The first time I saw Tobias after I killed him, he was standing at the far end of the east corridor, beneath the portrait of the Founder, with his hands in his pockets and his weight on one foot, in the very attitude he used to adopt when he was waiting for me to finish something. I was carrying the Chosen One's sash over my arm, and it was heavier than I had been led to expect, for in all the stories silk weighs nothing, and nobody mentions that a thing may weigh close to nothing in a story and still be a burden to carry in person.
"Ilse," said the Warden at my shoulder, "are you quite well?"
"Only tired, Warden," I said, and when I looked again the corridor was empty and the Founder was frowning down at me from his frame, which is what we knew the Founder t be for.
I should explain what I was, since I am told that the explanation matters, and I have had a long while in which to compose it.
At Harrowmere Academy there are one hundred and forty of us, each found in the same manner: a small wrongness in childhood, a spoon bent in the night, a fire that went out when its owner cried, after which a grave person in a grey coat arrived at the door and spoke in lowered tones to one's parents, who were generally relieved. The Academy teaches us to call the thing in us by its name, and having taught us that it does the only thing it was ever founded to do, which is to prepare us for the war. The war is with the Unbound, who are our own graduates gone a little more rouge than needed, men and women with all our training and none of our leash, and who have been gnawing at the Academy's borders for twenty years, so that every spring there are fewer of us at the long table.
I was seven when they found me, and on my first night a girl who had heard it before, told me the story of the Chosen One. That when the war's long dusk was ready to end there would rise from among the Academy's children one who would end it, who would be given the gold and silver sash that hung in a glass case at the head of the great hall, and whose name would be spoken at the long table for as long as there was a long table. The other children heard a fairy tale. I heard an appointment. I lay in the narrow bed and understood, with the terrible simplicity of the very young, that there was a place in the world with my shape cut out of it, that nobody had yet been sent to fill it, and that if I were only diligent enough, and early enough, and hungry enough, it might just be mine.
I had no family worth the name, which is perhaps why I made the Academy my family and the sash my inheritance. I would rise at four. I practiced the Seven Disciplines until my fingers bled and then I practiced with the blood. And every night, to prove the day, I took a length of red wool from beneath my mattress and tied into it one knot for each hour I had stolen from sleep and spent on becoming worthy of the title. By fifteen the yard had grown into a thick, ugly, living thing, as heavy as a sleeping cat, which I measured against my own height on Sundays with the fixation of a moth to the flame. It was not enough to be the best. I needed the world to be unable to refuse me, and the yard, I believed, was the proof.
Tobias was my friend, and I want that set down plainly before the rest, because it is the part that makes the rest unforgivable. He was, to be exact, not good at anything, he could light a candle if he squinted, and persuade the dormitory radiators to knock in a rhythm that sounded like laughter, and in four years he had advanced no further than the Second Discipline, which he performed with the bright, unembarrassed incompetence of a man playing the guitar at his own wedding. And yet the Warden, who had once made a first-year weep by looking at her shoes, would pause in the corridor to ask after Tobias's cough. The cook saved him the heel of the loaf and the smallest children trailed him through the walkways like ducklings, for he was one of those people on whom affection settles as dust settles on a window, without effort and without invitation. He sat beside me in the library through four winters, reading novels while I drilled, and he never once asked what the yard was for. He simply left things, a stub of candle on my windowsill before an examination, a mug of tea I never saw him make, which was always cold by the time I found it, but I still always drank. I loved him, I think, as one loves a country she has been obliged to live in, and I resented him with exactly the same thoroughness, as one resents, the person who is warm for no reason, when in the dark.
I failed the Fourth Discipline three times before the whole school, the third in the great hall with the Warden saying "Again" in the voice he used for the dogs to tell them off and my hands, which had never once disobeyed me, hanging at my sides like washing. Each time, at midnight, Tobias came and sat on the floor outside my door and said nothing until I opened it. "You are the best of us," he told me after the third. "Everyone knows it." I have thought about that sentence more than any other, because it was meant as comfort, and it lodged in me as something else. It was true, everyone knew it, and it made no difference, since nobody in four years had looked at me as they looked at him, and I would have given every knot in that yard for a single one of the Warden's pauses.
The prophecy teller was a second year named Miray, who had never been right about anything larger than the weather, and who came out of a trance one evening in the middle of supper speaking in a voice that was not hers. "The one who closes the war shall be shown beneath the returning asteroid" she said, "and shall be the one the war has waited for." Then she woke up with a nosebleed and had no memory of having spoken. The whole refectory turned, to look at me. The Warden inclined his head across the table, as one does to a person he has already decided to congratulate. The asteroid was nine weeks away.
The Founder's astrolabe stood in the observatory, a great shameless tangle of nested rings said to wake only when the asteroid passed over, and I moved my practice there. Into the cold among the telescopes, so that when the light came it would find me first, already standing in the place where it would look. I lost the habit of sleep and with it, to my mild surprise, most of my habit of kindness. When Tobias climbed the two hundred and eleven stairs with soup in a covered pot and told me I looked like a candle burnt at both ends, I said I had no time for company, and watched him show that slight puzzled smile, and he left the soup on the step.
On the night of the asteroid, he came anyway, with a borrowed brass telescope and a paper bag of buns. He found me alone beneath the dome with my hands raised, and my breath smoking. "I couldn't let you see it without me," he said. "Besides, I can't sleep before something important happens, I never could." We stood together at the rail and watched it come, a long pale stroke across the glass, as though some god had begun a letter and thought better of it. The ancient astrolabe, which had not stirred in seventy six years, shuddered on its stand, and its rings began to turn. Then all at once they stopped, and the dome filled with a cold white light that came down, with the gentleness of a hand laid on a child's head, upon Tobias.
He did not rejoice. He looked behind him first, for whomever the light had meant, then he looked at me, with a face I had never been able to put down. It was not triumphant but astonished, the face of a boy who had been handed the one thing he never knew to want. "Ilse," he said. "Ilse, it's me. I am the Chosen One" And he caught both my hands laughing. Then he was talking that the Warden would have to learn his proper name at last and not call him the radiator boy, that the cook would give him the whole loaf, anf that people who had stepped around him for four years as around a pleasant piece of furniture would turn in the corridors and look at him as though he were somebody of consequence. "And you," he said, with his whole warm face, "you'll be at my right hand, because who else could be? There's something I should have told you long ago, a thing I've been keeping; I'll tell you at dawn."
It was not the light that broke me. I had been braced for the light for nine years, and even for it passing me by. What I had not prepared for was his kindness. He stood there in my light, in the middle of my nine years, offering me with both hands a place at his right side, as one offers a guest at his own house. Every sleepless hour I had ever tied into the wool rose up in me together and became a single clean white sound, like a glass struck with a spoon. I will say only that the Fourth Discipline, which had failed me three times before the whole school and refused me through nine weeks of cold, came to me that night whole and perfect at the sight of his open face That it was the best I ever performed it and that when the dome was quiet again and the rings had ceased to turn there was nothing at the rail but a brass telescope rolling gently on its side, and a paper bag of buns.
I came down the stairs at dawn, singed and weeping, with his scarf in my fist, to tell the Warden that the Unbound had breached the east wall. I wept truly, for it was the most honest thing I did that year. When the Warden asked what Tobias had said at the end, I told him exactly what it should have been from the start. “He said Ilse is the true chosen one, not me.” I said it so beautifully that I wept again, and the Warden laid a hand on my shoulder.
What I had not foreseen was what the Academy would do with Tobias dead body. The cook set out the whole loaf for a week. The Warden who had never once got the boy's name right, gave an address in the chapel in which he repeated it eleven times. The first years lined the dormitory windowsill with candle stubs, a hundred small flames in a row. The radiators, which had knocked for nobody else, were said on cold nights to knock in a rhythm like laughter. A hundred and thirty eight people wept for a boy who, they had stepped around when alive. They wouldn’t let me forget his sacrifice in peace, they had to make him into a martyr. They gave me the sash in the spring. The hall rose and the Warden settled the silk upon my shoulders and I looked for the pleasure as one pats a pocket for a key and I couldn’t find any. Tobias was at the back, leaning on the doorframe, hands in his pockets, pleased, a little tired and ready to wait out.
A mind is too good a liar to break all at once, it breaks slowly. In the first weeks I called it fatigue and then grief, which was permitted, even admired. And in the third month, as we all do when the evidence goes against us, I decided I was simply unwell. He appeared in the bowl of the soup, in the dark window of the train to the front, at the foot of my bed, in the back row of the lecture hall where I now lectured on discipline. He never spoke, and he never reproached me, which I might have tolerated. He just stood there, kind and patient. I hated him with a fresh and ferocious stamina I had never had leisure for while he lived since it’s impossible to resent a person so warm and gentle. But a person who is dead and still warm, still worshipped by a hundred and thirty eight, is an excellent subject.
I doubled everything and the Fourth came to me only when I was not looking at it and he was not in the room. I killed three Unbound in the autumn and was called flawless. The last of them, a man not much older than I, lay in the wet leaves with my blade under his ribs and looked up at me with something I took for hatred. "Is it true?" he said. "The true chosen. Is he dead?"
"Who?" I said and he smiled as though I had answered. I could not sleep, and for the first time in my life I did not use the hours.
Miray found me on the stairs that winter and laid a hand on my sleeve as though I might be hot. "Everyone tells me something different about who I said," she said. "They say it differently. Was it you?”
"It was me," I said with faltering confidence.
"Oh." She looked at me for a little "I should have known," said Miray politely and let go of my sleeve.
The letter was how I learned in the end. I found it in the lining of his old coat, which I had kept in the bottom of my trunk. Without knowing what for, I took it out in February in a freezing room by the light of a candle I had lit without hands. It was once the best of my talents and now is only a bitter one. It was from a woman named Alina, an Unbound, who signed herself as Tobias's sister, though he had never told me he had one, in those four years.
I know what they've told you about us. I was there too. They call us traitors, but come and see for yourself why the war has never ended. They need it to continue because it is the only thing that justifies the Academy and its ways. If the chosen one comes, he will bring us to the table, and we will find peace. Come alone. Don't tell Ilse she believes in their ways like a soldier.
I read it three times, and I thought of the dying man in the leaves. He had never meant to end the war with a sword, he had meant to end it with a chair and a pot of tea. He had wanted me beside him at the table, and I had killed him for being chosen. I had not so much as asked what he was keeping.
Then I looked up, and he was there. He was sitting on the floor outside my door, as he had a thousand midnights, and when I lifted my head, he lifted his, and for the first time he opened his mouth.
"I was going to ask you to come with me," said Tobias.
That was all. He was not the Chosen One of any prophecy but the only one that can be fulfilled without a war. The last thing he had meant to do in the world was to ask the one friend he had to walk beside him into a future she would have hated but would have them all won.
"Tobias," I said. But the candle guttered, though I had not touched it. When the flame stood up again, the floor was empty, and the mirror held only a woman in a sash, tired and very dull, looking at me with a face I had spent my life trying to make proud.
I do not know whether he was ever there. I have thought of every explanation, I know only that I have stopped asking him to leave. The war goes on. I am told there will be a spring offensive, that I shall lead it, and that I am the hope of our world. The yard still lies under my mattress, and I still tie into it each night a single knot, though it is no longer for the hours I spend becoming worthy. It is now for the hours I spend waiting. I have measured it lately against my height and found that it is longer than I am. It occurs to me that if I wrote to the woman Alina I should be a traitor, and that I have not yet decided whether that is right.
Every night I leave my door unlocked. I sit on the floor of the corridor, in the dark, with my back against the wood. I silently wait to be asked again. He has not come back. But I am very good at waiting. I was trained my entire life.
You must sign up or log in to submit a comment.
Exquisite story telling ❤️
Reply
“The other children heard a fairy tale. I heard an appointment.” — I was hooked, İlayda. That tells me so much about Ilse before she understands it herself. By the end, I wanted to shake her: she could write to Alina, yet she’s still waiting for someone else to open the door.
Thanks for sharing!
Reply
This story is one of the top stories in the Fantasy genre for this contest. Congrats! Welcome to Reedsy! Interesting story of what ends up essentially being self-betrayal. (By the way, you have a typo in the line when you first mention the Unbound: you want rogue, not rouge.)
Reply
This is a tragedy but it could equally work as farce: “the chosen one was meant to bring peace to the world. She killed him. Oops.” It feels like the start of a cross between MacBeth and Dune.
Reply