The Cricket's Summer Song

Drama Fiction Horror

Written in response to: "Start or end your story with a strange and/or persistent sound." as part of What Keeps You Up at Night.

The first chirps meant nothing.

A summer night. An open window. A lakeside breeze. A cricket’s merry song. 

I kicked off the quilt to luxuriate in the night. Maggie snored lightly on the other twin bed. The cottage was quiet. Alex, Sydney and Mia slept downstairs.

2:17 a.m. 

I remember checking my phone in a drowsy haze, hoping for several more hours of sleep. My eyelids grew heavy with the cricket’s chirps.

And then, the chirps changed. 

My eyes snapped open, body rigid. Shriek. Desperation. Help. 

And this — the rhythm never changed.

It was still a cricket’s chirp.

Chirp. Chirp. Chirp.

I ran to the window but saw nothing in the dark. I pulled the cord on the overhead light and scanned the room. Nothing. Heart pounding, I opened the door.

“Kate…what’s going on? Are you ok?” Maggie sat up in bed blinking.

“What is that?” I felt my breath shallow, rapid.

“What is what? What are you talking about?” 

I scanned the room, putting my hands over my ears. 

“That noise! The cricket!”

“Cricket? What?” Maggie pushed back the covers and went to the window.

What wasn’t she getting?

“I don’t know! I don't know what it is! Something’s hurt — I DON’T KNOW WHERE IT’S COMING FROM!” I shouted to be heard over the cries. 

Then things went hazy. I have this sense of worried voices, arms around me as the chirps (screams? cries? I never know what to call them) went on. 

When I woke, sunshine filled the room. I could hear children laughing outside. Maggie was perched on the daybed with a magazine, peering at me. 

“Kate? Are you awake?” 

“Ummmm…yeah.”

“How are you feeling?” 

“Ummmm — ok? What time is it?” 

“1:30.” She went to the door and called out. “She’s awake!”

I heard feet on the stairs. Alex, Sydney and Mia appeared, looking serious.

“Are you ok? How are you feeling? What happened last night?” 

Oh God, there it was. I could hear the cries again. Different this time. More like an echo. My face felt hot.

“You didn’t hear anything?” They all shook their heads. 

“Nothing.”

“It was really calm, super-quiet.”

“What did you hear?”

I tried to explain, but I could see the doubt in the glances that slid toward each other. 

“Do you hear anything now?”

I did. 

“No.”

Maggie shrugged. “It was probably just a nightmare.”

“You didn’t take anything, did you?” Alex asked. 

“No. Nothing.”

The nightmare explanation seemed to satisfy everyone. We went out to dinner, shopping on the boardwalk, ice cream, sunset, wine around the fire. All the while, the cries echoed through me. Steady, relentless, but more distant somehow. 

2:17. 

They came back. Shrill. Plaintive. Urgent. Where were they coming from? I ripped the covers off my bed, crawled underneath, pulled the curtains off the rod, threw everything out of the shower and looked down the drain. I ran downstairs, outside. Pulled bushes apart, dug through the dirt. But nothing. Nothing. Nothing. Nothing. 

“You must hear it. You have to!” I shouted at my friends who — I think — trailed me at a distance.

I remember covering my ears. Begging the sound to stop. As the sky began to lighten, the cries started to fade, little by little. But never entirely.

When I woke in the afternoon, no one was in the house. They’d left a note. “Went sailing, get some rest.” I went back to bed, tears running down my face. 

Sunday was our last night in the house. Maggie slept downstairs. I didn’t sleep, frozen in the dark, waiting for 2:17. I don’t want to write it again. You know what happened.

The drive back to the city the next day was quiet except for the cries echoing in my mind. I closed my eyes, pretending to sleep.

That night, back in my own apartment, I paced. I watched TV. I sat on the couch. Waited for 2:17. It came and went with the cries remaining muffled, almost sounding like cricket chirps. The same happened the next night. And the next. And the next. It was going away, I was going to be ok. Still, I saw my doctor. He referred me to a psychiatrist. Conclusion: “generalized anxiety.” They sent me home with Xanax. 

I met up with my friends. They smiled, laughed, looked relieved and for a time, everything seemed close to normal. What I didn’t tell them is that I still heard it in that haunting, echoing way. 

We went back to the lake house the next month. No one mentioned the incidents, but I noticed Maggie stayed downstairs. I climbed into bed tense, heart pounding, window closed, lights on. Earplugs in. Oh, the cries were still there, living in me, always in the background, but damned if I wasn’t going to live with it. “It’ll be fine. It’s just anxiety. You’re fine now. It’ll be fine.” 

2:17. 

The cry shrieked. Over and over again. Even louder, even more desperate than before. The closet? For a second, I had the sense of watching myself rip open the closet door and throw everything out of it, scratching and pulling at the drywall. “Where are you? Where are you? Where are you?” Nothing. Nothing. Always nothing. But the sound was deafening. 

I stared at the destruction. My fingers shook so hard that I almost couldn’t call an Uber. If the others were awake — how could they not be — they didn’t stop me. By 3 a.m., I was gone. The further we were, the more the cries faded. But not entirely.

That was thirty years ago. 

I never heard from my friends again. I never returned to that house. I never heard those cries again, not like that. Still, I heard them constantly. Distant, calling. Some moments are as innocent as a cricket’s chirp, and others shrill and desperate. Why don’t you try therapy? I can hear you asking. Oh friend, come look at my dresser covered with bottles, half-filled with pills that never worked. Can you see the stacks of folders and books lining my walls, filling the tables? That’s decades of research on all of it. Can you see that I moved about as far away as—

What’s that? 

Can you hear it? 

No, of course you can’t.

Posted Sep 18, 2026
Share:

You must sign up or log in to submit a comment.

8 likes 6 comments

The Old Izbushka
September 21, 2026 12:53

What really struck me is that Kate can never escape it and will never know the truth. Is it real? Is it imagined? That's what makes it so unsettling for me --- I loved that the ending never fully answers the question and keeps the mystery alive long after the story is over. Nicely written!

Reply

Kristin Neubauer
September 23, 2026 14:26

Thank you so much for taking the time to read it and offer your thoughts! Apologies for my slow response - the past couple of days have gotten away from me. The theme of uncertainty has been a big one for me lately. Like most people, sitting with uncertainty is usually unsettling and can be down right scary at times. I think most of us have a predilection to resolve things. But what if something is unresolvable? This story started with an annoying cricket in my closet last week and worked its way to this. Hearing your thoughts is very helpful - I really appreciate it!

Reply

Louise Chambers
September 19, 2026 22:19

I really enjoyed this story. The short snappy sentences kept the pace and momentum and the repetition of 2.17 worked well with the constant chirps and desperate shrills. It added to the suspense and the creepy vibe. I felt sorry for Kate never finding out where the chirps were coming from or why. The final line leaves you wondering…

Reply

Kristin Neubauer
September 20, 2026 11:33

Thank you, Louise! I was really interested in this idea of Kate being plagued by this horrible sound for life with no explanation. I imagine that would be so unsettling, so isolating....like living in a nightmare. Also, thank you for the feedback on the short sentence structure. I am working hard to compress my writing. To make sure each word carries purpose and value....to give the reader enough for satisfaction, but to also leave room for the reader's imagination. It feels awkward and clumsy now, but I'm going to keep at it!

Reply

Marjolein Greebe
September 19, 2026 13:27

The repetition of 2:17 and that relentless chirping created such an unsettling rhythm. I especially liked that you never fully explain it — the final “No, of course you can’t” leaves exactly the right kind of chill.

Reply

Kristin Neubauer
September 19, 2026 14:38

Thank you so much! I never explain it because I couldn't explain it - thank goodness ambiguity is acceptable in writing. This was inspired by a cricket that was chirping in my closet last week. Those chirps are eerie to me. I remember years ago in the final weeks of my elderly dog's life, I'd lay with her in the living room at night and hear a cricket outside the front door all night long. It represented something very mournful to me, which all came back as I wrote this one. I appreciate you taking the time to read and give feedback - super-helpful!

Reply

Reedsy | Default — Editors with Marker | 2024-05

Bring your publishing dreams to life

The world's best editors, designers, and marketers are on Reedsy. Come meet them.