The Aftermath Keeps Getting Bigger

Funny Holiday Middle School

Written in response to: "Write a story that includes the line “I can’t sleep.”" as part of What Lingers.

Prompt: Write a story that includes the line “I can’t sleep.” Write about a character who yearns for something they lost — or never had.

The Aftermath Keeps Getting Bigger

Dear Diary,

Journal Entry Date: Not sure. One grueling day after Halloween.

If someone should find me later in the week and I am not moving, let this journal entry be an explanation why I almost became a leftover corpse from the scariest night of the year. 

The devastation was formidable. I awoke to candy wrappers that were strewn all about my bedroom. Stacks of foil, paper, and cellophane resembled mementos from a hoarder’s series of conquests. Amid the rubble, I lay prostrate on the floor on my back. The pain all over my body was excruciating. My stomach also lay in ruins.  I bargained in my mind with the ghouls and spirits of all Hallow’s Eve to never, ever eat another gum drop, nutty bar, gummy beast or licorice stick again only if I they would make me feel better.  I was a disaster spelled S-T-U-P-I-D. I was no superhero tonight. I could barely remove my Water Dude superhero mask from my head.

“No, not ever again,” I painfully whispered to my wiener dog Shrimpy who lay at my side. 

“If seismologists measured my belly for quake activity it would register a 1000 on the Richter scale with anything more than ten being meteoric. This is going to be a very long night. I can’t sleep. I can’t even move. I certainly can’t let mom and dad see me this way or I will be locked down for the rest of the holiday weekend.”

I continued lamenting to my best friend, Shrimpy. 

“Oh, Shrimpy, I really did it this time. I pressed the envelope. I should have never accepted Billy’s challenge to see how much candy we could eat in an hour. Yeah, I still won. Poor Billy had to race out of the house to toss his ‘cookies’, his ‘gummy beasts’ and anything else he managed to stuff down his throat. Frankly, I never knew anyone who could manage to ingest so much candy as we did. We should have just poured sugar from the sugar jar right down our throats. I think then I would have conceded the challenge over to him if he could have finished his sugar jar before mine.”

I caught my breath and continued on babbling to my disinterested dog.

“I need to do something to burn off all these extra calories. It’s so early in the evening. But I just can’t move. If I do, it feels like boulders are pushing through my guts. Maybe if I turn on my side the raging landslide in my belly will subside. Shrimpy, move out of the way!”

Perhaps it was the turbulence within me, but I managed to turn on my side. Moments after I turned, there were bellowing, thunderous sounds coming from my backside.

Pffft. Poot. Toot. Fraaaaapp. Thrrrrrppp. Flaaaarrtthpt.  More Pffft.

“Oh, man that was a doozie, Shrimpy. I am feeling a little better now.”

Meanwhile, Shrimpy, with his nose in the air, whimpers and moves to the other side of the room with his tail down.

“What time is it? Where’s my Water Dude superhero watch?” 

I became frantic scrambling to my feet.

“I have to find it Shrimpy! Help me look for it boy. Use that nose of yours to sniff it out. It’s my prized possession that I got for my birthday this year. Mom and Dad spent a fortune on it. If they notice I am not wearing it, they will ask a lot of questions.”

I took a deep, exasperated breath.

“I am in so much trouble. I am dead meat. A post Halloween nightmare on Maple Street. I must find it!”

I searched my room like a detective analyzing a crime scene.  I still had the evening to look for it, but it would come at a cost. I would not have any more fun.

“I am so mad. This just can’t be happening. Maybe a ghoul is playing a dirty trick on me. I should find Billy and see if he took it Come now Shrimpy. We are headed over to Billy’s house.”

As Shrimpy and I headed out the door with my trick or treat bag, I decided that I would retrace my footsteps during the early hours of trick or treating.  Perhaps it fell off my wrist. I would scour the sidewalks carefully like Wilcock Domes, the architect of English investigations. A sleuth having a reputation that mystifies even the local constabulary.   I shall use stealth and sharpness of wit to solve this mystery.

That frame of mind and wit did not last more than ten minutes. I found nothing on the short walk over to Billy’s house. Anxiously, I pounded on Billy’s door. Nothing. I pounded again. Then I remembered Billy said his parents would be at a Halloween party. Nothing like leaving an eleven-year-old to fend for themselves on Halloween night.  I really pounded hard once more.

Billy sheepishly answered the door. I got a warm welcome of sorts.

“Gee, it’s only you. I am not accepting trick or treaters now, dude. I feel like someone reached into my mouth and yanked all my guts out. Please go away. I am finished for the night.”

“Billy, I need to ask you one question. Do you have my Water Dude watch? Did you take it?”

“That’s two questions. Why would I take your dumb Water Dude watch? I have my own Timmy Time Digester Watch. Now please I just need to sleep!”

Angrily I said, “Well it’s good someone can sleep. I can’t sleep! I need to find my watch, you bonehead of a friend!”

Billy slammed the door in my face. I think I lost my second-best friend.

“Ok, Shrimpy. It’s time to retrace my steps. Come on now.”

Shrimpy and I proceeded down the street all the while I was looking high and low for my watch. Shrimpy was too, albeit every five feet he was marking his territory with a splash of urine. A neighborhood woman got really mad at us at seeing Shrimpy mark her flowers. She grabbed some apples from an apple tree. For an old lady her aim was remarkable. Shrimpy was unscathed by the storm of apples. I, on the other hand, sustained apple mush on the top of my head and back. 

I yelled back at her.

“Hey, lady, thanks for the snack., you ole bitty.” 

I picked one off the ground. 

“A red delicious. Yummy, as I took a few bites out of it.”   It was laced with worms. I returned and puked on her flowers.

I had to make up for lost time. There still might be a chance to enjoy the rest of the night if I find my watch. I retraced my steps from house to house with Shrimpy. Meanwhile, it started to drizzle. The temperature dropped to where I could see my breath and a few snow flurries fell. I thought I might as well get some more candy even though I had trick or treated earlier at the same houses.

I came up to one house, and a large man answered the door. He looked me over suspiciously.

“Hey, weren’t you here earlier? You were some sort of ugly superhero. Are you trying to double dip and get extra candy you little cheat.”

I stammered answering, “You must be mistaken.  Look at my dog. Would a superhero have such a mutt like this? By the way, did you find a watch? I am poor and can’t afford one.”

Apologetically the man replied, “Nah, no watch. I need a new one myself. Here take some extra. Here’s an apple to keep the doctor away, heh, heh.”

The number of trick or treaters had thinned out to virtually just two.  Me and Shrimpy. I suspected it was getting very late.

I continued onward looking under bushes, under parked cars, and even under manhole covers. No luck. I was getting desperate. There was a house along my path that was covered with toilet paper. It had been wrapped as toilet paper teepees after my first visit. Instinctively, I knew this might be risky, but I had to check out their yard for my watch.   

“Shrimpy, please be quiet. Be a good boy.”

I began to search through the mass of unwound toilet rolls that adorned the bushes and yard. A rabbit raced past Shrimpy. Guess who started to bark his head off? It sure wasn’t me. Suddenly, spot lights and an alarm were activated in the yard by the crazy skunk chase as I lost control of his leash. The chase caused the paper to bunch up and stick to Shrimpy. When Shrimpy tired and had settled down, I grabbed him darting out of the yard. It wasn’t long after that I saw a police car racing down the street to the house that looked like a toilet bowl decorated with lots of wet toilet paper.

Hiding in some hedges on another street, I whispered to Shrimpy.

“A close one, indeed Shrimpy. Pee you! When we get home, I’ll have to wash off the evidence of your skunk chase. Looks like you’ll have to sleep in the doghouse tonight. And, thanks to you, I might be in the doghouse too.”

I am so very depressed now. I stink to high heaven. I’m covered in apple mush and wet toilet paper. My belly aches from the apples and candy. I’ve been farting all night. I still can’t find my watch. On top of it all, I can’t sleep!”

In spite of my anxiety and panic, I desperately carried on the search. Shrimpy and I were now about a mile from my house. I rummaged through garbage cans. I even checked mailboxes and newspaper holders. I felt like the old woman in a story told by our Sunday school Pastor who searched her house looking for a missing gold coin. She finds it and gets her neighbors and rejoices about it. The Pastor said the angels in heaven also rejoice when someone asks to be forgiven for their sins. (1) 

I got to thinking that I should ask God to forgive me for my stupidity this Halloween and for my hurtful words to Billy, the old lady, and the lies and bad behavior I had done. Maybe He would help me find my watch? I hope He would.

The few flakes of earlier turned into a gentle flurry. The flurry quickly turned into a raging blizzard. Shrimpy and I were freezing. I had to carry him because my little sausage dog was shivering. I benefited by getting his warmth too. In hindsight, I should have called off the search while I was still in my neighborhood. Plus, I need to come clean about the watch with my parents. But right now, I really am miserable. 

I hope God is listening to me. I remember my memory work from last Sunday’s class. The Pastor told us a few good verses to memorize when we are in trouble. I am glad I remember at least one of them.

“Search for the Lord and for His strength; continually seek Him.” (2)

The snow turned into ice balls pelting me in the face. I opened my coat putting Shrimpy inside. He stuck his head out of the unzipped opening. I still had a half mile to go even before I reached my subdivision. This was going to be a life and death situation. Funny how it seems that my dog and I would likely become frozen corpses on Halloween night!

I could barely see three feet in front of me when I heard the honking of a horn. I should have responded with great joy, but it was my mom and dad in the car. I was expecting a stern reprimand, but instead I got nothing but love and gratitude we were okay. Mom voiced a whispered prayer,

“I will praise You, Jesus, for You have answered me and have become my salvation.” (3)

My mom insisted I take three baths that night with Shrimpy in the tub as well. We smelled better, but it was still like lavender skunk scent.

Later after the tub scrubbings, I decided to see what other candy I managed to get on the second round of trick or treat. I dumped my bag on the floor. There wasn’t much candy, but I was really happy to see my superhero watch amid my sparce pickings! I am now so wide awake, I can’t sleep!

Thankfully, there was nothing lurking in the shadows this Halloween night because everything including the shadows were covered in six inches of snow.

“Thank you, Jesus as I weathered the aftermath of this weird holiday called Halloween.”

Posted Nov 07, 2026
Share:

You must sign up or log in to submit a comment.

4 likes 0 comments

RBE | Illustrated Short Stories | 2024-06

Bring your short stories to life

Fuse character, story, and conflict with tools in Reedsy Studio. All for free.