Purgatory

Science Fiction Thriller

Written in response to: "Your character makes a life-changing decision. What happens next?" as part of Not What It Seems.

I

Anthony McKenzie returned from the past expecting the world to fracture. He had changed something enormous—something history should have screamed about. Instead, the present greeted him with the same traffic and the same indifferent sky. It was as if time had watched him interfere, considered the alteration, and quietly declined to acknowledge it.

Anthony sat in his parked car long after the engine died, staring at the intersection — gray asphalt, cracked crosswalk, the bakery on the corner with its red awning — like it was a riddle he’d failed to solve. His son’s death replayed in his mind with the precision of a punishment: the screech of tires, the flash of white, the impossible silence afterward. He had gone back to fix it. He had done everything differently. He had stolen the driver’s keys, sprinted across two blocks, and planted himself at the exact spot where the world had ended for him.

And he saw it happen — or rather, not happen.

The white Mercedes. His son behind the wheel. The light turning yellow. The car gliding through the intersection, unscathed.

Alive.

A half second delay in the turn signal. A song on the radio he didn’t remember his son liking. A look on his son’s face — not quite the expression he remembered from that morning. Small things. Forgettable things. Except Anthony didn’t forget anything about that day.

Still, the outcome was clear. He had changed the past.

So why was his son still dead?

“What did I miss?” he whispered. “What did I do wrong?”

He blamed himself. He should’ve been there. He should’ve driven him. He should’ve done something. Anything.

And now he had. He had changed the past. He had watched his son survive.

But the present refused to acknowledge it.

He opened his eyes.

The same bakery smell drifting from the corner, the same jogger with neon shoes, the same delivery truck idling too close to the crosswalk.

If stopping the driver wasn’t enough, then he would go back again.

He would intervene in ways he had sworn he never would. He would make a change the universe couldn’t ignore.

He stepped out of the car, jaw clenched, eyes fixed on the street where his son had died. He already knew what he was going to do next.

And it wasn’t going to be clean.

II

The world snapped back into place with a violent lurch, and Anthony found himself standing in the dim hallway — peeling paint, flickering fluorescent light, the smell of stale carpet and overcooked dinner — outside the driver’s apartment. A dog barked behind a nearby door. Everything felt ordinary.

He checked the time on his watch. Seven minutes until the man would step out, lock the door, and begin the chain of events that would end with his son’s death.

Not this time.

Anthony moved quickly, quietly. He had studied the building’s layout, memorized the angles of the security cameras, rehearsed the timing. He wasn’t improvising anymore. He was executing.

He walked to the breaker panel at the end of the hall and flipped the main switch. The lights in the corridor flickered, then died. The hum of appliances behind the apartment doors faded into silence.

He returned to the driver’s door and crouched beside it. He pulled a small screwdriver from his pocket and removed the screws from the lock plate. His hands shook, but not from fear. From purpose.

He disassembled the mechanism just enough to make it fail.

He would miss the drive. He would never cross paths with Anthony’s son.

Anthony stepped back, breathing hard. Four minutes left.

He moved to the stairwell and waited in the shadows.

Right on schedule, he heard movement inside the apartment — footsteps, keys jingling, the soft thud of a bag being lifted. Then the rattle of the doorknob.

A pause. Another rattle. Harder this time.

The man cursed under his breath. Metal scraped. The lock refused to turn.

This was it. This was the moment the universe would finally bend.

He listened as the man tried again, then again, frustration rising. Finally, the footsteps retreated deeper into the apartment. A phone rang. A muffled voice answered.

"Looks like I'm not coming in today" then "Yeah... I can't get the damn door open."

Calling out of work. Perfect.

Anthony exhaled slowly. He had done it. He had changed the morning.

He activated the device.

The world folded around him.

III

The world snapped back into place with a cold, metallic shudder, and Anthony stumbled forward, bracing himself against the hood of his car. He blinked hard, waiting for the shift, the ripple, the tremor in reality that should’ve followed what he’d done.

Nothing.

The intersection — gray asphalt, cracked crosswalk, the bakery on the corner with its red awning — looked exactly the same. The same bakery smell drifted from the corner. The same jogger with neon shoes passed by, earbuds in. The same delivery truck idled too close to the crosswalk, engine rumbling like a bored animal.

Anthony’s stomach tightened.

He checked his phone. Same date. Same time. Same unread messages from people who had stopped knowing what to say to him.

He looked toward the intersection. The asphalt was clean. The traffic light cycled lazily from green to yellow to red. No scorch marks. No shattered glass. No ghost of the moment that had destroyed his life.

He swallowed hard.

He had trapped the driver in his apartment. He had changed the path.

So why was the world still the same?

Anthony walked into the street, ignoring the honk of a passing car. He stood exactly where his son’s body had lain, where the paramedics had knelt. He closed his eyes and tried to feel something—anything—different.

But the world felt indifferent. Untouched. Unmoved.

A tremor ran through him.

“What else do you want from me?” he whispered to no one.

The universe didn’t answer.

He turned slowly, scanning the street, searching for any sign—any microscopic deviation—that his intervention had mattered. A changed storefront. A missing car. A different face in the crowd.

The sameness pressed against him like a weight.

He felt something inside him shift. A small, dangerous click. The sound of a boundary giving way.

If sabotaging the driver’s morning wasn’t enough, then he would go back again.

Earlier.

Deeper.

Further upstream.

He would find the point where the chain began. And he would break it with his bare hands if he had to.

Anthony exhaled shakily, the breath trembling out of him.

He wasn’t done.

He reached into his coat, fingers brushing the device.

“Fine,” he murmured. “We go bigger.”

He pressed the activation switch.

And once again, the world folded around him.

IV

The world reassembled around him with a low, bone‑deep hum, and Anthony landed hard on cracked pavement. The air was colder here, sharper, carrying the metallic scent of early morning. He steadied himself against a brick wall and waited for the dizziness to pass.

He knew exactly where he was.

The alley behind the driver’s apartment building. Two hours earlier than his last intervention. Further upstream.

He checked his watch. 6:10 a.m.

The man wouldn’t wake for another twenty minutes.

Anthony exhaled slowly, watching his breath fog in the dim light.

He walked to the back door of the building, the one that opened into the stairwell.

He slipped inside.

The stairwell was silent except for the faint hum of a vending machine on the ground floor. Anthony climbed the steps, each footfall measured, controlled. He reached the second-floor landing and paused outside the driver’s door.

He listened.

Anthony moved to the breaker panel. He unscrewed the cover, reached inside, and pulled a wire free. Sparks snapped in the darkness. The hallway lights flickered, then died completely.

The man would wake to a powerless apartment.

Anthony stepped back, breathing hard. He felt the line he was crossing — the moral boundary he’d once believed was immovable — but he didn’t stop. Couldn’t stop.

He whispered to himself, “You’re not leaving that apartment today.”

He turned to go, but froze.

A sound.

A soft, muffled cough from inside the driver’s apartment.

Anthony’s pulse quickened. He hadn’t expected the man to be awake this early. He hadn’t planned for this.

He backed into the stairwell shadows, heart pounding.

Footsteps approached the door. A hand rattled the knob. A frustrated sigh.

Then the man spoke, voice groggy and irritated.

“Not again… damn building.”

Anthony closed his eyes.

He slipped down the stairs, out the back door, and into the alley. The sky was beginning to lighten, a thin gray line stretching across the horizon.

He pulled the device from his coat.

He didn’t need to stay and watch. He didn’t need confirmation.

He pressed the activation switch.

And the world folded around him.

V

The world snapped back into place with a violent, bone‑deep crack, like glass shattering in his skull. Anthony staggered forward, reaching for the hood of his car—

Except it wasn’t his car.

It was the same model. Same color. Same dent. But the license plate was wrong.

He blinked hard.

The air felt thick, buzzing faintly, like static trapped in a jar. He inhaled—

No bakery smell.

The scent that had anchored every return — gone. The air was empty, sterile, like a hospital corridor.

Anthony turned slowly.

The bakery was still there… but the sign was different. Different name. Different font. Different color. And the windows were boarded up, as if it had been closed for years.

His stomach tightened.

A jogger ran past him.

Neon shoes. Earbuds in. Sweat on the back of his shirt.

Anthony exhaled shakily.

Then another jogger ran past.

Same neon shoes. Same earbuds. Same sweat pattern. Same man.

Anthony’s breath hitched.

He turned sharply.

Two delivery trucks idled near the crosswalk. Same model. Same driver. Same dent. Same bored expression.

They were parked inches apart, like mirrored reflections that had forgotten which one was real.

Anthony stepped back, pulse hammering.

The world around him flickered — not visually, but conceptually. Like the air was struggling to decide what belonged.

A woman exited the bakery holding a paper bag.

Then she exited again. And again. Three versions of her, stepping out in the same motion, each slightly out of sync.

Anthony’s throat tightened.

He looked toward the intersection.

The traffic light glitched — green, yellow, red, green, yellow — cycling too fast, then freezing, then cycling again. Cars moved through it in overlapping patterns, some obeying one color, others obeying another, none of them colliding, all of them wrong.

He whispered, “No… no, no, no…”

This wasn’t a loop. This wasn’t a glitch. This wasn’t the universe ignoring him.

This was every version of the street he had ever returned to — every branch he had created, every timeline he had touched, every change he had forced — all collapsing into one impossible, suffocating space.

A convergence.

A place where contradictions lived side by side because the universe no longer had the strength to separate them.

Anthony staggered backward.

He saw the driver’s apartment building in the distance.

Or what was left of it.

The building was burned to the ground — charred beams, collapsed floors, smoke still rising. But layered over it, flickering like a dying hologram, was the intact version. And another version with a different paint color. And another with a missing balcony.

All of them overlapping. All of them wrong.

Anthony’s breath came in sharp, panicked bursts.

He reached out to touch a nearby lamppost.

His hand passed through it.

Not like a ghost. Not like a glitch.

Like the world was rejecting him.

He tried again. His fingers slipped through the metal like it was made of fog.

He couldn’t touch anything. He couldn’t anchor himself. He couldn’t belong.

He was outside reality. Outside all realities.

A bubble. A pocket. A purgatory made of every mistake he had carved into time.

Anthony turned — and froze.

He saw himself across the street.

Same age. Same coat. Same haunted eyes.

Then another Anthony. And another. Dozens. Hundreds. All flickering in and out of existence, each one belonging to a different branch he had created — each one displaced, each one lost, each one trapped.

One of them looked directly at him.

“What are you doing to us?” the other Anthony whispered.

Anthony’s knees buckled.

He reached for the device.

It sparked in his hand. Cracked. Flickered. Died.

He was trapped.

The convergence tightened. The overlapping worlds pressed closer. The air vibrated like a scream held underwater.

Anthony realized the truth with a cold, perfect clarity:

He had broken reality. And now he was trapped in the space between all the lives he never got to live.

VI

The world didn’t snap back this time.

It sagged.

It slumped into place like a dying animal collapsing under its own weight. Anthony felt it before he saw it — the heaviness, the drag, the sense that reality was no longer assembling itself so much as giving up.

He opened his eyes.

The street was gone.

Not replaced. Not altered. Not overlapped.

Just… gone.

In its place was a gray expanse stretching in every direction, flat and depthless, like someone had erased the world but forgotten to draw a new one. The sky was a blank sheet of colorless light. There was no horizon. No shadows. No sound.

Anthony stood alone in the middle of nothing.

He turned slowly, heart pounding.

No bakery. No joggers. No trucks. No buildings. No versions of himself flickering in and out.

Just silence.

Just emptiness.

Just the space left behind when too many realities collapse into each other and cancel out.

He swallowed hard.

“Hello?” he called.

His voice didn’t echo. It didn’t travel. It didn’t exist beyond the moment it left his lips.

He tried again.

“Is anyone—”

A shape flickered in the distance.

Anthony froze.

It was a person. Walking toward him. Slowly. Deliberately.

As it approached, the shape sharpened.

Anthony’s breath caught.

It was him.

Not older. Not younger. Not thinner or hollowed or broken.

Just… him.

The original him.

The one who had existed before the first intervention. Before the first change. Before the first fracture.

The other Anthony stopped a few feet away.

They stared at each other.

Anthony felt something inside him crack — not physically, but conceptually, like a belief dissolving.

The other Anthony spoke first.

“You shouldn’t have kept going.”

Anthony’s throat tightened. “I was trying to fix it.”

“You didn’t fix anything,” the other said softly. “You broke the only thing that could’ve saved you.”

Anthony shook his head. “I saved him. I saw it. I changed it.”

“You changed everything,” the other Anthony said. “Except the one thing you wanted.”

Anthony’s breath trembled. “Where are we?”

The other Anthony looked around at the blank expanse.

“Nowhere,” he said. “Everywhere. The space between the branches. The place that forms when there are too many versions of the same moment and not enough universe to hold them.”

Anthony swallowed. “Purgatory.”

The other Anthony nodded.

“You don’t belong to any reality anymore,” he said. “You stepped outside all of them. And now they’ve collapsed without you.”

Anthony felt his knees weaken.

“Can I go back?” he whispered.

“To what?” the other Anthony asked. “There’s nothing left. Not for you.”

Anthony closed his eyes.

The device in his hand flickered weakly, a dying ember. He tried to activate it.

Nothing happened.

The other Anthony stepped closer.

“You can’t fix this,” he said gently. “You can only stop fighting it.”

Anthony opened his eyes.

The gray expanse around them began to dissolve — not into darkness, but into absence, like a page being erased.

The other Anthony’s voice softened.

“Let go.”

Anthony exhaled.

For the first time since his son died, he stopped resisting.

The world — or what was left of it — folded inward, not violently, not painfully, but quietly, like a curtain closing at the end of a play.

Anthony felt himself fade.

Not die. Not vanish. Just… stop.

The last thing he heard was his own voice, from somewhere far away, whispering:

“We’re done.”

And then there was nothing.

Posted Aug 03, 2026
Share:

You must sign up or log in to submit a comment.

16 likes 4 comments

Dana W
August 13, 2026 02:32

Poor Anthony!

Reply

Manuel Garcia
August 13, 2026 15:36

I know. Right?

Reply

Kendall Defoe
August 09, 2026 22:46

Chuck Palahniuk and Raymond Carver have nothing on you, sir! This was excellent!

Reply

Manuel Garcia
August 12, 2026 14:35

I honestly appreciate your comparison. But I'm not even close. Thank you for your comment. It really helps.

Reply

RBE | Illustrated Short Stories | 2024-06

Bring your short stories to life

Fuse character, story, and conflict with tools in Reedsy Studio. All for free.