To be Perfect

Mystery Thriller

Written in response to: "Write a story about a meeting of a secret society." as part of In On a Little Secret.

Does any innocent child ever look up to the stars and wish to become a killer one day?


Do they read about prosecuted murderers in the newspaper and hail them as their heroes?


Valora never did this. She had respectable heroes, one’s who changed the world with their brilliant ideas and made the most magnificent masterpieces using the art of science. She had the perfect uprising, loving and caring parents who taught her the difference between right and wrong, and the value of hard work.

She studied harder than all of her classmates, being dedicated to becoming the best version of herself that she could be. She even put the focus on helping others in her valedictorian speech at her med school graduation


All of the stars in Valora’s life had aligned just right. She had everything she needed to become the perfect person, a hero who could do no wrong. She had everything she needed to change the world, just as she had always dreamed of doing.


If it was all perfect, then why did it all go wrong?


She tried as hard as humanly possible to forget the ungodly act she committed, but there is no better reminder than the feeling of cold metal around her wrists. They rang out as she did her walk of shame out of her hospital unit. The sound attracting all those who had previously looked up to her.


The ride to the police station was silent. There was a conversation between the two offices and chatter coming from the car radio, but it was nothing but hum in her ear. The only thing she could focus on was her tears running thicker than the blood that coated her hands.


She had failed to be perfect. Her crown had shattered, and now she was nothing more than dust. As soon as they brought her to the interrogation room, she knew what her plan was going to be. Valora would confess to her crime and plead guilty to the jury before accepting her fate as a prisoner.


But that wasn’t how things were going to turn out. She was no longer perfect, so why would anything else she did be perfect, either?


An hour into the silence, the door opened to reveal two new faces. There weren’t detectives as Valora expected—wearing grim faces while drinking mediocre coffee—but instead entering the room were two women who were dressed to impress.


The first woman to enter was a pale, short little thing, the glasses on her face almost covering the bags under her eyes. She stumbled into the room, placing a briefcase on the table before taking a seat across Valora. This stranger was attractive, but she was nothing compared to the next woman to enter the room.

She strutted in with a king’s confidence, wearing the beauty of the night as if it were a gown explicitly made for her. Her eyes glimmered and struck Valora hard, a quick sensation ran through her body as she immediately became intrigued by these two new strangers.


“I already know the whole story, so don’t even bother lying to me,” The black woman stated while unloading the briefcase the other woman brought in. “I want the entire story from beginning to end, skip the boring stuff but keep the facts. We have much to do and don’t need any more delays.”


“Beg my pardon, but who are you?” Valora asked, feeling quite timid under the stares of both strangers.


“Amira and Dixa, legal defence,” The black woman pointed to herself than to the small white girl, their choice of clothes finally making sense.


“I didn’t ask for legal counsel.”


“That man you killed didn’t ask to die, but yet here we are.” Amira’s face told Valora she wasn’t playing any games, but even if they were, Valora had no doubt that she would win. “Now, please stop wasting my time. Start with your name, education and occupation.” Valora wanted nothing more than to crawl into a hole and die, but the glare Amira gave her forced the words out of her throat.


“Valora Mour, I have a Ph.D. in toxicology, and I work as an ER doctor at the Red Rose Hospital.” Amira nodded while Dixa seemed to be cross-checking information on a paper with a chart on it.

“On what day did you meet Michael Romariz and his son Sam Romariz?”


“September 16th.” Her voice started to waver, but Valora didn’t want to show any more weakness. Something told her that Amira was the kind of person to slap adults who sob at problems they caused themselves.


“What caused him to come into the ER?” Amira asked, clicking her elegant long gel nails along the counter, mimicking the sound of a countdown. Valora starting picking at the skin on her arms, her nerves getting the best of her.


“He had the symptoms of Appendicitis, he went into surgery that same day. I was the lead doctor while he was in the ER. He was one of the hospital’s biggest investors, so he was put on high priority.” Amira and Dixa shared a quick glance and nod before getting back in Valora’s face.


“When did you first notice that Sam was being abused by his father?”


“I noticed a lot of bruises on his arms and legs, along with a limp that he couldn’t explain with a plausible story.” Amira tilted her head, urging Valora to continue. She struggled through a deep breath before telling the rest of her sin. “I used one of our social worker’s accounts to look up his family history and saw the father had won full custody of Sam. After I questioned him more, he confessed to the abuse and asked for my help to get him back to his mother.”


“Did you attempt to get support from your fellow co-workers.” Valora shook her head with more tears trying to push through.

“They were too scared to mess with such a big investor.”

“What did you do after no one was willing to help you get this young boy out of his situation?” Valora’s heart started to race while Amira only gained a more intense stare.


“Michael was prescribed fentanyl to relieve pain after the surgery so he could sleep through the pain. I changed his prescription to be more lethal, so when he went to bed..” Valora wanted to continue, but she felt her breath catch in her throat.


“He wouldn’t wake up,” Dixa spoke for the first time, finishing what Valora couldn’t say. She just nodded while her tears finally broke through. Amira poked her hand into her bosom and produced a handkerchief to which Valora covered in tears and snot.


“You did the deal, and the aftermath has already taken place.” Amira stated, sliding her a news article covering Michael’s death and the reunion of Sam and his mother, the biggest smile painted on both of their lips. It was beautiful. “I’m going to ask you a question, and I only want to hear yes or no. Would you do it again?”


“Yes,” Valora whispered without a moment of hesitation.


“That’s exactly what I want to hear,” Amira smiled while placing another set of documents in front of Valora, this time they contained different pieces of ID, all with her face on it but instead having the name ‘Elsa Salour’.


“What is this?” Valora asked, a slight sniffle in her voice.

“You have two choices here. You can risk it with the court and be sent away to jail to rot for the rest of your life, or you can join us and actually do something worthwhile.” Amira offered while Dixa nodded, her smile being stiff and sweet.


“Who exactly are you?” Valora felt terrible for having to ask again, but the last answer she received gave her nothing more than names to stick to two faces. Amira slipped a card out of her pocket and handed it to Valora. She had to read it over a couple of times for the words to sink in.


“The Peace Lily Spa, a place where all your problems disappear!”


“You work at a spa? I thought you were lawyers?” Valora questioned the two women, never having felt more confused in her life. “Why do you care about me?” Amira scoffed as she snatched the card back.


“As the card says, we make problems disappear, and you made quite a big problem disappear. I have been looking for someone new to join the Peace Lily team, and your qualifications line up perfectly.”


“You want a doctor to massage people? I don’t know how to massage.” Amira’s face dropped as she leaned in, getting as close to her ear as humanly possible.


“I want a toxicologist who knows her way around drugs and poison to help deal with our client’s problems.” Amira pulled back with a smile on her lips instead, as Valora understood what was happening.


“How many of you are there?” Valora asked in a whisper, Amira’s smile now growing.


“Sixteen, all with different skills. Daxi, here is our forensic psychologist while I am a lawyer.” Valora nodded, looking back down at all the pieces of a fake ID.


“Can you make all of this just go away?” Valora gestured vaguely to the room they were sitting in, but Amira seemed to get her point.

“Consider it done. Now, do we have a deal?” Amina stretched out her hand, calling out for Valora to submit. She contemplated the decision, thinking back to her aspirations as a child. She wanted to be the perfect girl, to change the world for the better.


Maybe this was what she was meant to do. Play her part as a killer, to help those who need it most. Change the lives of more who suffered in silence the same way Sam did. Valora beamed as she embraced the hand, accepting the deal.


It wasn’t ideal, but she went for it anyways. In no way was it all perfect, but it was a perfect way to change the world, and that’s just what she needed.

Posted Aug 16, 2020
Share:

You must sign up or log in to submit a comment.

145 likes 96 comments

September 22, 2020 15:06

I didn't read all of your stories. But as much as I have read, this was the best. Can I ask you to read my latest stories, it's a comedy though.(and the other one is a fan fic)

Reply

Lynn Penny
September 23, 2020 13:48

Thanks! This one is one of my favourites as well, I’m so glad it was well received. I’d love to read your work!

Reply

Rachel Alex Wall
August 27, 2020 16:11

Excellent story, I really enjoyed it. I would love to hear more about the peace lily team!

Reply

Lynn Penny
August 27, 2020 18:32

Thanks! I’ll see where the future prompts lead me!

Reply

Amogh Kasat
August 24, 2020 12:44

It's a wonderful story! Please read my latest story The Secret Organisation { Part 2 }

Reply

Lynn Penny
August 24, 2020 15:41

Thanks, I'd love too :)

Reply

Amogh Kasat
August 24, 2020 17:04

I would be waiting for your comment and like

Reply

Naomie K
August 21, 2020 11:27

I didn't want the story to end!! Will you be turning this into a series? Would love this story to continue.... Rock on!!

Reply

Lynn Penny
August 21, 2020 14:54

I may! This was a book idea I slimmed down into a story, so it may become a longer thing in the future! Thank you for your kind words.

Reply

Rachel <3
July 18, 2021 02:05

Wow, I loved this story! There were one or two out-of-place words ('uprising' when I think you meant 'upbringing' stood out the most), and the dialogue didn't always feel natural, but the plot was really intriguing, and it was very well written. I hope you write a part two!

Reply

Lynn Penny
July 18, 2021 04:07

Thank you! This was one of my favourite pieces, and dialogue has always been a struggle. I do hope my new pieces have shown improvement!

Reply

Milja Luomala
September 18, 2020 09:45

A very interesting story that leaves a possibility to continue! :)

Reply

September 05, 2020 11:04

I love this story. I just hope you continue. It's so amazing. Thumbs up to the Peace Lily Team and you truly did well at that. I never expected two lawyers to turn into that. Sometimes doing wrong for the right people is right and you just showed me that. I just hope it doesn't end there

Reply

Lynn Penny
September 05, 2020 15:04

I hope to one day continue this saga, it’s something I’ve been thinking about for a while. Thank you so much for taking the time to read it.

Reply

September 06, 2020 10:41

You're always welcome :)

Reply

Sam S.
August 27, 2020 15:45

This should really turn into a series because this is too good for 3K words, this is the very first story I read from you and its simply amazing.

Reply

Lynn Penny
August 27, 2020 18:31

Thanks! I’m trying to plan out of novel with this concept so I hope I can nail it!

Reply

Sam S.
August 28, 2020 05:55

Good luck with that!!

Reply

Bianka Nova
August 27, 2020 13:14

Great story! I kept imagining it as an episode from a TV show - a mixture of ER, CSI and maybe Scandal XD

Reply

Lynn Penny
August 27, 2020 14:13

Thanks! That’s what was going through my head as I was writing it!

Reply

S. Closson
August 27, 2020 03:28

Oh snap, that was a great story! I didn't see that ending coming at all. You could totally turn that into a series if you wanted to, I know I'd read it!

Reply

Lynn Penny
August 27, 2020 04:50

Thanks! I hope to expand on this more.

Reply

Annie James
August 25, 2020 15:50

This is a truly intriguing story! Are you going to continue it as a series?

Reply

Lynn Penny
August 25, 2020 21:26

I hope to! Thank you!

Reply

Maya W.
August 24, 2020 14:18

Woah, this was amazing! I loved the ending and the whole concept in general. This was so beautifully written, as well. Would you mind checking out some of my stories here? I also did one for this prompt. Thanks!

Reply

Lynn Penny
August 24, 2020 15:43

Thanks, I'd love to check out your take. :)

Reply

Kristin Neubauer
August 24, 2020 12:37

That's a cool story, Lynn! I love the mystery of those two women suddenly appearing and then the twist of their somewhat vigilante secret society. I also thought your final line nailed it, where you raised the theme of perfection again. Fantastic!

Reply

Lynn Penny
August 24, 2020 15:39

Thanks. I have a habit of trying to bring back a central theme, good ol high school english coming through in my writing.

Reply

Kristin Neubauer
August 24, 2020 19:10

Thank goodness for high school English - it works perfectly!

Reply

Shea K
August 24, 2020 04:18

Love your story! I’d really like to see where it goes next—the Peace Lily Spa is such a fun idea!

Reply

Lynn Penny
August 24, 2020 15:06

Thanks! I'm glad you liked my idea.

Reply

María Barrios
August 24, 2020 03:27

This reminded me of Knives Out, although it's a very different kind of story. It has potential for more and I'd like to read more of it in the future.

Reply

Lynn Penny
August 24, 2020 15:06

Thank you! I hope to expand one day, I'll be sure to write it justice!

Reply

Esther Salami
August 24, 2020 01:12

This is beautiful. I didn't know what to expect at the end.

Reply

Lynn Penny
August 24, 2020 15:04

Thank you, I'm glad you enjoyed :)

Reply

Aarshia Ray
August 23, 2020 18:44

I thoroughly enjoyed the story!
Especially, when Amira offered Valora, unexpectedly, to join the Peace Lily Spa.
Only in the fifth last paragraph, I think there is a typing mistake (Daxi instead of Dixa).

Reply

Lynn Penny
August 23, 2020 19:05

Thanks! I really should spend more time proofreading, thank you for letting me know. Gotta change it on my saved draft!

Reply

Doubra Akika
August 23, 2020 18:13

Lynn, this was so good! The pacing was great. I loved how the beginning connected with the end like how you mentioned the thing about her wanting to be perfect.
This was such a great story! Amazing work again Lynn!
Hope you’re staying safe!

Reply

Lynn Penny
August 23, 2020 18:59

Thanks! I like to try and loop my beginnings and ends together. You stay safe as well!

Reply

Doubra Akika
August 23, 2020 19:00

You definitely did an amazing job with that! And thanks, I will!

Reply

Kingshuk Kundu
August 23, 2020 16:34

A very great first line and a compelling ending! The twist of their hidden identities was amazing. 😄 Hope to read more from you.

P.S: would you mind checking my recent story out, "Better Late Than Never"? Thank you 😊

Reply

Lynn Penny
August 23, 2020 18:52

Thank you, I love to hear such kind words. I'd love to read your work :)

Reply

Thom With An H
August 23, 2020 12:51

I can see this as a movie too. You really do have a gift. This is so well written and perfect for expansion. I can’t speak for anyone else but I could see every part of it in my head and I was begging for more.

I’m not sure if you read “Coming Out”, my latest attempt at story writing but if not give me a read. 😀

Reply

Deborah Angevin
August 23, 2020 08:00

The opening sentences are powerful, Lynn! I thoroughly enjoyed reading this story!

P.S: would you mind checking my recent story out, "Yellow Light?" Thank you :D

Reply

Lynn Penny
August 23, 2020 18:33

Thank you! I'd love to read your work!

Reply

August 22, 2020 21:27

This was soooo good. I enjoyed reading this a lot. I could picture this as a tv show or a movie. Great job Lynn!

Reply

Lynn Penny
August 22, 2020 22:49

Thanks!

Reply

Velma Darnell
August 22, 2020 18:43

Wow! This story is fantastic, you made such an unexpectable plot twist, and descriptions of those "legal defense" ladies were so well-thought.
Also, Valora's (such a unique choice of name, by the way) attempts to be perfect went to another level. I would also love to read more about The Peace Lily Spa, and I think its background could be sooo interesting!
Very well written, Lynn :)

p.s. I was wondering if you could check out my story "Hi, darling" when you have time and tell me what you think? Thanks!

Reply

Lynn Penny
August 22, 2020 21:18

Aww, thanks! I'd love to check out your work!

Reply

Kate Rucker
August 22, 2020 08:20

:0 WHAT A PLOT TWIST!!!!! This was so good!!! You clearly have a gift! I love how you described Amira!
“with a king’s confidence, wearing the beauty of the night as if it were a gown explicitly made for her”
Ah! Gorgeous similes! I wish you all the luck in the world with the book you are writing and hope your moments of writers block are few!

Reply

Lynn Penny
August 22, 2020 13:41

Awww, thank you so much for your kind words. They made my day 🥺

Reply

Kate Rucker
August 22, 2020 18:53

Haha! I’m so glad! ♥️♥️

Reply

Abhishek Todmal
August 20, 2020 14:41

Lynn, great job with the story ! I loved it. So much. There are few things that tempt more than a story with an element of mystery. I was so tempted to write a story on this prompt but in order to divert myself onto other spheres, I chose to deal with another prompt this time around. But if I was going for this one, I'm sure I'd have given you a fair fight on your hands ! :D Seriously though, real nice work. I see many who say you should turn this into a novel. I was tempted to butt in and say writing a novel is a completely different endeavour, and the effort required to do so is nothing short of gargantuan. Ask me. I have so many ideas. And they all seem equally wonderful to write. Short stories provide that relief in a sense that I can get them out of me before I end up bursting !

Reply

Lynn Penny
August 20, 2020 15:02

I agree, writing a novel is a pain in the butt. I’m currently working on my first one now and it’s going to take FOREVER! It’s fun at the same time. This short story was kinda based on a novel idea I had and the secret society prompt just gave me a hailstorm of motivation. Are you working on a novel? I’d love to discuss ideas with you.

Reply

Abhishek Todmal
August 21, 2020 10:02

I am working on a novel( maybe two) depending on if I can convince myself that there's a story to be told there. The process seems mammoth for a beginner whose starting off. It's like gazing at a colossal mountain ahead wondering how you're going to climb it .
Yes, I would love to interact with you and pick your brain . Maybe email works for you ? Would love to get in touch. I haven't many "writer friends" as to speak. You might very well be the first !

Reply

Lynn Penny
August 21, 2020 14:53

Awesome! I’ve got two in the works right now, and it honestly feels like a mountain. You shall be my first writing partner as well! My email is corrie-lynn@hotmail.ca

Reply

Reedsy | Default — Editors with Marker | 2024-05

Bring your publishing dreams to life

The world's best editors, designers, and marketers are on Reedsy. Come meet them.