Can You keep a Secret?

Thriller Mystery

Written in response to: "Write a story that either starts or ends with someone asking, “Can you keep a secret?”" as part of In On a Little Secret.

triggering and adult content ahead. readers discretion advised.


"Can you keep a secret?" the man asks me while I am playing on the swings. The sun is shining like a bright sunflower, and my hair is wet after my evening bath. There is a nice breeze wafting around the two of us in the park.


It is almost dinner time and I need to head off but the man has offered a secret and my twelve year old brain can’t refuse. I need to know the secret before I head down for dinner!


So I stay.


"Sure, but you'll need to hurry up. My Mom's gonna be out any minute to get me for dinner."


He seems agitated when I say that and quickly holds my hand, staring behind my back at my house as if a monster might pop out any minute. "Let's go to my van, hmm?" He says, pulling me away without even waiting for a reply. His grip is hard and it kind of hurt. But he’s smiling at me and looks like a good man. "We'll have more privacy and I'll tell you all about that secret and you can drink hot chocolate while I tell you!"


"Like in Narnia!?"


He nods eagerly, shoving me into the dingy van and quickly buckling me in. I don’t think much of it; he seems harmlessly nice.


He couldn't possibly hurt me.


“Do you like secrets?” he asks me, an eager grin on his face.


“Yep~ I love secrets!” 


“Good, girl.”


I wait in the passenger seat. Eager to listen to this grand secret of his as he punches the ignition and starts driving. I wait patiently for him to reach the destination. He has promised hot chocolate, after all. 


“Where are we going, Mister?”


He ignores me so I choose to look out the window for clues of where we're headed. Mom always says to never distract the driver.


We seem to be travelling towards the outskirts of the town. I’m not sure why we need to go so far for some hot chocolate but he looks like a good, harmless man for now. And Mom always tells me never to judge a book by it’s cover. 


The duller the cover, the better the book.


He pulls out a bottle from the dashboard in front of me once we drive past the police station. It’s covered in a brown paper bag and about the size of a water bottle. He keeps drinking from it. I don’t understand why he wouldn't offer some to me, but Mom did tell me that sometimes adults drink things children should not. 


And he seems nice enough so I’ll forgive him for being rude.


His eyes keep darting towards me as he drives. An unknown expression shading his face. He almost looks like Jafar from Aladdin for a moment.


I shrug it off. It’s almost time for dinner and I had promised Mom, I'd be home by then.


By the time we reached the destination -- a quiet, eerie forest enclosing -- the sky is crimson and blue, and the man looks hungry too.


"When are you gonna tell me that secret, Mister?" I ask him as he’s unbuckling my seat belt.


He has a devilish grin sitting on his face. And he looks at me like he’s ready to eat me. It almost grosses me out, but I have to know the secret. I can not leave without knowing.


He leans towards me, hands riding up my legs -- up my skirt. And he growls into my ear, "oh~ muffin. I'll tell you that secret alright."


He is too close, and smells of the bad juice that daddy drinks on weekends. And he is touching above my knee. And he’s just too close!


His breath makes me feel dizzy and I hate him! 


And his secret’s out now.


He is a bad guy.


The kind my mother had told me about.


I smile at the knowledge. Mom’s always right.


The badder they are, the better they taste.


Without warning, I sink my canines into his carotid artery, relishing in his desperate cry of pains. And pull back fiercely, unable to stop my giggles as I pull out his clavicle.


His blood spurting everywhere, I smirk into his face, leaning down to lick that sweet, sticky thickness off his neck.


The look of betrayal is evident in his terrified eyes and Oh~ how I love that fear in their eyes! Feigning innocence as if they aren’t devils that deserve much worse than being eaten alive. 


He’s trembling as he moves back and races out the car. Falling and crawling as he tries to escape. And I can’t help but laugh at his utter stupidity.


He’s so utterly helpless it’s hilarious!


Leisurely, I jump out the van, skipping towards him as he tries to escape me. That fool. I catch up to him in no time and it’s so delightful watching him beg for mercy. 


I love watching them beg.


And his cries sound even more delightful when I bend down to bite off his achilles tendon. Mom might get mad that I ate it, but I don’t care. It’s my reward for catching such a fine specimen for tonight, right? There’s no running away now. The cries his lips illicit are music to my ears when coupled with the eerie forest and the cawing crows.


He's perfect for dinner, I clap my hands excitedly. Mom will be delighted!


I drag him back to the van. Letting his skull hit a few of the boulders in the way, and push him into the passenger seat as he writhes in pain. Enjoying his ugly sounds of despair filling the car as I drive back home.


As we enter the driveway, I turn to him. Still alive, still fresh. Because they taste so much better alive. And smile almost just as deviously as he had back in the woods. 


I enjoy their fear so much.


Patting his head violently, his body shakes like a leaf in a storm, I mumble into his ear, "Mister, can you keep a secret?"


author’s note: yes, I enjoy torturing imaginary pedophiles and murderers.

Posted Aug 20, 2020
Share:

You must sign up or log in to submit a comment.

27 likes 14 comments

Noorin Tiaat
August 20, 2020 21:58

This was unexpectedly brilliant!

Reply

Dunya Zatde
August 20, 2020 23:06

Thankyou~~~

Reply

Karen Johnson
September 03, 2020 14:46

I enjoyed your story's surprise. We all long to see justice and bad guys punished.
I'd describe the pedophile's appearance more. This sentence "He almost looks like Jafar from Aladdin for a moment." stumped me because I don't know what Jafar looks like! (must be my age) Keep up the good work!

Reply

Barbara Burgess
August 27, 2020 09:50

A very interesting story and take on - can you keep a secret. I love the way you wove the unexpected middle and ending into it. Well done. Keep writing.

Reply

Deborah Angevin
August 23, 2020 08:19

Oooh, the concept is amazing! Totally didn't expect the ending!

P.S: would you mind checking my recent story out, "Yellow Light"? Thank you :D

Reply

Dunya Zatde
August 23, 2020 09:28

Thankyou~~~ and I sure will check yours out!

Reply

Elle Clark
August 22, 2020 17:11

I was not expecting that ending! I really, really enjoyed him getting his dues. This was so disturbing and quite graphic in places. It’s the very epitome of I told you so! You really take your reader on a rollercoaster of emotion - I felt wrung out by the end but in a good way. Really enjoyed this - thank you for inviting me to read it. I think it’s even better than your last one!

Reply

Dunya Zatde
August 23, 2020 00:34

Oh! Thankyou~ I feel so honoured you liked it. I love your stories so much that it feels accomplishing knowing you liked one of mine🤗

Reply

Rambling Beth
August 21, 2020 08:38

Wow, I wasn't expecting the ending! I loved how you took us on a journey in so few words.

I liked how the girl seemed innocent until the end, which is suitably graphic and disturbing. I'm glad the man died though. He was terrifying.

Excited to read more of your work. :)

Reply

Dunya Zatde
August 21, 2020 13:34

Thankyou~~~ you comment means a lot! And I hope to read more if your work too!

Reply

Yolanda Wu
August 21, 2020 06:43

Oh wow, I really wasn't expecting that ending which was what made it so goooodd! You captured the voice of a child perfectly, how she's all innocent and trusting at the start, but then she pulls that awesome stunt at the end. The way you described the blood spurting and all those gory details actually made me cringe, but in a really good way. Amazing work!

Reply

Dunya Zatde
August 21, 2020 13:33

Thankyou for the encouragement!!! I’m so happy you enjoyed it. I didn’t think people would tho???🤩

Reply

Shaista Khadim
August 21, 2020 02:15

My heart just went on a roller coaster and im still unsure about how i feel. Girlllll you did justice mannnn!!!! Too good!

Reply

Dunya Zatde
August 21, 2020 02:40

Yaaas~ pedophile and molesting assholes deserve this end tbh!

Reply

Reedsy | Default — Editors with Marker | 2024-05

Bring your publishing dreams to life

The world's best editors, designers, and marketers are on Reedsy. Come meet them.