The Gingerbread Cookies

🏆 Contest #229 Winner!

Horror

Written in response to: "Write a story in which a character is stuck reliving their worst Christmas ever, over and over again." as part of Mistletoe and Meet-Cutes.

The Gingerbread Cookies

Let’s go downstairs and bake some cookies, like mother used to make. The warm smell sits right at home in your nostrils, invading them like wild ax-murderers hacking and slashing their way through endless miles of human bodies that stand in the way of their inhumane, carnal desires. Shhh, shhh, but that’s too dark. It’s Christmas after all. So let’s go downstairs and bake some cookies, like mother used to make.

One step… then two… Ooooohhhh, isn’t this great? You’ve never baked gingerbread cookies before, oh no, because you always thought that you would never be able to make them oh so good like mother used to. What did she say she made them with? Some kind of special ingredient. What was it? Was it sugar and spice and everything nice? Was it…love? That special ingredient that every mother cooks with because you are their extra special little kid?

Oh my, this is exciting! Your heart hammers against your ribcage as you set the oven to… Oh, you don’t know what to set the oven to, you’ve never made these before. Probably 300º will be good. You bend down, spin the dial. But what’s that? What the heck? There’s already a baking tray in there. You take it out, confused. On it, there’s a set of perfectly cut gingerbread men. They wear little black tuxedos with white buttons, their smiles expose endless rows of sharpened, white teeth, and their wide green eyes watch you intently with their white pupils. In the center, one of them stares right at you, holding a folded up note in its tiny dough hand. You snatch it from him, not caring about the little man’s feelings.

“To my little boy,

My oh my, I can’t believe how the years have passed! It seems like just yesterday that whatever secret deity governs this universe sent me to my untimely punishment beneath the Earth’s soil. I know, I was always so poetic, right? Now enjoy these cookies, I hope they taste just like how mommy used to make.

Love,

Mother”

Ding! Apparently ten minutes pass while you read that short letter, but to be fair you don’t read it once, do you now, you read it time after time until the words start doing tangos in your head as they spin spiderwebs around one another. 

Now after it dings, you’re supposed to put the cookies back in and start the baking, Mother said.

How hot do you bake them? you asked.

Hot, very hot, Mother said.

But don’t they not like being so hot?

Oh, these little guys won’t mind at all, Mother said, She slid the tiny men into the three hundred degree heat chamber. She smiled. There was really nothing to it.

Nothing to it.

Well, there’s nothing to it, you think as you slide the baking tray in.

And as the minutes tick by, their faces change. No more are the artificial smiles plastered on by a woman who would ruthlessly murder them. Now are the faces of men who know their deaths are coming, smiles that slowly flatten in the corners as three minutes turn to four, five minutes to six, until the red frosting of their mouths fall clean off, and they can’t shout for help, just as you couldn’t call the ambulance when your – their? – mother started clutching her heart and breathing heavily minutes after she slid the baking tray filled with small people into the oven for the final time, yelling for you to get the phone, to get up, to do something and not just sit there as the people cooked in their torture chamber. 

And then they come alive. One of them pokes its head up, its blank eyes staring into your heart. It’s lifeless, dull, unknowing of the infernal fire around it, like you on that fateful night, not knowing that mother will soon be gone for good. It looks at you, and then it stands on its two stubby legs, stumbling as it gets up. It walks to the edge of the baking tray, carefully navigating around its still dead – unconscious? – friends as they lie down, their backs against the aluminum’s sun-hot surface. It looks its friends in the eyes, and maybe it thinks “I’m sorry that I’m here and you’re not,” and then steps over the edge, falling down into the oven’s fiery, incomprehensible bottom. 

Clunk.

Mother? you asked, your body shaking all over. Why was she on the ground? Why were her eyes closed? She may have been asleep for all you knew. Maybe she was. Maybe–

And then they all stand up. They look like an army, all dressed in their uniform suits. One of them peers down and looks at its friend, all dismembered and burned on the oven’s floor. It looks more like charcoal than a body. They form a single file line in the middle of the tray, a gingerbread snake if you will. And one by one, each of them takes turns taking suicidal leaps off the edge, and one by one you catch their faces as they take their fatefull falls. 

“Stop crying, kid,” they all say. “Mother will be okay.”

Clunk. Clunk. Clunk.

The gingerbread charcoal pile grows and grows until it is a small mountain. In it, you see a face. Mother. And she smiles the gingerbread smile, looking at you, and you can’t tell if it is a smile of relief or a smile of scorn. But it doesn’t matter. Your mother’s smile is the thing you have always wanted the most, and if this was the way you got it then so be it. But that smile rang hollow, now devoid of any meaning, any life. An eternal reminder that mother is gone. 

And who’s to blame for that?

And yet you bake those cookies every year, forgetting that you tried the year before because the waves of memory forces their dark underbellies to recede. And every year you hope that they taste like how mother used to make.

Posted Dec 23, 2023
Share:

You must sign up or log in to submit a comment.

123 likes 64 comments

April 17, 2024 01:49

OKAY YOU ARE AMAZING I COULD READ THIS ALL DAY EVEN THO IT'S 2024!

Reply

Mariana Aguirre
March 09, 2024 01:21

Love it 👏👏👏

Reply

Nandini Shukla
February 25, 2024 13:00

A wonderful take on the prompt, congratulations! A great piece, can't wait to see more from you :)

Reply

Mark Wilhelm
February 20, 2024 05:09

Aaron, great story! My name is Wilhelm and I love to take short horror and read it on my podcast Frighteningtales.com. i’m looking for new stories for season 4 and I think this would be a nice fit. It’s got all the right ingrediants. Have a listen and if your game to let me read it write me at creepy@frighteningtales.com. Anyone can submit stories.

Reply

Popunonu N
February 07, 2024 11:00

hey i'm a small youtuber , this story is very interesting ,would you mind if i make a video and mention your work

Reply

February 01, 2024 14:56

Hey! Great Story. Can i use this story for my youtube channel. Please:|

Reply

Aaron Chin
February 02, 2024 03:55

Hi! What is your YouTube channel called? What kinds of videos do you post?

Reply

K R Elle
January 24, 2024 20:40

This was a perfect combination of creepy and sad. Reading it was like watching a scene that I couldn't look away from!

Reply

Camden Chalfant
January 22, 2024 03:08

Shoot for the moon! If you miss you hit a star!

Reply

January 12, 2024 06:12

The moral of the story "The Gingerbread Cookies" seems to revolve around the theme of coping with loss, guilt, and the complexity of emotions tied to a traumatic event. The protagonist experiences a mixture of excitement and dread while baking gingerbread cookies, a tradition that connects them to memories of their mother. However, as the cookies come to life, mirroring a traumatic incident involving the protagonist's mother, the story delves into the emotional aftermath.

The gingerbread men's reassurances to "Stop crying, kid. Mother will be okay" are both haunting and comforting, encapsulating the intricate nature of grief and the human mind's ability to cope with tragedy. The recurring act of baking the cookies every year becomes a ritual, a way to reconcile with the past and perhaps seek solace in the familiar, despite the hollow smile of the gingerbread representation of the mother.

Ultimately, the story explores the enduring impact of loss, the complex emotions tied to it, and the ways in which individuals attempt to navigate and make sense of their grief through rituals and traditions. Well Done!

Reply

Shirley Beattie
January 11, 2024 21:53

I don't know whether to be sad or amused at the plight of these little guys. But great pathos when talking about the mother and the inability to help her as she was dying. A captivating story - great job.

Reply

Zoie Herwig
January 09, 2024 00:34

I really like your story. I was just looking through the horror and I saw the words Gingerbread cookies and got curious. I started reading it and couldn't look away I got so lost in it that I couldn't hear anything around me. I really enjoyed how you could turn a child's common snack cookie into a horror. Congrats! Hope I could read more of your stories.

Reply

Chelsea Therrien
January 05, 2024 14:13

great story it was right up my ally i had been trying to find a good christmas horror story and happy new year

Reply

Emma Morgan
January 04, 2024 15:28

Im not rlly a fan of horror, but i have to admit, it was really good

Reply

Zanjabella Zoud
January 04, 2024 05:15

This story is so captivating. Short and sweet and terrifying. A very well deserved win man

Reply

Andrew Fruchtman
January 03, 2024 17:06

First story and a WIN! Nicely done. I liked that your descriptive language incorporated horror, as to set the stage for the stories unfolding.

Reply

Nina Swanson
January 03, 2024 16:54

Wow, that was a very... what's the word... creepy story! I loved it! The back and forth from thinking yum, gingerbread cookies to the creepiness of being cooked alive. I just loved it! Congratulations on your win!

Reply

Justin Brockett
January 02, 2024 02:13

What was it? Was it sugar and spice and everything nice?

- Smoothly embedded childhood rhyme.

Reply

January 01, 2024 17:27

Wow. What a story. Had me from the start.

Congrats on the win and welcome to Reedsy! 🏆 Hope to see more from you soon :)

Reply

Mia Black
January 01, 2024 12:17

This is actually a very good story and i like the words you used in it.

Reply

Anna W
December 31, 2023 21:36

wow! This was delightfully menacing. Well done! Congratulations on winning!!

Reply

Serena Luna
December 31, 2023 20:04

Have you got some more to share, or a website to read them?

Reply

Serena Luna
December 31, 2023 20:03

I loved the story and very well suited to the prompt. Good writing. Thanks!

Reply

Jeremy Stevens
December 31, 2023 18:51

Great voice. Thanks for this.

Reply

Philip Ebuluofor
December 31, 2023 14:36

Congrats. Those in the know understand far better than I do.

Reply

Tammy Mills
December 30, 2023 21:14

Loved the fast pace and the creepiness! I could see the story in my mind and that’s a BIG a plus for me! Congratulations on the win!

Reply

Reedsy | Default — Editors with Marker | 2024-05

Bring your publishing dreams to life

The world's best editors, designers, and marketers are on Reedsy. Come meet them.