that a kid would eat more varied food. Also the boy thinking the teacher didn’t notice someone else raising their hand for him is typical, as if the teacher isn’t standing most of the time looking at them. Dealing with a loss like that in the home or the workplace would be devastating. You can’t spend time working with children without caring for them, even the marks of his vandalism had value after the fact. That’s pretty powerful.

Reply

Suzanne Marsh
November 12, 2026 20:08

Great story, history is at times stranger than fiction

Reply

November 12, 2026 09:45

Powerful story. You gave just enough detail about Daniel and Maggie, and the condition of the school, to make this very compelling. You also captured the era very well with historical details and dialogue like someone being "cross". Great work!

Reply

Jonathan Page
November 12, 2026 15:44

Thanks Scott! I like to dabble in the historical accounts from time to time!

Reply

Curtis Lonsdale
November 10, 2026 13:52

Tragic indeed, and real grim, but I love the restrained way in which you write, the less is more approach really works for stories like this one. Just letting the tragedy sit bleakly in the air without having to dramatize it. Very skilled writing. And also, weird coincidence, we both have characters called Daniel and Mr. Evans in our stories this week, that's kind of crazy! Lol. Well, great story, Jonathan, well done.

Reply

Jonathan Page
November 12, 2026 15:44

Thanks Curtis!

Reply

Ron Sewell
November 08, 2026 15:47

Tragic in every way.

Reply

Jonathan Page
November 09, 2026 17:16

Thanks Ron!

Reply

November 07, 2026 23:07

Heartbreaking 💔

Reply

Jonathan Page
November 09, 2026 17:17

Thanks Nicola!

Reply

RBE | Illustrated Short Stories | 2024-06

Bring your short stories to life

Fuse character, story, and conflict with tools in Reedsy Studio. All for free.