Your hands trembled as they reached through the car window for the dollar bills, cracked and weathered now, the same hands that once shot three pointers and palmed exam cheat sheets with ease.
I remember those hands from seventh grade, carrying your tray at lunch period, when you sat down at my empty table without asking. Not the popular kids’ table where you belonged, but mine, the one by the emergency exit where I ate alone and sketched in the margins of my notebook.
“You drew that?” you asked, pointing at my cartoon of the lunch lady as a dragon hoarding tater tots.
I’d nodded, waiting for the mockery that was to come.
Instead, you laughed, not at me, but with genuine delight. “That’s sick. Draw Coach Patterson as a troll.”
I did, right there on a napkin. You grabbed it, ran over to the basketball team’s table, and held it up. They erupted. Even Coach Patterson, walking by, shook his head with a grudging smile. You came back grinning. “Do the principal next.”
After that, you just kept sitting with me, recruiting me for increasingly elaborate pranks with my drawings as the blueprint, your popularity used as a shield when we got caught. Your basketball friends would call you over, confused why their star point guard kept hanging with the weird art kid, but you’d wave them off. “I’m good here”, you would say
We became inseparable. Not because we were alike. You were the athlete, the one who was a sought after recruit while I fumbled through gym class. I was the artist, the one who could forge our parents’ signatures with surgical precision. You had the charisma to talk us out of trouble; I had the creativity to get us into it. We balanced each other perfectly, two halves of something neither of us could have been alone.
The summer before junior year, we built a treehouse in your backyard using scavenged plywood and some nails from your dad’s garage. It took us three weeks, working in the brutal heat, splinters embedding themselves in our palms, mosquitoes feasting on our necks. Your mom brought us lemonade and sandwiches, calling us her “construction crew.” She was healthy then, laughing at our crooked measurements, teasing you about your terrible hammering technique. We spent nights up there after it was finished, legs dangling through the hatch, sharing contraband weed that made us dizzy and philosophical. You told me about your dreams then. Europe first. You wanted to see the Eiffel Tower, the Colosseum, all those places from the history books we never read. Then Asia, South America, anywhere that basketball scouts might notice you, everywhere life felt bigger than this dying mill town.
“I’m getting out,” you’d said, flicking ash into the yard below. “We both are. You’ll design something famous, I’ll play overseas. We’ll send postcards to all these assholes.”
I believed you.
Junior year, when your mom got sick, I watched those dreams begin to fold in on themselves. You started missing practice, then games. The scouts stopped calling. Senior year you took the night shift at the bottling plant, still trying to finish school, coming to the parking lot before first period with bags under your eyes that made you look decades older.
“Just temporary,” you insisted, meeting me there each morning, sharing a breakfast burrito and pretending everything was normal. “Soon as Mom’s back on her feet.”
But she never got back on her feet. By Thanksgiving, you were working double shifts. By Christmas, you’d stopped showing up entirely. Dropped out to work full-time. I called, you didn’t answer. I showed up at your house, your dad said you were sleeping. The distance grew, not from anger, but from the weight of everything unsaid between us. Your mom didn’t get better. The funeral was small. I attended, stood in the back, didn’t know what to say. I left for state college with a scholarship while you stayed behind, tied to obligations I couldn’t begin to understand.
And now I see you at the stoplight, your frame gaunt beneath a stained jacket, beard unkempt, and I was flooded with images of our shared detentions and elaborate pranks colliding with the sight of your hollow eyes, your cardboard sign with its desperate Sharpie plea. The car ahead of me pulled away, and you lowered the dollar bills into a coffee can with a practiced motion that broke something in me.
The light turned green.
I wanted to call your name, but what would I say? That I remember when you dreamed of traveling the world, when you turned my drawings into legendary pranks? That I’m sorry I went to college and sent only a few texts that you never returned? That I drove through town twice a month to visit my parents and never once stopped to seek you out, telling myself you probably didn’t want to see me anyway?
My foot hovered over the brake. So close yet so far. Separated by only a few feet of asphalt but a gulf of circumstance. I could roll down the window. Hand you money, sure, but also—what? My number? An invitation to coffee? And you’d stand there, holding your cardboard sign, forced to smile and pretend we were still friends while I pretended this was anything other than pity. You’d have to thank me, maybe even hug me, while inside you catalogued everything I had that you didn’t. The clean car, the full tank of gas, the college degree, the fact that I could drive away.
I couldn’t do that to you. Couldn’t make you perform gratitude for my guilt.
Instead, I drove on, leaving you in my rearview, smaller with each passing block until you disappeared completely. The treehouse probably rotted years ago. The postcards we never sent remained fantasy. And I, the one who escaped, couldn’t even muster the courage to look you in the eye and acknowledge that once upon a time, you’d made me visible when I was invisible.
You must sign up or log in to submit a comment.
Such a heart-touching, poignant piece. Almost made me cry :(
Reply
Thank you Aria, for taking the time to comment. I'm glad you enjoyed the story
Reply
This was a very good story. It was really, really gut-wrenching, but honestly, I love stories like these. Amazing job!
Reply
Thank you Lilyana, for taking the time to comment. Glad you liked the story
Reply
I don't like the way this story makes me feel, guilty, sad. But I think that's the beauty of it. Its real, something that could happen to anyone we know or maybe even ourselves. Beautifully written!
Reply
Thank you H.M., for taking the time to comment. Probably the highest compliment a writer can receive is that the reader felt something. Thank you
Reply
This is really good, Scott. This is really sad but in such a good way. The way the guilt is painted is just beautiful. Just an amazing job.
Reply
Thank you Hazel, for taking the time to comment. I tried to lend some humanity to the guilty, but perhaps he doesn't deserve any
Reply
Beautifully written, I was left feeling quite sad for both. Guilt makes us do strange things, whether or not we think it's the right choice at the time. Story is very grounded, very real, and all the more painful for it. Great use of second PPOV too!
Reply
Thank you Tai, for taking the time to comment. Yes guilt is confusing, sometimes warranted, sometimes not. In this story, I think guilt is the appropriate response
Reply
You did great ❤️ love the story
Reply
Thank you Rebecca
Reply
What a conundrum of a story! Sad in so many ways. I almost wonder about afterwards -does he return to that same street again to check on his wayward friend? An excellent and succinct read that nails the prompt. Well done.
Reply
Thank you Elizabeth for taking the time to comment. We will never know what happens afterwards, unless of course it's a fit for another prompt
Reply
Wow, such a beautiful story.
Reply
Thank You T'keyah
Reply
Great story! Well done.
Reply
Thank You Helen
Reply