Can you keep a secret? (Part 1)

Mystery Fiction Suspense

Written in response to: "Write a story that either starts or ends with someone asking, “Can you keep a secret?”" as part of In On a Little Secret.

Beatrix is in the front seat of her mother's car, chewing gum and scrolling on Instagram posts.


She hesitates for a moment before sinking her phone into her pocket and leaning in, "Mum, why are we going to Grandma's house?"


Mrs Lemons sighs and glares at Beatrix in the side-view mirror. "I told you already Bee, I have a conference I can't cancel so you're staying over at Grandma's."


"But it's going to be boring!" she moans.


Mrs Lemons shrugs grimly. "You can play a board game with Grandma." she shrugs as she parks the car into Grandma's driveway.


Mrs Lemons presses the doorbell firmly. The doorknob twists and Grandma Lolla's face appears. "Martha, you're here!" she smiles brightly at Mrs Lemons. "Ah, Beatrix has come too hasn't she?" she smiles warmly at Beatrix who manages a small hurried smile back.


They enter the house, staring at the jumbled kitchen and the taped boxes lying on the floor. They had been there ever since Grandma moved in and stayed there ever since then. Chipped and cracked plaster make up the walls along with paint that looks like it was splashed and scrape marks.


Grandma Lolla beams excitedly. "I've got an old family recipe for making brownies," she says happily, clutching a cookbook and bestowing it in Beatrix's face, cheerfully.


Beatrix forces on a strained smile and settles on the couch, whipping up her phone again. "Maybe later, Grandma," she replies, grinning at a text message on her phone and replying to it at once, her agile fingers shifting up the keyboard on her phone.


"Maybe we can go check out photo albums? You know, the ones when you and Grandpa Larry married? I've never seen a photo of him before," Beatrix suggests again, looking up hopefully at the two grown-ups.


Mrs Lemons and Grandma Lolla exchange dark looks as she brings Mrs Lemons to the door. They whisper something and Grandma Lolla's smile is now forced and strained. "Well, how about I teach you how to knit?" she smiles extravagantly, picking up a pair of socks with enormously large holes in them.


Beatrix groans. "Uh, Grandma, why can't we see Grandpa Larry's photo albums? I've never got a picture of him before. And besides, I already know how to knit." she pushes eagerly.


Grandma Lolla swallows nervously. "Um,” 


The phone in her hand quivers and she looks relieved as she quickly hurries to answer it, glad to get away from Beatrix. Grandma Lolla wipes her wet, damp hands on her apron and hastily makes her way to the front porch, answering the call and pressing the phone to her ears.


Beatrix rolls her eyes. She is getting suspicious. Quickly, she glances at Grandma, now engaged comfortably in the front porch, clutching her phone.


Beatrix tip-toes up the stairs and pushes Grandma Lolla's room door.


The room smells of heavily scented perfume and old roses. The curtains are drawn and the dressing table is crowded with talcum powders and shiny brooches. The second half of the room is covered with medals and awards. Ones that Beatrix suspected were awarded to her mother.


The floor is dark walnut and the soft rocking chair planted at the side of the room is a delightful beige colour. The wallpaper is studded with maroon and violet polka dots and there is a scented aroma coming from the direction of the scented candles fixed in the bathroom. There are silky gold-coated pillows on her bed and a couple of high cupboards on the left.


Grandma Lolla usually deposits her special things up in a high cupboard. Beatrix grabs the dressing table stool and reaches for the shiny brown cupboard standing proudly in the middle. She wrenches open a drawer.


There are a few old letters stamped easily and some deftly decorated cards stocked at the bottom that Beatrix had given to Grandma for Christmas.


After a few minutes of digging around in the cupboard, Beatrix comes across an olden photograph, blanketed in shiny dust and coveted in a golden frame.


Grandpa Laurence.


He looks neat and was a thin, smooth, well-made man in his twenties. He is thick-lipped and his hair is drowned in some shiny gel. Grandpa Larry is grinning into the photograph, but there is something odd about his smile.


This must be taken before Grandpa Larry was married, Beatrix realizes thoughtfully.


But what she doesn't understand was why Grandma Lolla keeping his photograph a secret. There must be something, a reason why she acted hesitantly before changing the subject.


It was almost as if, as if, she is ashamed. Ashamed, of something Beatrix yearns to find out.


A faint burrow of footsteps pounds against the wall of Grandma Lolla's bedroom. Beatrix quickly tucks the photograph in her shirt and pulls it hastily over it, as it is tucking out of the pockets.


She slams the cupboards, returns the stool promptly and stands still, awkwardly. Grandma Lolla frowns and stares at Beatrix and at the cupboard.


She stutters, before tucking the phone into her pocket, looking miserable. "I know what you're looking for. And I want to give it to you as badly as you want it, Bee. It's just that...just that, I c-can't." she sobs.


Beatrix is startled. She hugs Grandma and ushers her awkwardly to a couch before bringing out the photograph of Grandpa Laurence.


Grandma Lolla gasps and stands promptly. She moves a pace back. "Get that man away from me," she demands


Beatrix, astonished, tucks the photograph away before Grandma Lolla hesitantly perches on the couch. "Something happened. Tell me, Grandma."


"I can't Beatrix, I can't. It's a family secret." she stammers.


"I'm part of the family aren't I?" Beatrix asks, surprised.


Grandma nods. "I know, but you don't understand. I meant to tell you when you were older." she weeps, burying her wrinkled face into her knobbly hands.


Beatrix sighs. "I'm fifteen, Grandma. You can tell me." she cries.


Grandma looks at the kitchen. "What about those brownies eh?"


Beatrix forces a smile. "You're changing the subject." she reminds her.


Grandma gives her a strained smile before closing the curtains and leaning over hesitantly.


"Can you keep a secret?"







Posted Aug 18, 2020
Share:

You must sign up or log in to submit a comment.

82 likes 100 comments

Princemark Okibe
October 21, 2020 08:27

Charles Strucker is kind of my role model on reedsy, so there is no way I am going to read this till the end without dropping suggestions.

I know that this contest has ended but I still wanted to drop suggestions for you.

Firstly, I can see that this story was well written and edited and your punctuations are on point. Good work. So most of my edits maybe on sentence structure.

So here goes.

In the sentence below, the dialogue tags does not convey your message well. Though I think you did it to sound a little poetic.
[Grandma Lolla beams excitedly. "I've got an old family recipe for making brownies," she says happily, clutching a cookbook and bestowing it in Beatrix's face, cheerfully.]
You can rewrite it to convey your idea better by simplifying it.
[Grandma Lolla beams excitedly. "I've got an old family recipe for making brownies," she says happily, flashing a cookbook at Beatrix.]

[The floor is dark walnut and the soft rocking chair planted at the side of the room is a delightful beige colour.]
This statement can be rewritten to make it convey better.
[The floor is of dark walnut and the soft rocking chair planted at the side of the room is a delightful beige colour.]
I added 'of' before 'dark walnut' because you did not indicate that dark walnut is a colour and that may cause confusion to readers mind. If you don't want the 'of' you can rewrite it and add colour after dark walnut.
[The floor is a dark walnut colour and the soft rocking chair planted at the side of the room is a delightful beige colour.]

[Grandma Lolla usually deposits her special things up in a high cupboard.]
While 'deposits' is more flowery, 'keeps' convey better and flows better.
That is
[Grandma Lolla usually keeps her special things up in a high cupboard.]

I don't usually edit dialogue as characters are human and can speak whatever way they want but in the sentence below, an important comma is missing making what she is saying super weird.
["I'm part of the family aren't I?"]
If you place the comma, you have
["I'm part of the family, aren't I?"]

Keep writing and best of luck.

Reply

Niveeidha Palani
October 22, 2020 12:13

Hi Princemark, first of all, I really appreciate you taking the time to comment really helpful and constructive feedback here. However, my story's already been approved and as much as I want to alter and correct my mistakes, I can't. :(

Thank you so much for helping out, though, and I'll really try to apply all these feedback in the next story I do!

Reply

October 15, 2020 04:02

Love the story. Great job! :)

Reply

Niveeidha Palani
October 15, 2020 05:01

Thank you!

Reply

Authoring Studio
September 24, 2020 15:32

Dear Niveeidha
Thank you for speaking up against downvoting. We have all suffered. Thanks a ton. :)

Reply

Niveeidha Palani
September 25, 2020 09:35

Hi Pranati, I appreciate how concerned you are with the downvoting. We all are and most of us have suffered quite a lot. I really hope this downvoter will be caught, as it's unfair to most of us who have been earning our points by hard work.

Reply

Ariadne .
September 21, 2020 22:09

This story needs a follow-up! There are some grammatical errors and some phrases could be substituted to make the words flow smoother, but it's a great story regardless!
Keep it up! You are a talented author!
Mind checking out my stories? Thanks!

Reply

Niveeidha Palani
September 21, 2020 22:23

Hi Adrienne, thank you so much for leaving detailed feedback on my story! Of course! I'd love to check out yours! Going there now!

Reply

Niveeidha Palani
October 08, 2020 06:39

Hi Adrienne, just to let you know, that a Part two of this came out, and I was wondering if you'd like to read it and give me feedback!

Reply

Amany Sayed
September 11, 2020 22:51

I don't know WHERE you found my quiz lol, but I make the collages using an app called Montage. There's no templates or anything though, I arrange the photos myself. yep, that's it, bye

Reply

Niveeidha Palani
September 11, 2020 22:55

Hhahahahah, I actually found in your bio. Thank youuu!!!! wow you certainly have a talent for arranging collages....they're coool!!! I also saw the one in Wattpad (I have a wattpad account, cause I needed to read your stories 😂)

Reply

Amany Sayed
September 11, 2020 22:56

Oh yeahhhh, forgot I put it there lol. No prob! Awww, thanks! Lol, glad you like em!

Reply

Doubra Akika
August 18, 2020 16:01

I really need a part two of this!
I'm so glad I read this.
I had a few grammar suggestions but Amany already pointed them out.
Overall though, this was beautifully written!
Loved it so much!

Reply

Niveeidha Palani
August 18, 2020 21:55

Hi Doubra, thank you so much or commenting, it means a lot to me. Stay safe!

And of course, don't worry, I will be planning to do a sequel on this, so I'll tell you when it comes out! :)

Reply

Doubra Akika
August 18, 2020 23:26

Kk I’d love to know when it comes out.
And it was my pleasure!
Whenever you’re free would you mind checking out my story?

Reply

Niveeidha Palani
August 19, 2020 09:55

Of course! Going there now! ;)

Reply

Niveeidha Palani
October 08, 2020 06:40

Hi Doubra, you asked me to inform you to tell you when a sequel would come out. I just posted a new sequel a few days, ago, and was wondering if you'd like to read it. :)

Reply

Doubra Akika
October 08, 2020 19:42

yeah sure! I'll make sure I get around to reading it.

Reply

Niveeidha Palani
October 09, 2020 00:46

:)

Reply

August 18, 2020 12:12

Noooooooo! I need a part two right now! 😉
But for real, though.
Just kidding! Anyways, the way you interpreted the prompt was amazing, and your description was beyond my personal abilities. I was really able to see everything; you did a great job with show-not-tell. Oustanding job, Niveeidha!
Keep writing and stay safe,
Your Reedsy Friend-Brooke

Reply

Niveeidha Palani
August 18, 2020 12:53

Thank you so much, Brooke! It really means a lot to me, commenting on my story! Stay safe too! And, of course, for the "part two" thing, don't worry! I'll do a sequel on it for sure! ;)

Your Reedsy Friend-Niveeidha 😉🤗

Reply

August 18, 2020 12:56

You're welcome!
Yay! Please let me know when you submit it!

Reply

Niveeidha Palani
August 18, 2020 21:54

Of course!

Reply

Niveeidha Palani
October 08, 2020 06:40

Hi Brooke, just wanted to let you know that my sequel came out. Was wondering if you'd like to read it! :)

Reply

Philip Clayberg
December 24, 2020 04:29

Thank you for writing this letter.

I confess I read this story and "Dead Letter Department" in reverse order (the 2nd story first, and the 1st story second). Sorry about that. At least I now understand the secret part in the 2nd story better. I'm glad I read both stories.

It's never easy hiding a secret, because it can be revealed by someone else (and usually when you really wish they hadn't revealed it). Kind of like keeping feelings suppressed until they finally boil up and explode anyway.

Reply

Niveeidha Palani
December 24, 2020 07:17

Ah, no worries at all, we all make mistakes. Yes, very true, it never easy to hide a secret.

Reply

Kristin Neubauer
October 09, 2020 15:38

This is great, Niveeidha! What a mystery. I absolutely love your description of Grandma Lolla's house....I could see it in an instant. Fantastic writing, great suspense. I'm heading over to the sequel now!

Reply

Niveeidha Palani
October 10, 2020 00:44

Thank you so much Kristin. Your comment is much appreciated!

Reply

Andrew Krey
September 13, 2020 10:41

Hi Niveeidha, I liked your story. It builds up he tension well, then ends on a cliff hanger! I look forward to seeing the sequel and finding out what the secret can be about this lovely Grandpa!

One of the things I did think when reading it was the phone in Grandma's hand that she answers to avoid answering the question. Was that a mobile already in her hand? I felt it was a mobile, and thought this seemed out of character for someone her age to actually carry her phone. She also walks away so Beatrix can investigate. It was a minor point, but I just thought the house phone ringing and the grandma walking away to answer it serves both purposes just as well, but is more plausible for her generation.

I hope my feedback was useful.

Happy writing.

Reply

Niveeidha Palani
September 14, 2020 06:47

Thank you, Andrew, for taking the time to comment on this story! Oops, I must have made a minor error. Thanks for spotting it! Yes, I see it now that it would have been more realistic that way.

Thanks for leaving feedback and happy writing too!

Reply

Andrew Krey
September 14, 2020 14:17

You're welcome Niveeidha, I'm glad it was helpful! I wouldn't say it was an error, just a minor tweak that adds to the plausibility of the story. The story is good so the only thing I can suggest is fine tuning :)

Reply

Niveeidha Palani
September 14, 2020 21:54

:)

Reply

Amogh Kasat
September 08, 2020 16:02

The last line is the best!
Some grammatical issues.
that's alll

Reply

Niveeidha Palani
September 08, 2020 22:23

Thank you Amogh, do you mind telling me what grammatical errors so I can change them?

Reply

Amogh Kasat
September 07, 2020 07:55

It's a wonderful story! Please read my latest story

Reply

Niveeidha Palani
September 08, 2020 07:24

Hi Amogh, of course, I will, but it seemed like you didn't really read my story. If you please, I don't mean to be rude or offensive but I will prefer constructive feedback!

Thanks! 😊

Reply

Amogh Kasat
September 08, 2020 11:24

I will give but I am busy now afterwards

Reply

Niveeidha Palani
September 12, 2020 01:33

Uh, okay!

Reply

August 30, 2020 05:05

I love the story Niveeidha ! I love the way you brought in the suspense, The ending was not something I expected...
Waiting for your next !

Reply

Niveeidha Palani
August 30, 2020 10:38

Thank you so much! I will be doing a sequel on this, and I'll let you know when it comes out ;)

Reply

D. Shikha
August 25, 2020 17:20

Nice story, Niveeidha:) Would you mind checking out my first story?

Reply

Niveeidha Palani
August 25, 2020 21:54

Hi Deepshikha, thank you so much! Of course! I would love to! Going there now!

Reply

Mary Rothery
August 24, 2020 12:45

Great ending! I'm dying to know what happened!

Reply

Niveeidha Palani
August 24, 2020 21:53

Thank you so much Mary! :)

Reply

Niveeidha Palani
October 13, 2020 06:52

Hi Mary, just wanted to let you know that my sequel to this story is out! Thought you'd be interested in it!

Reply

Roshna Rusiniya
August 23, 2020 05:47

Welcome back Niveeidha! Hope your exams went well.
This was very well-written! That last line was quite a cliffhanger. A sequel on the works? :D

Reply

Niveeidha Palani
August 23, 2020 07:07

Hi Roshna, thank you so much for inquiring. Yes, they went well :).

Thank you so much! And of course, I'm working on a sequel, but the prompts this week don't seem to fit, so I'm struggling a little. 😅

Reply

Roshna Rusiniya
August 23, 2020 07:20

Ha ha. Good to know the exams went well.

I will keep an eye on that sequel ;)

Meanwhile have a look at my latest one too. :)

Reply

Niveeidha Palani
August 23, 2020 07:25

Of course! I would love to check it out!

Reply

Niveeidha Palani
October 08, 2020 06:42

Hi Roshna, I wondered if you're back on Reedsy now. We're all missing you so much. :(

Just wanted to let you know (if you have time, don't trouble yourself if you're busy!) that the sequel for this came out! I was wondering if you'd like to check it out. :)

Reply

Krishi Norris
August 20, 2020 20:34

I need Part 2! I repeat: I NEED PART 2222! lol.

PS - Do you mind checking out a few of my stories? Thanks!

Reply

Niveeidha Palani
August 20, 2020 21:53

Thanks! Don't worry, I'll be doing a sequel on this. Of course, I'd love to! Going there now!

Reply

Niveeidha Palani
October 13, 2020 06:53

Hi Zenisha, just wanted to let you know that Part 2 came out!

Reply

Rambling Beth
August 20, 2020 18:58

Loved this! Would definitely love to read a sequel. :)

Reply

Niveeidha Palani
August 20, 2020 22:14

Thank you Beth! (If I can call you Beth?) I'm planning to a sequel on this so no worries!

Reply

Rambling Beth
August 20, 2020 22:16

Beth is fine, and I'm excited to hear that. :)

Reply

Niveeidha Palani
August 20, 2020 22:18

Hi Beth! Just wanted to let you know if you'd be interested in my latest story, which is a sequel to this! ;)

Reply

Avery G.
August 19, 2020 02:12

Wow! Great story! I loved it! Amazing job!

Reply

Niveeidha Palani
August 19, 2020 09:55

Thank you so much!

Reply

Avery G.
August 19, 2020 15:22

You're welcome!

Reply

Niveeidha Palani
August 19, 2020 21:56

:)

Reply

Amany Sayed
August 18, 2020 13:59

Nice one! I enjoyed this story! PART 22222 NOWWW
Anyway, though it was well written, I have a couple suggestions:
" Ones that Beatrix suspected was awarded to her mother." Here you should probably change was to were.
And you also say " photograph in her photograph" which doesn't make sense.
The whole story felt sort of stiff, I don't know how to explain it. It might be because you used present tense, I don't know.
Overall, well written! Keep writing!
~Amany~

Reply

Niveeidha Palani
August 18, 2020 21:52

Hi Amany, thank you so much for giving me honest feedback! I'll go edit it now! :)

And of course, I'll be planning to do a sequel on this, so don't worry, I'll tell you when it comes out! :)

Reply

Niveeidha Palani
August 18, 2020 21:54

Okay! I've edited it and corrected the mistakes! :)

Reply

Amany Sayed
August 18, 2020 22:02

No problem! Good job! :D

Reply

Niveeidha Palani
August 18, 2020 22:07

Thanks! :)

Reply

Niveeidha Palani
October 13, 2020 06:54

Hey Amany, just wanted to let you know that I recently posted a sequel for this story! Thought you'd wanna check it out!

Reply

Nirosha P
August 18, 2020 07:34

I love this story! It kept me hooked until the end. I really hope you're going to make a sequel for this! ;)

Reply

Niveeidha Palani
August 18, 2020 07:38

Hi Nirosha, thank you so much! And I feel so relieved, I finally managed to submit a story! 😅

I was planning to do a sequel on it, but I'm still not so sure, 🤔😥

Reply

Batool Hussain
August 18, 2020 10:31

Oh C'mon! You can't really leave us readers hanging. We want a sequel. This is so good. Btw, I just posted a story too:)

Reply

Niveeidha Palani
August 18, 2020 10:45

Well, I'll post a sequel then and I'll go check it out now!

Reply

Niveeidha Palani
October 13, 2020 06:59

Hi Batool, just wanted to let you know that the sequel to this story is finally out! Thought you'd like to check it out!

Reply

Unknown User
October 05, 2020 08:21

<removed by user>

Reply

Niveeidha Palani
October 05, 2020 10:34

Hi Waverley, thank you so much! It's very much appreciated! :)

Reply

Mohsen Baqery
August 26, 2020 18:20

And that's how you end it. Well done Niveeidha. (Hope to read more from you)

Reply

Niveeidha Palani
September 12, 2020 01:35

Oops, sorry Mohsen, I was just going through the comments on my story and realized I hadn't replied to this comment. Funnily enough, I don't remember this comment appearing in my notifications, so I must have missed it.

Thank you so much though!

Reply

The Cold Ice
August 26, 2020 03:42

Good story.I loved the story.Great job👍keep it up.
Would you mind to read my story
“The dragon warrior?”

Reply

Niveeidha Palani
August 26, 2020 07:58

Thank you Sahitthian. Of course! I would love to read your story. :)

Reply

Amogh Kasat
August 24, 2020 12:25

It's a wonderful story! Please read my latest story The Secret Organisation { Part 2 }

Reply

Niveeidha Palani
August 24, 2020 21:53

Thanks! Of course! I'll be glad to read your story. :)

Reply

Amogh Kasat
August 25, 2020 05:03

I would be waiting for your comment and like

Reply

Niveeidha Palani
August 25, 2020 06:20

Hi Amogh, I already commented on your story :)

Reply

Amogh Kasat
August 25, 2020 06:38

Ok

Reply

Reedsy | Default — Editors with Marker | 2024-05

Bring your publishing dreams to life

The world's best editors, designers, and marketers are on Reedsy. Come meet them.