Ear Worm

Contemporary Fiction

This story contains sensitive content

CW: Mental health issues and Self-harm

Written in response to: "Make a character’s obsession or grudge a key element of your story." as part of What Lingers.


I should have walked without pausing past that yard sale. But there was something about the lumpy figure perched uncomfortably on the front stoop. I should not have rested my gaze on her, that doughy-faced teenager whose mother had assigned the unenviable task of watching the jumble table. She seemed to abhor the sun: its brightness, its merciless exposure of the pimples on her skin and the flotsam of her family’s life. All the more reason, I thought to myself, to cross to the other side of the street.

But that thought arrived too late. We locked eyes. Her lips turned downward, as if she did not like what she saw, and perhaps mine did the same. I registered her outlandish garb: black shirt, black tank-top, black pants, black sandals on a freakishly hot day. Each was a slightly different shade of black. There were patches of sweat already spreading from under her arms and between pendulous breasts.

She shifted her eyes from me to the throng of people ruthlessly evaluating dog-eared books, plastic coasters, and outgrown stuffies. Without examining the taped-on prices, I was determined to buy an item, to show her she could not deter me. She hated me but I sensed she hated herself even more.

“How much are these?” I said, spreading my fingers at the table.

“What, these?” Her voice sounded raw. Had she just had a screaming fight with her mother over whose fault it was that her XL-size black shirt had not yet been washed?

I nodded, breaking eye-hold with her long enough to glance at where my hand had waved. There was a clacking row of plastic jewel-cased CDs. The bands were obscure—Boneyard, The Queers, Mad Pudding. “Fifty cents each,” she said, “three for a buck.” She sneered as if to say only a dickhead would be caught dead nowadays with a CD. My mother had owned CDs, I knew, because she dragged them out every Christmas. Forty minutes of Patsy Cline’s Christmastime, followed by Handel’s Messiah.

“Um,” I said, touching the soap dishes and ashtrays.

“Check out the CDs. You’re passing up the deal of a lifetime,” she said.

“I don’t even have a CD player.” It bugged me that she would call it the deal of a lifetime when the CDs were so clearly a pile of junk.

“Oh, well, then,” she huffed, pulling out from under the table a clunky plastic grey object, twice the size of a lunch-kit. “Five bucks.”

Who could tolerate a monstrosity like that, I wondered, especially in a tiny bachelorette like mine? Yet, now that Patsy Cline’s Christmastime had been released into a thought-balloon in my mental amusement park, I realized I did have a use for the player, at least once a year.

“I’ll throw in a free CD,” she said, popping the lid. There was a disc in place, vile yellow in color. Purple Confusion was its title.

I pulled out a bill. Persons close to the jumble table leaned in a fraction closer—oh, is there a good deal to be had?—and as soon as they saw the CD player, they smirked. I felt like the last person to drive an Edsel out of the dealership.

The CD player was branded “XPress Player.” It was heavy and the handle was awkwardly placed, so it bumped against my thigh all the way home. I dumped it in my closet, on top of my winter boots and Abdo-Miracle machine, and soon forgot about it.

At the office where I was temping, some staff were organizing a bridal shower. They had convinced the bride-to-be, Shayna, to bring in “her song.” She brought in a CD of Danny Wright, that preternaturally clear and sparkling tunesmith. I volunteered to bring in my XPress Player to play it on.

At home, I plugged in the player to test it. A little red light shone, and I could hear the whirr of the disc spinner. I listened distractedly to the first track of Purple Confusion, picturing how we would make a fuss over Shayna. Remembering the dirty fingernails of the girl I’d bought it from, I spritzed cleaning spray on the push buttons and polished the unit until it glowed.

I left the CD playing while I busied myself with housework. The songs struck me as companionable and soothing, verging on analgesic. By the time of the last song I looked forward to a fine mid-day meal.

On my way in to my afternoon shift, my steps quickened to the remembered tempo of the CD. I tried to hum the first song, but I could not. It was kind of a techno-beat, insistent yet tuneless. I spent the afternoon in petulant silence, on the verge of hearing the tune in my head, but not quite capturing it.

When I returned home, I pressed Play before I even pried off my clammy pumps. I took a bath while the oven warmed my dinner. The bath was more luxuriant and the calorie-controlled casserole smelled more mouth-watering than I ever remembered. Soon it was time to watch Survivor and Stranger Things, shows that I couldn’t miss unless I wanted to be frozen out of the chitchat in the coffee room. I reluctantly pushed Stop.

Later, when I lay down to sleep, I tried to remember even one of the tunes. Despite all the times I had listened, I could not summon an actual melody, only a sensation. I simply had to play the CD again. At three in the morning I started awake, in silence, with the vicious red light gobbling up the darkness in my room. I unplugged the machine and lay there, heart pounding; I suddenly feared that the player had over-heated and irreparably warped Purple Confusion. I lay still, wondering why the music beguiled me so, and soon I had a dream about ferny trees bedecked with colourful birds that sang to one another. I awoke feeling reassured.

Friday, I brought the CD player to the office. At two o’clock festivities began, normally an awkward interval of over-rich canapés and pretend conviviality. After we heard Best of Danny Wright twice through, I put on Purple Confusion and the gathering eerily dispersed.

Shortly before five I sprinted to Sully’s building. Sully’s receptionist is strictly professional when she announces me, but I know she has suspicions. A twenty-year difference between us: I know I would have.

“Well, well,” Sully says when he receives me in his office. His tone is guarded; I imagine him calculating that if he is too pleasant about my intrusion, then I might start to drop by on a regular basis, and that might develop into an “inopportune moment” because Sully is the sort of man about whom my friends would say, “a girl would take a number.”

“This won’t take long,” I tell Sully. My voice sounds trembly. “I was just—on my way to drinks with some friends.” This is the understanding we have: I am not aggressive and he does not take advantage. It’s called expectations management.

He cups my cheek with his hand. “Something has upset you,” he says, like he has concluded a diagnosis. Sully treasures the phrase “older and wiser.” Occasionally he embodies it.

My fingers touch the edge of the CD in my purse. The contact, like the smoothness of gun-metal, reminds me of my mission. “I need you to listen to this,” I say, showing him the vile yellow CD.

 “I’ll listen after work.” He motions to the sleek Bose speakers on either side of his big desk. Sully has a thing about sound systems like some guys have a thing about Harleys.

I explain that I need a back-up made. I can’t copy a CD on my work computer, but Sully, who is a VP at this firm, can. Sully hands the task to his IT hireling and takes me downstairs for coffee.

Not only do I leave with two CDs, the original and the copy, but Sully also copies the music to his computer. He calls me that evening from his office.

“Well, well,” I say. With two hours of Purple Confusion in my head, I feel mellow again.

Sully laughs, a pleasant, hearty tone. “Wish you were here right now.”

I hear such longing and ardor that, for a moment, I seriously consider Ubering to his office to hear the songs on Sully’s high-quality system. Then I remember our arrangement. “You’re coming over tomorrow, right?” He affirms and I say, “Well, good. We can listen together then.”

And listen we do when he drops by Saturday evening. I find it oddly distracting to listen together, though. It reminds me of watching a movie at the house of a friend who had a large dog. The presence of the dog—his wagging tail, his chilly nose, his sopping tongue—intruded on my watching so much that, afterward, I could not call the movie to mind.

The evening unwound, as it usually did, with Champagne and the light of a single candle. Sully is very self-conscious of the stitches that snake around his body, mementoes of his quadruple bypass. I am self-conscious of my baggy and puckered skin, which is still four sizes too big for me. I lost a massive amount of weight after I left home and, sure, I’m a “real knock-out” like the ads promise, until the body stocking comes off, that is. The CD was playing, our bodies were swaying, and the flickering candlelight smoothed our ravaged skins. He held me and I was contented. I no longer worried if he was comparing me to his alabaster-skinned ex-wife, or—running my tongue along the blade of jealousy—those women populating the imaginary waiting room, those who had to “take a number.”

I awoke in the morning, chilly and resentful. Sully had stolen the blanket; I shivered without the pyjamas that I normally wear, believing that nudity would be more romantic. Yes, I would offer myself again to Sully, I’d planned, as I drifted asleep last night, but in the morning light I could see the surplus skin drooping from my gut, my calves, my breasts and I ran to cover myself.

As soon as he left, I dead-bolted the door and pressed Play. I made coffee and began my yoga. I forced myself to do an extra round of difficult positions because the music encouraged me to be better. Indeed, as I pulled the folds of skin from my tummy and thighs, to see how well my “right-sizing” was progressing, the fit did seem to be snugger. The skin did seem tauter. I visualized the notes of the music suspended like delicate beads as I opened my limbs and stretched toward the floor, the wall, the sun. I was struck by the beauty of the single moment.

 “Hey.” Sully’s voice whispered to me two nights later when I picked up the phone. “I have something for you,” he said. He told me to meet him in the coolness of the evening at St. Alban’s, a fountain in my neighbourhood.

As I watched Sully approach, I was struck by how dashing he was. No paunch, only silvery overtones that accentuated his fine features. I imagined the music swelling in the background of this movie being shot with us as the Oscar-calibre stars.

He handed me a small green velvet bag, the type a jewellery store might provide. I held my breath. At that moment I didn’t know if I was dreading or expecting this gift. I held the bag and time stood still. All the months before now, Sully and I had been ensnared in a sexual minuet, each of us operating with a certain well-defined formality. Ahead of us, there would be, what? A memory of this night at St. Alban’s fountain?

I looked at Sully closely, the asymmetric creases on his cheeks; I cocked my head to one side, as if weighing the gift with my fingertips. But no; I was listening to a song that had resumed playing in my head.

“Go on,” he said.

In the bag, swaddled in white tissue, was an iPod with outsized earphones attached. He turned it on and showed me he had copied all the tracks of Purple Confusion.

***

The thing about an obsession is that it becomes bigger than you, or anyone else, or your relationship with anyone else. I know I should have declared my feelings of gratitude and love to Sully after that night, but I could not. I saw the headphones and was pierced by the thought of the bliss that could be mine—all mine—within seconds, but instead this Sully person would want to sit at the fountain, pointlessly swinging his feet, until we went to a café and just as uselessly drained our macchiatos. I feigned the sudden onset of a migraine, that’s how I was able to extricate myself from social obligation.

At home I greedily unbundled the precious gift. The new device enabled me to listen to songs on the way to and from work, and while carrying out the stupid small errands of urban existence. Do laundry, get shoes reheeled, purchase mouse traps….

Two days later Sully dropped by unannounced. He demanded that I “unplug” when we were together, as if his inane ramblings about Italian design or the shortage of diesel deserved an audience of one. One who would bear the opportunity cost of not being able to listen to anything else. The only way I could mitigate the burden of conversing with Sully was to invite him to my place and arrange to have the music playing in the background. Then, the shabby pensées we uttered, while the music played a mesmerizing counterpoint, felt profound

One evening Sully was delivering opinions about the solo careers of members of the Grateful Dead. They were a band before my time, and I asked him repeatedly to keep it down so I could listen to Purple Confusion.

“What do you know? Your mind is polluted,” Sully said with a laugh, speaking so loudly I could not properly hear my favorite track.

“Shut up!” I screamed. I pushed him out the door.

“You’re worse than polluted,” he said. “You’re a zombie.” The door slammed.

With that, Sully left.

At first he was gone for the rest of the evening, and it was a relief. No one to interrupt. No one who insisted on talking over the music. I lived a few days in a twilight world, half expecting a phone call or text, half dreading it. Sometime within the week, perhaps, I expected an apology, no matter whether he was right or wrong because Sully was predictable: sucking up to me when he became lonely. But no phone call came.

Still, I believed that he would call, and that my relief from Sully the Interrupter would be short-lived. I decided I should enjoy the hiatus while it lasted, and thus I became saturated with Purple Confusion.

Weeks of uncertainty became months. I played the music a little louder whenever I sensed the sadness creeping closer. Sometimes I saw that sadness in my dreams; I would look down at my bare feet like they were a shoreline, with sadness lapping at my toes, sometimes approaching and sometimes receding.

One day I returned to St. Alban’s Park. Children scored soft sand with dull plastic tools. Not one wore earbuds. Teens hunched at a picnic table. They had earbuds dangling around their necks but not one had buds in both ears. Only two pensioners had earbuds, gentlemen wearing beards and those many-pocket Scotty vests. About half the working-age adults wore earbuds or headphones. They looked cross and impatient; they were striding purposefully through the park as a shortcut to work or shopping. I tried to turn up the volume on my iPod, to no avail. The icon for battery life flickered and then my player went dead.

The silence convinced me to call Sully. The receptionist recognized me immediately and, with pity in her voice, said he was in Tanzania for an extended period on business and maybe was having trouble with phone networks or jet lag. As I hung up, I wondered if ours was the last substantive conversation I would ever have.

My numbness, bizarrely, turned into agony. I could not tell if Sully, or someone to play the Sully-type of role in my life, might reappear some day.

I decided I wanted to be ready. I would show him I was clean. I broke the two Purple Confusion CDs in half. I took a brick to the iPod and collected the red-dusted pieces in a baggie like a forensics technician. I dealt more leniently with the grey Xpress Player, leaving its clunky chassis curbside with a hand-lettered sign (“Free to Good Home”), along  with the Patsy Cline CD already in it as an incentive for adoption.

As I set the player down on the worn cement, I felt a burst of fury toward the girl who’d sold it to me. I imagined confronting her. Purple Confusion. What tenebrous purgatory did she now inhabit? I raced outside to retrieve the Xpress Player, imagining how I would bludgeon her with it or at least inflict heavy bruising.

But the player and Patsy Cline CD had already been picked up from the curb.

To ensure I would never be the dupe again, of the dour teen, or treacherous Sully, or the reprehensible musicians of Purple Confusion, I knew there was only one answer. I bought a pair of knitting needles.

It is not so very difficult to lacerate your own eardrum. Have a double scotch first, perhaps. There will be a loud pop and a small burst of pain, but then the needle will slide out effortlessly.

Still, the music does not die. What, then?

THE END

Posted Nov 07, 2026
Share:

You must sign up or log in to submit a comment.

4 likes 0 comments

Reedsy | Default — Editors with Marker | 2024-05

Bring your publishing dreams to life

The world's best editors, designers, and marketers are on Reedsy. Come meet them.