The cafe was on the west side of the park. It formed a triangle between the otherwise quiet, tree-lined streets that would disappear when its rolling glass doors opened in the morning. Coffee beans and humidity wafted through the busy, tightly placed bistro tables and all the way down the block, just like it did in Paris or New York, but this was only a rust belt city.
Her petite silhouette contrasted against the bright blues of the tiles of the bar. A casual black sundress exposed her tanned back, gleaming in a hazy sunlight from the yoga session next door. Her dirty blonde hair, which normally came down just beyond her shoulders, was pulled up off her dewy neck in a messy sort of bun, and her bangs stuck slightly to her forehead.
Her dog, Zuzu, an unusual mix of collie or aussie and golden, lay contently at her sandaled feet, unhooked from a green leather leash that hung loosely over the side of a tote bag marked ‘AD’.
Thunderclouds ahead tempted sunrays painting a pink morning sky, but a good summer rain was her favorite.
It was Saturday at just 9:03 in the morning.
She set aside her neatly filled notebook, unconsciously twisting the diamond-banded ring on her right hand, the way she always did. She looked over at her empty plate of eggs and then down into the cup of her usual dark roast; its perfectly formed heart, now beginning to dissolve. She paused, but only for a moment. As she closed her eyes to take another sip, a familiar scent washed over her– something of amber or peppermint, as the delicate breeze carried it through the salted air and the wispy strands of her golden hair grazed across her cheek. She thought it to be only a memory, her writing still lingering in her mind, when no sooner, a cool hand pressed gently upon her shoulder.
Breathing in, she turned, with an uncertain smile, toward the well of the bistro, and found herself looking up into a pair of piercing blue eyes, set on the familiar face of a boy in the body of a man she used to love.
She felt the blood drain from her, as he casually said,
“Milly? I thought it was you. How long has it been, 15 years?”
The sky rumbled softly above them. Time seemed to freeze.
Her mind raced backwards like an old tape;
Twenty years to the day they met and every moment thereafter– rapidly recounting all the times he made her cry, and how he once apologized, and how she once forgave him; Remembering his words and how they, ‘just never connected.’
She surprised herself by thinking this way, and no later how– this couldn't possibly be in her story anymore, not after everything, not after all this time.
Deep in her heart, this moment had been something she had once imagined, sure; Something at one time she thought she wanted, but something that had also broken her up for years.
She didn’t know herself then, she reasoned.
She didn't know what would happen and how much life would change, or all of the things she would have to go through, and how she didn’t expect anyone, let alone him, to accept any of it, or her, at all.
Her nerves resisted as her body, in present time, attempted to remind herself of all of the sun salutations she did a mere hour ago.
Why was she so nervous?
Hadn’t she settled these feelings? Hadn’t she made sense of it all?
Years of uncertainty had answered her, certainly.
But this? Now?
She thought she had grown and changed.
‘Why does this matter anymore?,’ she asked herself impatiently.
‘Remember who you are,’ she wrestled back.
But at that exact second, she didn't know anything anymore and all of the positive mantras that had been written on her mirror for years were seemingly falling down the drain; Everything she used to remember and remind herself of, she couldn’t.
Her brain was as scrambled as the eggs she just ate, as her ears gradually began to take hold of the cafe-clatter surrounding them and the upbeat notes of jazz moving through the speakers, though still playing, as it seemed to her, in slow motion.
In that point in time, all she could manage to muster and grasp ahold of was the feeling of sheer surprise, as the room around her, the cup, and his face, emerged again.
But not a beat later, Zuzu, as if feeling the twinge in her owner’s heart, leapt up from the concrete and tore out from under the barstool.
“I’m sorry!,” she blurted to him–The only words that broke her years-long silence as she jumped up after her dog.
The moment, once more, had gone.
The leaves on the trees rustled amidst the subtle commotion while cafe dwellers carried on with their flaky pastries and Italian espressos, immersed in the morning chatter of their breakfast rituals, completely oblivious to the scene that had unfolded beside them.
‘The timing was never right,’ she assured herself when clipping the leash back onto a now panting Zuzu, who had been lured by a familiar florist’s pocketful of biscuits while passing by to open up shop.
But this feeling she had, she knew, was something she couldn’t ‘just erase’– not immediately anyway.
In her daze, she found herself standing in the middle of the sidewalk, picturing his face, grown from her last memory but somehow still the same, and she allowed herself to wonder, only for a moment, who he might have become.
The air grew thicker and the morning sky dimmed, succumbing to hues of grey.
A loud crack in the distance gave way to a patter, motioning across nearby rooftops and hot pavement.
With Zuzu by her side, she turned to walk back down the emptied block toward home, when at the end of the street, breathless and almost defeated, there he was, and then— the rain.
You must sign up or log in to submit a comment.
Hi,
I read in your bio that you are trying to figure things out. Not sure what things, you're talking about so I started reading your story. \
You have a strong eye for atmosphere. The café, the approaching storm, the dissolving heart in the coffee, and the final image of him standing in the rain all give the scene a cinematic, slightly dreamlike quality. Milly’s shock also feels believable, especially because her body reacts before she manages to think clearly.
Here are some points of advice, all given in good faith;
I think the main thing to work on is focus. The opening contains many descriptive details before the encounter begins, and several sentences carry multiple images at once. Choosing only the details that reveal something about Milly or build tension would make the meeting arrive more quickly and give it greater impact.
The same applies to her internal reaction. We understand very early that seeing him unsettles her, but the story explains that feeling several times. You could trust the physical details—the twisting ring, the scrambled thoughts, Zuzu suddenly running off—to show more of that emotion for you. The fewer times you explain it, the stronger those moments will become.
There are also a few technical points worth checking: *contently* should be *contentedly*, some semicolons would work better as full stops, and words following a semicolon should not normally begin with a capital letter. The sentence beginning *“She thought it to be only a memory…”* could also be divided into two or three shorter sentences for clarity.
The ending is your strongest section. His reappearance at the end of the street creates a real question about what Milly will do next. You already have the atmosphere and emotional premise; tightening the language and trusting your strongest images would make the story much more powerful.\
Shouold you have any questions on how to figure things out, you can always reach me via my profile page. Looking forward reading more from you.
Till then.
Reply
Thank you for taking the time to write and comment. Your timing was quite kismet, as I had opened this writing just a few hours before, after not looking at it for months (just after reading your beautiful story). I am glad you were able to get a visual out of the writing and I appreciate the cinematic reference.
Revisiting the piece, I will say, that middle section makes me cringe! It's not my best work. I agree with you, I stretched it too far. It definitely lacks focus and diminishes the build-up of the moment.
Perhaps I was caught up in the time and word count of the contest, or if I'm being honest, in the blurred line between fiction and non...a writer's dilemma.
I very much appreciate your analysis and critique. It is always good to get constructive feedback. I hope to revise this if I can...Its a story I've been trying to unfold for quite some time. Thank you for reading & reviewing it!
Reply
Thank you for receiving my feedback so openly. I can imagine that the blurred line between fiction and personal experience makes it especially difficult to know what to keep and what to cut, because every detail may carry its own meaning.
The atmosphere and emotional core are already there, though, so I hope you do return to it. I’d genuinely be interested to read the revised version someday.
Reply