People Pleaser

Contemporary Funny Romance

Written in response to: "Write about a character who yearns for something they lost — or never had." as part of What Lingers.

A peachy diner, warmly lit. Fairly priced, clean, and open late. It was relatively empty given it was almost midnight and she would’ve preferred a morning picnic in a busy park, but her date apparently worked ungodly hours and kept absolutely raving about this place, so she agreed to meet him here.

The waitress had already come up to her five times to ask if she was ready to order. Sarah had told her no, that she’d been indecisive. A little white lie to hide the fact that her date was forty minutes late, but heaven forbid she had told the waitress that. She’d be setting herself up for a lonely walk of shame if her date stood her up. So, she pretended to study the menu harder. 

The condensation from her water glass left a damp ring on the table. Sarah traced its circumference with her finger, occasionally glancing toward the entrance, but made sure not to do so obviously. Finally, a tall, lanky man approached her table hesitantly.

“Sarah?” he asked.

“Harry?”

He pushed his black, thick-rimmed glasses that magnified his brown puppy eyes up his nose. “Yes! It’s me—I mean, that’s me! Wow, it’s so nice to finally meet you in person. I mean—wow, you’re even more beautiful than your picture!” The excitable man shook her hand firmly, not letting her go until he had fully settled into his seat.

“Oh, uh, wow.” Sarah smiled bashfully, head tilting forward as she tucked her hair behind her ear.

“Sorry, was that weird? I didn’t mean to make it weird.”

“Oh, oh no, not at all, I was just—“

“Oh!”

“Yeah, I’m just a bit shy of compliments, that’s all!”

They continued to exchange reassurances until their dialogue fizzled out. He looked at her, and she looked at him. Harry shook his head, breaking the ice again.

“So, sorry, to make you wait so long, my boss made me do something last minute, we’re all so crazy about this…stupid project, boring stuff.” He nervously pulled at his already disheveled tie, attracting her eye to his wrinkled white button-up mostly covered by a beige windbreaker.

“That’s okay, really! Y’know, work stuff, I get it.”

“Lucky me, I’ve got my baby girl’s picture on my desk! Gets me through the day.”

“Y-you have a daughter?” 

“No, no, no, I meant my cat!”

Sarah lightly smacked herself on her forehead. “Right, right! Lulubelle!” He talked about Lulubelle before when they first began texting, their chat frequently flooded with pictures of the petite, grey lady. Sarah found it sweet. They laughed, Harry’s big eyes squinting with affection as she pulled down her dress’s neckline until it hugged her shoulders.

“She’s such a beautiful girl,” she commented. 

“Very, and she’s such a quiet cat too. I was so surprised how affectionate she was considering how shy she is, but she really is a sweetheart once she gets to know you. She’ll get used to you in a few weeks, surely.”

“Hopefully, she likes me.”

“Of course, she will! I mean, I like you.” Harry’s crooked smile made Sarah melt into the cushy diner booth.

She waved him away, “Please, I’m too flattered.”

Harry pretended to wipe sweat off his brow with an exaggerated ‘whew.’ “I’ve made a good first impression.” Sarah giggled and nodded in agreement. The waitress came back around and scribbled down their orders. In just a few moments, she returned with hot plates and they dug in. 

“How’s the food?” Harry asked. 

“Y’know, I have to hand it to you, this is a solid seven-point-five-out-of-ten diner.”

“…Is that…good?”

“Yes!”

“Seven-point-five?” 

“Yes! That’s like a low B.” 

“More like a pity C.” 

“No!” Sarah placed a hand over her heart, “I’m being serious, it’s good!” 

“Well, this place, to me, is a ten out of ten every time,” Harry defended with a smile, “I’ve never had better eggs.”

“Eggs? Their eggs are what makes you crazy about this place?”

“I’m somewhat of an egg enthusiast,” Harry quipped. Sarah threw her head back in laughter, gently slapping the table. 

“Clearly! You chose to eat breakfast for dinner.” 

“Actually, since it’s twelve twenty-three, we’re just having a really early breakfast.” 

“Well, when you’re in the mood for eggs again, I know a place.” Sarah took a bite of her hash brown.

“Certainly! Maybe Lulubelle can join us, she loves eggs too.” 

“Cats can eat eggs?” 

“Oh yes! I give her scrambled, my favorite, but I like mine a little more seasoned than she does,” he joked.

“Interesting…cats can eat eggs. I did not know that.”

“Not raw eggs though! Salmonella risk. Good thing I warned you, the princess is quite particular about her diet—it’s quite extensive. You’ll see. Sadly, I had to rely on the timed feeder to feed her tonight because—well, I’m not at the house at the moment.” 

“Aw, well I hope she gets her eggs soon.” 

“For sure!”

“Hey! I just remembered, you said you were a sculptor,” Sarah recalled. But Harry seemed to be dismissing the idea already.

“That’s a generous description, I’m more of a person who plays with air-dry clay.” He chuckled, cracking his knuckles on one hand.

“No, but that’s what sculpting is! It’s play, I’m a doodler myself. I play with colors and pencils, and colored pencils,” Sarah said encouragingly. He scratched the back of his neck with a nervous smile.

“I make small things here and there.”

“What’s your favorite subject?” 

“Uh…let’s see, I love making little boats because I can watch them float in the tub. Lulubelle sometimes steps on my—sculpture? It’s not really a sculp—anyway, she steps on whatever I’m making, and she always makes a perfect paw print and I keep them, and…those are my favorite.” Harry adjusted his glasses. 

“Aw, that’s so cute!”

“Yeah, I have the paw prints of my…late cat, Melly. She used to do the same thing.”

“Oh…my condolences—“

“Yeah, she passed away two months ago.”

“Oh.”

A damper had been put on the mood. The waitress passed by them, rolling a cart full of clinking dirty dishes. Sarah felt compelled to wave as she passed by.

“B-but, enough of that! Back to Lulubelle!” Harry exclaimed, real sweat accumulating on his forehead. Sarah supposed talking about the alive cat was better than the dead one.

“Yeah, as I was saying…” Harry cleared his throat. “I love making boats, Lulu loves playing with them in the bath too.” 

“A cat that likes baths? That’s unheard of.”

“Oh, please, she hates them! But if I’m in the tub with her she calms down.”

“Like, standing in the tub while you wash her?”

“No. A bath.”

“…together?”

“Yeah?”

“Oh!…okay.” She placed her chin in her hand, biting the inside of her lip. “C-continue,” she said and Harry instantly lit up again.

“Cats care about hygiene, so I find it very respectful to show her that I care about my hygiene too! It’s really bonding, I’ve never felt closer to a cat before. Not even with Melly. I named her Melly after ‘smelly’ by the way because my goodness that cat got stinky so fast!” Harry certainly seemed entertained. Sarah was still caught up on the whole bathing with his cat situation. She tapped her fingers on her table, thinking of ways to escape—just in case. Slowly, her mouth opened attempting to tell her date that she was getting tired and should get going, but Harry beat her to it.

“Would you like to meet her?”

Sarah blinked rapidly. “Huh?”

“Lulubelle!”

Before she could make up her mind, her head nodded and her lips tightened into a thin smile. “Sure! I’d…love to meet her!”

“Great!”

Soon, she was jostling in his beat-up Toyota Corolla, a community of apartments coming into view. 

“Oh, and please don’t mention pets to the receptionist. I’m technically not allowed to have any,” Harry whispered cheekily. The modest lobby was chilled, yet the sour-faced receptionist’s gaze was colder. She judged the two harshly, multiplying her crow’s feet, but said nothing. Harry waved at her anyway and led them to the elevator.

“She’s a treat, right?” Harry flashed a smile to Sarah who had to remind herself to react warmly. 

“Uh, yeah…super inviting,” Sarah responded, causing Harry to let out an especially sharp laugh, startling her.

“Good thing Lulu is such a sweet, quiet girl. I’ve had neighbors report meowing from my other cats before.”

“Other cats? I thought you only had Lulubelle.”

“I meant my previous cats,” Harry said with no further explanation.

The elevator pinged, announcing they had arrived at their destination. Sarah followed Harry, heels clacking on the cracked, white tiles. Half of the doors didn’t even have numbers, and somehow, despite being on the fourth floor, they made it to apartment three twenty-five. 

Harry opened the door and invited her in. The first thing that greeted her was the unidentifiable, pungent smell of chemicals. 

Then came the smell of cat. Together, they gave off the impression that someone had desperately stripped, coated, and scrubbed the apartment down with every cleaning product imaginable to get rid of the scent of cat litter but to no avail.

Then came the taxidermy. 

Dozens of taxidermied cats were perched on shelves, dressers—God, even the coffee table. Their eyes reflected like glass. They were arranged in various poses, and every single one had a different texture of fur. Brittle, matted, a lot of them unnervingly realistic. 

“Mhmm,” Sarah hummed, then cleared her throat. She had wanted to compliment his home, but couldn’t find the courage to take in a breath.

“So? What do ya think?”

Visually, it was clean. The decor was sparse, and the color palette was mostly white. At least, the lighting was warm and the couch looked comfortable. The infamous Lulubelle was stretched out across the cushions herself, so that was one positive review.

“It’s nice, very rare to see a tidy bachelor pad,” Sarah acknowledged. 

“Appreciate it! I take cleanliness very seriously,” Harry explained as he beelined to Lulu.

“Hi, sweet girl,” he scratched the cat under her chin. “You should see my closet. I organized the garment type, then alphabetically by brand.”

“Wow,” was all Sarah could manage. 

“Want a drink? Some water, juice, gin?”

“Water is fine.”

“One water for the lady coming right up—make yourself at home!” he exclaimed over the sputtering sound of the fridge dispensing ice as he motioned to the couch. Sarah’s eyes flickered to the living space, tentatively walking over and sitting on the very edge of the couch as she clutched her purse. Lulubelle hadn’t appreciated the intrusion and swiftly jumped off, disappearing into Harry’s bedroom.

“Rude,” Harry playfully called out to Lulubelle. “Yeah, like I said, it’s gonna take a second for her to get used to you.” He returned with two cold glasses of iced water and made himself comfortable on the couch as well.

It took about ten full seconds of silence before Sarah noticed Harry eagerly staring at her with those big, damn puppy eyes. She shifted slightly to face him.

“So, um…how’s, uh…” Her eyes searched for a topic to discuss, but all she could see was stuffed felines. It was impossible not to bring up the cats. “Isn’t taxidermy expensive?” Maybe he was rich and this whole night could be salvaged.

“Oh, yeah. I had my very first cat, Marshmellow, taxidermied. She was the best childhood cat I could ask for. Lived twenty years. The taxidermist did so well, but…” Harry blew air through his lips. “Man, it cost almost a thousand dollars.”

Sarah leaned in, intrigued.

“So, this is like, what? Fifteen thousand dollars worth of taxidermy?”

“Technically, yes, but not out of my pocket! I learned how to do taxidermy myself!”

Sarah deflated and leaned back into the couch, sipping her water while Harry stood up and picked up a frightfully misshapen cat. “Missy was my second cat and wow I did not do her any justice, but I’m sure she’s laughing about it in cat heaven right now!”

Sarah swallowed thickly, trying not to let her disgust show. “Oh…it’s alright, you did…good, for your first time.” She chewed on ice, hoping to calm her nerves.

“I did, didn’t I? I’m learning to be gentler with myself.” He shrugged nervously and placed Missy back on the shelf that displayed most of the cats, then sat back down, “Obviously, I’m much more skilled now! I could probably charge for my services, but…I don’t know. I enjoy it more when it’s sentimental. And I probably couldn’t handle the emotions of all those sad owners. It’s just too much for me.”

“Right…” Sarah kept eyeing the cats, “and which one is Melly?”

Harry shook his head, “Exactly the reason why I can’t taxidermy other cats. I can barely do my own without crying. Every time I try to start the process I break down.” His doe eyes had already begun tearing up as he let out a long, melancholy sigh. “So, Melly’s just been sitting in my freezer.”

Sarah paused, head cocked. 

“…”

Harry shuffled in his seat, noticing a change in her demeanor.

“The freezer?” she asked.

“Yeah, she’s in a ten-gallon storage bag—“

“In the freezer…with the same ice…in my drink.” Sarah held out the glass of water to Harry like she was offended to have even touched it. He closed his eyes and stammered before he found the words. 

“…O-oh, sorry, no! Well, yes, it’s the same freezer, but she’s not in the ice tank, she’s just in a—in a bag on the shelf. A ten-gallon storage bag, like the ones for food. Nothing is contaminated or anything…she’s…very far from the ice.”

Sarah stared, mouth agape.

“S-so sorry about that, I probably should’ve told you, but lesson learned! Next time, I’ll have chilled bottled water for you! O-or tap, if the lower area of the fridge is still too much.” 

Sarah rose from the couch.

“It was lovely meeting you, Harry, but this is weird.” 

“My…my cats?”

“Yes!” she responded snappily, “FYI, you don’t serve dead cat iced water to your date or anyone for that matter!” Sarah hastily made her way to the front door, unlocking it.

“You’re sweet…I think. Please, seek help.” She slammed the door behind her.

Posted Nov 07, 2026
Share:

You must sign up or log in to submit a comment.

6 likes 4 comments

Sarah Empire
November 10, 2026 16:01

I love how you built this from an awkward but promising first date into such a bizarre, hilarious horror reveal! Harry’s innocent enthusiasm makes the discovery of his taxidermied cats even more unsettling. Did you always plan for Lulubelle’s introduction to take such a disturbing turn?

Reply

Seanna L. Grimes
November 10, 2026 18:04

I did! But I transformed Harry from an obvious case of someone dangerous or suspicious to a guy who genuinely loves his cats, but has an odd relationship with them. I don’t think it registered just how unsettling this reveal is to a new reader. As the author, I’m quite fond of Harry, and found myself laughing a lot while writing.

Reply

Sarah Empire
November 11, 2026 10:26

Haha, that contrast makes Harry even more memorable! His genuine love for his cats makes the unsettling reveal all the more unexpected. I’m curious, is this story part of a published book or still a work in progress?

Reply

Seanna L. Grimes
November 11, 2026 14:59

No, this is actually a stand alone short story I wrote specifically for the Reedsy weekly competition!

Reply

Reedsy | Default — Editors with Marker | 2024-05

Bring your publishing dreams to life

The world's best editors, designers, and marketers are on Reedsy. Come meet them.