Kelsey Mitchener

Kelsey Mitchener – Editor

Editing's my bread and butter—and also my jam. Narrative nonfiction and memoir copy editor. 21 years, 145+ published books, 30+ bestsellers.

Overview

I’m Kelsey, a nonfiction copy editor with over twenty years of in-house and freelance experience. I've edited over 145 published books, including 32 bestsellers (and counting).

I’ve edited for HarperCollins, Penguin Random House, Macmillan, and Simon and Schuster (four of the Big Five publishers), as well as Dotdash Meredith, America’s largest digital and print publisher, and I’ve helped thousands of writers around the world to get their messages out there.

I’ve edited books by many first-time and indie authors, as well as popular figures like:

• Chip and Joanna Gaines

• Meghan Trainor

• Willie Nelson

• Reba McEntire

• Mark Harmon

• Kathie Lee Gifford

• Senator Tim Kaine

• Kristin Chenoweth

• Dave Ramsey

• Michael Crichton

• Wilmer Valderrama

• Zachary Levi

• Andre Ward

• Rachel Held Evans

I especially love editing memoirs, autobiographies, biographies, and other personal narratives. If you have a memoir, I'm your copy editor! Other themes/categories/genres I also really enjoy editing include:

• inspirational

• health and well-being, including mental health

• self-help and self-improvement

• personal growth

• religious harm, spiritual trauma, deconstruction, and exvangelical

• strong female leads

• creative nonfiction

My signature service is an above-and-beyond copy edit I call The Fine-Toothed Comb. You’ve poured yourself into your book, and I honor that by pouring my expertise into it, too. I never do things by halves, and you and your book get to benefit. Not to ruin the surprise, but the writers I work with are usually astounded by just how thorough this edit is.

As a firstborn, eldest daughter, Virgo, INTJ, and recovering perfectionist, I’m more or less hardwired for editing as a detail-obsessed, analytical type A. I start most days seeking validation from Wordle (and most days, I’m “impressive”). I organize my sock drawer by season, height, and color, and I have strong opinions about the Oxford comma.

I know, I know—I sound like I’d be fun at parties! 😅 But let’s be honest: My deep experience and hardwiring as an editor are wins for you because I can come alongside you and your book as an expert friend. I’ll make your book better and make you look better along the way. Let's get your story out there!

Services
Non-Fiction
Biographies & Memoirs Health & Wellbeing Inspirational Self-Help & Self-Improvement
Languages
English (US)
Certifications
  • Member of ACES: The Society for Editing
  • BA in English Literature, Taylor University
  • Minor in English Writing, Taylor University
  • Poynter ACES Advanced Certificate in Editing

Work experience

Self-employed

Sep, 2013 — Present
I copy edit and proofread for publishers and writers, focusing mainly on nonfiction titles. I've edited over 145 published books, including dozens of bestsellers.

Community.co

Feb, 2019 — Present
I edit thought leadership articles that are published online by Forbes, Fast Company, Rolling Stone, Inc., Newsweek, Kiplinger, and more.

ApricotLaw

Aug, 2018 — Jun, 2022 (almost 4 years)
I edited and search engine optimized online content for over 90 law firms across North America on behalf of digital marketing agency.

MedStudy

Aug, 2016 — Aug, 2018 (about 2 years)
I edited medical textbook series that are widely used in the field, and I also edited in-house marketing materials.

Portfolio

Made with Reedsy
The Unself-Help Book: How to Get Out of Your Our Way and Start Being Happy

Vreeland, Carl T.

Lauer Books LLC

Copy Editing
Copy Editing
Made with Reedsy
Plus More Life A #HeartStrong Story: A Survivor’s Journey of Heart, Humor, Healing, and Health

Prewitt, Sam "SP"

Cool and Creative Concepts LLC

Copy Editing
The In-Between

Hadley Vlahos, R.N.

NEW YORK TIMES BESTSELLER • Passionate advocate for end-of-life care and TikTok star Hadley Vlahos shares moving stories of joy, wisdom, and redemption from her patients’ final moments in this... read more
Proofreading
Copy Editing
Copy Editing
A New York Times bestseller! In a world that feels increasingly disconnected, it’s time to reclaim a life of rich, authentic connection—because we are all made better when we trust one another... read more
Copy Editing
Walk Ride Paddle

Thomas Nelson

A compelling account of one man’s journey across hundreds of miles of Virginia wilderness and a moving testament to the optimistic spirit of America, Walk Ride Paddle provides an unseen glimps... read more
Copy Editing
Proofreading
Copy Editing
Proofreading
Copy Editing
Copy Editing
An American Story: Everyone’s Invited

Valderrama, Wilmer

Harper Select

Copy Editing
Proofreading
Copy Editing
Copy Editing
Copy Editing
Crescendo

Allen Cheney

A hidden story of human triumph, Crescendo takes you on the rare journey of a musical prodigy who changed an entire community forever.More than eighty years ago, a musical prodigy with a brill... read more
Proofreading
Saving Aziz

Chad Robichaux

Now a Wall Street Journal BestsellerIt was the right thing to do. And someone had to do it.Aziz was more than an interpreter for Force Recon Marine Chad Robichaux during Chad's eight deploymen... read more
Proofreading
Lemons on Friday

Mattie Jackson Selecman

When your life is suddenly full of questions, how do you move forward in faith?After being married for less than a year, country music legend Alan Jackson's daughter Mattie was faced with navi... read more
Proofreading
Look for Me There

Luke Russert

INSTANT NEW YORK TIMES BESTSELLERIn Look for Me There, Luke Russert traverses terrain both physical and deeply personal. On his journey to some of the world’s most stunning destinations, he vi... read more
Proofreading
A Real Good Life

Stevie Hendrix

Where are you looking for joy, contentment, and purpose? Stevie and Sazan Hendrix show us that the good life we're looking for won't be found in our latest purchase, achievement, or dream vaca... read more
Proofreading
Copy Editing
Radical Love

Zachary Levi

Radical Love is the debut memoir from actor Zachary Levi (Shazam!,?American Underdog,?The Marvelous Mrs. Maisel,?Chuck), which shares his emotional journey through a lifetime of crippling anxi... read more
Copy Editing
My Own Magic

Anna Kloots

For every woman searching for her voice, Anna Kloots shares her story of starting over by trusting the magic that was always within...Despite what appeared to be a glamorous existence full of ... read more
Copy Editing
Copy Editing
Copy Editing
Proofreading

Kelsey has 17 reviews

Professionalism

Quality

Value

Responsiveness

Sam SP P.

Sam SP P.

Jan, 2026

Pinned
Working with Kelsey was a game-changer for my memoir, Plus More Life. As a first-time author dealing with a deeply personal story, I was initially intimidated by the editing process. Kelsey erased that fear immediately. She made everything feel easy, approachable, and collaborative, never judgmen...
Read more
Paige D.

Paige D.

Jul, 2025

Pinned
I highly recommend Kelsy. Her editing style, skills and thoroughness are amazing. Kelsey provided a plan and details about her editing process, and it was exactly what a first-time author like me needed. I had a sense of relief when I gave her the manuscript. Kelsy delivered by her deadline. ...
Read more
Paula H.

Paula H.

Jul, 2025

Pinned
Working with Kelsey on my manuscript was an absolute gift. She brought whip-smart insight, unwavering attention to detail, and a genuine sense of care to every stage of the copy and proof editing process. From the very beginning, she was deeply engaged, offering thoughtful guidance with both prec...
Read more
Lora L B.

Lora L B.

Mar, 2026

as a result I will not meet my lauch date You can add that to the review like this: *** My first experience using Reedsy, unfortunately, was not a positive one. I hired Kelsey for line editing and proofreading, with an agreed timeline to complete the work by the end of February for a March lau...
Read more
Corey S.

Corey S.

Jan, 2026

I always love working with Kelsey! She is super thoughtful and thorough in her edits!!

Sign up to read more reviews

Create a free Reedsy account to connect with Kelsey and thousands of other publishing professionals on Reedsy.

Professionals similar to Kelsey

Get a range of offers by requesting quotes from multiple professionals.

Jenny Malnick

Jenny M.

Diligent, thoughtful, friendly editor with almost 30 years of experience. Reading people's stories and making them better is my life's work.

Redwood City, CA, USA

100% reply rate

View profile
Richard Arcus

Richard A.

A 10-year track record at Hachette UK, editing Booker-nominated authors and Sunday Times bestsellers. Memoir, Lit Fiction, Crime/Thriller.

London, UK

95% reply rate

View profile
Duncan McHenry

Duncan M.

A copyeditor and proofreader with a passion for words, culture, and ecology. More than 10 years of experience. Freelance with Hachette.

Boulder, Colorado, USA

100% reply rate

View profile