It Was Never Me

Contemporary Drama Fiction

Written in response to: "Write a story about a character who believes something that isn’t true." as part of The Lie They Believe with Abbie Emmons.

I didn’t realize the belief was wrong because it worked.

It kept everything organized in a way that felt safe. It gave meaning to moments that might have otherwise felt random or unresolved. It gave me a structure to move inside of, something predictable enough to rely on.

It explained people.

It explained distance.

It explained endings.

And most importantly, it explained me.

I didn’t think of it as something I believed. That would have required a kind of awareness I didn’t have yet. It wasn’t something I repeated to myself in words. It didn’t sound like a sentence in my mind.

It lived in my reactions.

In the way I anticipated things before they happened.

In the way I adjusted before I was asked to.

In the way I softened myself in places where I thought friction might exist.

It felt like instinct.

Like something I had always known.

I believed I was someone people eventually grew out of.

Not immediately.

Not in a way that made beginnings impossible.

But eventually.

There was always a point where something shifted.

And I had learned how to recognize that point before it fully arrived.

It started small.

It always did.

A delay in response that felt slightly longer than usual.

A conversation that didn’t carry the same weight it had before.

A presence that felt… thinner.

Less anchored.

Less certain.

And I would notice.

Not because I was perceptive, but because I was prepared.

Because I had already decided what it meant.

I didn’t wait for confirmation.

I didn’t need to.

I understood the pattern.

So I adjusted.

I became easier to be around.

Quieter in the places that might create tension.

More flexible in ways that felt like consideration.

Less demanding in ways that felt like maturity.

I told myself I was being understanding.

I told myself I was being patient.

I told myself I was protecting something that mattered.

But what I was actually doing was preparing for the moment I believed was already on its way.

I had learned early that attention could feel temporary.

That closeness could feel conditional.

That the safest way to exist inside connection was to not expect it to remain the same.

So I didn’t.

I expected change.

I expected distance.

I expected endings to arrive slowly enough that I could meet them halfway.

And because I expected them, I saw them everywhere.

Even when they weren’t there.

That was the part I didn’t understand.

That was the part that stayed hidden.

Because when something does eventually end, it feels like confirmation.

It feels like proof.

It feels like something you predicted, something you understood before it became real.

It never felt like coincidence.

It felt like accuracy.

And once you start believing you’re accurate, you stop questioning what you’re seeing.

You trust it.

You build around it.

You let it guide you in ways that feel subtle but shape everything.

I didn’t notice how much of my life was built around that belief until I started paying attention to what happened before things ended.

The endings were easy to explain.

People change.

Things shift.

Life moves.

But the patterns before the endings—

Those were harder to ignore once I started looking at them.

I noticed how quickly I adapted to other people.

How easily I stepped into whatever version of myself felt most manageable in the moment.

How rarely I paused to consider what I actually needed.

I noticed how often I anticipated disappointment before anything had the chance to unfold.

How I braced for it.

Prepared for it.

Adjusted around it.

I noticed that I wasn’t just responding to what was happening.

I was responding to what I believed would happen.

And those are not the same thing.

I didn’t see it clearly at first.

It came in pieces.

In small moments where something didn’t align with what I expected.

Like when someone stayed consistent longer than I was prepared for.

When their presence didn’t shift.

When their tone didn’t change.

When their attention didn’t feel temporary.

At first, I didn’t trust it.

Of course I didn’t.

It didn’t match the pattern.

And anything that doesn’t match what you’ve come to expect feels suspicious.

Even if it’s stable.

Even if it’s healthy.

Even if it’s exactly what you would have said you wanted.

Consistency felt unfamiliar.

And unfamiliar felt unsafe.

So I waited.

For the shift.

For the moment where everything would realign with what I already believed.

But it didn’t come.

And without that moment, I didn’t know how to exist inside what was happening.

Because I had never learned how to stay present in something that didn’t require adjustment.

So I created one.

Not intentionally.

Not consciously.

But predictably.

I started pulling back.

Becoming less expressive.

Less available.

Less engaged.

Not because anything had changed.

But because I expected it to.

And if something was going to change, I wanted to be ahead of it.

I wanted to control the timing.

Control the distance.

Control the ending before it had the chance to surprise me.

It felt like protection.

It always had.

But this time, it didn’t go unnoticed.

He saw it.

Not as distance to match.

But as something to understand.

“Did something change?”

The question was simple.

But it didn’t land that way.

Because something had changed.

Just not in the way he meant.

What had changed was my position.

My expectation.

My willingness to sit inside something that didn’t confirm what I believed.

I could have said no.

I could have redirected the conversation.

I could have done what I always did—

And adjusted.

But something about the way he asked made that feel unnecessary.

Or maybe it made it feel impossible.

Because he wasn’t pulling away.

He wasn’t creating distance.

He wasn’t confirming anything I had prepared for.

He was still there.

And that disrupted everything.

“I think I’ve been expecting you to leave.”

The words felt unfamiliar as soon as they left my mouth.

Not because they weren’t true.

But because I had never said them out loud before.

He didn’t respond right away.

Not with reassurance.

Not with confusion.

Just with a kind of stillness that made space for what I had said.

“Why?” he asked.

And I didn’t have an answer.

Not one that could be explained simply.

Not one that could be traced back to a single moment.

Because it wasn’t one moment.

It was accumulation.

Pattern.

Repetition.

It was something I had learned how to recognize before I learned how to question.

“I don’t know,” I said.

And for the first time, that felt honest.

Because I didn’t know.

Not in a way that could be solved in one conversation.

Not in a way that could be undone by one person choosing to stay.

The belief wasn’t attached to him.

It existed before him.

It would have existed after him.

Unless I questioned it.

And that was the part I had never done.

Because questioning it would mean considering that it wasn’t true.

And if it wasn’t true, then everything I had built around it would have to be reconsidered.

The way I showed up.

The way I adjusted.

The way I anticipated endings before they arrived.

It would mean I hadn’t just been reacting to reality.

I had been shaping it.

That realization didn’t feel dramatic.

It didn’t feel like a breakthrough.

It felt quiet.

Uncomfortable.

Unsettling in a way that stayed with me longer than anything else.

Because it meant I had been participating in the very outcomes I believed were happening to me.

Not intentionally.

Not maliciously.

But consistently.

I had been preparing for distance in ways that created it.

That was the part that stayed.

Not the conversation.

Not the moment.

But the awareness that followed.

I started noticing things differently after that.

Noticing when I pulled back before anything had actually shifted.

Noticing when I translated neutral moments into confirmation of something negative.

Noticing when I chose silence instead of clarity because it felt safer.

And slowly—

I started interrupting it.

Not perfectly.

Not consistently.

But intentionally.

Saying things I would have kept to myself.

Asking questions I would have avoided.

Allowing moments to exist without deciding what they meant immediately.

It felt unfamiliar.

And at times, uncomfortable.

Because the belief had been a form of control.

A way to prepare.

A way to protect.

Letting it go didn’t feel like relief at first.

It felt like exposure.

But it also created something else.

Space.

Space to see people as they were, not as I expected them to be.

Space to respond instead of anticipate.

Space to experience connection without deciding its ending before it had the chance to unfold.

And most importantly—

Space to see myself without the filter I had been using to understand everything else.

It didn’t happen all at once.

The shift.

It unfolded.

Gradually.

Quietly.

But once I saw it, I couldn’t unsee it.

It wasn’t that people had always been leaving.

It wasn’t that I had been too much.

Or not enough.

It was that I had been moving through every connection with a belief that made leaving feel inevitable—

And then shaping myself around that inevitability.

And the truth—

The one that took the longest to settle—

Wasn’t dramatic.

It wasn’t loud.

It didn’t arrive all at once.

It arrived in pieces.

In moments.

In the absence of what I had been expecting.

Until eventually, it became something I could hold.

It wasn’t that I had been wrong about the world.

It was that I had been wrong about who I thought I had to be to survive it.

And that—

more than anything else—

was what finally began to change.

Posted Mar 25, 2026
Share:

You must sign up or log in to submit a comment.

6 likes 0 comments

Reedsy | Default — Editors with Marker | 2024-05

Bring your publishing dreams to life

The world's best editors, designers, and marketers are on Reedsy. Come meet them.