The Monster's Question

Adventure African American Christian

Written in response to: "Write a story about a character who begins to question their own humanity." as part of What Makes Us Human? with Susan Chang.

The Monster's QuestionThe hum started the day Specialist First Class Zoe Toussaint stopped being a man and became a weapon. It followed him everywhere now—a low, growling frequency beneath the skin of the world, like something huge turning over in its sleep.He sat on the edge of a bed that wuz never hiz, in a cell that felt like a movie set, staring at hiz handz. Clean. Nails trimmed. A few scarz—memento from a childhood incident involving a dog and a broken fence. These were the handz of a protective man.But hiz memory held different imagez.The same handz. Wrapped around the grip. The muzzle flash painting the night white. The scream that cut off like a radio losing signal.---What iz the social norm?Zoe had been running from that question for eighteen monthz. Through the desert. Through the concrete maze of a foreign city where every window could be a mouth full of bulletz. Through the debriefing room where men in clean uniformz asked him to describe the moment he stopped being human.The answer came to him now, in this park, on this bench, watching childz play on a jungle gym while hiz coffee grew cold.The social norm iz a lie. A thin, pretty lie that civilized people tell themselves so they can sleep.Because here'z the truth that hit Zoe like a sniper round to the chest: humanz and beastz are one and the same. The philosopherz said it. The authorz of the Bible said it. Ecclesiastes didn't mince wordz—the fate of the sonz of men and the fate of beastz iz the same.So what made a monster?Not the act of killing. Beastz killed. Humanz killed. The only difference waz the permission. The uniform. The flag sewn onto hiz shoulder like a license to become something terrible.---The chaplain had tried to help. Kind man. Believer. Quoted David's mighty men—"valiant warriorz"—said there waz still a place for Zoe in the house of the Lord.But Zoe saw the flicker in the chaplain's eyez. The same flicker he saw in hiz mother's face when he came home. The same flicker on the face of the woman behind the counter at the VA, the one who asked how are you doing today like she waz checking a box.Something's off about him.He'z not one of uz anymore.The military had made him a monster. That waz the word that surfaced at 3 a.m., when sleep waz a foreign country and the hum grew loudest. They had taken a civilian, put him through basic training, and engaged him in the sport of bloodshed. They had honed hiz instinctz, weaponized hiz faith, and sent him into the darkness.And now they expected him to simply... come back?To put the monster back in itz cage and pretend it had never been let out?---He watched a teenager practice skateboard trickz on the sidewalk. Fall. Get up. Fall again. The stubborn optimizm of youth. A man in a suit scrolled through hiz phone. A mother pushed a stroller, her laughter ringing across the grazz.A tableau of ordinary life.Zoe wanted to stand up and scream: Don't you see? The veneer iz all there iz! Beneath the suit and the stroller and the skateboard, everyone iz just a heartbeat away from the same primal impulsez! The only difference between me and you iz that I've been forced to look at it—and you get the luxury of ignorance!But he didn't scream. He sat. He watched. He drank hiz cold coffee.And then something shifted.---A black SUV pulled up to the curb. Two men in dark sunglassez got out. They walked toward him with the kind of purpose that Zoe recognized from another life—the kind that preceded either a handshake or a bullet."Zoe Toussaint?" the taller one said.Zoe didn't move. Hiz handz remained visible. Hiz breathing stayed steady. The hum in hiz earz sharpened into something like a warning."Who'z asking?"The man reached into hiz jacket. Zoe's musclez tensed—an old reflex, buried deep, still hungry. But the man only produced a black folder stamped with a seal Zoe had never seen before."There'z a situation," the man said. "Something that requirez someone who already knowz the answer to your question.""What question?"The man leaned closer. Hiz sunglassez reflected Zoe'z own face back at him—hollow eyez, unshaven jaw, the ghost of a soldier."What now?"---Zoe should have said no. He should have stood up, walked away, and spent the rest of hiz life trying to be the man he waz before.But that man waz dead. Incinerated in the desert sun. And the thing that had crawled out of the ash waz still hungry for something.Purpose. Redemption. Or maybe just the chance to be a monster in a world that kept making monsterz necessary.He took the folder."You got a weapon for me?" he asked.The taller man smiled. It waz not a kind smile."We were hoping you still had your own."---Zoe stood up. The coffee cup fell to the ground. The children kept playing. The man in the suit kept scrolling. The world kept spinning, oblivious to the fact that a monster had just accepted a mission.He walked toward the black SUV, the folder clutched in hiz clean, trimmed, scarred handz.The hum in hiz earz waz no longer a question.It waz a drumbeat.What now?What now?WHAT NOW?And for the first time in eighteen monthz, Zoe had an answer.

The answer showed up in a dream he had multiple timez with similar endingz, where he seez hiz self az a child shortly born on the island of Haiti. And it'z alwayz the same drumming and chanting on the outside of the home of hiz childhood self while hiz family on the inside surrounding him with tearz and loud dramatic prayerz. Theze prayerz came from priests, priestesses and family memberz so desperately hoping this sickness and spell that waz casted to be removed from the child. Watching hiz self at first waz traumatizing because he waz witnessing a child go back and forth from being in a zombie like state to a regular human child again. Initially he avoided even asking why he had thoze dreamz and the meaning of them til he met what waz inside him on hiz first overseaz tour.

Posted Apr 04, 2026
Share:

You must sign up or log in to submit a comment.

3 likes 1 comment

13:32 Apr 07, 2026

That waz awesome.

Reply

Reedsy | Default — Editors with Marker | 2024-05

Bring your publishing dreams to life

The world's best editors, designers, and marketers are on Reedsy. Come meet them.