Now You See Me

Contemporary Fiction

Written in response to: "Set your story at an event (a party, séance, funeral, etc.) where something goes wrong." as part of A Fright to Remember.

Now You See Me

Abraham Bullfinch died suddenly Sunday, November 3rd, after watching the midterm election results.He is survived by his two estranged sons, an ex-wife, a dog, and a neighbor who said he felt like he was living next door to a political garden. He died, it is rumored, of a heart attack. No confirmation of his death from heart failure was confirmed at the time of this obituary. 

#

“No!, it’s the one on the left. Gladys Johnson is in that room. She didn’t like people they say, so it might be best if you confined your visit to the ones you know, safer that way.  Mr. Bullfinch is behind the pink door. He requested the color in his last will and testament which he posted to the internet shortly before his demise.  A premonition, a bad lunch experience, It raining and he forgotten his umbrella, no one knows or will ever know, thankfully. The neighbor, the one who thought Bullfinches yard looked like a political garden because of all the political signs, said Bullfinch once put a sign up, according to Mr. Kelley the neighbor, he refused to take it down.

Mr. Kelly stated for the record that Bullfinch had no party allegiance. He didn’t care if you were a republican or democrat, he disliked them all the same. But he loved signs. He thought the reds and blues contrasted each other nicely and when he added the yellow and green signs of the environmental advocates, he was in heaven, so to speak. He didn’t believe in God, only color and signs; that was, according to Mr. Kelley; the other neighbors refused to talk to me about Bullfinch. Many of them, although they didn’t come right out and say so, did imply, that speaking of the dead was paramount to fast tracking yourself to Hatti, which I interpreted to mean the other place, hell.

Mr. Bullfinch believed the elections were safe, secure, and as accurate as they can be considering the poll workers are all volunteer citizens claiming to be performing their civic duty. I found the reference to performing a rather odd choice of words considering democracy is not a performance, that is reserved for the politicking before the election; but then we all make mistakes, assumptions at the top of the list.

The viewing, which was more like a social gathering, a movie premier or an author’s reading, more so than a wake. Half the people I interviewed, when asked, couldn’t come up with one thing they liked about Bullfinch. So I asked, “what are you doing here?” I was expecting the same old song and dance about duty, obligation or my wife made me, but no. They all had their own reasons for coming, only two were duplicate reasons, “we wanted to make sure he was dead.” The majority of the others said, and I quote, “he wasn’t so bad once you got to know him.” Two of those who said that, added, “he was much worse.”

I’d never been to a wake where people were genuinely concerned that he wasn’t actually dead, or with the aid of an elaborate scheme pretending, or that somehow his death was going to make him a lot of money. I’ve never understood how wealth and death can be related. I was taught you can’t take it with you. I know that people have tried and will probably continue to try. I believe it all started with the Pharaoh's of Egypt being buried with all their valuables so they could make a good impression when moving to the other side.

I asked one of the visitors what she thought was meant by the other side. I explained first about the belief that you can’t take it with you so she’d know what I was referring to. She believed it meant that on the other side of death is another form of life. I asked what would be the point? And she said that, “it is the way we get to get it right, had we gotten it wrong previously.” I asked, “so you believe it is a second chance to make up for the mistakes we made the first time around?” 

“It sounds weird when you put it that way. I was thinking more along the lines of asking for forgiveness because we admitted to making mistakes and wished to rectify them.” I could see her point, but Bullfinch claimed he didn’t believe in God, so what does someone do when there is no one to repent to or do penance for? She didn’t know, but said she believed no one really doesn’t believe in God, they just say they don’t because it is easier than admitting your life is full of mistakes and you are to arrogant to admit it. 

I could see from the answers I was receiving, that I was not going to get a headline obit out of any of them if I didn’t get to the heart of the matter and ask the question I know everyone dreads but it needs to be asked; “regardless of what kind of man he was, do you believe God will forgive him or will he have to make amends for all his transgressions?” They all looked at me like I hadn’t been paying attention.     

He was an atheist they all said, not at the same time, but during the course of our conversations. They all believed that those who do not believe in God don’t have to go through the same rigorous questioning that believers do. One older woman told me that, “if you don’t believe in God, then he can’t believe in you. So how could he judge someone he doesn’t know?”

How could He judge someone he doesn’t know? A good question although it is hardly a mystery. We judge other people we don’t know all the time. It’s like a pass time we’ve developed to justify our prejudices. From gerrymandering what little we do know into fact or selectively bargaining with ourselves to choose just the right combination of facts to make our point, we have developed a game that has taken on all the aspects of prejudice without being politically incorrect. It is not an easy thing to pull off, even when we are aware of our own shortcomings when it comes to selective reasoning or overt lying if you prefer. 

But that is neither here nor there. Everyone has had to say goodbye to someone they know. Each person that knew him could and did make up their own minds about what they thought of him. I began to understand the democratic process wakes present to those who feel they have an obligation to be kind and understanding, on the one hand, and those that believe there aren’t enough devils in the world and they’d like to volunteer. 

I have to be truthful, I was shocked by the callus attitude everyone seemed to have toward Abraham Bullfinch. I didn’t know him personally, but I had come to despise him nearly as much as those in attendance, with a little help from his friends. There is something about ill will that is contagious. It is one of the few times in my career as an investigative reporter, where I felt the tide shift to incorporate truth and fact and not simply sentimentality, because someone is dead.

#

I’ve been listening to this one-sided version of events and to be honest I feel sorry for people who find it easier to look at other people’s lives to make themselves feel better about their shortcomings. It is always easier to find the fault in someone when you yourself have exhibited the same tendencies, whether it be for self-aggrandizement, or financial gain. It is easier to find what you are looking for when you know exactly where to find it. If you have never been in the situation I find myself in, a visitation where people have come to say goodbye, or from the looks of things, good riddens to me. I’ve known a lot of these people for over forty years and I don’t know how I managed.If I had to give one piece of advice to anyone it would be that telling the truth is the most self-destructive thing you can do. 

People don’t want to know what you think of them or what they do, they would rather you lied to their faces and pretended you admired them to the point of changing your entire life in order to emulate their every movement. Of course you’d being lying to yourself at that point, but you probably wouldn’t have a line of people that have come to say goodbye who were more than pleased you have left and their only regret, is that you hadn’t left sooner.

I’m not attempting to say they are wrong. We are all wrong when you get down to it, but there comes a time when you realize you can’t please everyone, so you’ve got to please yourself. I don’t believe I was intentionally cruel.  Like I said, honesty has a way of changing beliefs and allegiances and you find yourself alone. It takes a while to realize being alone is not as bad as being complicit in someone else’s fantasy about themselves. What I will miss the most is people’s inability to be honest with themselves as it reflects their view of everyone they come into contact with. The most difficult thing I’ve had to get used to, to this point, is that I no longer have the physical aspects of life to blame for my failures. Once you remove your body from the equation it leaves only you. Who you were, who you are, and whether you’ve learned to differentiate between the two.

The chapel minister has agreed to carry my remains to the burial plot my family purchased years previously, and spread my ashes amongst grasses I do not know, but then I don’t know that I ever really knew anyone, let alone grasses. Becoming part of another system, a different form of energy, old histories and a new beginnings, gives me hope all is not lost, for the grasses that is.           

Posted Oct 31, 2026
Share:

You must sign up or log in to submit a comment.

0 likes 0 comments

RBE | Illustrated Short Stories | 2024-06

Bring your short stories to life

Fuse character, story, and conflict with tools in Reedsy Studio. All for free.