She walked in the bar on a rainy night, found a corner booth, and slid in. The candle on her table was the only light back there — just enough to cast her in the shadow. Across the room, a spotlight aimed down at the live singer, who’d just started strumming the guitar.
She ordered a Manhattan.
The first chords came. She recognized the song at once. And unfortunately, the singer too. It was a folk song. One they’d listened to on a stormy summer afternoon, trapped in a lecture hall while rain hammered the windows. One of his favorites.
Maybe it’s just the voice, she thought.
She had never liked spirits. He liked them, back when they were together. Starting from a time she couldn’t remember, she started liking the taste of how a minty mojito slides down her throat, and how a long island iced tea makes her head spin in a good way. Not Manhattans though. They burn. That first Manhattan after him — the real one, the one some bartender made without thinking — had burned. She’d choked on it, coughed, and finished it after she diluted it with a vitamin C drink.
Memory is a strange thing. She couldn't remember the burn anymore. Instead, it became something else: a drink she’d had a hundred times, in a hundred places. It followed her to rooftops in moist summer air, creaky old British pubs, and fancy hotel lounges where the ice came in perfect spheres. She’d ordered it so often, in so many moods, that the taste had blurred into something of her own making. Or rather, something of his making: the version he’d crafted for her, the one that had way too much sweet vermouth. The one she’d been chasing even since.
It's not cloying, not sugary, but warm. The way a good wine settles in your chest, but stronger. The way a whiskey rolls down your throat, but deeper. She knew that the first one had burned, and the second, and probably the tenth. She knew that the only reason she’d kept ordering them was because of him — not the real him, not the one who loved straight rye whiskey, but the version of him that had made it sweeter for her.
But that was years ago. She didn’t order Manhattans for him anymore. She ordered them because somewhere along the way, she’d convinced herself that she liked them.
That she’d always liked them.
That the burn was never really there.
The folk song ended, and another followed, and another. They all sounded the same to her, and she lost count of how many he performed.
A shadow loomed over her candlelight. She raised her head, and locked eyes with him. He looked older. He had a stubble now, but still wore the same kind of plaid shirt with dark washed jeans. He invited himself to sit down and raised a brow when he saw her two empty glasses of Manhattan.
“I thought you didn’t drink.”
When they were together, she only drank when he made her drinks. She shrugged. “People change.”
“Do they?” He leaned back, studying her. “I remember you crying into a gin and tonic once. Said it tasted like medicine.”
“That was years ago.”
“It was.” A pause. “I remember a lot of things from back then.”
She looked into her glass. The lone cherry sitting there, half bitten. “Funny thing about memory,” she said. “It’s not a photograph. It’s more like —” She gestured vaguely. “A painting. One you keep touching up, year after year. Until the original is gone.”
He had gone quiet for a moment. “Is that what you did? Touched it up?”
She met his eyes. “Maybe we both did.”
He shook his head slowly. “I remember it pretty clearly, actually.”
“Do you?”
“The day we met. You were posing in the middle of the zebra line, and I remember thinking this girl is a wild one. She’s going to get run over.”
She almost smiled.
He went on: “I remember the first time I made you a Manhattan. You said it burned, but you drank it anyway. Because I made it for you.”
She remembered this, but also something else. “The second time you made me a Manhattan, you added extra sweet vermouth,” she said. “You knew I wouldn’t like it straight. So you cheated the recipe.”
He tilted his head. “I don’t remember that.”
She paused. She let herself feel the warmth of that memory. The way his eyes had watched her take the first sip, waiting for her to like it. She had liked it. That was the problem.
“You wouldn’t. That’s the thing about memory. You remember my bright pink hair and I remember that you always ordered for me at restaurants, because you said I took too long to decide. You remember making me Manhattans. I remember that you made them sweeter, because you knew I couldn’t handle the burn — and I remember thinking, even then, that you were changing yourself — losing yourself almost — so that I could fit. And I let you.”
A long silence followed.
“Which one is true?” he asked.
She thought about it. The candle flickered between them.
“Both,” she said finally. “Neither. I don’t know anymore.”
“I remember the breakup.”
He tilted his face so that she could only see half of it.
“I remember you walking away,” he said. “I remember standing there, watching you go, thinking 'she’s not going to look back'. And you didn’t.”
She did, in fact, look back. Twice. One at the corner of the street, another when she reached a streetlamp. But she didn’t say this. Maybe she only remembered looking back because she wished she had. Maybe she didn’t. Maybe they’re both wrong.
“That’s the problem with memories,” she said. “They don’t come with receipts.”
He laughed bitterly. “No. They don’t.”
Her fingers traced the cracks of the wooden table, moving to caress what seemed to be a carving of the letter "M". “The moment when you added extra sweet vermouth, I knew that we weren’t going to last.”
She didn’t look at him but kept staring at the flickering candlelight. “The ratio was wrong. The bitterness of the whiskey was diminishing…”
He opened his mouth and closed them. No voice came out.
“Two to one to one,” she said. “That’s the recipe. Rye to sweet vermouth to dry.”
He looked up surprised. “You never used to know that.”
“I learned.” She swirled her fourth glass. “The thing is, if you change the ratio, it’s not a Manhattan anymore. It’s just…whiskey with stuff in it.”
The music in the bar changed to jazz. The sound of the saxophone sounded broken, something in between a whine or a mumble.
“You changed yourself. You started giving me more space, being more considerate when I cancelled plans, pretending like you’re not hurt. You became too sugary. I couldn’t tell that you were someone who loved straight rye.”
She carried on, blowing a piece of hair out of her face.
“It wasn’t because you did something wrong. You did something right — you made it easier for me. And I thought: if this is what love looks like, if this is him bending for me, then what happens when I need to bend? What happens when we both stop being who we are?”
Her voice came out raspier. “And I became more bitter. I used my studies as an excuse, my silence as a weapon, your indulgence as a leverage… I was scared that I wasn’t bitter enough. That if I sweetened even a little, you’d just keep bending until there was nothing left of you.”
“We didn’t lose to love,” he said quietly. “We lost because we couldn’t stop trying.”
“So what now?” He asked.
If he had asked her two years ago, she would’ve suggested they try again. To hell with the ratios and the receipts and whatever else. She would’ve let him play her his favorite folk song again, let him tell her it was always her song, and let herself believe it.
But now? She knew that some records skip. You can lift the needle, move it back a groove, but the scratch is still there. The song never sounds the same after.
“We move forward. And one day, when someone puts a Manhattan in front of me, I’ll find that it’s only a drink, and not a chapter of life.”
He waited.
“But not tonight,” she said. “Tonight, it’s still yours.”
You must sign up or log in to submit a comment.
Hello April,
I love how the Manhattan becomes more than a drink; it carries the history of two people who gradually lost themselves trying to accommodate each other. The detail about the extra sweet vermouth is especially poignant, and “They don’t come with receipts” is such a memorable line. Did you always envision the cocktail recipe as a metaphor for their relationship?
Reply
Thank you for your comment! Yes, I thought the cocktail recipe is a pretty good way to put it. From another perspective, it's the idea that a taste can be morphed into different emotions over time as memories become makeshift and blurry.
Reply
Hi April, I love that interpretation! It's fascinating how the same taste can carry completely different emotions depending on the memories attached to it. Almost makes you think twice before ordering your usual drink, you never know what memories might be hiding in the glass! 😂 I especially like the idea of memories changing the flavour of something familiar. Do you often use everyday objects or experiences to explore deeper emotions in your stories?
Reply