Never My Love

Fiction Romance Sad

This story contains themes or mentions of physical violence, gore, or abuse.

Written in response to: "Make a character’s obsession or grudge a key element of your story." as part of What Lingers.

Jack and his wife Isabella lived in a nice little two bedroom condo on the outskirts of New York City. They had been married for ten years and never had any children. Jack owned his own tool rental business and Isabella was a writer. Jack started his business five years ago, due to the fact he had a lot of tools and his friends would borrow them from time to time if they needed one. Of course as soon as he needed one, that would be the one he didn't have, so he would have to go buy or rent one. Isabella had quit her job as a bookstore owner and started writing full time from their New York view she saw every morning and every night. She wanted to be able to work her own hours so they could travel. Last year they took a trip to Africa for their yearly vacation. Isabella had started writing a book about it when Jack fell ill later that year, so she stopped writing and helped Jack with his tool business. This year they decided to go to Hawaii, the island of Oahu. They weren't leaving for about five months, so that gave her time to finish her book on their African trip.

They planned their vacations very carefully and well in advance. The plane tickets were all paid for, then the next month they rented the condo. Everything was going according to plan, so they finished up with the car rental and bought some well needed luggage. Hawaii had been on their bucket list for a while now and they couldn't wait to leave and experience the island. Finally the weeks turned into days before it was time to leave. Jack and Isabella planned their trip from the waterfalls to the lava beds they were going to go see on the way to their first luau.

Before they knew it, they were landing in Oahu. The island was everything they imagined it would be, so beautiful and the smell was amazing, so many shades of green. When they arrived it was raining, which was abnormal for that time of year, according to the locals. The rain wasn't going to alter their plans to have the best time ever. The first day they decided they would just drive around the island and explore. Isabella had her camera out taking amazing pictures while Jack was stopping at every beach park they passed, getting out at everyone to take selfies. Every beach they stopped at was more amazing than the last. One beach had tons of beach crabs and the next one, not one crab to be seen. They had been collecting shells for years from all their ocean adventures, they had one shell from every beach they had ever been on. So far only one beach had shells on it, which was surprising to them, nothing like the California beaches that have shells everywhere. This beach was in a little cove on the west side of the island, with small clear shells, most of the ones on the shore were broken, and being the first day they were not dressed to go get the unbroken ones that were in the water.

The condo they rented was completely furnished, had everything from toothpaste to boogie boards and snorkel gear. After a great night's sleep their first night on the island they woke up, had their coffee, grabbed their stuff including the snorkel gear and umbrella. Heading to the beach with the clear shells they decided finding one unique shell would make them happy. Jack set up the umbrella and Isabella got the snorkel gear ready. Neither one of them were ever really comfortable in ocean water, but they weren't going to let that stop them from snorkeling for the first time. Isabella went first as Jack held onto her feet. She was finding a lot of the clear shells which turned white when they dried. They took turns snorkeling and gathering more shells, for the wind chimes they wanted to make with the smaller shells. Isabella looked over and saw the tip of a four inch spiral shell sticking out of the ocean floor. When she showed Jack, they looked at each other and smiled, they knew their search was over for the day. Being late in the afternoon they went back up on the beach, had lunch and then laid under the umbrella for a well needed rest. Isabella woke up first and wanted to go back into the water one more time before they left for the day. She woke Jack up to see if he wanted to join her but he wanted just a few more minutes and told her not to go far. For 10 years every time they would separate she would jokingly say, "don't leave me!" and he would always reply with, "never my love".

As Jack laid there enjoying his last few minutes before leaving for the day he heard Isabella screaming with a distinct gurgling sound. He jumped up just in time to see the tail end of a shark heading out to sea threw a pool of bloody bubbles. He jumped in the water to look for Isabella but couldn't see under the water, so he ran back up to the shore and grabbed the snorkel gear. Running as fast as he could jumping in the water, diving and screaming her name, there was no sign of Isabella. He had swam out so far looking for her that he could barely see the shore anymore. Diving and looking with still no sign of her, Jack swam back to the beach and called the island police. Within what seemed like minutes there were two lifeguards running towards him as he pointed to where he last saw the bubbles, then both lifeguards jumped in and started looking. He saw a coast guard rescue boat racing around the corner into the cove with three divers hanging off the side and jumping in at different times. The sun finally went down as the coast guards and the lifeguards kept telling Jack that they would keep looking and to stay on the shore. Hours later the words, "I'm so sorry sir" fell on deaf ears as he kept expecting Isabella to swim up at any moment. Finally a police officer came to escort him back to their condo, covered in a thick gray blanket Jack could barely open the door.

Two months later a family with a little girl were vacationing on the same island. Every day they would go to the same beach with all the little clear shells. On the sixth day the little girl walked up to a man sitting on the beach and said, "I see you sitting here every day looking at the beautiful water, but you never go in, why?". The man looked at the little girl and said, "she said, “don't leave me” and I replied, “never my love".

Alice Osinski

Posted Nov 04, 2026
Share:

You must sign up or log in to submit a comment.

1 like 0 comments

Reedsy | Default — Editors with Marker | 2024-05

Bring your publishing dreams to life

The world's best editors, designers, and marketers are on Reedsy. Come meet them.