Dollface

Creative Nonfiction Mystery Suspense

Written in response to: "Write about a character who yearns for something they lost — or never had." as part of What Lingers.

"You're setting up Christmas decorations already? We just passed out candy last night!" Colin said jokingly as he approached his girlfriend, Maddie, who was lining the driveway with giant candy canes. Like most, he is highly against the holiday switch up so soon after Halloween. "I know, I know," Maddie said sheepishly, "but this might be nan's last year. We're not sure if she'll even make it to Thanksgiving. I just want to make it special for her." Maddie is the sole caretaker to her great grandmother, Audrey, and moved into her house a few months ago when she became dependent on home care. Although Colin is supportive of Maddie and has nothing against the decision, if anything it made him admire her even more. But he's always had an eerie sense about the Victorian home that has been in Maddie's family since 1890, and Colin couldn't decide what spooked him the most. The way the floors creaked with nearly every step, making anyone's presence known; or the old family photos arraigned around the house; a few of them being older than Audrey herself. All of which he could swear the eyes followed as you walked past them.

"Are you sure nan's house is the only option? It's so old and hardly accessible; it doesn't seem logical for home care." He could never admit to Maddie that the house made his blood run cold, especially with knowing how much family means to her. "Dad and I rearranged the sitting room into a bedroom for her. It's easier to access everything that way and she can still be comfortable in her own home. I just can't stand the thought of her being anywhere else." Maddie continued, "C'mon, I need help with a few things." Colin turned to grab some things from his car before heading in. He paused and stared at the house for a moment. A chill went down his spine when he thought he saw something in the window upstairs, but after he blinked, it was gone. He stood and stared, trying to see if his eyes played tricks on him. "Colin! I need a hand, please!" Maddie yelled from the porch. He hesitated, staring at the window for a few more beats before making his way inside.

After passing through the dreaded hall of photos, he peered around the corner and saw Audrey’s set up in the large sitting room surrounded by equipment needed for her hospice care. He walked in to observe the thoughtful personal touches Maddie had set up to make her comfortable, including the tables on each side of Audrey's bed. One with a small ceramic Christmas tree that has been in the family for decades, surrounded by holiday mementos. And the other had an old photo of two little girls sitting on the hallway steps of this very house, one blonde and one brunette. Each of them was holding a doll that matched their hair and outfit. As he walked closer, he noticed Audrey had the brunette doll tucked into her arm. He continued to admire the care Maddie put into the room when Audrey's eyes jolted open and she started to gasp for air. Colin jumped and then shouted for Maddie, prompting her to run in asking "what's wrong?" Colin stammered, "I-I don't know. I didn't do anything, she just" he was cut off by Audrey saying weakly, "my doll, my doll." between gasps of air.

Maddie knelt down and spoke softly, "it's okay nan. We have one of the dolls here for you." Audrey calmed down as she closed her eyes again. "Poor thing. Hers has been missing for years. This one belonged to her sister Alice." Maddie said sympathetically as she tucked Audrey's arm with the doll under the blanket. Audrey kept repeating "my doll, my doll" hoarsely until she fell back asleep. "I think she has nightmares about losing her doll. She's been asking for her own ever since she got sick." Maddie continued, "She's only been able to say "my doll" ever since she entered hospice." Once Audrey was settled, Maddie looked at Colin and asked, "babe, can you help me bring some stuff down?" Colin was still shaken from the episode; all he could do was stare at Audrey and her doll. "Babe?" Maddie walked up to him and touched his arm, unintentionally startling him. "Sorry." He said, wiping the sweat from his palms onto his pants. "I was just startled; I wasn't sure what to do." Maddie took one of his hands into hers and said "it's okay, it is pretty shocking for anyone that isn't around her often. She's okay though; this is pretty common for her." She led them out of the room.

Maddie kneeled down in front of the pile of boxes in the foyer. "I'm still looking through boxes that I brought up from the basement. I found some and I want to look through the rest of these, but I think the main holiday decorations are in the loft. Would you mind getting them for me?" Colin's face turned pale. The so-called loft was actually an attic, a creepy one at that. "The loft?" He said, not asking a question but more so pleading to do anything else that didn't involve going up there. Maddie laughed and said almost mockingly "it's fine, there's nothing up there but boxes." He started to sweat again. "Yeah, nothing but boxes and ghosts, probably", he said under his breath. Maddie still heard him and laughed. "There aren't any ghosts, those aren't even real. Put on your brave boy pants and help, please." She grinned and gave him shooing motion. He playfully groaned. Colin walked to the edge of the staircase and the cold sweat returned; he couldn't shake the eerie feeling. "Alright, I'll be back." He said as he started the accent.

Colin made a point to not look at any photos or into any rooms on the way up to avoid potentially seeing anything. "If I don't see it, it doesn't exist." he told himself repeatedly. After climbing what felt like an eternity of stairs, he finally made it to the third floor. The door to the loft was so old; Colin was certain it was the original door from when the house was built. When he finally worked up the nerve, he grabbed onto the brass door handle, yelling "AH!" The handle was so cold it almost burned. "You okay up there?" Maddie shouted from downstairs. "I'm fine, it's just so cold up here the door handle is like ice." Colin shouted in return. Maddie's reply was muffled but said that was normal this time of year and to just use the sleeve of his shirt to open the door. Doing so, he was met with a gust of cold air. He tightly closed his eyes and started breathing heavily, trying to gain the courage to step forward. Finally, opening his eyes, he stuck his head inside to look both ways with caution. And there it was. The window at the back of the house was broken. No wonder it was so cold. He rubbed his hands together to heat them up as he stepped forward.

There were boxes everywhere; he didn't know where to start considering they weren't even labeled. Upon opening the first box, he was startled by and old rubber Halloween mask of a werewolf. He gasped and nearly fell backwards. "C'mon, Colin. Get it together" he told himself. A few boxes later, he finally saw some tinsel peeking through the cracks. Ready to leave this room, he swiftly grabbed that one and brought it downstairs. "Here's one at least. I looked through several and this was the only Christmas box so far." He said as he set it down next to the other boxes in the foyer. Maddie clapped her hands together with enthusiasm. "Thank you so much! Let's see what we have." Maddie opened the flaps of the box and started digging through. She kept coming across old holiday mementos, each meant with more excitement than the last. "Oh my gosh, the garland I made for nan when I was five!" She jumped up to promptly hang the garland in Audrey's room. Colin was curious about the rest of the box and started to look through it himself. After shuffling through more decor, he saw a small hand at the bottom. A doll's hand. When he brought it up from the bottom, it was revealed to be the blonde doll in Audrey's photo. This must be her actual doll, he thought to himself. He stood in the doorway waiting for Maddie to notice what he found.

"Oh my gosh, nan's doll! Colin, you found it!" He laughed nervously and handed it over to her. She kissed him on the cheek and then brought it over to Audrey, tucking it into her other arm. "This has been gone for so long, I think it ended up in a holiday box from when I played with it last. I got my own doll and a tea set as a gift that year and wanted them to play together." Colin smirked at the thought of her memory. That's when Audrey's eyes opened slightly, and she smiled before whispering, "My doll, my doll." This time with relief instead of yearning and then drifted back to sleep. "Babe, she's been missing that for so long, look how happy she is." Colin peered down at Audrey as she smiled in her sleep, squeezing the dolls closer to her. He smirked, and the uneasy sense that followed him around the house faded. "It's all in my head" he thought to himself. "There's more boxes to go through, let's see what else we can find. I'll go up with you this time." Maddie said as she patted his arm. He looked back to Audrey, who was smiling in her sleep. He saw her lips move and swore he heard her say "finally" but it was so faint.

Upon returning with more boxes from upstairs, Maddie and Colin set them on the floor with the others to see what other treasures they beheld. After a few minutes of searching, Maddie found another old photo of Audrey and her sister. Maddie looked at the picture with sorrow. "It's so sad. She was nan's only sibling. They were so close when they were girls.” Colin leaned in to observe the black and white photo. One of the girls with blonde hair, the other brown, and both wearing similar dresses and holding their dolls. He assumed the blonde was Audrey considering she only had the brunette doll earlier. "What happened to Alice?" Colin asked. "She became severely ill when she was 10." Maddie stood up and continued, "They separated the girls from each other because Alice was contagious and after a few weeks of being sick, she lost her fight. The year before, they were gifted with these dolls for Christmas. They were made by their mother herself so they both could each have one that looked like them. They went everywhere with their beloved dolls. So much that Alice died with hers in her arms. Nan always treasured them and kept them safe. I was the first one she let play with her own since she was a kid, and that caused it to be lost ever since. But you, my love," she grabbed colin's hands and pulled him in close, "you saved the day." and leaned in to kiss him and then they then embraced each other with a hug. 

When Maddie let go of colin, she grabbed the photo of the sisters to show Audrey. "Nan, you won't believe what else we-" she stopped and gasped. "Nan?" Audrey was missing from her bed, but both dolls were still there. "Oh my god, Nan!" Maddie looked around the room. "She was just here. She can't even walk, where did she go?" She panicked running to the next room to look. "I-she was just-" Colin stammered as he was just as shocked. That uneasy feeling returned to him when he swore he saw the dolls moving. Frozen in horror, he witnessed the dolls reach out to each other to hold hands and then they smiled. He paled and shouted for Maddie without breaking his stare from them. When Maddie came running back, a gust of cold air rushed through the room causing them both to lose their balance enough to step back a couple of steps. When they stabilized themselves, Colin looked up, saying "Maddie, the dolls!" They were gone. Colin and Maddie held each other in shock. They looked behind them and when they looked back, they both screamed. Audrey and Alice appeared before them as they were in the photo by the bed; two young girls, dolls included. "Thank you" the girls said in unison before fading into thin air right in front of them. They both breathed unsteadily for a moment until Maddie finally said "did- did we just witness-" unable to finish her sentence, both breathing heavily. "I think we did." Colin replied, knowing what she meant. “I think- I think she knew and held on as long as she could to see Alice again.” Suddenly, every uneasy feeling he ever experienced had left. Even he could sense the peace that settled. He almost felt guilt for fearing what had only been grief.

Posted Nov 05, 2026
Share:

You must sign up or log in to submit a comment.

3 likes 0 comments

Reedsy | Default — Editors with Marker | 2024-05

Bring your publishing dreams to life

The world's best editors, designers, and marketers are on Reedsy. Come meet them.