ACT I: THE AUDACITY OF HAPPINESS
Have you ever met someone who was perfectly happy?
Disgusting creatures, aren't they?
They wake up in the morning, kiss their spouses, water their plants, and go about their miserable little routines without a single thought of what could have been. No grand ambitions left unfulfilled, no desperate longing for another life, no particularly interesting emotional breakdowns.
Frankly, I find them exhausting.
Take Arthur Bennett, for example.
Seventy-eight years old, married for fifty-two of them, three children, seven grandchildren, and a retirement spent reading history books that he had probably already read several times.
A perfectly ordinary man.
A perfectly happy man.
A perfectly dreadful protagonist.
Every morning, Arthur prepared two cups of tea. One with milk, one without. Margaret, his wife, preferred hers with milk, although after fifty-two years of marriage, Arthur still occasionally pretended to forget.
"Milk?" he would ask.
"Arthur."
"Sugar?"
"Arthur."
"Whiskey?"
"Now you're talking."
And they would laugh.
Every. Single. Morning.
I considered poisoning the tea once. Nothing fatal, of course. Just enough to introduce some variety. But that would have been terribly unimaginative, and I do have standards.
Arthur had been a history teacher. A good one, apparently. Former students still wrote to him, which I consider rather suspicious. I never understood the appeal of remembering someone who made you memorize dates.
His retirement was comfortable, his marriage affectionate, and his greatest complaint was that the neighbor's cat occasionally relieved itself among his roses.
He had everything he wanted.
Or rather, he believed he did.
An important distinction, dear reader.
One Tuesday morning, Arthur received news that an old university acquaintance, Edward Hale, had passed away.
Edward was an internationally respected historian. A celebrated scholar, author of several books, recipient of prestigious awards, and a man whose contributions to Roman archaeology had earned him considerable recognition.
Arthur read the obituary twice.
"Good heavens," he said. "Edward Hale. Margaret, do you remember Edward?"
"The one with the ridiculous mustache?"
"That's him!"
"I thought he died years ago."
Arthur laughed.
"Look at this. He became quite something."
For a brief, wonderful moment, I anticipated jealousy.
Instead, Arthur smiled.
"Good for him."
Good for him?
GOOD FOR HIM?
Honestly, some people make my work unnecessarily difficult.
Still, I had prepared a little something.
Three days later, an old photograph arrived in the post. Two young men stood outside a university building, smiling with the ridiculous confidence of people who hadn't yet discovered taxes.
Arthur and Edward.
On the back, written in Edward's handwriting, were seven words.
We were supposed to conquer Rome together.
Arthur stared at the photograph for a long time.
And for the first time in years, he asked himself a rather entertaining question.
What if?
Oh, I do love those two words.
ACT II: A BEAUTIFUL ALTERNATIVE
Now, Arthur had indeed been offered an opportunity in Rome.
A prestigious academic fellowship, no less. Fifty-three years earlier, a promising young historian had been invited to pursue the very career he had always dreamed of.
Unfortunately, Margaret was pregnant, money was tight, and Arthur had decided that a stable teaching position was preferable to dragging his young family across Europe.
A sensible decision.
How terribly inconvenient.
But Edward had gone.
And Edward had flourished.
Over the following weeks, Arthur began receiving the occasional reminder of his old friend's accomplishments. A university newsletter, a newspaper clipping, an invitation to a memorial lecture.
Nothing particularly extraordinary.
Just a few conveniently timed deliveries.
You'd be amazed what can happen when the right letter arrives on the wrong morning.
Arthur began reading Edward's books. He studied photographs of archaeological expeditions, academic ceremonies, and crowded lecture halls.
He discovered that Edward had received an award for research remarkably similar to a theory Arthur himself had once explored.
That one was especially delicious.
"He used to borrow my notes," Arthur told Margaret one evening.
"Who?"
"Edward."
"Well, perhaps you taught him something."
Arthur smiled, although not quite as widely as he once might have.
Perhaps.
Such an innocent little word.
You can fit an entire lifetime of disappointment inside it if you try hard enough.
Soon Arthur was spending more time in his study. His gardening tools gathered dust, his books accumulated on the dining table, and Margaret found herself drinking her morning tea alone.
Not every morning, mind you.
I wouldn't want you thinking Arthur had suddenly become unpleasant.
Not yet.
One afternoon, he found an old university recommendation among the papers that had accompanied the photograph.
Two names had been considered for the fellowship.
Edward Hale.
Arthur Bennett.
Beside Arthur's name, someone had written:
Exceptional potential. A regrettable loss.
Arthur read those words repeatedly.
Then he folded the paper and placed it in his pocket.
He didn't show Margaret.
Oh, Arthur.
Secrets already?
How exciting.
ACT III: THE COST OF LOVE
Regret is a curious thing.
It rarely arrives announcing itself. That would be terribly impolite. Instead, it slips into familiar memories and begins rearranging the furniture.
A wedding becomes a limitation.
A child's birth becomes an obligation.
An ordinary career becomes evidence of wasted potential.
And the truly beautiful part?
Nothing actually has to change.
Arthur began remembering things differently.
The little house they had bought after their first child was born. The promotion he had declined because it required moving. The evenings spent grading examinations while Margaret rocked a crying baby.
He had loved those evenings once.
Well, perhaps not the crying. Nobody enjoys a crying baby, except other crying babies, and they're hardly reliable witnesses.
But now Arthur wondered what Edward had been doing during those same years.
Rome, perhaps.
Or Athens.
Or standing before an audience of brilliant scholars, receiving applause that should have belonged to Arthur Bennett.
He began correcting Margaret more often.
Then interrupting her.
Then occasionally ignoring her entirely.
One evening, she found him examining the old photograph again.
"You've been looking at that quite a lot."
"Just remembering."
"Good memories?"
Arthur hesitated.
"I suppose."
Margaret sat beside him.
"You know, I always thought you might go back to university eventually."
Arthur looked at her.
"Did you?"
"Of course. You loved your research."
"Not enough, apparently."
She frowned.
"What does that mean?"
"Nothing."
Ah, nothing.
The favorite word of people who are about to make a great deal of trouble.
A few days later, Arthur found an old letter from Margaret, written during their engagement.
If Rome is what you want, we'll find a way. I don't want you wondering what might have happened.
A lovely sentiment.
Unfortunately, Arthur no longer saw it that way.
Why had she written we'll find a way instead of simply go?
Why hadn't she insisted?
Why had she allowed him to make such a terrible decision?
You see, my dear reader, I hadn't needed to invent a cruel wife.
I merely had to convince Arthur that a loving one hadn't loved him quite enough.
He confronted her that evening.
"You could have told me to go."
Margaret stared at him.
"Arthur, I did."
"You said we'd find a way."
"Because we would have."
"You were pregnant!"
"Yes, Arthur. I remember."
He looked away.
"You knew how difficult it would be."
Margaret remained silent for a moment.
Then she asked something rather inconvenient.
"Do you regret staying?"
Arthur opened his mouth.
Closed it.
And said nothing.
Oh, that silence.
Magnificent.
ACT IV: FIFTY-TWO YEARS TOO LATE
Arthur's transformation was not particularly dramatic.
There were no smashed plates, no outrageous declarations, no midnight departures into the rain.
How disappointing for the furniture.
Instead, he simply became a little less Arthur every day.
He stopped telling his grandchildren stories. He no longer corrected historical inaccuracies on television. Even the neighbor's cat enjoyed an unprecedented period of freedom among the roses.
Margaret tried everything.
She suggested holidays, visits to old friends, even a trip to Rome.
Imagine that.
A seventy-six-year-old woman offering to accompany her husband to the very place he had begun blaming her for never seeing.
I almost admired her.
Almost.
Arthur refused.
"What would be the point now?"
A reasonable question, considering the circumstances. Although I personally thought the trip might have provided some excellent material.
His youngest daughter noticed the change during Sunday lunch.
"Dad, are you feeling alright?"
"Perfectly."
"You seem quiet."
"Apparently I spent fifty years talking too much."
His daughter laughed uncertainly.
Arthur didn't.
Margaret began watching him with the careful expression of someone trying not to disturb a sleeping animal.
And Arthur noticed.
Naturally, he interpreted her concern as pity.
I had arranged one final piece of correspondence, a commemorative publication celebrating Edward Hale's extraordinary career.
Inside was a photograph of Edward standing before an archaeological excavation.
Beneath it, a quotation:
History remembers those who dare to pursue it.
A rather pretentious thing to say, don't you think?
Arthur didn't.
He tore out the page and kept it beside his bed.
That night, Margaret reached for his hand.
He pretended to be asleep.
And just like that, fifty-two years of habit became something unbearable.
I must confess, I was rather pleased with myself.
ACT V: A LIFE WELL WASTED
Arthur's seventy-ninth birthday arrived on a Sunday.
His children organized dinner. The grandchildren made cards, Margaret baked his favorite cake, and the house filled with the irritating warmth of people who genuinely loved one another.
There were photographs.
Stories.
Laughter.
Even the neighbor's cat made an appearance, although I hadn't invited him.
Arthur sat at the head of the table.
Everyone seemed delighted to be there.
Everyone except Arthur.
His eldest grandson had prepared a little speech about how his grandfather had inspired him to study history.
A touching gesture.
Arthur barely listened.
Then his youngest granddaughter, Sophie, climbed onto his lap.
"Grandpa?"
"Yes, sweetheart?"
"If you could go back and be young again, would you?"
Arthur looked at her.
Such a simple question.
Children are wonderful, aren't they? Completely unaware of the devastation they can cause with a few innocent words.
"Of course he would," Margaret said, laughing. "He'd probably marry me all over again."
Everyone chuckled.
Arthur didn't.
Margaret noticed immediately.
"Arthur?"
He looked around the table. At his children, his grandchildren, the photographs covering the walls, and the woman who had shared nearly every day of his adult life.
For a moment, something familiar appeared in his expression.
Something warm.
Something almost like the old Arthur.
But then his eyes settled on the photograph of Edward Hale, resting on a nearby shelf.
And the moment passed.
"I think," Arthur said quietly, "I'd do things differently."
His daughter smiled.
"Well, wouldn't we all?"
"No."
The room grew quiet.
"I mean it."
Margaret put down her fork.
"Arthur, perhaps we should talk about this later."
"That's the problem, isn't it?"
Nobody answered.
"Everything is always later. Tomorrow. Next year. When the children are older. When there's enough money."
He laughed, although there was nothing particularly amusing about it.
"And then suddenly you're seventy-nine, and there isn't any later left."
Sophie climbed down from his lap.
Arthur didn't notice.
Margaret looked at him for a long moment before asking:
"Would you still choose us?"
Now, I could tell you that Arthur hesitated.
That he struggled.
That somewhere beneath all those dreadful thoughts, he still remembered the man who had once considered himself fortunate beyond measure.
But I've never particularly enjoyed lying to my audience.
Well.
Not about everything.
Arthur looked at his wife.
"I don't know."
Three words.
Fifty-two years.
Ruined.
Margaret stood up and quietly left the room.
Nobody followed her immediately.
Nobody quite knew what to say.
Arthur remained seated, staring at the birthday cake that nobody wanted anymore.
And for the first time in his seventy-nine years, Arthur Bennett genuinely believed that he had wasted his life.
Wonderful.
Simply wonderful.
CURTAIN CALL
Now, before you start feeling too sorry for Arthur, there's something I should probably mention.
Edward Hale was miserable.
Oh, profoundly miserable.
His celebrated career had cost him two marriages, several friendships, and any meaningful relationship with his only son.
He had spent his final years alone, surrounded by awards that couldn't remember his birthday.
Quite tragic, really.
But here's the interesting part.
Edward had written Arthur a letter shortly before his death.
A proper letter. Several pages, handwritten, sentimental, and full of the sort of emotional nonsense people indulge in when they suspect their time is running out.
He confessed how much he envied Arthur.
His family.
His marriage.
His wonderfully ordinary life.
Edward had spent years wishing he'd made precisely the decision Arthur now despised.
Funny, isn't it?
Two men, each convinced the other had received the better life.
Although, to be fair, only one required my assistance.
Arthur never received that letter.
I thought it might spoil the atmosphere.
You see, Arthur never needed a different life. He had everything he wanted, and for seventy-eight years, he'd been perfectly aware of it.
All I did was introduce a little doubt.
A photograph here, a letter there, a few conveniently timed reminders of what might have been.
Nothing particularly difficult.
And now Arthur will spend his remaining years regretting a decision that once made him happy.
His family will wonder what happened to him. Margaret will wonder what she did wrong. And Arthur, poor Arthur, will wonder whether he ever truly lived at all.
I suppose I could tell him.
It would be rather easy, actually.
One letter. That's all it would take.
But where would be the fun in that?
Besides, I think we've established that Arthur has had quite enough correspondence for one lifetime.
And as for Edward?
Well, he's dead.
Rather difficult to complain about missed opportunities when you're dead.
Arthur, on the other hand, still has plenty of time.
I intend to make certain he appreciates every miserable minute of it.
And to think, he was perfectly happy when I found him.
You must sign up or log in to submit a comment.
Good story! It makes me wonder which of muses was the narrator here. Or perhaps its Envy, one of the 7 deadly sins. The ending was poignant
Reply
This story is unbelievably good! No unnecessary noise, just sharp, punchy writing and perfectly placed sarcasm. It’s so good that I’m almost annoyed I didn’t write it myself.
Reply
This story left me thinking that the grass is always greener until you walk a mile in another person's shoes. The narrator transforms the story into psychological horror by deliberately cultivating doubt and emotional suffering. The moral turning point is Edward's letter, but the cruel narrator deliberately withholds the truth. This brings me back to my Stoic readings, which teach that happiness comes from within, through our judgments and choices, rather than from external circumstances. Great work!
Reply
This made me chuckle a lot as I read it. Reminds me of the one word in our lives. IF.
Well written. Thanks for sharing.
Reply