If Only, If Only

Creative Nonfiction Romance Sad

Written in response to: "Write about a character who yearns for something they lost — or never had." as part of What Lingers.

TW: Suicide/self harm

Let me tell you a story.

Before

I had never met someone like him. He was perfect in every way. He was the talk of the town. Everyone loved him. School by day and house parties every night. I don't know how he managed. Girls in bikinis and strappy heels fell all over him, desperate for attention. I knew I would never be one of them. How could I? But secretly I liked him too. Just a little. Then one day, I saw him. Alone. At my favorite coffee shop, sitting at my favorite table, holding a bouquet of dark lilies. Not roses. He knew. Somehow he knew. So we sat down, and I ordered my coffee like normal. So did he. We talked. Well, I talked, and he listened. I don't remember exactly what happened, but I do know that at some point during my review of the latest book I had read, he asked me out. He said he loved the way I laughed and talked too much. He loved the way I ignored people not worth my time. I don't know how he loved that, but he did. He said he loved it all, and wanted to know if I could ever love him the same way. I said why not.

3 Days Before

He wraps his arms around me. He pulls me close. He kisses me in the passenger seat.

That day

He is gone. He walked through the same door he once held for me. He took back all of the clothes that smelled like him.

The next day

Today I saw him at the train station. It's not his fault. But it hurt. Like. Hell. I can tell he didn't sleep, and I hate to make assumptions but I know it's because I wasn't there, in his arms, to hold while he slept. My first thought was I should go over there and slap him, punch him, kill him, for doing this to me. My second thought was that I should go over there and cry, kiss him, and beg him with my whole being to forgive me for not being enough. And it's true I mean I'm not enough. And I never was. Because who wants a girl that never gave her love to another not because she didn't want to but because it just wasn't there. And who wants a girl that fell in love with love and not the one that gave it to her. But that's not true I did love him. I loved him so much it felt like hate sometimes. Like I really just wanted to hold his hand and dig my nails in. Like my heart twisted for him so hard I wanted to punch him in the face just to make him feel the kind of pain I did. That's a good word for it. Pain. All that time the love was pain. Anyways as soon as he saw me he took the other train the other way.

2 days later

His memory is seared into my very being. Into everything I do. I can't watch TV without remembering how he used to pull me onto his lap while we watched Titanic. I can't get dressed without breaking down because all my favorite shirts are all his favorite bands. I can't even sleep, because without his body I just roll into the dent he left in my mattress so I really think I need a new one. So I stare at the mirror and cry, cry, cry for the girl staring back because she looks at me and thinks I am enough but I know I'm not because he told me I'm not as he pulled his old backpack over his shoulder and didn't look back.

5 days later

I vomit into the sink. But not really. Lately there hasn't been anything to vomit up. I can't eat can't eat can't eat because he used to get all my favorite foods and now all I have is the memory of him and the way my stomach twists when I think about the alcohol I use to fill it. Empty empty empty everything in empty my head my heart my stomach my soul.

17 days later

I don't have friends anymore. They said get over him or at least try it was only a few years. Get over him you weren't married. Get over him he doesn't belong to you. I said no no no it was so much more than that. So they said get over him there will be others. Get over him this can't be healthy. I said it's not just a phase he was my everything I need him. So they said get over him or we're done. I said fine he's the only one I want anymore and that's true I would give anything to have him back. So they all left me alone in tears on the floor. Just. Like. He. Did.

20 days later

I woke up earlier in the hospital bed. The lady said I shouldn't have done something, something I don't remember what I did but she thought it was bad but I don't care because what does she know she didn't know him. Only I knew him and no one else will and I need to find him tell him the scars around my neck hurt they hurt and the alcoholin my head hurts too everything hurts. Everything hurts please come back and make it okay again you always did so please please please. What changed?

1 month later

Please please please please please please please please please please please please please please please please please please please please please please please please please please please please please. Please. Please. Please. PLEASE PLEASE PLEASE. PLEASE I NEED YOU IT ALL HURTS SO BAD PLEASE. Please. Please. please-

1 month and 1 day later

TOP STORY OF THE SEACREST WEEKLY

She was said to be a bright girl who always excelled in school. Her final says were spent with her "loving boyfriend who recently moved to Boston" says the girl's parents. Her mother and father mourn the death of their daughter, wondering what might have been had she not been pushed from the Seacrest Bridge sometime during Wednesday night. The body was searched for but not found under the Seacrest Bridge.

Posted Nov 01, 2026
Share:

You must sign up or log in to submit a comment.

1 like 0 comments

Reedsy | Default — Editors with Marker | 2024-05

Bring your publishing dreams to life

The world's best editors, designers, and marketers are on Reedsy. Come meet them.