Desperate Remedies

⭐️ Contest #248 Shortlist!

Drama Contemporary Lesbian

Written in response to: "Write a story titled 'Desperate Remedies'." as part of From the Top.

Was she taunting me? 

I was jolted awake by a strange sound — pee-pee-paw, pee-pee-pee-paw. It drilled into my skull, causing shockwaves, though that might also have been the alcohol. I forced my eyelids open a fraction, afraid to face the light. It having been New Year’s Eve, I at least had an excuse for a change. For the first time in five years, I greeted the new year alone. 

What kind of new bird could this be? I went outside to look for the source of my annoyance. A female tui. I could tell because of the size and plumage. Strange. She wasn’t making typical tui noises. They sound more like aliens. Should be quork-quork, grrr-rruk-rruk-rruk.

Pee-pee-paw, pee-pee-pee-paw

“Hey, you! Stop that!”

To distract myself, I opened Instagram. The first post in my feed was Katya’s — thanks, universe. On the photo she stood on a hill overlooking a cliff, the majestic ocean in the background. She smiled with radiance, and her eyes shone. The post read: This past year was a difficult one, I’m not gonna lie. But I was finally brave enough to put myself first and it has already reaped rewards. I have never felt so free and so safe in my life. Here’s to a new year full of more incredible experiences and people to light up my life!

Pee-pee-paw, pee-pee-pee-paw

She repeated the one tune in her repertoire with glee every five minutes. Was she showing off? I ignored it at first, but by the end of the day I felt myself spiralling into madness. There was nowhere to hide — closing the windows didn’t block out the sound, and besides, it made it too stuffy in the house. 

She was ruining my life. It may sound like I’m exaggerating, but honestly, I couldn’t concentrate on anything. Every time I would sit down to do some work, watch television, or take a nap, I would hear her annoying song ringing out in the yard. My only respite was going out, but I couldn’t do that all the time. I had a right to spend time in my own home without being harassed, surely?

I messaged Katya for ideas, but she didn’t reply. What, or who, was she so busy with? 

Pee-pee-paw, pee-pee-pee-paw.

With Katya not helping, I ventured online, but most articles were about how to attract rather than deter birds. I did find one useful Facebook post, so tried out some of their remedies. First, I attempted to scare it away by pulling branches near it, hoping the disturbance would drive it off. But she was unfazed, her call as loud as ever. 

I checked my phone, but didn’t have any new notifications. 

Pee-pee-paw, pee-pee-pee-paw.

Plan B was going to Bunnings to get a non-toxic, bitter-tasting substance. On my way to the car I met my neighbour, Phil. 

“Lovely day, isn’t it?” he said. 

“Mmm,” I replied. “Hey, do you know why this tui is making such strange noises?”

“Eh?”

“The tui, it sounds different, and it won’t stop. It’s new here.”

He just stared at me like I was speaking in a foreign language, and after a pause, shook his head. Had he not noticed? How could it possibly not bother him? 

“Ok, well, I’m off, see you,” I said and got in the car. 

I got what I needed from Bunnings and sprayed it on one of her favourite berry trees. It seemed to work at first, but then she merely went higher up, where I couldn’t reach. This tree was Katya’s favourite as well; she used to sit under it to read all the time.  

As if I had summoned her with this thought, my phone lit up with a notification. She replied at last. 

Tracy. Stop messaging me with every little thing. We’re no longer together. Get a grip and leave me alone!

Pee-pee-paw, pee-pee-pee-paw.

That’s rude. Didn’t she say we could still be friends? Anyway, I had bigger problems. My next idea was putting reflective things around the yard, hoping it would scare her off, but that didn’t work either. She seemed to like it, actually, and fluttered and sang with even more gaiety. A party bird, really?

I opened Instagram and checked to see if Katya had any stories. She did. There were a few pictures of graffiti, buildings, and the waterfront, but the last one was what disturbed me. She was with a woman I didn’t know, and a heart emoji had been added. Who the hell was that? How could she move on so quickly? 

I threw a rock at the bird in frustration, then sank down on my knees and screamed, tears forming in my eyes. 

Pee-pee-paw, pee-pee-pee-paw.

Desperate times called for desperate measures. I had to return to Bunnings to get a chainsaw and get rid of the tree for good. It was the only way. 


***


We had been fighting more than usual, but I didn’t see the end coming at all. She must have thought it over for some time. She came into my study one night. I remember how happy I felt at that moment, oblivious of what was to come. 

“Tracy, can we talk?”

I swivelled around in my chair. “Sure, what’s up?”

“I can’t do it anymore.”

“Do what? Do you need help with something?”

She smirked. “No. This. Us. I can’t do it anymore. I’m not happy.”

My heart started racing and my thoughts spiralled. What had I done wrong? Surely it must be fixable. This cannot be happening. I don’t want to be on my own. We’ve had fights before where we ‘broke up’, only to get back together again an hour or so later. But this felt different. The surreal quality of the moment – its calm unchaotic nature – underscored its seriousness. It was clear that she had thought about it deeply and made a deliberate, calculated decision. One that I likely couldn’t change.  

“But why?” I finally stammered. 

She sighed deeply. “The fact you even need to ask is the reason.” 

“What do you mean?” I strained to hold back my tears. 

“Tracy, you have so many mental issues. And I know it’s not your fault, but you refuse to do anything about it, to get the help you need. And that is your fault. It’s just too hard, I can’t deal with it anymore. It’s not fair. I’m no longer happy, I don’t feel free.”


***


I decided against getting a chainsaw. I saw in my mind’s eye how I would fumble with the tool, likely losing a finger or more in the process. I’ve always been rather clumsy. No matter how much I wanted to get rid of this bird, the desire to keep all my limbs was stronger, if only just. And besides, I didn’t want to destroy the tree, her favourite, and one that provided so much food and shelter to the birds. 

Instead, I sat in the garden, watching the tui hop from branch to branch, indulging in her favourite snacks. Despite everything, she was only a bird after all, doing what birds do. She just happened to be a very annoying one. I had tried every possible way to silence her, but in the end, I realised it was I who needed to change, not her. 

I started seeing Anna, a therapist my friend recommended. She helped me sort through my obsessions and compulsions, much of it more persistent and unsettling than any bird could ever be. Session by session, the weight I carried began to lighten. I started checking Katya’s Instagram less and less, and didn’t let myself get quite as riled up by each pee-pee-paw. In fact, the bird’s song had woven itself into my daily existence. 

Then, one day I realised I didn’t hear the rogue tui anymore. In her place there was nothing but a thunderous silence. I scanned the branches, expecting her to reappear and resume her song, but she didn’t. I waited for days for her to come back, but she never did. 

In the silence, I was surprised to find myself missing her. She had, without intending to and without me realising it, kept me company through my toughest period. She had been there, a constant presence as I wrestled with my thoughts and my heartache. And now, with both her and Katya gone, the silence felt heavy. 

Why did she leave me?

But I was different now. The emptiness was something I could face. I was learning to appreciate the quiet, to sit with my thoughts without being overrun by them. I went up to the tree, tracing the empty branches where the tui once sang. My heart still ached, but it no longer overwhelmed me. I had a strong urge to message Katya, to tell her I’ve been going to therapy, ask if we could try again. But I knew that would be a mistake, and surprisingly, was managing to resist. 

With a deep breath, I rose from the lawn and went inside, my shadow long and solitary in the fading light. I opened my laptop, not to spy on Katya’s social life but to write. I typed out everything — my feelings, my growth, and my setbacks. On the screen, words flowed like a quiet stream, not for the world but for me. 

Perhaps, the end of one song was simply the beginning of another?

Posted Apr 28, 2024
Share:

You must sign up or log in to submit a comment.

79 likes 70 comments

Ken Cartisano
May 28, 2024 18:20

This is excellent. I didn't realize it was shortlisted until I read some of the comments. Congratulations on the recognition. Also glad to hear everything but the bird was made up. I'm not sure what's so amazing about this story, but I think that it's the tone. The tone of intermittent sanity shining through the character's struggle with her emotional crisis. And, how life, the universe, and something as simple as a bird (or a towel) can serve as a focal point, like a seasick sailor, focusing on a point of land to steady his/her stomach against the turbulent water. (Until the storm passes. Or she reaches the safety of the breakwaters.) Skillful writing.

Reply

May 28, 2024 20:50

Thank you, Ken! I'm glad you enjoyed it! Insightful comments.

Reply

Marty B
May 11, 2024 04:31

I appreciated your theme. For a contest based on a title, your last line was amazing.
'Perhaps, the end of one song was simply the beginning of another?'

Reply

May 11, 2024 06:38

Thank you, I'm glad you liked it!

Reply

Alex Parise
May 24, 2024 22:57

Have to read more of the words you use to make my day a lot more rewarding..... anymore like this?

Reply

May 26, 2024 09:56

That's so nice to hear, thank you! :) This is probably my best one, but hopefully I can write more that you like. I look forward to reading your stories too.

Reply

Alex Parise
June 01, 2024 20:01

My story Melissa was The Dreamer...Wish you would read it.

Reply

Graham Kinross
May 14, 2024 23:15

Art imitates life? Taking a broken heart and turning it into art? Congratulations on being shortlisted.

Reply

May 14, 2024 23:34

Thank you, Graham! Luckily everything except for the bird was made up :)

Reply

Graham Kinross
May 15, 2024 02:54

And the writing?

Reply

Philip Ebuluofor
May 13, 2024 03:17

Fine work. Congrats. At times, it pays to face forward.

Reply

May 13, 2024 03:39

Thank you, Philip.

Reply

Fern Everton
May 10, 2024 22:18

Congratulations on the shortlist!! Your story has a powerful message and I enjoyed reading it! Great job!

Reply

May 10, 2024 22:51

Thank you so much! I'm glad you enjoyed it :)

Reply

Kristi Gott
May 10, 2024 16:50

Congratulations! A very deep and well written story. Skillful with well developed characters.

Reply

May 10, 2024 21:15

Thank you very much! 😊

Reply

Ty Warmbrodt
May 10, 2024 16:33

Congrats on the very well earned short list!

Reply

May 10, 2024 21:26

Thank you 😊

Reply

Helen A Howard
May 10, 2024 15:51

Congratulations Melissa 🥳

Reply

May 10, 2024 21:14

Thank you! 😊

Reply

Crystal Wexel
May 10, 2024 14:31

I love the symbolism in this story , and I love how you used a bird to show it .

Reply

May 10, 2024 21:14

Thank you, glad you enjoyed it!

Reply

Cara Fidler
May 08, 2024 18:50

Well done. I enjoyed this story; an interesting tale you wove there.

Reply

May 08, 2024 20:25

Thank you, so glad to hear you enjoyed it!

Reply

Jeremy Stevens
May 08, 2024 15:38

So, you're a New Zealander! I learned this from "tui." What a beautiful bird, and a beautifully told, spiritual story.

Reply

May 08, 2024 20:26

Thank you! Yes, they are truly special birds.

Reply

Jahson Clarke
May 08, 2024 05:53

What a beautiful piece. I was engaged the entire time.

Reply

May 08, 2024 07:40

Thank you so much! I'm so glad you enjoyed it ☺️

Reply

Kay Reed
May 08, 2024 03:45

Hi Melissa- fantastic work on this story! I think you handled the mental illness material so well - a lot of stories I read of this nature always seem to have a character devolving and/or breaking from reality, and I love how you flipped the script and had your character evolve, grow, and seek help instead. Love to have this kind of representation out there! Well done.

Reply

May 08, 2024 04:35

Thank you so much for your thoughtful comment! I'm very glad to hear you enjoyed my story :)

Reply

Carol Stewart
May 07, 2024 18:04

Enjoyed the parallel of the tui and the narrator's past relationship, much left unsaid there but one can fill in the blanks. Held my attention throughout.

Reply

May 07, 2024 19:52

Thank you, glad you enjoyed it!

Reply

Thomas Payne
May 06, 2024 02:41

Nicely done. I liked the comments on seeking mental health treatment. To paraphrase, "It's not your fault but it is your responsibiliy". Very true. Great story and well written. Looking forward to more.

Reply

May 06, 2024 02:42

Thank you so much, that means a lot!

Reply

David Pampu
May 05, 2024 00:50

Oh, how I loved this story! I can relate to it on several levels. Well done.

Reply

May 05, 2024 01:13

Thank you so much! Glad you liked it and could relate.

Reply

Martha Kowalski
May 04, 2024 23:43

I like that that MC could grow and make a happier ending (or simply a beginning?...) for herself.

Hello from a fellow economist and thanks for the like and follow! :)

Reply

May 04, 2024 23:55

Thank you, Martha! Great to meet another economist here :)

I look forward to reading more of your work!

Reply

Kendall Defoe
May 04, 2024 15:09

Oh, I really like this...
And we need more!

Reply

May 04, 2024 21:52

Thanks, Kendall! Glad you enjoyed it.

Reply

Daryl Kulak
May 02, 2024 18:15

Really beautiful. I like the tui as metaphor for Katya.

Reply

May 02, 2024 18:26

Thank you!

Reply

May 01, 2024 00:29

We have to learn to live with ourselves before we can share it with another. Beautifully written. You have captured the hyperfocus on the annoying of a depressed person perfectly.

There are ways to tighten up the writing and I'll give you a few examples. Think of it this way. We should try to write sentences with as many meaningful words and get rid of as many connectors, what they call glue (words use to stick other words together but that bog us down when reading.) Jettison as many repeats, adjectives and adverbs as you can. Especially repeats and adverbs. Think of stronger verbs to express what you want to say. These are ideas only, not suggestions to change every word:

eg 'woke up grudgingly' - forced my eye lids open a fraction, afraid to face the light. I could etc

'quite some time.' vague. Stronger - forever, all year?
'fighting a lot, more than usual.' - one or the other here?

Turns out the bird is outside so somehow mention you don't have double glazing as many do and you wouldn't hear the bird if you did. eg 'How I wished I had double glazing." I, as a reader, started thinking about the fact you couldn't have had double glazing. Took me out of the story. It could also serve as a possible remedy, but too expensive! Or it is Summer and the window is open? Remedy - close it? Mention the season? Better - 'slam it shut'.

'she was standing on a hill' - she stood on a hill.
'A tui. I could tell it was female because of the size and plumage.' - A female tui. I could tell because etc?

'I was feeling' - I felt?

'She was smiling broadly, and her eyes were shining.' - She smiled broadly, and her eyes shone.
'This was unmistakably real. The surreal quality' - Remove 'This . . .real' sentence. Idea (and the word 'real') repeated in the following sentence. If you want to retain your adjective, try - The unmistakably surreal quality etc?

'rather than chaotic' - unchaotic?

'She wasn’t reacting out of emotions.' - If someone isn't doing something, or hasn't done it, don't say it. Only state what is happening. And a reader has already read her unemotional words and worked it out.

'was making' - had made?

'close to tears, but trying to control myself.' - I strained to hold back my tears?

The word was (a passive verb) can be often repeated. Try to eliminate them by using an 'ed' ending verb? Use 'ing' ending verbs.
The above examples can give you ideas to use in all your sentences.

Reply

May 01, 2024 01:32

Kaitlyn, wow, thank you so much for taking the time to read my story so thoroughly and give me such good advice! I really appreciate it. It's so valuable. I'm going to go through my whole story again and try to sharpen it up. Thanks so much!!

And yes, you're right about the lack of double glazing. So common here in NZ that I didn't even think of mentioning it... and if you're renting, it's not something you have the power of changing. There's no way to block out any sounds where we live. This bird is based on a true story, haha (minus the break-up).

Reply

May 10, 2024 20:17

And now I can say, congratulations!!! Despite the suggestions which I'm so happy you appreciated, It was so real to life. Captured the setting of your story and what your MC was going through. so well.

Reply

May 10, 2024 21:12

Thanks! :) And thanks again to you - you helped make the story much better than it was.

Reply

May 11, 2024 03:20

Thanks, we'll never know if a few tweaks did the trick for your story to be shortlisted and then end up in the few chosen. Well done you.

Reply

April 30, 2024 17:49

I love this story Melissa - it shows how tenacity can positively and negatively impact the human spirit, and I am glad your character had an awakening through self love. Well done!

Reply

April 30, 2024 20:43

Thank you very much, Natalie! I'm so glad you enjoyed it :)

Reply

Helen A Howard
April 29, 2024 12:07

Great story.
I loved the way the bird was in the background all the time echoing Tracy’s frustration, almost charting her progress as she began to gradually find the strength move on from the break up. I could picture the tui so well; it seemed impressively determined. I felt its loss when it was gone.
Really enjoyed reading.

Reply

April 29, 2024 21:29

Thank you so much! I'm glad you enjoyed it :)

Reply

Alexis Araneta
April 28, 2024 17:47

I'm glad your MC was able to deal with her emotions better. Great flow to this, lovely descriptions. Splendid work !

Reply

April 28, 2024 20:40

Thank you very much!

Reply

Angel Roberts
February 27, 2025 16:26

I'm new to this but I just want to how you think this up Chefs kiss

Reply

RBE | Illustrated Short Stories | 2024-06

Bring your short stories to life

Fuse character, story, and conflict with tools in Reedsy Studio. All for free.