Plot 42

Crime Fiction Urban Fantasy

This story contains themes or mentions of physical violence, gore, or abuse.

Written in response to: "Center your story around an unexpected criminal or accidental lawbreaker." as part of Comic Relief.

Plot 42

At sixty-two, Arthur Tarmack was retired from his career as an actuary, a job he found thrillingly predictable. He was reliable as a Swiss watch. He drank his tea at precisely lukewarm temperatures. He drove four miles under the speed limit. He had a closet full of beige cardigans. He worked in the community garden, Plot 42, at exactly the same time every day—-unless it was pouring rain.

His greatest nemesis was a woman named Brenda, who flagrantly ignored Section 4, Paragraph B of the community garden rules by allowing her peppermint plants to spread into his designated plot.

Arthur was not a man built for the criminal underworld. He was a man built for Sudoku.

The descent into international narcotics trafficking began on a damp Tuesday in March, via an internet forum called The Soil Sifters. Arthur was searching for a competitive edge for the upcoming Tri-County Produce Exhibition. Brenda had taken the blue ribbon in the "Misc. Gourd" category three years running, and Arthur’s pride could not withstand another defeat.

In a thread titled RARE EXOTICS—-HIGH YIELD, a user named DarkWebSpade offered seeds for the "Andean Sunset." The description promised a vibrant, fleshy fruit with a "mind-altering aroma" and an "unforgettable bite."

Arthur paid forty dollars via a very confusing crypto-currency app—which he assumed was just the modern equivalent of a cashier’s check—and eagerly awaited his mail.

Two weeks later, a discreet, unmarked envelope arrived. Inside were six tiny, iridescent purple seeds. Arthur planted them in Plot 42 with the reverence of a priest handling holy relics. He utilized his proprietary blend of bat guano, crushed eggshells, and sheer actuarial willpower.

By July, Plot 42 was terrifying.

The plants had shot up to seven feet tall, dwarfing Brenda’s pathetic zucchinis. They possessed thick, pulsing magenta vines and broad, serrated leaves that seemed to hum when the wind blew. But the fruit was the real marvel. They looked like tomatoes, if tomatoes had been designed by a rave promoter. They were neon orange, glowing with a faint, bioluminescent sheen in the twilight, and covered in tiny, soft fuzz.

"Genetics," Arthur whispered to himself, adjusting his spectacles. "Superior South American genetics."

The trouble began at the neighbourhood tasting mixer.

Arthur had sliced the Andean Sunsets into neat wedges, arranging them on a platter with toothpicks. He stood behind his folding table, chest puffed out, battle-ready.

Brenda sidled up, eyeing his spread with thinly veiled jealousy. "What are those, Arthur? They look irradiated."

"They are Andean Sunsets, Brenda," Arthur said stiffly. "A heritage breed. I wouldn't expect you to understand; your soil pH is historically a disaster."

Brenda scoffed, snatched a wedge, and popped it into her mouth. She chewed. Her chewing slowed. Her eyes dilated until they were completely black.

"Well?" Arthur asked. "Notes of plum? An earthy finish?"

Brenda looked at Arthur. Then she looked past Arthur, into the sky. "The clouds," she whispered, her voice trembling with awe. "The clouds are made of screaming geometry."

She then sat cross-legged on the mulch and began petting a plastic pink flamingo. Minutes later, she softly wept because, as she explained, the flamingo "knew too much about sorrow.”

Arthur frowned. "A bit dramatic, Brenda, even for you."

But Brenda wasn't the only one. Old Mr. Henderson ate a slice and spent the next three hours trying to conduct a symphony of squirrels. Mrs. Gable took a bite and immediately filed for divorce from her husband, claiming she was now spiritually betrothed to the concept of the color purple.

Arthur packed up his table early, feeling quite smug. The flavor profile must have been overwhelmingly complex. He had definitely secured the blue ribbon.

Within a week, the demographic of the Shady Pines Community Garden shifted dramatically.

Arthur was used to seeing retirees in sun hats. Now, his plot was surrounded by young people in oversized beanies, tie-dye shirts, and sunglasses, regardless of the cloud cover. They spoke in hushed, reverent tones.

A young man with dreadlocks and a shirt that said FREE YOUR THIRD EYE approached Arthur as he was diligently pruning a magenta vine.

"Hey, man," the youth whispered, looking around nervously. "You the... you the Botanist?"

"I prefer 'Horticultural Enthusiast,' but yes," Arthur said proudly. "How may I help you, young man?"

"I heard you got that Sun-Glow. The Electric Orange. The... you know." The kid tapped the side of his nose, which made no sense to Arthur, as tomatoes were for eating, not smelling.

"If you are referring to the Andean Sunsets, yes, the yield has been spectacular. Would you like a sample?"

The kid’s jaw dropped. "A sample? Just... for free?"

"Well, I am a firm believer in the barter system," Arthur said, leaning on his hoe. "I am currently in need of some cedar chips. The garden center is completely out."

The kid nodded furiously. "Yeah. Yeah, man. I can get you cedar chips. How much for a whole... uh... fruit?"

"A fifty-litre bag of cedar chips seems a fair trade for two plump Sunsets," Arthur calculated.

"Done. Don't move, man. I'll be back in twenty."

By mid-August, Arthur was the undisputed kingpin of the tri-county area. He didn't know this, of course. He just thought there was a sudden, massive youth movement dedicated to organic gardening.

His shed was stacked to the ceiling with premium cedar chips, imported Japanese pruning shears, organic pesticide, and, bizarrely, three high-end flat-screen televisions, which a particularly enthusiastic "gardener" named 'Twitchy Pete' had insisted on trading for a baker’s dozen of the tomatoes.

Arthur kept meticulous track of every transaction in a Microsoft Excel spreadsheet titled: Produce Yield & Barter Equivalencies (Q3).

The cartel arrived on a Thursday.

Arthur was on his hands and knees, aggressively weeding near the fence line, when a pair of heavy leather boots stepped onto his perfectly raked soil. Arthur looked up.

The man was built like a cinderblock. He wore a leather jacket despite the eighty-degree heat, and had a tattoo of a snake eating a skull on his neck. Behind him stood two equally imposing men.

"Excuse me," Arthur said, standing up and brushing the dirt from his khaki knees. "You are compacting the aeration layer."

The large man squinted at Arthur. "You the guy pushing the Orange Haze on my turf?"

"If by 'Orange Haze' you mean my award-winning Andean Sunsets, yes. And this is not your turf. This is Plot 42. Your turf, if you are a registered member, would be assigned by the committee. Are you on the waitlist?"

The man chuckled, a deep, rumbling sound. "Listen, pops. I'm Hector. And you're cutting into my profits. My guys can't move a single bag of Molly while you're out here handing out magic spirit-fruit to every raver in the state."

Arthur frowned. Molly? Was that a new hybrid of melon? "I assure you, Hector, I have no interest in your Molly. My focus is entirely on the Sunsets. Now, I must ask you to step off the soil. You are ruining the pH balance."

Hector stepped closer, towering over Arthur. He reached inside his leather jacket, revealing the dark metallic grip of a handgun. "I don't think you understand, old man. I'm shutting you down. This whole operation? It belongs to Hector now."

Arthur’s eyes narrowed. He looked at Hector's heavy boots, trampling a fragile magenta vine. He felt a surge of cold, actuarial fury. Nobody—absolutely nobody—threatened his yield.

Arthur calmly reached into his gardening belt and withdrew his brand-new, Japanese steel, titanium-coated pruning shears. He snapped them open and shut making a snick-snick sound.

"Listen to me very carefully, Hector," Arthur said, his voice dropping to a terrifyingly level register. "I have spent four months cultivating this crop. I have battled aphids. I have battled root rot. I have battled Brenda's invasive peppermint. I am not about to let some leather-clad hooligan with no respect for topsoil take my harvest."

Arthur took a step forward, raising the shears, his eyes dead and unblinking behind his spectacles.

"If you do not leave Plot 42 immediately," Arthur whispered, "I will prune you. I will prune you with extreme prejudice."

Hector stared at the mild-mannered man in the beige cardigan. He looked at the glowing, pulsing plants surrounding them. He looked at the razor-sharp shears. In the criminal underworld, Hector had faced rival gangs and corrupt cops. But he had never faced a retired actuary defending his garden. The sheer, psychopathic calmness of Arthur’s threat unnerved him to his core.

"Man, you're crazy," Hector muttered, backing away slowly. "You're a freaking psycho. Keep your weird magic tomatoes. I ain't messing with no garden warlock."

Hector and his men practically jogged back to their black SUV and peeled out of the parking lot. Arthur sighed, knelt back down, and resumed weeding. "Ruffians," he muttered.

The raid happened three days before the Produce Exhibition.

Arthur was hosting what he called a "Tomato Slicing and Preservation Seminar." In reality, there were forty-five heavily pierced, dilated-pupil youths sitting in a circle on the grass, waiting to purchase the "Orange Haze."

Suddenly, the sky roared. Two black helicopters descended, kicking up a hurricane of mulch and ripped leaves. Armored vans smashed through the Shady Pines front gate, flattening the 'Welcome' sign. Dozens of men in black tactical gear poured out, assault rifles raised.

"DEA! NOBODY MOVE! GET ON THE GROUND!" a voice boomed over a megaphone.

Panic erupted. The youths scattered like startled pigeons, diving over hedges, scrambling up oak trees, and cooing in an attempt to look inconspicuous.

Arthur stood frozen, clutching a clipboard and a paring knife. A SWAT officer rushed him, tackling him into a compost bin.

"Suspect is down! I have the Kingpin!" the officer yelled.

Arthur, covered in decaying vegetable matter and coffee grounds, gasped for breath. "My clipboard!" he wheezed indignantly. "You've wrinkled my sign-in sheet!"

They dragged Arthur to his feet, slapped heavy iron cuffs on his wrists, and threw him into the back of a tactical vehicle. As the doors slammed shut, Arthur looked out the reinforced window in horror.

"My plants!" he screamed. "They haven't been watered today! They require a gentle misting! You monsters!"

Room 4B at the DEA field office was cold, windowless, and smelled of stale coffee. Arthur sat at the metal table, his beige cardigan slightly soiled from the compost, his posture impeccably straight.

Two detectives sat across from him. One was a grizzled veteran named Miller; the other was a younger, sharp-eyed woman named Cortez. On the table between them sat a glowing, fuzzy orange fruit in a plastic evidence bag.

"Let's cut the crap, 'Heisenberg of the Hedges'," Miller growled, leaning forward. "We know everything. We know you’ve been distributing a highly modified strain of Botanicus Delirium, a Schedule 1 hallucinogen from the Andes, previously thought extinct."

"I have been distributing Andean Sunsets," Arthur corrected politely. "And they are a heritage tomato."

Cortez slid a thick stack of papers across the table. "We raided your shed, Arthur. We found the ledgers."

"Ah, yes. My Q3 spreadsheets. I hope you noted the pivot tables; I was quite proud of how I cross-referenced the vermiculite trades against the rainfall averages."

Miller slammed his fist on the table. "You expect us to believe this is a joke?! You moved an estimated three million dollars' worth of street-value narcotics! You controlled the entire tri-county supply! You ran Hector 'The Blade' Ramirez out of town!"

"Hector was compacting my aeration layer," Arthur stated firmly. "And he lacked basic horticultural manners. I simply threatened to prune him."

Cortez exchanged a bewildered look with Miller. "Arthur... do you know what this plant does?" She tapped the evidence bag.

"Of course. It wins blue ribbons," Arthur said. "Though I admit, the flavor profile must be acquired. Brenda ate one and spoke to a flamingo for an hour. I assume it causes mild indigestion."

"Arthur," Cortez said softly. "It is one of the most powerful psychedelic compounds on the planet. One bite contains enough psychoactive alkaloids to make a man believe he is a glass of orange juice for a week. You haven't been running a farm stand. You’ve been running an international drug cartel out of a community garden."

Arthur stared at the glowing fruit. He thought about the youths in beanies. He thought about Twitchy Pete giving him three televisions for a bag of "tomatoes." He thought about Brenda and the screaming geometry of the clouds.

A long, silent minute passed.

"Well," Arthur finally said, adjusting his spectacles. "That certainly explains the market demand for cedar chips.”

The trial of Arthur Tarmack was a media sensation. The press dubbed him "The Botanical Baron." The prosecution tried to paint him as a criminal mastermind who used the facade of an elderly actuary to build a drug empire.

However, Arthur’s defense attorney, a brilliant woman named Ms. Vance, simply put Arthur on the stand and let him talk. She approached the stand and smiled.

"Arthur, did you realize that you were running a drug operation?"

He pondered the question for a couple of seconds and then smiled.

"If the prosecution truly believes I am a 'ruthless kingpin,'" Arthur said, adjusting his spectacles and addressing the glassy-eyed jury, "I would ask them to explain how one runs an empire with a soil pH of 5.8. It is horribly acidic, Your Honor. The nitrogen uptake would be entirely compromised. It is horticultural suicide."

The judge slowly lowered his face into his hands, letting out a long, defeated sigh.

For four agonizing hours, Arthur continued to lecture the courtroom on the importance of earthworms and the formulaic calculation of life insurance premiums. He presented his Excel spreadsheets, pointing out that no criminal mastermind would meticulously document the trade of Class-A narcotics for "two bags of chicken manure and a gently used garden hose."

Furthermore, Arthur’s meticulous ledgers inadvertently broke down the entire command structure of Hector's actual cartel, as Hector’s men had eventually started trading actual stolen goods for the magic tomatoes, and Arthur had recorded all their names, license plates, and gang affiliations under "Customer Feedback."

The jury deliberated for forty-five minutes.

They acquitted Arthur of all charges, citing extreme, aggressive, and undeniable ignorance.

A year later, the Shady Pines Community Garden was quiet once more. The DEA had burned Plot 42 to ashes and salted the earth, much to Arthur’s enduring annoyance.

Arthur was back in his beige cardigan, kneeling beside a newly assigned plot: Plot 12. Brenda was tending to her zucchinis a few yards away, eyeing him warily. She hadn't been quite the same since the incident, having taken up transcendental meditation and abandoning her invasive peppermint.

"What are you growing this year, Arthur?" Brenda called out, a hint of trepidation in her voice.

"Just mushrooms, Brenda," Arthur called back cheerfully, patting the damp soil. "A rare Japanese strain called the 'Twilight Star Takes.' I read about them on a new forum."

Arthur smiled as he watered the soil. He couldn't wait for them to sprout. The seller had guaranteed a high yield, and promised they would be a completely "transcendent" experience.

Arthur felt confident. The Tri-County Produce Exhibition wouldn't know what hit them.

Posted Apr 17, 2026
Share:

You must sign up or log in to submit a comment.

3 likes 0 comments

RBE | Illustrated Short Stories | 2024-06

Bring your short stories to life

Fuse character, story, and conflict with tools in Reedsy Studio. All for free.