Multiple Choice

🏆 Contest #198 Winner!

American Sad High School

Written in response to: "Write a story that contains the phrase “Okay class! Pop quiz.”" as part of Teacher’s Pet.

Okay class! Pop quiz. If you've been doing the readings, this should be a piece of cake. Remember to fill out both sides of this paper. You have the whole class period to finish. Good luck.


1. Christopher Columbus first traveled to the Americas using which means of transportation?


A) A cargo ship

B) A steam locomotive

C) A Boeing 747 airliner 

D) A vintage red 1985 Camaro with a crack in the middle of the windshield and no heated seats



2. What is the term for the pilgrims leaving England to journey to America?


A) Immigration

B) Emigration

C) Migration

D) A breakup



3. What is the name of the people who were already living in America before the arrival of the Mayflower?


A) Indigenous Peoples

B) New Yorkers

C) Canadians

D) A fiancée



4. Founded in the early 1600s, Thanksgiving best symbolizes which of the following?


A) Eating a Tofurky dinner alone in a home that smells like pumpkin pie and the leftover bottle of aftershave you found under the bathroom sink and summarily poured down the drain

B) A celebration of the harvest and a means of giving thanks for other such blessings of the year

C) Your five-year-old son choosing to spend the holiday at his father's new apartment

D) Both A and C



5. Salem, Massachusetts, was famous for its witch trials, wherein a number of men and women were accused of performing acts of dark magic and sentenced to death. Now, imagine a woman named, say, Sally. Which of the following is something a guilty woman like Sally might reasonably have been accused of?


A) Sneaking off with another woman's fiancé during your springtime PTA meetings

B) Luring a woman's son to Thanksgiving dinner with the promise of cooking a real turkey

C) Driving a vintage red 1985 Camaro that doesn't belong to her to the Safeway in your neighborhood, despite her apartment, which she now shares with the car's owner, being on the other side of town, twenty-five minutes away.

D) All of the above



6. Please select the adjective you think best describes Sally from the previous example.


A) Caring

B) Considerate

C) Thoughtful

D) None of the above



7. Please select the adjective (or phrase!) you think best describes the nameless fiancé from question 5.


A) Ignorant

B) Hedonistic

C) Confused

D) Doesn't understand he's letting a good thing go by choosing Sally instead of the superior PTA woman.



8. What is the definition of a "pilgrim"?


A) A person who journeys, especially a long distance, to some sacred place.

B) A person who journeys, especially twenty-five minutes away, to an apartment in the gutter of Bismarck, North Dakota.

C) A person who journeys, especially twenty-five minutes away, to a supermarket in the heartland of Bismarck, North Dakota, with the intent of running into people on the PTA so she can "accidentally" display her new engagement ring, the same sapphire ring that fit on someone else's finger not too long ago.

D) A woman who shares joint custody of her turkey-bribed son, a woman who tucks him in and reads him a bedtime story every night and kisses him on the forehead, then spends the next thirty minutes scrolling through her ex-fiancé's social media posts in the hopes that she'll see her name pop up.



9. What is the name for someone who invades a foreign state or nation with the intent to dominate or gain control over its settlers?


A) Homewrecker

B) Adulterer

C) Sally

D) Colonialist



10. What was the reason the pilgrims left their first home and strayed to America?


A) They said their needs weren't being met with England.

B) They wanted to break away from the Protestant Church and start their own religious community.

C) They said they hadn't been truly happy in a long, long time.

D) They said the only reason they hung in there as long as they did was because of the five year old.



11. Which of the following statements is true, pertaining to question 10?


A) England watched the pilgrims sail away to America, watched them drift toward the horizon until they were nothing but a speck in the sunset, knowing there was nothing they could do.

B) England waited for days, weeks, months, hoping the pilgrims would come back, checking every starlit night for a sign of their return. 

C) England would still take them back with open arms, even after they chose another place and another life, if they only chose to come back.

D) All of the above



12. Do you think the pilgrims ever thought about returning to England when they were off with their homewreckers/adulterers/Sallys/colonialists?


A) Yes, definitely

B) Maybe once in a while

C) Every other weekend, when the joint custody kicked in

D) No (briefly explain your reasoning in the space below, if chosen)



13. How quickly things change. Not even 200 years after the arrival of the pilgrims to America, the founding fathers spearheaded the American Revolution, instituted the presidential system, and even created the Declaration of Independence. Which of the following is a line from that famous document?


A) "We need to talk."

B) "Look, Lainey, this just isn't working out anymore. It's not you, it's me. Please don't bring Sally into this."

C) "We hold these truths to be self-evident, that all men are created equal."

D) "Daddy said you can come to his wedding with me, Mommy. Why are you crying? He said you can come too."



Extra credit bonus question: You finish your quiz early. When you walk up to the front to turn it in, you notice your teacher is at her desk, silently weeping into her thermos of lukewarm first-period coffee. What should you do?


A) Turn in your paper, say nothing, and return to your desk—chances are that if she scheduled a quiz for the entire class period, she probably needs some time to herself.

B) Turn in your paper, say nothing, and return to your desk—chances are that your teacher is like England when they were waiting for the pilgrims to return, and with enough time, she'll understand the truth.

C) Turn in your paper, say nothing, and return to your desk—chances are that you could end up like her someday, because history repeats itself.

D) All of the above.

Posted May 20, 2023
Share:

You must sign up or log in to submit a comment.

286 likes 189 comments

RJ Holmquist
May 26, 2023 21:24

Facinating how this format made the story "unputdownable." Each question contained little clues that drew me along and even though, as the second to last line suggests, the plot of the story is all too familiar, the putting together of the clues made it "must find out" for me as a reader. Seems like maybe this is "show not tell" doing its best work. Congratulations on the win!

Reply

Zack Powell
May 26, 2023 22:40

Thanks, RJ! Your winning story really made me go back to the drawing board with how I approached storytelling for these prompts. This piece was the aftermath of that recalibration, so a special thank you to you for the inspiration. Cheers!

Reply

Jody S
May 26, 2023 20:05

This is awesome and I am so happy I got to enjoy it!! I love how you ran with the prompt in one of the coolest takes I have seen in any prompt situation! Congrats on the win!! Well deserved!!

Reply

Zack Powell
May 26, 2023 21:06

Thank you very much, Jody! Knew I had to try this format when I read this prompt, but I didn't think it'd actually amount to anything. I appreciate the generous comment!

Reply

Jody S
May 26, 2023 21:16

I wrote to the same prompt. I was about 55% pleased with the outcome of mine. I just love how out of the box you took it!! That is what I am missing in my writing!

Reply

Andrew Fruchtman
May 26, 2023 19:41

This was a hoot!! Loved it. Very clever take on the prompt. LOL funny.

Reply

Zack Powell
May 26, 2023 20:04

Thanks, Andrew! Was an absolute blast to write, so I'm glad it was well-received.

Reply

Viga Boland
May 26, 2023 19:21

Clever beyond words. Bravo! Congratulations on this week’s win. 👏👏

Reply

Zack Powell
May 26, 2023 20:04

Thank you very much, Viga! 👏

Reply

Mac Paul
May 26, 2023 18:04

A perfect creative examine, Zack for this weeks prompt. I agree with all the previous posts and congratulate you on your well deserved victory. Bettie MacIntyre

Reply

Zack Powell
May 26, 2023 20:05

Thank you so much for the kindness! It's much appreciated.

Reply

Marty B
May 26, 2023 17:57

An A+ for this quiz! and Congrats on the Win!
I loved the multiple levels of the story behind the story. The details of the different senses were great,
-smells like pumpkin pie and the leftover bottle of aftershave
-no heated seats
-watched them drift toward the horizon until they were nothing but a speck in the sunset
and the great descriptive words- 'luring'

Loved it
Fav line: 'Turn in your paper, say nothing, and return to your desk—chances are that you could end up like her someday, because history repeats itself.'

Reply

Zack Powell
May 26, 2023 19:53

Thanks for the love, Marty! Was a super fun story to write with all the layers and senses, so I'm glad you caught onto what I was going for. Much appreciated, and I see you've got a new story of your own out there. Looking forward to reading it this weekend!

Reply

Matthew Guerrero
May 26, 2023 17:45

That was brilliant, congrats on winning.

Reply

Zack Powell
May 26, 2023 19:51

Thanks a bunch for the kindness, Matthew!

Reply

Kendall Defoe
May 26, 2023 16:37

Brilliant, and a well-deserved win!

Reply

Zack Powell
May 26, 2023 19:51

Thank you very much, Kendall!

Reply

Wally Schmidt
May 26, 2023 16:07

Couldn't be happier for you!!! Tears of joy. Congratulations!

Reply

Zack Powell
May 26, 2023 19:51

Wally! Thank you, thank you, thank you! Your positivity gives me life. I appreciate this comment so much.

Reply

Susan Catucci
May 26, 2023 15:46

Congratulations, Zack! What do I think of this win? (A) Thrilled for the author, (B) The judges got it right, (C) The story's so good, I'm anxious to read it again, (D) Not at all surprised but super pleased, (E) It's great when good stuff happens to good stories. :)

Reply

Zack Powell
May 26, 2023 19:50

Hopefully there's an (F) for all of the above, Susan! 😂 Thank you very much for the kindness and the praise.

Reply

Susan Catucci
May 26, 2023 20:08

It was implied, Zack - there's not an "F" in sight other than for fantastic.

Reply

May 26, 2023 15:31

5th win for the Mr. Powell -- WOO HOOOO
So pleased for this piece. Clever clever clever

Reply

Zack Powell
May 26, 2023 19:49

And a resounding congratulations on your fifteenth shortlist, Deidra! You did Van Halen proud.

Reply

Suma Jayachandar
May 26, 2023 15:12

Woo hoo Zack, that audacity paid off! Congratulations🎉👏👏

Reply

Zack Powell
May 26, 2023 19:48

Suma! Thank you as always for the kindness, the love, and the support. The audacity certainly did pay off!

Reply

Susan Catucci
May 25, 2023 20:08

Hi Zack - You do not disappoint because (A) you engage a reader from the first word to the last; (B) you execute so well the perfect balance of humor, savvy smarts and insight; (C) you have a gift; (D) you will accept my apology for going a little overboard with this comment; (E) all of the above. :)

Reply

Zack Powell
May 26, 2023 02:20

This is one of the best comments I've ever received, hands down. Multiple choice responses? I love it. Thanks for the kindness and levity, Susan. (And there's no such thing as "overboard" in a comment - the more, the better!)

Reply

Wally Schmidt
May 24, 2023 20:32

This is F-in Fabulous!
At first I thought this story was going to be a MC test full of Zack slaps like these:
https://www.boredpanda.com/hilarious-funny-test-answers/?utm_source=google&utm_medium=organic&utm_campaign=organic
but it became apparent rather quickly that there was something deeply troubling going on with the teacher.
Although the heart of the story is gut wrenching, you managed to include the Zack slaps and stay true to the form. I think I never really thought about form until the Reedsy prompt a few weeks ago that focused on that, but I have grown more fond of it since then and this piece is a stellar example of what you can do with it.
As for the content, who knew you could put so many emotions into a MC quiz? The depths of despair that the teacher is experiencing comes through in every single question. I wish I could give her a big hug; I also hope the kids left her alone that day.
Not enough accolades for this story my friend.

Reply

Zack Powell
May 24, 2023 23:21

Those test answers are hilarious, Wally! And funny enough, this story was supposed to go in that comedic direction, but as it went deeper, so did this woman's pain and hurt. So, there's that.
Regarding form, I think you've done some wonderful experimenting there too. Dialogue-heavy stories, the repeating line at the beginning of each paragraph. I always look forward to seeing how you're going to attack the prompts you've chosen.
And I'd also like to give this woman a big hug. Can't imagine how tough life would be in this situation, especially if you take that with you to your job.
Thanks again, Wally! Your comment made my day.

Reply

56 Independent
May 24, 2023 13:16

I love how you experiment with the form of storytelling! It makes your story stand out among a crowd of others.

Reply

Zack Powell
May 24, 2023 15:54

Thank you very much! Experimenting with form is my favorite thing about short story writing, so I'm glad it was well-received here.

Reply

56 Independent
May 24, 2023 18:14

I mean, i am biased, as i also love experimenting with form. I've tried parrelel stories where two main characters go about their lives together in a linked way, a "document collection", and once this really weird one in a non-linear order which wasn't that good.
Good luck!

Reply

Nathaniel Miller
May 24, 2023 03:13

Smart. Really smart.

Clever use of a multiple-choice test to tell a snarky, inevitably heartbreaking story. I’m a big fan of this one.

Like others have said, this one is a winner, whether it wins or not. A win for creativity, for sure. You used the prompt in a way I haven’t seen in a long time. You owned it, perhaps even defined it. So, yeah. A win.

I’ve said this before, but what I like so much about your storytelling is how deftly you intertwine sadness with humor (and, in this case, snark). It creates a nuance that has very few rivals on this platform.

Anyways, thanks for a really entertaining, thought-provoking read. I’ll be thinking about your approach to this (and, of course, the brilliant execution) for a while. Cheers!

Reply

Zack Powell
May 24, 2023 04:09

Very kind of you to say, Nathaniel. I adore this kind of sad/funny storytelling, because those genres are so closely related in my mind. Humor's gotten me through some rough times, so that mentality kind of oozes into the fiction. (And it also gives me a chance to be as snarky and sarcastic and cutting as I want.)

Very glad the formatting worked for you, too - always a gamble when you get creative with structure, and I had my doubts after submitting it. Thanks for the thoughtful feedback. It made my night. Cheers!

Reply

Sue Hunter
May 23, 2023 22:06

So creative, Zack. Well done.

Reply

Zack Powell
May 24, 2023 04:48

Thank you very much, Sue!

Reply

Michał Przywara
May 23, 2023 21:22

What a cool format :)

We start off with a "one of these is not like the others" vibe, and it's even quite amusing. But what's happening behind the scenes quickly becomes apparent, and it takes a sad turn.

I had initially imagined this was someone taking the quiz, and that she was understandably distracted. But it seems she actually created the quiz, so now I'm not sure if it is distraction, or if perhaps some of these answers made it into the actual quiz, and she's broken with reality.

The theme is clear either way. A breakup like that weighs on the mind, and invades all aspects of life. Comparing it to the British/US split is a neat device. Particularly given it was a rather violent parting. And it makes me wonder how other things fit into the analogy, like the son. (And given history repeats itself, who then is the Civil War about?)

Very creative story, Zack :)

Reply

Zack Powell
May 23, 2023 23:02

Thanks, Michał! Couldn't pass up a chance to try out a new format. I'm of the opinion you've shared with me before - at worst, you just throw one week away, but the benefits of experimenting usually outweigh the downsides.

You're right, in that the quiz is from the POV of the teacher who made it, and I'd like to think you're equally right about the distraction factor. I imagine she's so caught up in her own personal turmoil that it bubbles over from her broken private life into her professional school life. And now you've got me thinking of a Civil War corollary. Hmm.

Thanks as always for giving me something to think about with my own story.

Reply

Michał Przywara
May 26, 2023 20:54

Woo congrats :D

Experimenting definitely paid off this week :) And you've established a new format to boot! That sounds like a good Friday to me :)

Reply

Zack Powell
May 26, 2023 21:08

Thanks, Michał! Always nice to have experimentation rewarded, especially for a format like this that I probably won't be able to use again. A good Friday, indeed.

Reply

Will Oyowe
May 23, 2023 17:06

Hey Zack, I really liked the experimentalism that you submitted.
I wish I had more time to read it; maybe I would have liked it more.
But I really appreciate your experimental vision and the multichoice questions.
I think that was a brave effort. I was a bit confused about that (multichoice questions.}
well and how they correlated. In the end, though, the story fell flat for me and made me not want to read it again.

Although I did like this sentence here, which is excellent.

9. What is the name for someone who invades a foreign state or nation with the intent to dominate or gain control over its settlers?

A) Homewrecker

B) Adulterer

C) Sally

D) Colonialist

The reason why I like this is the three multi-choice responses that metaphorically mesh well with the question.
Kind of like you playing around with the metaphor of colonialism with being a like homewrecker, which I thought was very interesting.

Reply

Zack Powell
May 23, 2023 18:32

Thanks for the good feedback, Will! This piece was definitely an experiment in form and seeing how much you can tell vs. how much you can leave unsaid, so no worries if it fell flat for you. I appreciate you letting me know where you got confused. Helps me out tremendously so I can know what to tweak. And I'm glad question 9 worked for you; it was my favorite part of writing this. Thanks again for the thoroughness of your two comments.

Reply

Will Oyowe
May 23, 2023 19:53

No worries, bro. To be honest, of all the ones I have read, this was the most interesting, lol. I would. Instead, people do new things in their writing than just conventional narrative. Continue experimenting. MORE PLEASE!!

Reply

Will Oyowe
May 23, 2023 16:44

Hey Zack, First off, I really liked your experimental style. I don't have a lot of time during the day, so I didn't have to delve deep into it; I bet ita a lot better than I read it the first time. I was it little confused about Sally, the interrogation of colonialism and how this factored into the modern day, and how the test and questions somehow intertwined with the narrative. This prevented me from getting into the narrative and really prevented me from wanting to read it again, but I guess I may have needed time to digest it.

I did like this
"""""9. What is the name for someone who invades a foreign state or nation with the intent to dominate or gain control over its settlers?

A) Homewrecker

B) Adulterer

C) Sally

D) Colonialist""""""

I think this was clever as the words can be multiple answers to the question, even from a metaphorical sense. I was just confused about the theme of it. Anyway brave effort.

Reply

May 23, 2023 15:02

This is somehow both hilarious and heartbreaking. Oozing cleverness. Lainey can do much better!

Reply

Zack Powell
May 23, 2023 17:21

Thanks, Anne! Glad the hilarious/heartbreaking counterbalance worked for you. And I agree with you 100% about Lainey.

Reply

May 26, 2023 19:47

Very pleased that you won this! Congratulations

Reply

Zack Powell
May 26, 2023 20:32

Thank you very much, Anne!

Reply

Mike Panasitti
May 22, 2023 15:56

You know you're not taking any ordinary multiple choice quiz when the possible answers to the questions make you laugh harder the further into the quiz you go.

My favorite question is number 9, the one that puts colonialists, homewreckers, and adulterers on equal footing with Sally.

You've conducted an original formal experiment here and deserve acknowledgement for charting previously unnavigated waters.

Reply

Zack Powell
May 22, 2023 18:46

Thanks as always, Mike. As this was meant to be a funny (or at least sarcastic/jaded) story, I'm glad there were some laughs. And I think you deserve acknowledgement as well - your book review story a few weeks ago got me wanting to do some experimenting of my own.

Reply

Rylee Rose
August 18, 2025 13:04

Nice story it is cool

Reply

Roshni Bhatia
May 21, 2025 00:12

Great story! It's always inspiring as a young writer to read others' stories to discover new types of stories and genres. Thanks for the great read, Zack!
~Roshni

Reply

Kitan Peters
January 17, 2025 19:32

Wow! Amazing! I loved the rhythm and flow of it; really clever to use a pop quiz as a story! *chef kiss*

Reply

RBE | Illustrated Short Stories | 2024-06

Bring your short stories to life

Fuse character, story, and conflict with tools in Reedsy Studio. All for free.