The Hitchhikers

Mystery Thriller

Written in response to: "You looked out the window and, not for the first time, thought about how wrong the weather forecast had been." as part of Second Person.

You know better than to pick up a hitchhiker. How many stories had you read where the innocent girl picks up a stranger on the side of the road and they turn out to be a murderer, kidnapper, escaped psychiatric patient etc., You get the picture. But this time was different.

           You worked late tonight, your shift should have ended two hours ago but you stayed late for a co-worker so she could leave early to tend to her sick child. You work every Monday, Wednesday and Friday as a waitress and you go to nursing school during the day. You knew you wanted to be a nurse ever since you were a little girl, nursing your teddy bears and dolls back to health, applying bandages to their paws and listening to their little stuffed hearts. One more week and you graduate, you smile. You can’t believe you’re almost done. Especially since you’ve been through so much this year, mainly with Professor Ross. Ugh.

You thought it was just some harmless flirting, until he cornered you in his office that day. You heard he had a bad reputation. You probably should have reported it to the Dean but you only threatened to report it and then you switched classes. It was final semester, you didn’t need any more drama. Switching out of his class seemed like the best idea. Now next week is graduation and then you are out of there and you don’t have to see any of them again.

           Almost home, you sigh, it’s nearly 10 p.m. and you have class tomorrow. The rain beats furiously against the windshield making it nearly impossible for you to see, so much for zero chance of rain, you think shaking your head. It must be nice to be a meteorologist, to be wrong so often with no repercussions. If a nurse is wrong, people die.

           As you’re sitting at a red light you see something in the distance coming closer. It looks like people coming down the sidewalk. Two people. As they get closer you can see its one adult and one child. They are running now, are they waving at you? Now you can see it’s a mother and child. They look like they’re in trouble. Neither are wearing raincoats or have an umbrella, they probably watched the same newscast as you. The mother is holding her daughter’s hand trying to shield the poor thing from the rain. They’re getting closer now. You hope they don’t need a ride. You know better than to pick up a hitchhiker. Now you can see them more clearly. The little girl is holding a doll under her arm. Aww she’s trying to shield the doll the way her mother is shielding her. What are they doing out at this time? It’s late and its pouring rain. Maybe their car broke down. The poor things, they are soaked. They don’t look dangerous. Most killers don’t, though. It’s a mother and a child for heaven’s sake. She’s attractive and well dressed. But you know better than to pick up a hitchhiker. They’re some bad areas around here, though. What if they run into trouble? What if they are trouble? They can’t be, look at them, the poor things. The child looks no more than eight years old. You unroll your window. She bends down to speak to you.

           “Excuse us, we’re so sorry to bother you,” the woman says. “Our car got a flat tire,” the woman says pointing down the road. “You’re the first person we’ve seen go by so we thought we might ask you for a ride. We live just down the road, any chance you could give us a lift? If you were a man we probably wouldn’t ask, I’m sure you can understand that. It can be so dangerous out here for women. And in the chaos of it all we locked the keys and my cell phone in the car,” the woman said shaking her head, her daughter looking up at you, raindrops or maybe tears, streaming down her cheeks. You think for a moment, look them up and down, and you unlock the doors. 

           “Okay. Sure c’mon in,” you say. The mother opens the door and the little girl slides in first and then her mother slides in behind her.

           “Thank you, thank you so much. We live at 150 Briarcliff Drive, so go left at the next light and then a right and then we’ll be there. It’s only about five minutes from here. We really appreciate what you’re doing for us. Thank you so much,” the mother said, trying to dry her daughter’s face with her shirt sleeve.

           Five minutes later you are still driving. “Just a little bit further now. Thanks again for doing this,” the mother says pointing down the road.

           You look in the rearview mirror at the little girl holding her doll tight against her chest, her mother’s arm wrapped around her shoulder.

           “Here we go… now it’s this white house up here on the left,” the mother says. You had seen this house many times before. It was in a nice area actually, across the street from a small lake with running trails that you run on every Saturday morning. You feel relieved. It is the only house on this side of the lake. You pull into the driveway.

           “There you go,” you say, putting the car in park and looking into the back seat.

           “Would you mind just waiting here for a quick second? I need to make sure the spare key is under the mat before you leave and we get stuck outside again,“ she explained.

           “Ok,” you say, that makes sense. You look at the little girl and she smiles at you as her mother gets out.

           The woman runs to the door and checks under the mat and gives you a thumb’s up. As she goes to unlock the door a man opens it as he’s putting on his raincoat. They talk for a moment and she points to you. He looks familiar but it’s hard to tell because it’s raining so hard. Maybe you’ve seen him on the running path. They both hurry towards your car. The little girl has gotten out to join her mother now. You unroll the window as he bends down. You know that cologne, cedar mixed with fresh soap and spice.

           “I just wanted to thank you for helping my family get home safe. That was a real nice thing for you to do,” the man says as he leans down into the window. Then he hesitates.

           “Sarah?” the man asks. It’s Professor Ross.

           “Oh, uh...hi...Professor Ross. What a coincidence. Ha. It was no problem. I got to get going now, though, so you all take care,” you say nervously and begin to roll your window up. Your doors are already locked, thankfully.

           “Yes, of course. Good luck with finals,” he says as he reaches out his hand to shake yours. You glance and see the mother and daughter in front of your car, they’re waving goodbye. So you reach your hand out to shake his hand when suddenly his other hand comes out of his pocket. He smothers a rag over your nose and mouth. You flail. Reaching out, trying to move his hands or push the horn. Now you can’t see. You can’t breath. You start to see spots and then everything is black.

           He unlocks your door and drags you into the house. The mother gets behind the wheel of your car and drives it into the pond across the street. It sinks silently into the murky darkness. She goes into the house and shuts the door behind her. You knew better than to pick up a hitchhiker.

Posted Jun 20, 2020
Share:

You must sign up or log in to submit a comment.

85 likes 38 comments

Lindsey Lasson
July 06, 2020 17:08

Oh gosh. This was so well done. I didn't see the twist coming even though you literally told me it was coming XD

Reply

July 07, 2020 00:22

Thank you so much for reading Lindsey and taking the time to comment. I’m glad you enjoyed ☺️

Reply

Wow! Rip Sarah at the end there! No knight in shining armor to come save her!

Reply

June 22, 2020 14:01

Thanks for taking the time to read Caleb! Ha nope, one of these days I’ll write a story with a happy ending 😃

Reply

Lilah Peters
July 13, 2020 18:09

THE DRAMA!!! Great story!! I cant help but want to know what happens next!

Reply

July 13, 2020 18:38

Thanks Lilah! I’m so glad you enjoyed it

Reply

Gip Roberts
July 10, 2020 20:23

Good line about meteorologist vs. nurse. The whole story kept me begging to find out what was going to happen next, and the second-person style made it even more suspenseful.

Reply

July 10, 2020 22:22

Thanks Gip! I’m so glad you liked it

Reply

Sarah A
July 09, 2020 14:30

Wow, did not see that coming. That’s terrifying and so well written.

Reply

July 09, 2020 15:00

Thank you Sarah! I’m glad you enjoyed it

Reply

My Name
July 08, 2020 18:39

Jeepers. I expected the ending to be something like a misunderstanding getting cleared up between the MC and the professor but boy, was I wrong. Nice twist. I recommend fixing the structure of the sentences and paragraphs but not the writing; it's awesome.

Reply

July 08, 2020 04:42

I took time to read this story and went over twice. This was a thrilling roller-coaster read. The twist in the though expected came as an unexpected surprise. Looking forward to reading more from you. Cheers and Good luck!

Reply

July 08, 2020 11:54

Thank you so much Parvathy! I’m so glad you liked it. Two times even. Wow!

Reply

Spider Baby
July 07, 2020 06:02

I was expecting the ending to veer more into the supernatural, especially when the child's character was introduced. But I guess all real monsters are human :x Either way, it was a phenomenal story. oh and thanks for reading my story, btw! (^▽^)

Reply

July 07, 2020 06:43

Thank you for reading and your thoughtful comments. I appreciate it

Reply

Miss Tee
July 04, 2020 15:39

OMG, You totally got me, Somehow I knew it would end badly but I wasn't so sure, I love the twists to the story

Reply

July 07, 2020 00:30

Thanks Edima I’m so happy you enjoyed it. And thank you for taking the time to comment

Reply

Miss Tee
July 25, 2020 12:29

Please help leave a comment on my story, I'm just here to learn from great writers like you
Thanks for your time

Reply

Kyla Jernigan
June 30, 2020 01:52

Hey Sarah! Fantastic story! I love a good killer story like this!

Reply

June 30, 2020 14:03

I know right, lol. Thank you so much for taking the time to read and respond. I appreciate it.

Reply

Kristy Reynolds
June 29, 2020 23:47

Nice twist!

Reply

July 01, 2020 16:46

Thanks Kristy!

Reply

Praveen Jagwani
June 29, 2020 04:31

Twisted people are infinitely more interesting to write about. Well done. Another good story and well told. No ornate distractions. You've kept a taut pace throughout. Some odd word placement like smothers. Also since there are two of them, should be hitchhikers (plural). Thank you for sharing :)

Reply

July 01, 2020 16:45

Thanks for reading and taking the time to comment. I will reread and do some editing. Thanks again !

Reply

Elle Clark
June 28, 2020 22:40

Holy moly. Okay, well. I was expecting a negative twist because you’d signalled it so clearly but even so - you got me. Great writing that builds smoothly and the repetition both reinforces the ending and helps with flow. Fab writing!

Reply

June 29, 2020 10:48

Aww thanks so much Laura. Comments like that are better than winning any contest. Thank you 🙏🏼

Reply

Elle Clark
June 29, 2020 11:05

You’re welcome! It was brilliant!

Reply

Shirley Medhurst
June 27, 2020 15:16

I enjoyed your story. What a twist to have the guy be Mr Ross! I thought there had to be a terrible outcome with the ominous repetition about not picking up hitchhikers but I wasn’t expecting that.
By the way, if you have time, would you mind checking out my story & giving me your feedback?
Many thanks Sarah

Reply

June 27, 2020 20:30

thanks for reading Shirley and taking time to comment. Yes, I'll check yours out shortly

Reply

Tvisha Yerra
June 25, 2020 18:33

Love the build-up. Absolutely amazing!

Reply

June 25, 2020 19:07

Thank you so much Tvisha! Your kind comments are better than winning any contest 🥰

Reply

Batool Hussain
June 21, 2020 10:55

Great story!

Mind checking my recent story out?
Thanks,

Reply

June 21, 2020 11:45

Definitely. Thanks for reading !

Reply

Maya Reynolds
July 16, 2020 17:11

Wow great twist at the end - I did not see that coming!

Reply

July 06, 2020 15:01

Always expect the unexpected. Good job.

Reply

July 07, 2020 00:22

Thanks George ! I’m glad you enjoyed it

Reply

Kelechi Nwokoma
June 25, 2020 17:52

Wow. I sure knew better that to pick up a hitchhiker, haha. I love how you stated this is the beginning and the end.
Could you please read my story, 'Silent Betrayer' whenever you have time and give me feedback? I'd really appreciate it.

Reply

Vincent Cruz
September 01, 2020 06:21

• I like how you built that tension. I had this sense that it might not end well, yet at the same time the comforting and reassuring voice inside of the character’s head continually convinced me that my fear was not valid. I was wrong.
• Your story recalled a memory of when I was in the car when my father picked up a hitchhiker when I was like seven or eight years old. Long story short my dad ended knowing the guy, it turned out they had grown up together.
• I also thought about how we tend to assume that nice looking people are nice, and that bad looking people are bad (although sometimes we are right). If it were a black or brown man would she have even considered picking him up? What if it were a black or brown woman? The story doesn’t reveal much more about her other than that she is “attractive and well dressed” so she could have looked like anything the reader imagines. I think the main anchor to your story here is the child. The child, no matter what the child looks like tricks the reader into thinking this is a safe situation. How could a woman with a child be dangerous? I’m curious to know how you would have told the story without the child in tow.
I really enjoyed the story! Keep writing.

Reply

Reedsy | Default — Editors with Marker | 2024-05

Bring your publishing dreams to life

The world's best editors, designers, and marketers are on Reedsy. Come meet them.