Charlie Parker was the kind of girl who woke up excited every morning, even on Mondays. She had a wild imagination, a laugh that bounced off walls, and a habit of running everywhere instead of walking. Her parents said she had “the energy of a small tornado,” and her teachers said she had “the wiggles.” Charlie didn’t mind either description. She liked being a tornado. Tornadoes were powerful.
But tornadoes didn’t always do well in school.
Charlie had two sisters — one older, one younger — and both of them seemed to glide through school like swans. They remembered everything they saw, everything they heard, everything they read. They didn’t study much, but they always brought home A’s and B’s. Their teachers adored them. Their parents bragged about them. Their report cards were taped proudly to the refrigerator.
Charlie’s report cards were… not.
She worked harder than both sisters combined. She studied until her eyes felt fuzzy. She stayed up late reviewing spelling words, math problems, science facts, and vocabulary lists. She made flashcards. She made color-coded charts. She even made up songs to help her remember things.
But when test day came, her brain felt like a shaken snow globe — everything swirling, nothing landing.
Her teacher, Mrs. Seaman, was a tall woman with a voice that sounded like she was always tired. She wore long skirts and sensible shoes and had a way of sighing that made Charlie’s stomach twist. Whenever Charlie handed in a test, Mrs. Seaman gave her a look that said, I hope you tried this time.
Charlie always tried.
She tried so hard.
But the next day, when Mrs. Seaman called her name and handed her the test upside down, Charlie already knew. She flipped it over anyway, hoping for a miracle.
D‑.
Again.
Her heart sank. Her cheeks burned. Her stomach felt heavy, like she had swallowed a rock. She tried to blink away the tears, but they came anyway.
Mrs. Seaman sighed. “Charlie, why can’t you be more like your sister?”
The words hit her harder than the grade. Harder than the disappointment. Harder than the hours she had poured into studying. Something inside her cracked — something small and tired and fed up.
Charlie gripped her pencil so tightly her knuckles turned white. She slammed it onto her test and dragged it downward. The paper tore. A dark graphite streak scarred her desk. She shredded the test into tiny pieces and let them fall like confetti of failure around her feet.
The classroom went silent.
Mrs. Seaman’s mouth tightened. “Charlie Parker, that is enough.”
Charlie didn’t argue. She didn’t speak. She didn’t even look up. She just sat there, breathing hard, wishing she could disappear.
That night, Charlie lay in bed staring through her window at the night sky. She loved the stars. She loved how peaceful they looked, how steady, how bright. She dreamed of working for NASA someday — of floating among the stars instead of drowning under expectations.
Her room was quiet. Her sisters were asleep. Her parents were watching TV downstairs. The only sound was the soft hum of the night.
Charlie whispered into the dark, “I wish I could be as smart as everyone else.”
Her voice trembled.
“I wish my hard work actually paid off.”
She paused. Something about the wish felt unfinished — too plain for the size of her hope. She sat up, thinking. Wishes needed sparkle. Wishes needed flair. Wishes needed… pizzazz.
Then it hit her.
“And I wish that every time I earned an A or B, my underwear would show it in real gold. Real gold letters. So everyone would know I did it.”
She grinned at the absurdity of it. It was silly. It was ridiculous. It was perfect.
Charlie lay back down, feeling lighter than she had in weeks. She fell asleep quickly, dreaming of stars and golden letters and a world where she wasn’t the “dumb one.”
Charlie Parker was the kind of girl who woke up excited every morning, even on Mondays. She had a wild imagination, a laugh that bounced off walls, and a habit of running everywhere instead of walking. Her parents said she had “the energy of a small tornado,” and her teachers said she had “the wiggles.” Charlie didn’t mind either description. She liked being a tornado. Tornadoes were powerful.
But tornadoes didn’t always do well in school.
Charlie had two sisters — one older, one younger — and both of them seemed to glide through school like swans. They remembered everything they saw, everything they heard, everything they read. They didn’t study much, but they always brought home A’s and B’s. Their teachers adored them. Their parents bragged about them. Their report cards were taped proudly to the refrigerator.
Charlie’s report cards were… not.
She worked harder than both sisters combined. She studied until her eyes felt fuzzy. She stayed up late reviewing spelling words, math problems, science facts, and vocabulary lists. She made flashcards. She made color-coded charts. She even made up songs to help her remember things.
But when test day came, her brain felt like a shaken snow globe — everything swirling, nothing landing.
Her teacher, Mrs. Seaman, was a tall woman with a voice that sounded like she was always tired. She wore long skirts and sensible shoes and had a way of sighing that made Charlie’s stomach twist. Whenever Charlie handed in a test, Mrs. Seaman gave her a look that said, I hope you tried this time.
Charlie always tried.
She tried so hard.
But the next day, when Mrs. Seaman called her name and handed her the test upside down, Charlie already knew. She flipped it over anyway, hoping for a miracle.
D‑.
Again.
Her heart sank. Her cheeks burned. Her stomach felt heavy, like she had swallowed a rock. She tried to blink away the tears, but they came anyway.
Mrs. Seaman sighed. “Charlie, why can’t you be more like your sister?”
The words hit her harder than the grade. Harder than the disappointment. Harder than the hours she had poured into studying. Something inside her cracked — something small and tired and fed up.
Charlie gripped her pencil so tightly her knuckles turned white. She slammed it onto her test and dragged it downward. The paper tore. A dark graphite streak scarred her desk. She shredded the test into tiny pieces and let them fall like confetti of failure around her feet.
The classroom went silent.
Mrs. Seaman’s mouth tightened. “Charlie Parker, that is enough.”
Charlie didn’t argue. She didn’t speak. She didn’t even look up. She just sat there, breathing hard, wishing she could disappear.
That night, Charlie lay in bed staring through her window at the night sky. She loved the stars. She loved how peaceful they looked, how steady, how bright. She dreamed of working for NASA someday — of floating among the stars instead of drowning under expectations.
Her room was quiet. Her sisters were asleep. Her parents were watching TV downstairs. The only sound was the soft hum of the night.
Charlie whispered into the dark, “I wish I could be as smart as everyone else.”
Her voice trembled.
“I wish my hard work actually paid off.”
She paused. Something about the wish felt unfinished — too plain for the size of her hope. She sat up, thinking. Wishes needed sparkle. Wishes needed flair. Wishes needed… pizzazz.
Then it hit her.
“And I wish that every time I earned an A or B, my underwear would show it in real gold. Real gold letters. So everyone would know I did it.”
She grinned at the absurdity of it. It was silly. It was ridiculous. It was perfect.
Charlie lay back down, feeling lighter than she had in weeks. She fell asleep quickly, dreaming of stars and golden letters and a world where she wasn’t the “dumb one.”
Over the next few weeks, Charlie’s life changed.
She still studied hard — she didn’t want the magic to be the only reason she succeeded. But studying felt easier now. Words stayed still. Numbers made sense. Facts stuck in her brain like glue.
Her grades climbed.
Her confidence soared.
And every time she earned an A or B, she discovered a new golden letter on her underwear. Sometimes it was a tiny B near the waistband. Sometimes it was a giant A across the hip. Sometimes it was a cluster of little gold stars.
She loved them all.
Her sisters noticed her new confidence.
“Why are you so happy all the time?” Lily asked one morning.
Charlie shrugged. “Maybe I’m magical.”
June rolled her eyes. “You’re still weird.”
Charlie didn’t mind. She was weird. And magical. And smart. And sparkly.
Mrs. Seaman noticed too. She stopped sighing when Charlie handed in tests. She started smiling more. She even wrote “Great job!” on one of Charlie’s papers — something she had never done before.
Charlie felt proud. Proud of her hard work. Proud of her wish. Proud of her golden underwear.
But she didn’t tell anyone about the magic.
Some things were too special to share.
Charlie’s golden underwear collection grew faster than dandelions in spring.
Every test she studied for — spelling, math, science, even the dreaded vocabulary quizzes — came back with A’s or B’s. And every time she earned one, a new golden letter appeared on her underwear like a tiny trophy.
Some days she discovered a single shimmering B near the waistband. Other days she found a giant A stretching across her hip like a superhero emblem. Once, she even found a cluster of tiny gold stars sprinkled across the fabric like confetti.
She loved them all.
She loved the magic. She loved the sparkle. She loved the feeling of finally being good enough.
But she didn’t tell anyone. Not her sisters. Not her parents. Definitely not Mrs. Seaman.
Some magic was too special to share.
You must sign up or log in to submit a comment.
Quick flag before I get going. I think there's a copy and paste issue in your submission? The section starting at "Charlie Parker was the kind of girl who woke up excited" all the way through "world where she wasn't the 'dumb one'" repeats itself. It's pretty much word for word as far as I can tell. Initially I thought it was going to be a Groundhog Day type thing where the day would have some significant decision or choice that changed and then would affect the following day. But it's just the same day, same D, same ripped up paper, same wish for golden underwear. If that's just a slip up that's fine, it's a quick fix. If it is intentional I'd flag it as a missed opportunity and worse, a bad swing and a miss as a narrative choice.
Ok now to the rest.
This was such a sweet and yet painfully recognizable story. Reminds me of working really hard and still not measuring up in my Reedsy Prompts submissions 😅
I love Charlie's personality and your writing style carries such a great flow. It was easy to read in a way a lot of other entries fail to achieve. I'm not a great writer and my knowledge of grammar and spelling is pretty minimal, so I lack the proper words to describe a lot of this. But I enjoyed your pacing, word choices, and sentence structure. It moved with rhythm and had a cadence that I could feel, almost like a breathless energy that was still very clear and concise. The magic wish was funny too, but I certainly wouldn't want gold stars next to my skid marks 😂
Normally I'd stop there, but you are one of my critique circle partners this week. Bear in mind I am not a professional, I've never been published, never won a contest, never even been short listed so do take everything I say below with a grain of salt while I pretend to be an editor 😅
1. There are a lot of dashes throughout. This isn't an AI em dash concern for me, I just don't know when or how to use them so they confuse me more than anything. I only use them for broken or interrupted dialogue. So my preference would be fewer of them. That being said, I wouldn't suggest dumbing your work down to my level.
2. "Her heart sank. Her cheeks burned. Her stomach felt heavy, like she had swallowed a rock." And very shortly later, "She didn't argue. She didn't speak. She didn't even look up." Personally I don't mind that, I probably use the triple beat quite a bit in my own stuff. One is just normal, two feels like maybe you couldn't decide between one or the other, and four is just a list. But three, oh that magic three. That tells me it's important, you meant it, and you didn't oversell it. But, I have been criticized for it. Something to keep in mind.
3. Gold lettered underwear... 🤣 Why? How? I just can't even fathom coming up with that idea. Would have been fun to get Charlie's personal reaction to it actually happening since her voice is so much fun. And now I want to know, if it's real gold, can she pawn her underwear for cash. Now that can take a weird turn and get dark quickly...
Overall this is a sweet, relatable story with a bonkers magic twist. But seriously, if I got handed that in a chain story prompt, she'd be older and swept up into a dark journey through seedy gold brokers, and creepy old men who like to buy used underwear out of Japanese vending machines or bathwater from OnlyFans models 😈
Reply
Thank you for your input and critique. Is it to late to go fix the repeated line? I am unsure how to go about it.
Jennie
Reply
Honestly I'm not sure. I think it's too late to fix it for the actual contest as it's already being judged? But I think you can still edit iit so the version people will see if they open your storywill be the newer version. But I've not tested that. There should be an edit button under your story in your profile page.
Reply