Sweet Tooth

Fiction Friendship Funny

Written in response to: "Start your story with someone being followed." as part of What Lingers.

It was a dark, quiet night in late October, with only the dim street lamps to keep the neighborhood from being shrouded in complete darkness. The howling wind carried a dreary chill through the air, and Sue was beginning to regret not taking a coat with her. All the effort she put into mirroring Carrie White seemed pointless now that all she had was her dress and fake blood to keep her warm. If anyone at the party actually seemed impressed with her costume, maybe that could’ve made the cold walk home worth it. But all anyone was interested in was the alcoholic punch bowl and swapping saliva with strangers. When the time came for horror movie trivia, Sue was the only one sober enough to play. 

She hoped that Brie, at least, would keep her promise and play trivia with her. But Sue found her with some dude whose whole “costume” was just a Ghostface mask. She said she wasn’t having any fun and wanted to know when they’d be going home. 

“It’s not a long walk,” Brie said, her red solo cup spilling liquor onto her lap. She went as a mean witch, and Sue thought she was playing the role well. “You’re a big girl, you can go home if you want to.”

“But it’s freezing—“

“Go, Sue! I’m busy.”

So here Sue was, walking down the street, sniffling as she mumbled under her breath. “Probably gonna get a cold. Can’t even hand out candy to trick-or-treaters tomorrow. Why does Brie have to be like that…” She popped a candy corn into her mouth and chewed furiously. She made out with a large handful of candy at least. The familiar waxy taste of the candy corn reminded her of old halloweens, where her older sister would carry her by the hand and she’d drag her pillowcase full of all sorts of treats behind her, and when they got home they’d spend the rest of the night trading candy. Remembering those times only made Sue sad now. 

As Sue walked down the street, the quiet air would be broken by sudden, scurrying feet. Sue stopped and looked over her shoulder, a Reese's cup halfway to her mouth. She didn’t see anything behind her besides the spooky decorations her neighbor left out. But she was almost certain that she heard something, so she crossed the street and continued walking. Just to be safe. 

But then she heard it again. It sounded like a cat running across the kitchen floor. She whipped her head around faster this time, “bloody” blonde hair briefly sticking to her face. Nothing! This time she began picking up the pace. She held her dress up with one hand and periodically looked over her shoulder. Nothing? Was that that little shape in the darkness a trick of the eye or something more? She began running faster. Was that rustling in the bush? 

Then she heard it again, in front of her this time, and followed by a shrill screech.

Sue fell backwards on her ass screaming. She flung her handful of candy at whatever was in front of her and began backing up, screaming bloody murder all the while. Until she saw what was making that noise. It wasn’t a wild dog or raccoon like she worried, although it’s bushy black tail kind’ve looked like a raccoon’s. And it was about as big as the raccoons that used to crawl under her parents porch. But it was shaped more like a koala than anything else, and its ears were pointed up, like a cat’s. It was an odd creature, there was no doubt about that, but it didn’t look like any vicious beast Sue conjured up in her head. 

Thankfully, the critter didn’t seem offended by Sue’s defensive tactic. In fact, it seemed more interested in her candy haul than anything else. It picked up a large butterfinger, which Sue had been saving for last, and used its little mitts to unwrap it. Then it opened its mouth; large and full of flat teeth, and chomped down on the candy bar. 

Sue stared with big, bewildered eyes. Only briefly upset at her candy being ransacked, she was quickly overcome with a kind of amazed curiosity with what was in front of her. It was something she hadn’t felt in years. Slowly, she pushed herself to her knees to watch the critter chew on the chocolate

“You like candy, little guy?” She cooed. “Were you following me? Did you want — hey, don’t litter — did you want me to share some with you?” She reached down at the scramble of candy and picked up a twizzler. She unwrapped it and cautiously held it out. “I don’t like the twizzlers all that much. You can have it…”

The critter didn’t seem to understand the gesture. It’s big, pumpkin orange eyes flicked between the offered candy and the hand that held it, then up to the face of the young woman whom the hand belonged to. Its four-fingered hand reached out, equally as cautious, and snatched the twizzler out of Sue’s grasp. It slurped it up like a noodle, and Sue giggled. 

“You’re a little sweet tooth, ain’t ya?” She almost reached out to scratch its head, but held her hand back. This was still a wild animal. But Sue always fancied herself something of a Disney princess. If anyone could domesticate the little critter, who’s to say it can’t be her? “Do you want to come with me, little guy? I’ve got more candy at home, and my sister probably won’t be coming home tonight. You could sleep there! I can make you a little bed in my room!”

The little critter didn’t respond to Sue’s offer, as its mouth was full of candy corn. But it was better than scratching her face up, Sue thought. She scooped up all the candy and all the wrappers. Holding out a Reese’s cup, she dangled it behind her and continued walking, and the sugar-rushed critter hopped behind her.

She was already thinking of what to name it. 

Posted Nov 06, 2026
Share:

You must sign up or log in to submit a comment.

4 likes 0 comments

Reedsy | Default — Editors with Marker | 2024-05

Bring your publishing dreams to life

The world's best editors, designers, and marketers are on Reedsy. Come meet them.