“For fuck’s sake Sarah, watch it!” Gabriel exclaimed as soon as she slammed the car door shut. Sarah didn’t think she had used that much force, but she refrained from making any comments. Carefully, she nested the cherry pie on her lap as he backed out of their driveway.
Gabriel’s knuckles were white on the steering wheel, and it took about 10 minutes into their uncomfortably silent drive for him to finally speak.
“Sorry” was his only word. His voice was harsh, but not unkind. Just as she was expecting. Sarah didn’t reply.
10 more minutes and they were in front of his parents house. Samuel and Elisa’s car was already parked in the driveway.
“Prick took up all the space, I’m going to block him in” Gabriel mumbled. Sarah sighed patiently while her boyfriend parked exactly behind his brother’s car.
They sat in silence for a couple of minutes, watching the glimmer of the Christmas tree shining through the living room blinds. “Are you ready?” Sarah asked eventually in a small voice, cautious not to trigger him again.
Gabriel shot her an annoyed look and nodded. This time, she smoothly closed the car door behind her.
“Oh there they are!” Gabriel’s mom exclaimed as soon the door opened. “I’m glad you got this one out of the house!” His mother playfully winked at Sarah, offering her a kind smile.
“Don’t get used to it” Gabriel replied briskly, walking past his mother and into the living room.
“It’s great to see you, Pamela” Sarah quickly replied, trying her best to divert attention from Gabriel’s rudeness, but it seemed to go unnoticed. His mom pulled her into a quick embrace, not letting her smile falter for a second.
"Hey Gabe! It’s been a minute, it's good to see you” Samuel patted his brother in the back “You remember Elisa, of course” Samuel gestured to where his wife was sitting by the fire with his father.
“Obviously I remember” Gabriel shot his brother an indignant look before extending a hand to his sister-in-law “How are you doing, Elisa?”
“Been doing good, can’t complain” she replied.
“Gabriel! I have something for you, come here” His father stood from his armchair with difficulty and gestured for him to follow.
Gabriel sighed, he should have fought harder to travel to Japan with Sarah, as they had originally planned. But she insisted they came here instead. Why, he would never understand.
He looked around the room trying to locate his girlfriend before he followed his father into the kitchen. Sarah was trying to place her cherry pie on the carefully ornate dinner table, his mother gestured wildly every time Sarah suggested a placement. Pamela was probably trying to find the best place to put a shitty pie without being too obvious and suggesting the garbage can straight away.
Gabriel followed after his father and found him holding up a bottle of green wine which he had just fetched from the fridge.
“I found this in the supermarket the other day, it's the same one you had at that nice place in Lisbon last year, isn’t it? When Sarah sent the photo she mentioned you liked it!” Gabriel stared at the bottle in his dad’s hand, the condensation was building on the glass.
He didn’t recognize the wine or the tree drawing on the label, but he remembered the restaurant and how much he enjoyed the food. He remembered especially the fight he and Sarah had had that day. She had slithered her way into the family group chat not many days before, he had already been pissed at her for that, and then she started sending pictures.
Gabriel suppressed the little smile that threatened to escape his lips and swallowed the lump on his throat “Thanks, it's a lovely wine” he forced the words out.
Pamela insisted that the family gather in the living room while the turkey was finishing up in the oven.
“Oh, Sam, darling, I made you trifle this year, I know how much you love it” Pamela exclaimed as she handed Elisa a glass of apple juice.
“Oh thanks, mom,” Samuel replied. Sarah placed a careful hand on Gabriel’s leg, he rolled his eyes.
The family wasted what felt like hours on empty conversation. Gabriel had to force himself to stop shaking his leg uncontrollably at least 3 times while Sarah side eyed him with a concerned look on her face in between her fake laughs at his mother’s irrelevant comments.
“And how’s work, Gabe? Still at the agency?” his father asked at some point. Gabriel doubted Michael knew anything about his work.
“Which one?” he teased. Gabriel had been working in the same place for years, but he still feigned ignorance, if only to relish on watching the man squirm.
“Oh, you know, the one you had just joined last time” his father replied idly, rubbing the bridge of his nose.
“Michael’s memory is getting worse by the day” Pamela said with a chuckle to no one in particular. The oven pinged before Gabriel could say anything else and his mother jumped up in excitement. “Dinner’s ready! C’mon, c’mon”.
Sarah squeezed Gabriel’s thigh one more time and shot him a sad smile before they followed the rest of the family into the dining room.
“This smells really nice, Pam” Elisa beamed at Pamela who was excitedly carving into the turkey’s crispy skin.
“Thank you darling, I used your mother’s sauce recipe. I have to thank her again next time I see her, is she doing well?” Pamela smiled broadly in return.
“Oh she is great, she sends her regards” Elisa answered.
Gabriel kept his attention on the turkey. He didn’t know how much longer he could take the fakeness around him and he struggled to understand whether he was happy or livid that his family had been completely ignoring Sarah and him, probably both.
By his side, Sarah was fidgeting with the hem of her skirt. He looked over at her, appreciating the distressed look on her face that she tried to hide behind the mask of friendliness. This whole night ought to teach her, he thought bitterly. Slowly, he rested a hand on her upper thigh and rubbed it tenderly. He did feel bad for her, which only added to his stress.
By the end of the dinner, Michael left the table to pick up something he announced he had recently found on a forgotten shelf, much to the displeasure of his mother, who hated interruptions to her perfect Christmas dinner time.
“Look what I found, Sarah, I don’t think you’ve seen this yet, it's Samuel and Gabriel’s graduation day” Michael approached them with the old photo album in his hand. Gabriel’s sad teenage face stared back at him from the page, making his pulse quicken.
“Dad, please. I hate this photo” he averted his eyes back to his plate.
“Gabriel is so dramatic, he hates everything” he heard his mom mumble to Elisa in a mocking tone.
“No mother, I love many things, I just heavily disliked celebrating Samuel’s graduation the day my dog fucking died” he blurted out.
The table fell silent. Gabriel did his best to ignore all the piercing eyes he felt burning his skin, instead he stabbed a piece of turkey. He could hear his heartbeat thumping in his ears. He hadn’t meant to say it, but he couldn’t hold it in, that was how these things always went.
“Our graduation, Gabe. Don’t be dramatic, what did you want? To stay home and cry the whole day?” Samuel was frowning at him.
“Sam, please. You know your brother, there is no way around him” He heard his mother sigh, but his focus was already on his twin.
“Our graduation my ass Sam, or did you forget the congratulations cake only you got? Or the fact that we went to your favorite sushi place to celebrate ‘our’ graduation?” The words just kept coming out of him against his will. That’s why he didn’t want to come, these people brought out the worst in him.
“Not my fault you couldn’t get into college” Samuel shrugged.
“I’M ALLERGIC TO SHRIMP!” Gabriel shouted.
“What does that have to do with anything?” Pamela interfered.
“Oh dear…” came another voice.
“Goddammit Gabriel! Leave it to you to destroy a nice moment” his father slammed the photo album shut and stormed out of the room.
“I’m so sorry about this, dear” Pamela whispered to Elisa, who shook her head slightly and offered an uncomfortable smile in return.
Sarah ran a hand over her forehead nervously by his side.
“Oh please, Pamela. Elisa knows exactly what kind of family she joined, no need to play pretend” Gabriel continued.
“You know, I’m sick and tired of your grumpy act, I don’t know how Sarah puts up with you” Samuel stood, slamming his napkin on the table like it would make a statement.
“Don’t talk about my girlfriend” Gabriel stood as well. Sarah followed, pulling him by his arm
“Gabe, please” she whispered to him, but he ignored her.
“You are an ungrateful little prick, that’s what you are.” Samuel closed the distance between them, pointing a finger at his brother’s face “Our parents did everything for us our whole life. Now, your stupid dog died on our graduation day and you think you can be an asshole to everyone? Everyone who, by the way, had gone through a whole lot of effort to put together a nice celebration for us. So what if you didn’t get a cake, what are you? 8? Our parents took us out to dinner, they planned a surprise party-”
“Oh my god, I can’t believe this!” Gabriel ran his hands through his hair in frustration “That was your party, you twat! Or do you remember any of my friends being invited?” Gabriel screamed at his brother.
For a moment Samuel looked taken aback. Had Gabriel finally gotten through to him? It had been years since he had last seen his family, and the more time he spent away, the easier it was to dismiss their negligence as ingenuity. Maybe that was why Sarah had been able to convince him to join Christmas this year, maybe deep down he had hoped his family wasn’t really indifferent to him, but rather they were just naive, and didn't realize the extent to which they cast him aside.
He had always felt like the odd one out, his parents were so obvious on their dismissal of anything related to him that it drove him up the wall that they wouldn’t just admit they didn’t like him. At least that would give him closure. It wasn’t just the graduation incident. His whole life had been like this, there was always a polite dismissal of his interests, or his feelings, or his achievements. It didn’t even surprise him that his parents couldn’t bother to remember where he worked for the past 8 years, and he had no recollection of the last time his mother baked him his favorite dessert. He doubted she even knew what it was.
They were masters manipulators, at least that was what his therapist had said, because at the same time, they always found a clever way to be just the correct amount of nice to make him feel like the goddamn villain for asking for more. He felt stupid and vulnerable and so incredibly small. A person shouldn’t have to beg to be loved.
“You need to see a psychiatrist Gabriel, you are dramatic to a concerning level” Samuel said eventually. Any and all hope Gabriel had nurtured from his brother’s earlier expression faded into nothing.
“Stop this nonsense now! Gabriel, sit your ass down!” Michael shouted as soon as he returned into the room. The photo album replaced by a glass of whiskey.
“No, I can’t do this anymore. I’m not going to sit here and let you all ignore me and Sarah any longer. The only reason I’m here today is because of her, because she wanted to be a part of this fucked up family, but none of you asked her a single question. Have you even noticed?!” Gabriel was fuming, he was sure he looked a bit unhinged, but at this point he didn’t care. This was ridiculous, he thought, these people needed to own up to their awful behaviour and he wasn’t going to let it slide this time.
He watched his mother’s eye widen slightly, her attention shifted to Sarah. If there was one thing Pamela hated was to be a bad hostess, he secretly hoped she died of mortification.
“I’m sorry, Sarah dear, we’ve been… distracted-” Pamela’s eyes flitted to Gabriel and back before she finished her sentence.
“No no no, don’t pretend like it’s all my fault that you neglected to care about anything or anyone in my life.” Gabriel interjected.
“Ok, that’s enough!” Samuel slammed down his chair and strode for the kitchen, his wife quickly followed after him. A moment later, so did his father.
Pamela dropped her head and sighed, eyes closed and hand clasped on her lap. Gabriel didn’t move. He could hear Sarah’s uneven breath by his side. Raised voices sounded from the kitchen, but he couldn’t make out what was being said. As the seconds passed, Gabriel’s heart thrummed back to normal.
Eventually he sat down. Once again, he felt stupid for bringing any of this up, it’s not like it was the first time he had made his discontent clear with the way his parents had always favoured Samuel, it had driven him away from his family and talking about it only made him feel guilty for that as well.
The voices from the kitchen dissipated slowly, his mother had resumed her dinner in silence, Sarah sipped her wine in small uncomfortable gulps. Gabriel refilled her cup and they shared an apologetic look.
Suddenly a laugh rippled through the house, his mother’s eye shot up just in time to see Elisa walk back into the dining room with a sweet smile on her face.
“Everything ok?” His mother asked.
“Yes, the boys will come out soon” Elisa answered unobothered. That woman fit right into their family, Gabriel thought, with her ability to pretend like nothing was ever amiss.
A few moments later his brother and his father came out as well, their faces distorted into stupid happy smiles, the latter was carrying the tray of trifle. Gabriel watched as his mother’s gleam returned to her eyes.
“Oh good! You brought the desert. I think we all need some sweet treat” Pamela was right back into hostess mode. Gabriel watched as the whole room carried on like nothing had happened, like he wasn’t even there. Little dishes of trifle were served, his dumbfounded look matched Sarah’s as they watched the scene unravel in front of them.
There weren’t many situations that rendered him speechless, but watching his family brush over an argument of that level had achieved it.
“I need to apologize” Samuel addressed the room suddenly. Gabriel’s attention shifted to his brother, the mood changed instantly, as if everyone had finally agreed to address the palpable tense atmosphere that was still lingering in the room.
“I shouldn’t have shouted earlier, I know it caused a lot of stress and stress is not something we can afford right now…” he paused.
Gabriel squinted his eyes, what the hell was he on about? He roamed his eyes across all the equally puzzled faces in the room until they landed on Elisa’s broad smile, a slight shade of pink had crept up her cheeks.
“We are expecting!” Samuel announced.
The room erupted in celebration, his mother hugged Elisa, his father embraced his brother, shouts of ‘oh my god’ and ‘this is a blessing’ overtook the table.
Gabriel couldn’t feel his face, but he was sure his shock was written on it. He felt Sarah’s hand grip his knee under the table before he heard her offer her clipped congratulations to Elisa across the table.
“I have just the thing to celebrate!” his father announced over his shoulder as he made his way into the kitchen. He came back carrying a bottle of green wine with a tree drawing on the label that Gabriel instantly recognized.
You must sign up or log in to submit a comment.
A very well written story. Family expectations and tensions are well brought out. Poor Gabriel!!
Reply
Christmas energy too right? Hahaha thank you for your comment!
Reply