The Wash

Crime Drama Suspense

Written in response to: "Write a story about a decision that can't be undone." as part of The Point of No Return.

I am extremely good in an emergency. This is not a boast, it is a job description, printed on a laminated card I keep in my scrub pocket, right under Universal Precautions and right above Signs of Compassion Fatigue. I have been doing this for nine years. I know how to look at a person bleeding out of somewhere and say, calmly, "You're going to be okay," while doing math in my head about whether that's true.

So when Danny came through the back door at 9:40 on a Wednesday, soaked through, though it wasn't raining, I did what I always do. I assessed.

"I hit somebody," he said. "I hit somebody with the car and I didn't stop."

"Okay," I said. "Okay. Take a seat."

He did not sit down. He stood in my kitchen dripping onto the tile I'd mopped that morning, a small ordinary betrayal, and I remember thinking, absurdly, that I'd have to mop it again, as if the floor were the emergency.

My husband was upstairs reading to our daughter, doing the voices, and some part of me was already composing the sentence I'd use to explain this to him later, one like a hallway with a door at each end and fire behind both.

"Where," I said. "Where did you hit them?"

"Cedar and Ash. I don't know. I don't know if they're okay. I didn't look, Ren. I kept driving, I kept driving, and I don't know why."

"Okay," I said again. I say okay a lot. It buys time without spending anything.

Here is a fact about Danny's probation that they don't put on a laminated card: it does not care about intent or that you are twenty-six and scared and that your sister raised you on cereal and half-shifts because your parents left the way some people leave, all at once, no forwarding address. Probation cares about outcomes, the way my hospital's Patient Satisfaction Survey cares about outcomes, which is to say entirely, and without much curiosity about how you arrived there.

If Danny was caught, he wouldn't get a fine. He'd get years. I knew this the way I know a resting heart rate shouldn't be forty, some things registering instantly and staying registered.

"Where's the car?" I said.

"In the garage. I put it in the garage."

"Danny."

"I panicked!" This came out too loud, and we both flinched, and upstairs the reading voices paused for one beat and then resumed, my husband narrating a rabbit's opinion on turnips, unaware that downstairs his wife was becoming a different kind of person.

I want to be clear that I considered, for perhaps four seconds, doing the correct thing. I want that on the record, even though there is no record, even though I am the only one keeping it.

I went and looked at the garage instead.

The headlight was gone on the passenger side, and there was a dent shaped like a shrug, and I stood there in my socks on the cold concrete doing an assessment I had no training for, turning damage into probability and probability into whether my brother would spend his thirtieth birthday somewhere with fluorescent lighting and no visiting hours on Wednesdays.

My phone buzzed. It was the neighborhood app, which exists to tell you about coyote sightings and stolen packages, delivering, this once, something worse: Police canvassing Cedar/Ash/Birch re: hit and run 8:50 PM. If you have security footage or information, please contact non-emergency line. Underneath, sixteen comments, already. Someone had used four exclamation points expressing concern for "our community." Someone else asked if it was safe to walk their dog. Nobody, yet, asked if the person who got hit was alive, which I noticed, and hated myself a little for noticing, as if noticing were a form of help.

"They're three streets over," I said. "They'll be here in twenty minutes. Maybe less."

Danny made a sound I'd only ever heard from patients right before the anesthesia took, a kind of surrender with no theater in it. "What do I do?"

I thought about the man, I was already sure it was a man, I don't know why, lying somewhere on Cedar or Ash, and whether an ambulance had gotten there in time, and whether some other nurse, some steadier version of me, was right now doing everything correctly.

"You were here all night," I said. "You got here at seven. We had dinner. You helped me put her to bed."

"Ren..."

"You were here all night," I said again, and this time it came out smooth, professional, the voice I use for families in the hallway, the one that says we are doing everything we can while meaning something closer to I don't know, I don't know, I don't know.

He nodded like a man being handed a diagnosis. I moved the car two streets over and parked it behind the Lindqvists' hedge, an act of hospitality so deranged it barely registered to me as a crime, and I walked home in the dark going over the story until it had no seams, the way you check a suture line, running your thumb along it, feeling for anything that might give.

The knock came at 10:15. I answered in my scrubs, which I had not changed out of, and which I understood, standing there, functioned like a costume of trustworthiness I hadn't even chosen on purpose.

"Evening, ma'am. Sorry to bother you." The officer was younger than me, with the overly gentle voice they must teach now, the one built to de-escalate, to signal I am not a threat, I am a helper, a voice not unlike my own. "There was an incident nearby tonight. We're asking if anyone saw anything unusual, or has a vehicle that might've sustained damage."

"Oh, no," I said. "We were in all night. Family dinner. My brother's visiting."

"And is he home now?"

"Upstairs," I said. "Should I get him?"

Please say no, I thought, with the specific fervor of a prayer from someone who does not pray. Please, for once, let the system be too tired to check.

"That's alright," he said, glancing past me at the shoes by the door, the smell of dinner still in the air, evidence of a life so unremarkable it read, apparently, as innocent. "Just standard follow-up. Y'all have a good night."

"You too," I said. "Stay safe out there!" I don't know where that came from. I have never in my life told a police officer to stay safe. It came out of me like a reflex, like the small bright lie a body tells itself in the seconds after impact, before the pain arrives to correct the record.

He left. I closed the door and stood in the hallway a long moment, listening to my own pulse the way I listen to a patient's, counting without meaning to, and it was fast, faster than it should've been for a woman standing still in her own home.

Danny came down the stairs slow, like a man checking ice. "Did it work?"

"Yeah," I said. "It worked."

He hugged me, and I let him, and over his shoulder I could see straight into the kitchen, where the sink still held the dinner dishes I hadn't gotten to, and beyond that the garage, empty now of the thing it had been hiding, as though emptiness were the same as clean.

Later, after he'd gone quiet on the couch and my husband had come down the stairs asking why the porch light was on, I stood at that sink and washed my hands, the way I do after every shift, three times, hot as I can stand it, a ritual so old I don't think about it anymore.

I don't know if the man on Cedar Street is alive tonight. I chose not to know, on purpose, the way you choose not to look at a wound you're fairly sure is worse than it needs to be.

The water ran over my hands for a long time. It has never once, in nine years, failed to make them feel clean.

It failed that night. I want that on the record too.

Posted Aug 09, 2026
Share:

You must sign up or log in to submit a comment.

25 likes 16 comments

Angell Brooks
August 20, 2026 19:03

Excellent story. You really captured the reality of a moral struggle. We'd all like to think that we'll do the right thing when it comes down to it. That last sentence is gold.

Well done.

Reply

Kate Winchester
August 18, 2026 22:33

I love how you weave the MC’s job into your story and how she reacts the way she would treat an emergency. It’s one of those things where you might react differently in a situation like that then what you think. The MC’s morality conflict just shows how human she is. I love all the little details too! Great job!

Reply

Jim LaFleur
August 19, 2026 06:47

Thank you, Kate!

Reply

Liza Mischel
August 17, 2026 18:44

This was so quietly devastating. I loved how her clinical approach to emergencies carried over into every choice she made for Danny—the alibi almost felt like another procedure she knew how to perform. And that final handwashing image was perfect—such a restrained, morally messy ending. (my favorite type of ending)

Reply

Jim LaFleur
August 18, 2026 05:27

Thank you, Liza.

Reply

Andrew Putnick
August 17, 2026 02:52

While I obviously am morally conflicted to say the least. It’s a side of the story that needs to be told. I think the brevity of the story helps. You don’t go into rationalizing in the protagonist’s mind too much. The rationalizations come later. They make the decision in the moment like it would happen and has happened in real life. It’s important to show that a lot of times it’s good people with good intentions making bad choices. You walk a really fine line here and it’s so well done. Great story.

Reply

Jim LaFleur
August 17, 2026 06:09

Thank you, Andrew!

Reply

Alla A
August 16, 2026 04:25

This is a great story, thank you for sharing!
The difficult choices we sometimes have to make ...
The little details make this story so alive. "Stay safe out there!" - Ren tried hard to sound normal. I felt her struggle and her pulse beating fast...

Reply

August 15, 2026 13:52

A brilliant character study tht reveals a whole persona in very few words through instinct and action. Very good Jim. The last paragraph and line hit hard.

Reply

Louise Chambers
August 12, 2026 22:50

‘He'd get years. I knew this the way I know a resting heart rate shouldn't be forty,’ ‘…going over the story until it had no seams, the way you check a suture line,’ I love the way that you used her work skills to emphasise her brothers predicament, it highlighted the tension. The whole family loyalty and love for her brother versus the moral dilemma of her job really came through. The ending was perfect! (As always!) Brilliant writing Jim!

Reply

The Old Izbushka
August 11, 2026 15:16

I loved the moral tension you created. She would have taken the Hippocratic oath to help save lives, yet she finds herself in a major moral dilemma. The ending is especially powerful—it shows that, no matter how hard we try, we can never simply wash away the guilt we carry. It now has become unwelcome “tenant” taking up residency in her life.

Reply

Marjolein Greebe
August 10, 2026 12:39

“I say okay a lot. It buys time without spending anything.” That line told me exactly who Ren was — and then you spent the rest of the story making her betray that person one small, horribly understandable step at a time. The scrubs becoming a “costume of trustworthiness” was particularly good. And those hands refusing to feel clean at the end? Yep. That landed.

Reply

August 10, 2026 10:43

I really liked how you captured the narrator's emotional conflict. The way you wove together the themes of morality and responsibility created a powerful contrast between the narrator’s professional duties and her personal choices. Her internal tension was palpable—her efforts to stay calm and methodical, in contrast with her fear, guilt, and uncertainty about what’s right. It made the character feel real and relatable. I also liked the small, specific details—like the rituals of washing hands. The ending was great and effective. I liked that it didn't offer easy answers or a clear moral resolution. Great work!

Reply

Jim LaFleur
August 10, 2026 10:54

Thank you so much, Veronika. Having a reader truly see her struggle between duty and conscience, right down to those quiet rituals, is the best compliment a writer could hope for.

Reply

August 10, 2026 11:05

You're welcome.

Reply

The Old Izbushka
August 11, 2026 15:18

I loved the moral tension you created. She would have taken the Hippocratic oath to help save lives, yet she finds herself in a major moral dilemma. The ending is especially powerful—it shows that, no matter how hard we try, we can never simply wash away the guilt we carry. It now has become unwelcome “tenant” taking up residency in her life.

Reply

RBE | Illustrated Short Stories | 2024-06

Bring your short stories to life

Fuse character, story, and conflict with tools in Reedsy Studio. All for free.