Mitzee’s Moment

🏆 Contest #187 Winner!

Fiction

Written in response to: "Set your story in a cat shelter." as part of Cat People.

Mitzee was in prison for a crime he did not commit.


Well, OK, he probably had committed it once or twice. Who knew? Who kept count? But he was very sure that he had been incarcerated now because of something he didn’t do. He glared through the prison bars, plotting. He was Houdini, Al Capone, and Einstein rolled into one. There was nothing he couldn’t do… except break out of this prison, apparently.


If looks could kill, there would be no one left alive in this joint. If he could get out, he’d make each and every one of them sorry they were born. So he sat and glared, the unblinking, one eyed glare that unnerved his enemies. No one stayed before his cell for long. They moved on quickly, repulsed by his battered visage and death ray glare from his single working eye.


He looked around at his fellow inmates. Some lay resigned to their fate, their eyes blank with despair, others shivered and cried, wailing at their fate with terror. The two brothers in the cell on the end of the opposite row cried in fear. They were barely legal, mere babes, and he wondered what was their heinous crime? What had they done to be sent here to maximum security? Perhaps they were framed.


Directly across from him was Snow. Butter wouldn’t melt in her mouth, and she reclined like a queen surveying her subjects. She knew how to work the system, all the guards bent to her will, as she slowly batted her lashes in their direction, purring her delight to see them again. She was a master at manipulation, that one. He’d met her more than once or twice on the outside, and they’d even had a thing going for a while. She looked sweet and innocent, but she was tough as nails. They had worked one joint together in the old days. She was sleek and fast, in and out with her purloined goods. He had been the scout that time, surveying the joint, ready to set off the alarm or create a distraction. Snow had shared the loot, she was an alright sort. Just don’t get on her bad side, or she’d cut you without remorse.


A smaller visitor stopped before his cell, eyes wide with an emotion Mitzee could not name. Horror? Fright? Disgust? Pick one. He gave the small visitor his best one eyed glare and accompanied it with a snarling growl. The visitor moved on, just as he liked it. He enjoyed being alone. He really did. Less to worry about, less to factor into a daily plan, and Mitzee had a plan. Bath, eat, glare. It worked for him. There was nothing else to do. He was on the countdown to death-row, and he knew it. Not much point worrying about it, not much point wailing. Bath, eat, glare. Right until the end.


Snow obviously had other plans. She simpered in her cell as the small visitor passed, flirting shamelessly. She was a chameleon, good at becoming what she needed to be to survive. Mitzee was just too old for it, it took too much energy, but good for her. Snow’s antics entranced the small visitor and she wound herself sinuously into convoluted dance steps that were designed to hypnotise and mesmerise the audience. Captive became captor, and soon Snow was free. God, she was good! From her small, transportable travel cell, she crowed triumphantly. Off to minimum security prison for her. Mitzee wondered how long it would be before Snow busted out. He reckoned she’d be back here within a month, but it was unlikely he’d still be here to see her. He sent her his best ‘well f*ck off and to hell with you’ glare. She smiled like a cat who got the cream. Good to know they still understood one another, he thought.


The prison guards came and went, his cell was cleaned on a regular rotation and the litter was removed and replaced. If he didn’t dream of freedom, of following the butcher bird in the early morning dawn and pitting his wits against the noisy little bugger, he’d be happy, or at least content. But freedom was as long gone as his eye. This was it for him, and he knew it.


He watched as each inmate got their reprieve, their chance at freedom that was precariously perched in the hands of unsuspecting visitors, victims if you will. But no one came for Mitzee.


“I’m unlovable,” he thought to himself with a kind of twisted pride. “I have a face that only a mother could love, and I never knew my mother.”


“Mommy, look, this kitty’s only got one eye!”


Mitzee opened said eye and glared at the little visitor. She wore a patch over her half her face, and the eye that was visible stared into his cell with interest. He hissed and glared, showing all his teeth. The little visitor’s mouth opened wide, showing him all her teeth too. Mitzee was impressed. Some teeth were missing. This little visitor was a scrapper. Must have fought many battles to be so scarred and toothless.


“I want this one.”


“Honey, don’t you think you should have a good look around? This one’s quite old, and he looks quite beat up!”


The little visitor turned her head to glare at the older one who spoke. Mitzee was at once amazed and enchanted. The glare was awe-inspiring, and it obviously came naturally to her.


“Well, if you’re sure. How about we ask the staff about him?”


Soon Mitzee found himself in a room he had never been in before, but had seen other inmates enter—the meet and greet room. It was strange to be in such wide open spaces again and he crept slowly, stomach low to the floor, poised and ready to leap out of harm’s way at any given second. The little visitor sat cross-legged in the middle of the floor and beckoned with treats and soft noises. Treats! Mitzee had never seen or smelled treats, and, against his better nature, he was intrigued.


“He likes me.”


“It would seem so,” the prison attendant said in amazement. “I’ve never seen old Mitzee cuddle up to anyone before. He’s usually the spitting, hissing kind of cat. We thought to re-home him as a barn cat. Are you sure you want this one?”


The little visitor looked Mitzee in the eye, single eye to single eye. “He’s just like me. He knows how to feel different from everyone else.”


“If that’s what you want to believe, little visitor, who am I to disagree?” Mitzee thought to himself, but outwardly he purred.


For the first time in his life, Mitzee was bundled into the transportable travel cell. This was his big moment, the one he never thought to have. He was off to minimum security. The little visitor babbled about a new home, a bed, food and toys. It all sounded so good, so warm and loving to Mitzee. He yowled a long, “Goodbye suckers!” to the inmates still incarcerated as he was bundled out through the doors, before being settled into the back seat of a car.


He yawned as he watched the scenery flash past, and already he was planning his big escape. His single eye twinkled with glee.

Posted Feb 26, 2023
Share:

You must sign up or log in to submit a comment.

208 likes 226 comments

Yen G
March 10, 2023 20:02

I love this story! It's so cute and humorous. I love Mitzee. You would think for him to be the bad guy, so I love that he actually got the love he deserved :)

Adorable story! I have to read your other ones! :DD

Reply

Michelle Oliver
March 10, 2023 22:51

Thanks Yen, he’s a pretty tough cat, but perhaps he is just a soft ball of fluff inside.

Reply

LEVI WOOD
March 10, 2023 19:59

CONGRATS ON THE WIN!

Reply

Michelle Oliver
March 10, 2023 22:51

Thank you!

Reply

Richard E. Gower
March 10, 2023 19:35

Congratulations and well done! You really got into Mitzee's head.-:)

RG

Reply

Michelle Oliver
March 10, 2023 19:40

Thank you for reading about Mitzee and I’m glad you enjoyed the little scamp!

Reply

March 10, 2023 19:29

I like to think that despite Mitzee's plan to escape from his new home, that he will soften with some love from a little one that understands his issues. I am betting that he settles in to a lovely new life.

Reply

Michelle Oliver
March 10, 2023 19:33

I’d like to think that too, thanks for reading about this little scamp

Reply

Frances Gaudiano
March 10, 2023 19:22

I loved your story. I've worked with animals for 30 years and you have got this type of cat exactly.

Reply

Michelle Oliver
March 10, 2023 19:34

Thanks for reading, I’m glad you enjoyed it.

Reply

March 10, 2023 19:01

Great characterization, charming story.

Reply

Michelle Oliver
March 10, 2023 19:34

Thank you

Reply

Kathryn Kahn
March 10, 2023 18:28

What a wonderful story! Mitzee's personality is so clear. You've made a little work of art that is both poignant and humorous. Brava! I really enjoyed reading it. And congratulations on your win. It's well-deserved.

Reply

Michelle Oliver
March 10, 2023 19:37

Thank you so much.

Reply

John Del Rio
March 10, 2023 18:16

Of course I have to give the obligatory "well deserved win" sentiment. This is easy because it's true. Very enjoyable story. Well written:and capturing the various feline spirits and personalities successfully make it more enjoyable still.
I can see Mitzi planning his escape, and postponing it over and over until he does actually bond with the little scrapper who chose/freed him.
I will read more of your stories when I can. Thank you foe this.

Reply

Michelle Oliver
March 11, 2023 01:13

Yes Mitzee would probably have at least a dozen grand escape plans, that would need to be postponed due to one reason or another. Perhaps this will be the plot of the sequel. Thanks for reading it.

Reply

John Del Rio
March 11, 2023 05:05

I look forward to the sequel

Reply

Simone J Fry
March 10, 2023 18:13

A big congratulations on your win Michelle. Well done!

Reply

Michelle Oliver
March 11, 2023 01:13

Thank you

Reply

Susan Catucci
March 09, 2023 01:03

Nice job, Michelle. Mitzee is a force to be reckoned with, the kind of scamp that can get in its own way because of attitude - palatable, fearless and don't tell me what to do! For some, it works as a defense; others, it's borne out of fear or insecurity. But, delving into a cat's mind? I'd surmise it's win me over, bitch! And, I'm thinking, at the right hand of the right human? Shall will be done!

Mitzee could have a sequel and a prequel I'd be interested in. Just a thought (and a compliment)!

Reply

Michelle Oliver
March 09, 2023 11:00

Mitzee, the sequel… hmm maybe.
Thanks for reading and I’m glad you enjoyed this little scamp.

Reply

Susan Catucci
March 10, 2023 17:12

YAY! Congratulations, Michelle! Talk about a force to be reckoned with, eh? That makes YOU a force to be reckoned with as well! I'm so happy for you. Keep writing!

Reply

Michelle Oliver
March 11, 2023 01:10

Thank you! Wow.

Reply

Michelle Oliver
March 12, 2023 11:18

You inspired me Susan, I posted a prequel. Not quite as charming as the original, but hey it’s there!

Reply

Mary Bendickson
March 08, 2023 06:01

We had to leave our ferocious bob-tailed cat, Bob, in a fancy cat hotel once. It had walls of glass fronted mini rooms with all the comforts of home for the cats to lounge in and they got individual playtime in the big room a couple of times a day. The report we got from the staff when we returned after a week was Bob acted exactly like Mitzee except kept his back on display and wouldn't come out to play. He never let anyone touch him and hissed at anyone who tried. He was fairly young at the time and has had an attitude ever since.

Reply

Michelle Oliver
March 08, 2023 06:59

Some cats have extra sass don’t they! Thanks for reading Mitzee’s story and I am glad you enjoyed it.

Reply

Mary Bendickson
March 10, 2023 17:57

Congrats on a well deserved win!

Reply

Michelle Oliver
March 11, 2023 01:19

Thank you!

Reply

Tara Leigh Parks
March 07, 2023 15:15

This has a wonderful pulp fiction style to it, especially when read aloud. For instance:

the joint line
the description of the "prison" and "crimes"
description of Snow

Your narrative is tight and active which engaged me right off. Strong character development. This is a fun, unique piece with just enough sadness to remind readers about shelters in general though this shelter doesn't seem awful because at least they planned to re-home him as a barn cat.

Last fall, I adopted a dog from a shelter and it's been a hard road. Jake's hard to handle. Not sure what happened to him before. He's young and I kind of think he might've been in the shelter the first year of his life. The shelter staff claimed no knowledge of his past; I think they just wanted to get rid of him. But this story made me think about all the adoptions I've done and the strays I've taken in over my life. First seeing the "kids". Good memories.

Reply

Michelle Oliver
March 07, 2023 22:49

Thanks for reading it. I am glad you enjoyed the story. Adopting from shelters is a risk, in terms of the fact that the animal comes with issues, but we all have issues! Those of us who take the time to love these slightly “used and possibly abused” animals can reap such huge benefits. Good luck with your Jake and just keep loving him.

Reply

Ren Sabo
March 06, 2023 18:32

Funny my cat growing up was Mitsy. Sweet write!

Reply

Michelle Oliver
March 06, 2023 22:36

Hi Ren. I wanted a common cute cat name, but played around with the spelling in a deliberate attempt to make it seem as if he had a tough life… you know toughen the name a bit. Mitzi looked too hard, Mitsy too soft so I went with something in the middle. Also the different spelling hopefully suggested that he’d never been loved enough to get the correct spelling. The shelter had named him, and they probably had thousands of cats with the same name, so to differentiate, they had to get creative with spelling. Yeah, perhaps I overthink things!

Anyway thanks for reading about the Mitzee and for leaving a response.

Reply

Stevie Burges
March 06, 2023 05:06

Loved it, loved it. I was totally sucked into Mitzee and his life; I felt for him. I loved that he and the little girl were so alike in so many ways - well-written and great observations.
Not being the author, I am convinced that Mitzee stayed - that attitude of his never got any better - but he and his new little girl totally bonded - and there we go: 'and lived happily ever after'!
Thanks so much for writing.

Reply

Michelle Oliver
March 06, 2023 05:23

I think you could be right. Even this author doesn’t know if he stays with his new family, but I’m hoping he knows what’s good for him! Thanks for reading it

Reply

Irene Duchess
March 06, 2023 03:24

did Mitzee ever escape? or did he learn to like his new life? :)

Reply

Michelle Oliver
March 06, 2023 03:40

I don’t know, I bet he tried to escape a few times. Hard to teach an old dog(cat) new tricks, so to speak. I’m hoping he just got fat and comfortable in his new life.

Reply

Irene Duchess
March 06, 2023 04:02

it is hard to teach an old animal. lol

Reply

March 06, 2023 02:56

I loved this story! I was sucked in from the very start, and I instantly fell in love with the character. Very well done!

I loved this line:

"If looks could kill, there would be no one left alive in this joint."

Reply

Michelle Oliver
March 06, 2023 03:03

Thank you for reading and responding. I enjoyed writing this lovely little scamp of a Tom cat.

Reply

Marty B
March 06, 2023 02:12

I like all the prison analogies this prompt unleashed.

What did the cat do to deserve such punishment, he doesn't even know! To me it sounds like profiling the one-eyed rough looking cat. I hope he breaks free of his most recent half-way. Can't trust those little kids-
Free the inmates!

Reply

Michelle Oliver
March 06, 2023 03:06

Mitzee agrees with you! Thanks for reading.

Reply

LEVI WOOD
March 05, 2023 20:51

I just read the story a second time and regret nothing.
I LOVE THIS.

Reply

Nathaniel Miller
March 05, 2023 04:32

Really great take on the prompt, Michelle!

Fascinating to see a cat shelter equated with a maximum security prison. A different perspective and one that feels realistic, thought-out. Well done. I thought Mitzee's character was nicely developed, too; equating him with all the geniuses - criminal and not - in the beginning was a masterful touch.

Also, as a bit of a grammar nut myself, I'd like to thank you for crafting a story where all the technical parts work. No grammar errors I caught; I know grammar is such a small part of a story but it bugs me so much when people get it wrong. So thank you, from the bottom of my heart, for not getting it wrong.

Great story, well-crafted... really just good on all the fronts. Thanks for sharing!

Reply

Michelle Oliver
March 05, 2023 05:06

Hi Nathaniel.

Mitzee was a great character to write, so I am glad that you enjoyed him.

As far as grammar goes, I do understand being a grammar nut. I do try, and sometimes I get it wrong, so I’m happy to have eagle eyes looking for those errors. Sometimes the errors are stylistic and intentional in order to show character, other times they are a result of poor typing skills and an auto correct gone mad.

Thanks for reading.

Reply

Nathaniel Miller
March 11, 2023 00:52

Many congrats on the win!

Reply

Michelle Oliver
March 11, 2023 00:54

Thanks!

Reply

Valerie Shand
March 04, 2023 22:34

I find myself wishing Mitzee would give this little girl and the chance for a happy, forever home a try, so I found your ending very sad. I hope his plans for a big escape come to nothing because he is loved and cared for enough to change his plans.

Reply

Michelle Oliver
March 04, 2023 22:38

Yes let’s hope he knows what’s good for him! Thanks for taking the time to read the story.

Reply

Zack Powell
March 04, 2023 22:21

What a fun direction to take this prompt! Equating a cat shelter to a maximum security prison? Writing the strays animals as inmates? Yeah, I really enjoy this setup.

It's a clever bait-and-switch, too. Had I not seen the prompt beforehand, like if this had been in a short story collection or an anthology or something, I would've thought this was a completely different kind of narrative. And yet, there are a lot of clues that let you know the what/when/where of the situation, which is why this story succeeds. It's not being gimmicky for the sake of being gimmicky; it's making a statement something bigger by Mitzee and company being stand-ins for the incarcerated. I'm here for that.

And on top of that, Mitzee's character is great. He has that 'hardened criminal' vibe to the narration, and the voice really sells me on the story. Plus, I appreciate the missing eye thing as being symbolic of him 'lacking' something - fill in the blank for what that something is: a home, love, etc. No wrong answers.

Great story, Michelle. Don't have any constructive critiques for you - I enjoyed my time here. Thanks for sharing this, and best of luck in the contest.

P.S. My favorite line (well, it's more than one line, I guess) was: "The little visitor’s mouth opened wide, showing him all her teeth too. Mitzee was impressed. Some teeth were missing. This little visitor was a scrapper. Must have fought many battles to be so scarred and toothless." (Really like the parallel between Mitzee and the child.)

Reply

Michelle Oliver
March 04, 2023 22:30

Thank you for your feedback. I enjoyed writing about this tough Tom cat. As always your reviews are so thoughtful and deep. I’m glad the prison narrative didn’t come across as gimmicky.
The line you picked was one of my favourite too. The idea that the child ad the cat were both missing something and perhaps they could connect through that .

Reply

Zack Powell
March 10, 2023 17:05

Michelle! Huge congrats on the win! Wishing you many more. You're on fire with these stories. Keep it up!

Reply

Michelle Oliver
March 11, 2023 01:11

Thank you!

Reply

Jennifer Brown
March 04, 2023 15:57

I really loved this one. Mitzee is a gem and I love him. The way he's already trying to plan his escape at the end. Though surely once he's being spoiled and pampered he'll forget those plans.

Reply

Michelle Oliver
March 04, 2023 22:36

Let’s hope Mitzee stays put, it really will be better for his health! Thanks for reading and I am glad you like the story

Reply

March 03, 2023 21:12

Wow. That's all I can say.
This is such a great story, I can't believe it!.
Great Story:)

Reply

Michelle Oliver
March 03, 2023 22:31

Thank you. I’m glad you enjoyed it.

Reply

Sophia Gavasheli
March 02, 2023 17:47

Oh, this was cute! I love how Mitzee thinks that he's in a prison (which, he is) but from a human perspective, it's funny because we don't see cat shelters as prisons. I feel like Snow and Mitzee really spring off the page as characters, and their escapades were particularly entertaining. And of course, the heartwarming moment where Mitzee and a human bond (sort of). Maybe he'll grow to like her and won't try to escape...

My favorite lines:
- "If looks could kill, there would be no one left alive in this joint."
- "Butter wouldn’t melt in her mouth, and she reclined like a queen surveying her subjects."

Reply

Michelle Oliver
March 02, 2023 21:58

Thanks for reading it and I’m glad you enjoyed the characters. They were definitely little scamps.

Reply

Kerry Batchelder
February 28, 2023 03:30

I really enjoyed your story. Great description and what an element of surprise at the end. I love the last sentence which fully describes Mittzee’s outlook on being held captive.

Reply

Michelle Oliver
February 28, 2023 10:59

Thanks Kerry, I had fun with Mitzee. I’m happy you enjoyed it.

Reply

Reedsy | Default — Editors with Marker | 2024-05

Bring your publishing dreams to life

The world's best editors, designers, and marketers are on Reedsy. Come meet them.