The Price of Remembering

Fantasy Science Fiction Speculative

Written in response to: "Your protagonist makes a difficult choice made for the sake of survival. What happens next?" as part of From the Ashes with Michael McConnell.

Sometimes memories sneak out of my eyes and roll down my cheeks. I don’t know why. The thoughts circling my brain, are they mine? Are they someone else’s?

At this point, I don’t know. All I know is that I have them, and they bring me money and power. It’s a funny business, really. I’m not old enough to remember when it became the vogue thing to do, or why most people don’t seem to have any memories of their own. The techs call us Hippos because the stories they mine come from our hippocampal region.

There are others like me. Most are young, but there’s one really old one. Othor. He tells of the Before Now, when people actually experienced things, and those things formed memories they carried through their lives. Memories that could be written down, painted, sung, passed from old to young. Shared. Not anymore.

People are still here, but they have none of that.

So they come to Cognify. A memory sculptor straps you into the chair, the Neural Transfer Interface hums, and you sleep. When you wake, you have someone else’s dream. It isn’t painful. Just like sleeping and dreaming, except the dream is pulled from one of us and grafted into you.

For that, we Hippos live well. We have rooms. Lights that stay on. Food, real food, not the gray paste most people eat. The taste, the feel, the smell of real food. The Company learned early that good food makes good memories, so they feed us until we’re sick with it, then stop us before the sickness itself becomes part of the memory record.

I was in the chair again this morning. The sculptor’s hands were cool and quick. “Deep breath,” she said. I closed my eyes. The interface pressed against my temples like gentle fingers. Then the familiar tug, the soft emptying. When I woke, the room smelled of citrus and warm bread with fresh churned butter. My stomach was full even though I hadn’t eaten.

Someone else would remember this fullness now. Someone who had never tasted real butter.

I wiped my face. Another tear had slipped out.

Othor was waiting in the common room, same as always. He sat by the long window that looked out on the gray wall surrounding the compound. His hair had gone white years ago, but his eyes were still sharp.

“You leaking again?” he asked.

I nodded.

He smiled the way he does when he’s remembering something he shouldn’t. “In the Before Now, people cried because they felt too much. Not because something was leaving them.”

I sat across from him. The chair creaked under me. “What did they feel?”

“Everything,” he said. “Love. Anger. The ache when someone died. The way rain smells before it falls. They didn’t pay for it. They just… had it.”

I tried to picture that. It made my head hurt.

The next harvest was scheduled for the afternoon. I ate slowly, roast chicken, soft potatoes, something green that tasted like earth and salt. I let the flavors settle so they would be rich for whoever bought them. When the tech came for me, I followed without speaking. The chair again. The hum. The tug. This time, when I woke, something was different. My mouth tasted of salt that wasn’t from the chicken. My chest felt tight, the way it does when you’ve run too far. I sat up too fast.

The sculptor frowned. “Residual echo,” she said, tapping her tablet. “Happens sometimes. Nothing to worry about.”

But it kept happening. Three days later, a buyer refused to leave the grafting room. I heard the techs talking in the hall. The woman had come out of the chair crying. Real crying, not the polite kind, and she kept whispering, “That wasn’t mine. That was mine.”

They sedated her and sent her home. The next morning, the sedation protocols for buyers were doubled.

Othor noticed it too. “The leaks are going both ways now,” he said quietly as we shared a plate of honeyed figs. “Someone’s feeding the machine the wrong memories.”

I didn’t ask who. I already knew.

Her name was Mara. She came in as a buyer, same as the rest. But when the interface touched her temples, she didn’t close her eyes. She looked straight at the sculptor and said, “I have something better than what you’re selling.”

They should have stopped her. Instead, they let the session run. Later, the techs whispered that the graft had reversed. Not pulled from a Hippo, pushed into one.

That night, I dreamed of a woman’s hands tying a child’s shoe. The laces were red. The child laughed. The sound cracked open something inside my ribs I didn’t know was closed. When I woke, my face was wet again.

I started watching for her. She came back twice more, always as a buyer, always leaving something behind. Small things at first. The smell of rain on hot pavement. The ache of a lie told to protect someone. A father’s anger that somehow still felt like love. Each time, the memories I sold afterward tasted sharper. Buyers began asking strange questions. One man left the chair and stood in the hallway for twenty minutes, staring at his own hands as if they belonged to a stranger.

The Company noticed. Extra monitors appeared in the common room. Othor was called for “maintenance” and didn’t come back. When I asked, the tech only smiled the way they always do. “He’s too old to remember,” she said.

I was scheduled for evaluation the next morning.

They put me in a white room I’d never seen before. Two chairs. No straps. The interface waited on a low table like a sleeping animal. Mara was already there. She looked tired, the way Othor used to look when he talked about the Before Now. Her hair was short and uneven, as if cut with something dull. When she saw me, she didn’t smile. She just studied my face like she was reading a page she’d read many times.

“I wondered which one would feel it first,” she said. Her voice was quiet. No triumph. Just recognition. I sat. The chair was warm from her body.

“Are you the one giving them the wrong memories?”

“Not wrong,” she said. “Real. The ones the Silence took. Grief. Wanting. The weight of choosing. They sterilized everything so no one would fight. No grudges. No wars. No reason to ask why the world is the way it is. But people aren’t meant to live in a dream someone else sold them.”

A tear slid down my cheek. I didn’t wipe it. “I don’t know which thoughts are mine anymore.”

She leaned forward. The interface between us hummed softly, waiting.

“That’s the point,” she said. “Some of them never were. But some could be. If you let them stay.”

She reached out and touched the side of the interface. Not to sell. To give.

The transfer began without the sculptor. Just her, me, and the quiet room. I felt it like warm water pouring into a cracked cup. A childhood that wasn’t curated. A mother singing off-key in a kitchen that smelled of bread and soap. The sting of a scraped knee. The first time someone said, “I love you” and meant it, even though it hurt later. The weight of loss that didn’t fade because it wasn’t designed to.

It hurt.

It was the most beautiful thing I had ever felt. When it ended, I was crying openly. Not the polite leaks. Real tears, messy and loud.

Mara watched me without pity. “They’ll purge you now,” she said. “Or try. But the leaks are already out there. People are starting to remember how to remember. They’re telling each other stories in the streets. No machines. Just mouths and ears. It’s slow. But it’s spreading.”

I swallowed. My throat felt raw. “What happens if they catch you?”

She shrugged, small and tired. “Same thing that happened to Othor. But some memories don’t erase cleanly once they’ve been shared.”

The door opened. Two techs. They didn’t look surprised to see her.

“Time for maintenance,” one said.

They took her first. She didn’t fight. At the threshold, she glanced back at me once. Not a goodbye. Just a look that said: Choose.

They left me alone with the interface. I sat there a long time.

The room was very white.

Very quiet. I could feel the new memories inside me, hers, and now somehow partly mine. Both settle like sediment at the bottom of a river. They didn’t feel borrowed. They felt heavy.

Alive.

When the sculptor finally came for the scheduled harvest, I shook my head.

“I’m not selling today.”

She blinked. “That’s not how it works.”

“I know.”

They scheduled me for a full wipe the next morning. I spent the night in my room eating slowly, tasting everything twice, once for me, once for whoever might never get to taste it again. I thought about Othor. About the red laces. About the way Mara’s voice had sounded when she said the world used to be full of things people felt without paying.

In the morning, they led me back to the white room. The interface waited. A new sculptor, younger, nervous. She kept glancing at the monitor like she expected alarms.

I lay back in the chair. The pads touched my temples. The hum began. I closed my eyes and held on. I held the mother’s off-key song. I held the scraped knee and the father’s anger that was still love. I held the weight of choosing even when it hurt. I held every tear that had ever leaked out of me without permission, and I named them mine.

The pull came stronger than usual, as if the machine knew I was resisting. For a moment, the memories blurred, threatening to slide away like water down a drain. I whispered, so quietly only I could hear it: “Stay.”

The machine stuttered. Just once. A small skip in the hum.

Then it stopped.

She looked at me, trying to gauge my reaction. Then, almost absently, she wiped her own face. She stared at her fingers as if surprised to find them wet before marking the session complete.

The sculptor stared at her tablet. “Anomaly,” she muttered. “We’ll have to recalibrate.”

They sent me back to my room instead of wiping me. I don’t know why. Maybe the infection had already reached the techs. Maybe the Company was afraid of what would happen if they erased the wrong Hippo now.

That night, I stood at my window and looked at the gray wall. Beyond it, somewhere, people were beginning to cry for reasons they couldn’t name. They were asking questions. Learning how to remember.

Sometimes memories sneak out of my eyes and roll down my cheeks. I don’t know why. The thoughts circling my brain, are they mine? Are they someone else’s?

At this point… I think I want them to be. I wiped my face. The tears were warm. Real. Not for sale.

Outside, the gray wall stood as it always had. But for the first time, I wondered what it would feel like to walk past it. To step into a world that hurt and sang and broke and mended without anyone’s permission. I smiled, small and uncertain.

It tasted like rain on hot pavement.

It tasted like mine.

Posted Apr 10, 2026
Share:

You must sign up or log in to submit a comment.

8 likes 3 comments

John Bishop
02:14 Apr 21, 2026

I have to reread this. I was completely intrigued. Please keep writing. You see things the rest of us don't. Thank you!

Reply

Tom Salas
04:28 Apr 14, 2026

I really like the twist on the idea of a memory market. The concept of a stunted world purchasing memories just to feel normal is really interesting. I also liked the idea of the leak feeding humanity back to the masses. I enjoyed the story.

Reply

Sarah David
16:40 Apr 17, 2026

Thank you for the kind words. Im glad you enjoyed it

Reply

RBE | Illustrated Short Stories | 2024-06

Bring your short stories to life

Fuse character, story, and conflict with tools in Reedsy Studio. All for free.