Conflicting Memories

Drama Fiction Funny

Written in response to: "Write a story about two people who remember the same event differently." as part of A Trip Down Memory Lane.

Tacara was absolutely certain that the worst day of her life happened on a Saturday in June. 

Dan, on the other hand, considered it one of the greatest days of his life. 

The disagreement had lasted eleven years, four and a half months, and two weeks. It has survived birthdays, holidays and even family reunions. The problem was simple. Tacara and Dan remembered the exact same event completely differently. 

And neither of them was willing to admit that they might be wrong. 

It all started with Tacara bringing up the subject one morning over breakfast while sipping her morning coffee. 

“Remember the time you tried to impress everybody at the neighborhood barbecue?” She asked, taking a small bite of her toast. 

Dan looked up from his pancakes. 

“Which time?” 

“The time you nearly burned down the whole block starting with Mrs. Henderson’s backyard.” 

“Burned down? That’s a little over the top dramatic.” 

“A little dramatic? Dan, the fire department had to be called.” 

“Because someone called them unnecessarily.” 

“Somebody? Tacara raised an eyebrow. “You mean the entire neighborhood?”

Dan shook his head. “Let me tell you what actually happened.” 

Tacara leaned back in her chair. 

“Oh this should be good.” 

According to Dan, it had been a beautiful Saturday afternoon. The sun was shining and the neighbors were friendly, and he had been in an exceptionally great mood. Mrs. Henderson had invited everyone over for a barbecue, and Dan had volunteered to handle the grill. 

He remembered wearing his favorite shirt, the plaid one with his blue shorts, sunglasses, sneakers and confident smile. He remembered everyone complimenting his grilling skills which he told everyone he had inherited from his dad and his dad had inherited them from his dad. All of the men in his family had superb grilling skills. 

He remembered the smell of delicious hamburgers filling the air along with the ribs on the opposite side of the grill. 

Most importantly, he remembered being the hero of the afternoon. 

Tacara remembered none of these things. 

In her version, Dan had arrived wearing that old ratty plaid shirt with the mustard stain that would never wash out no matter how many times he washed that shirt, sunglasses, old sneakers, shorts and the confidence of a man who had never successfully cooked anything without setting off the smoke alarm. 

“You were only supposed to bring the potato salad.” Tacara reminded him. 

“I did bring the potato salad.” 

“You brought a bowl of mayonnaise with three pieces of potatoes floating in it with three boiled eggs on top.”

“It was a new recipe.” 

“It was more like a crime.” 

Dan ignored her. 

He continued his story. 

According to him, everything had gone perfectly until someone suggested he try his special barbecue sauce. 

He prepared the sauce himself using a secret family recipe. 

Tacara snorted. 

“Your secret family recipe was brown sugar ketchup, and whatever condiment that was left in the fridge.” 

“That, my dear, is called creativity. Every good chief has it.” 

“That is called a case of food poisoning.” 

Dan pointed his fork at her. 

“Anyway, I poured the tasty sauce over the hamburgers and ribs and everyone was impressed and loved it.” 

Tacara nearly choked on her toast. 

“Impressed? Dan, you poured the sauce directly on the flames.” 

“That’s how you get the most flavor.” 

“That’s how you get the firefighters called.” 

Dan shrugged. 

“Minor details.” 

Tacara decided it was time to tell her version. 

She remembered arriving at Mrs. Henderson’s house with a perfectly prepared potato salad, a tray of deviled eggs, and a beautiful lemon cake. 

She remembered Dan standing beside the grill, telling everyone he had watched a cooking show the night before and decided he was an expert. 

She remembered telling him that the flames were not supposed to be higher than the fence. 

And she definitely remembered the moment everything went wrong. 

Dan had lifted the lid of the grill, poured the mysterious sauce onto the hamburgers and ribs and stepped backward just as a giant flame shot into the air. 

His eyebrows had disappeared into the smoke. 

His sunglasses landed directly into the bowl of potato salad. 

And his favorite shirt caught a little spark.

“Your shirt was almost on fire!” Tacara exclaimed. 

Dan looked offended. 

“It was a barbecue. There was smoke everywhere.”

“You were the one smoking, literally.” 

“Then you grabbed the garden hose.” 

Dan smiled proudly. 

“Exactly. I saved the day.” 

“If saving the day meant spraying Mrs. Henderson’s husband and the cat then yeah, you saved the day.” 

“That was an unfortunate accident.” 

“You also sprayed her prize-winning rose bushes and my delicious lemon cake that I had spent the morning baking to perfection.” 

Dan thought for a moment. 

“That cake was already in danger.” 

Tacara stared at him with the stink eye. 

“From what?” 

“From you. Because you baked it.” 

She opened her mouth but before she could say anything, Dan continued. 

“And then everyone started clapping.” 

“They were clapping because the fire was out.” 

“Still they applauded.” 

Tacara pushed her plate away. 

“I can’t believe that you still tell that story like you were some kind of neighborhood hero.” 

“Because I am the neighborhood hero. Some people call me the neighborhood super hero.” 

“Yeah, a superhero who was banned from ever using the grill.” 

“Just temporarily.” 

“For three years!” 

“Three years temporarily." 

Tacara sighed. 

There was only one way to settle this. 

They would visit Mrs. Henderson. 

If anyone could confirm what happened that afternoon, it was the woman whose backyard had nearly become a disaster zone. 

Mrs. Henderson answered the door wearing a floral robe and holding a cup of tea. 

“Well, look who’s here.” She said. “My two favorite troublemakers.” 

“We need you to settle an argument.” Tacara announced. 

Mrs. Henderson smiled. 

“Is this about the barbecue that nearly burned down my backyard?” 

Dan looked triumphant. 

Mrs. Henderson invited them inside. 

Tacara explained the disagreement. 

“Dan thinks that he saved the neighborhood from a fire. I remember him nearly burning down the backyard and the whole neighborhood.” 

Mrs. Henderson took a slow sip of tea. 

“Well, that is interesting.” 

Dan folded his arms. 

“Go ahead, Mrs. Henderson. Tell her.” 

Mrs. Henderson looked at Dan. 

“First of all, nobody asked you to cook.” 

Dan frowned. 

“What?” 

“I asked you just to move the cooler.” 

Tacara burst out laughing. 

Dan looked confused. 

“That doesn’t sound right.” 

“It’s absolutely right.” Mrs. Henderson continued. “I had already hired my nephew to do the grilling but you insisted that you could do it better and claimed that you were some expert grill master.” 

Tacara slapped her knees. 

“I knew it.” 

Mrs. Henderson nodded. 

“And you were wearing a bright red shirt.” 

Dan shook his head. 

“No it was plaid.” 

“Red.” 

“Plaid.” 

“Red.” Mrs. Henderson repeated. “I remember because the smoke stained it.” 

Tacara was laughing so hard that she had tears coming from her eyes. 

Mrs. Henderson continued. 

“You also did not bring potato salad. It looked more like macaroni salad.” 

Dan’s expression brightened. 

“Well, at least I brought something.” 

“And you forgot the macaroni in the salad!”

Tacara almost fell out of her chair. 

Dan stared at Mrs. Henderson.

“How do you make macaroni salad without the macaroni?” 

Mrs. Henderson took another sip of her tea.

“I don’t know. You tell me.” 

“And the fire was not actually that big. It was mostly smoke. But you panicked, grabbed the hose and sprayed my husband and cat.” 

Dan leaned forward. 

“But, wasn’t I trying to help?” 

“You were trying to turn off the water.” 

Dan blinked. 

“What?” 

“You had the hose pointed the wrong way. You sprayed my husband first then yourself and then my cat and rosebushes. Oh I almost forgot, the cake got sprayed too.” 

Tacara was now laughing uncontrollably. 

Dan looked at her. 

“Well, I don’t remember all that.” 

Mrs. Henderson smiled. 

“And there’s more.” 

Dan slowly sank into the sofa. 

“More?” 

“After the fire was out, you slipped on the wet grass and fell head first into the flower bed.” 

Tacara gasped. 

“You never told me that.” 

Dan cleared his throat. 

“Because that part was irrelevant.” 

“And than,” Mrs. Henderson continued. “You blamed the flowers.” 

Tacara covered her mouth. 

Dan stood up. 

“I think that we have heard enough.” 

But Mrs. Henderson wasn’t finished. 

“Actually, I have something you should see.”

She disappeared into the hallway and returned carrying a small photo album. She flipped through several pages until she found what she was looking for. 

“Here we are.” 

She placed the photograph on the coffee table. Tacara leaned forward. 

Dan leaned forward. 

And then both of them were silent. 

The picture showed Dan standing in the middle of the backyard, completely soaked, covered in barbecue sauce and holding the garden hose. 

His hair was sticking up and his shirt was stained. One shoe was missing. 

And behind him, Mrs. Henderson’s husband was holding a plate of food while looking absolutely furious. 

Tacara stared at the picture. Then she started laughing again. 

“Oh Dan!” 

Dan studied the picture. 

“That’s not how I remember it.” 

Mrs. Henderson smiled. 

“Well, that’s how the camera remembers it.” 

Dan pointed to the picture. 

“Wait a minute! Why is my shoe missing?” 

“Because you threw it on the grill.” Mrs. Henderson said. 

“I most certainly did not.” 

“You thought that it would smother the flames.” 

Tacara made a noise somewhere between a laugh and a cough.

Dan shook his head.

“That doesn’t even make sense.” 

Mrs. Henderson shrugged. 

“Neither did that whole afternoon.” 

On the drive home, Tacara was still laughing. 

Dan had been unusually quiet. 

Finally he said something. 

“I still think that I deserve some credit.” 

Tacara turned and looked at him. 

“For what?” 

“For trying.” 

“You destroyed a flower bed, soaked a grown man, lost a shoe and nearly drowned a poor lemon cake.” 

“But I still tried.” 

Tacara smiled. 

“Yes, you’re right you did try.” 

Dan nodded. 

“Thank you.” 

“Next time don’t try so hard.” 

He rolled his eyes. 

A few minutes passed. 

Then Dan suddenly snapped his fingers. 

“Wait!” 

Tacara sighed.

“What now?” 

“I just remembered something.” 

“Please don’t.” 

“Mrs. Henderson’s husband actually thanked me for that day.” 

Tacara looked at him. 

“For what?” 

Dan smiled. 

“For putting out the fire.” 

Tacara shook her head. 

“Dan, he thanked you because you finally stopped spraying him with the hose.” 

“Well, a thank-you is still a thank-you.”

Tacara laughed. 

Three weeks later, Tarcara and Dan attended another neighborhood barbecue. 

This time when they walked into the backyard at Mrs. At Henderson's house the food was already cooked and sitting on the picnic tables. 

“Are you sure that this is enough food?” Dan asked. 

Mrs. Henderson rolled her eyes. “Yes.” 

“Because I can always make more burgers on the grill.” Dan said. 

“NO!” Everyone shouted at one time. 

“Okay, Okay. Besides, I already saved this neighborhood once and I don’t want to make it a habit.” 

Posted Nov 12, 2026
Share:

You must sign up or log in to submit a comment.

0 likes 0 comments

RBE | Illustrated Short Stories | 2024-06

Bring your short stories to life

Fuse character, story, and conflict with tools in Reedsy Studio. All for free.