Surprisingly, Mia Reynolds was the first person to date in her grade.
Now ‘date’ actually might be a stretch, but it was a badge she tried to wear with pride. Marcie might have already had her first date, and Lucy might have already had her first kiss. But Mia was the first to have a boyfriend.
The memory was foggy, but she could remember his blonde hair, his bright blue eyes. The bliss they shared.
The kindergarten swing set was where it all started.
She swung on one swing, he swung on the other. They were perfectly in sync.
A boy pointed at them, “Ooh! Mia and Kaden are getting married!”
It was an old joke, something that Mia could now brush off without a thought, but little Mia took it like a blow to the chest.
Her face flooded with a sudden heat as the other kids laughed. She looked over at Kaden, who was blushing just as fiercely. But the moment they locked eyes, the blush was not from the embarrassment, but from the childish flutter in her stomach she had never felt before.
‘Butterflies’, her mother had called them when Mia asked during pickup. She couldn’t drop the feeling no matter how hard she tried. The next day while she was picking dandelions, Kaden had come to sit next to her.
He grinned, missing a tooth. “Hi.”
She smiled back, the feeling pulled stronger, “Hi.”
Kaden picked a dandelion. “What did you wish for?”
Mia looked at the bare stem in her hand, “For the butterflies to go away.”
“Why? Are you scared of butterflies?”
Mia laughed, “No! Not those butterflies! The ones in my belly!”
Kaden looked at her stomach perplexed, “How did they get in there?”
Mia could feel the heat come back, “My mommy says they come when you get nervous.”
He poked his stomach, “So I have them too?”
“Are you nervous?”
“Yes.”
“Why?”
He shrugged, “They came after the swings.”
“Mine too.”
Kaden smiled before grabbing her hand, “You’re fun. You wanna play?”
She nodded, the butterflies flapping stronger than before.
The next year was filled with the kind of love that could only make sense to them. Sharing crayons, playing tag during recess, sitting next to each other during story time. It was a special bliss that got the whole playground whispering, a kind of bliss that Mia couldn’t help but keep thinking about years later. The memories were burned into her brain, though the memory that stuck out the most was during craft hour.
Kaden had handed her a messy drawing. Two stick figures were holding hands with a squiggly red heart floating between them.
“It’s us!” Kaden declared proudly.
The blush came back, deeper than before, as she folded the drawing gently and stuffed it into her backpack. The butterflies swirled delightfully.
Unfortunately, the butterflies couldn’t stay.
It was the first day of first grade, Mia wore her best skirt, she hadn’t seen Kaden all summer and she wanted to look her best. She pictured the fun they would have, running around, holding hands, swinging in sync. But when she arrived and scanned the crowd, she couldn’t find a glimpse of those blue eyes. Kaden’s friends broke the news to her; Kaden had moved away to a nearby city months ago.
Mia didn’t cry, not then. But when she sat down on the playground grass and plucked a dandelion, a silent tear, formed from a feeling she couldn’t even explain, slid down her cheek as she made a wish.
Twelve years passed. Mia had grown taller, her hair grew longer, her features rounded out, though she still seemed to never match up to the other girls in her grade. The boys’ glances stayed on them, leaving Mia in the shadows. She tried to pretend it didn’t sting, she tried to pretend that she was fine.
Usually she could be convincing, fooling herself for who knows how long until the memories came back. It seemed silly to focus on a romance that was long dead, to remember a boy she probably would never see again. But she did, and it felt bittersweet. A sweet memory mixed with a stinging reminder of what she couldn’t get back.
But still, she returned to the playground.
It was smaller than she remembered. The once huge slide was now shorter than her, the thrill of the see saw now seemed dull, but then her gaze landed on the main event.
The swing set.
They were different, the bright paint was now dull and chipping and the chains were slightly rusted, but the feeling they brought seemed familiar.
She sat down and started to rock back and forth. She hoped something would happen, that someone would come, anyone would come. But only the silent creak of the swing filled the empty playground. Mia could feel the tears flow, she didn’t let herself cry often, but when she did the tears seemed to come in waves.
Stop. Get yourself together.
The thought was simple and demanding as she wiped her eyes, she wasn’t gonna ruin herself over this, not here.
She jumped off mid-swing, landing with a steady thump on the sand. She was gonna be okay, things were gonna be okay… Right?
She bit her cheek, unsure about the correct answer as she started to walk away.
“Nice landing.”
Mia turned around, the familiar voice surprising her. He was taller now, his missing tooth had grown in, his hair had grown darker with age, but his bright blue eyes seemed to hold the same energy.
Kaden.
Years earlier, during middle school, Kaden had moved back. He claimed that his mother wanted to be closer to home. Everyone was ecstatic about his return, especially Mia. Mia was more amazed than any of her classmates, and that was the first time the butterflies flared up again. A million times she walked up behind him to say hi, to ask him if the butterflies ever left. But she never could get the nerve to tap him on the shoulder. That’s when he started to see other girls, his eyes landing on everyone it seemed but her. She tried to pretend she wasn’t hurt, but that time she couldn’t lie to herself.
She smiled, though it felt hollow, “Thanks.” Then came the silence. It was a silence filled with the tension of where they were. The bright memories now felt as heavy as lead.
She opened her mouth to say something, but she couldn’t speak. Everything felt dry. In the corner of her eye she saw the gate that she entered from. She could just go. Forget any of this ever—
“Do you come here often?”
Kaden’s question surprised her. His voice was curious, but in a way, she could’ve even imagined it, desperate.
Mia shook her head, “No. I don’t think I’ve been here since.” She paused, pondering her words, “Well, since kindergarten.”
Kaden stepped closer, putting his hand on the chipping rail. “I come here all the time.”
“Interesting.”
Her response came out almost annoyed, she hadn’t meant it. Did she?
Confusion wiped across Kaden’s face, “Did I say something wrong?”
No, you just ignored me for the past five years and now decide to finally talk to me, Mia thought harshly. If there were any butterflies left for Kaden, they were dying.
Kaden took another step forward, almost timidly, “I actually come here often, just to think every now and then.”
“Oh really?” Mia didn’t realize she said that out loud until the hurt reflected on Kaden’s face. Mia’s face went red with embarrassment as she caught a glimpse of the exit once more. She turned on her heel.
“Hey! Wait up!”
She could hear Kaden’s rushed steps through the sand until he stood next to her, walking by her side.
Kaden smiled, “So… How have you been? Anything cool happening lately?”
Mia ignored him and kept her eyes trained on the exit. She kept her pace steady, hoping to get past Kaden. He couldn’t seem to take a hint.
He sidestepped, walking backwards while talking face to face with her, “I haven’t had much going on lately. That’s why I came here, I wasn’t expecting you though. The playground sure seems different doesn’t—”
Mia turned around, ignoring his gaze, “Why are you talking to me?”
Kaden sidestepped again, talking in front of her again, “Why not?”
She rolled her eyes and tried to step past him, but he moved in front of her playfully, laughing as he blocked her efforts. Mia’s face went red again from both embarrassment and anger. She thrust her hands outwards, shoving Kaden square in the shoulders. Kaden stumbled back a couple of steps, the shock freezing his laughter.
Mia stood still, trembling as the tears burned her eyes again. Kaden stared at her in shock and confusion before reaching out to her, “Mia?”
Mia stepped back, uncertain, before stepping back more. She turned her back to him. It hurt too much to look at him. But Kaden was only part of the problem, maybe not even part of it at all. It hurt to think about all the other boys, it hurt to think about the other girls as well. She felt alone. She turned her back to him so he wouldn’t see her cry before sitting down in the grass, heaving with silent sobs. It didn’t feel fair, how come she had to go through this? How come Marcie got the perfect smile and Lucy got the perfect face? Was she not beautiful? Was she not good? Why was she ignored? Why did she feel so alone? High school was stupid, she felt stupid.
“Mia?” She didn’t see it, but she heard Kaden sit down softly next to her. “Are you okay?” She opened her mouth to answer, but only another sob came out. She shook her head weakly.
“Hey. Don’t cry, please don’t cry. I’m sorry I pushed you too hard, I was just—”
“It’s not you.” The words came out mumbled, but he seemed to understand.
She expected him to ask why she was crying, or at least leave her alone with her thoughts. But he just sat there, letting her take her own pace.
Mia finally pulled herself together, barely. She wiped her eyes with her sleeves, “Look at me, “ She laughed brokenly, “I’m a mess.”
Kaden smiled sadly, “Don’t say that.”
Mia looked at him, she didn’t know if he felt guilty or sympathetic. But the way he was looking at her, it made the butterflies swirl.
She tried to brush it off, “What do you think I am then?”
“Beautiful.”
She froze, her face going hot as the butterflies flapped faster. She couldn’t look him in the eyes, though she could feel his gaze on her. Suddenly she felt his hand cup her cheek. She finally turned her head to face him. To look at those blue eyes. His thumb wiped softly at the wet tracks on her cheek almost reverently as he leaned in closer, his eyes closing shut.
Panic swept through Mia, she shoved Kaden back, “No!”
Kaden was pushed back, his hand still hovering where it cupped her cheek.
Mia’s hands trembled, she just shoved him again, “No…”
Kaden looked hurt, but understanding. He stood up, “Sorry. That was stupid. I’ll go.”
He turned around, walking towards the gate he entered from. Mia stared at him, part of her was happy he was leaving. He was an idiot anyway. But he tried to kiss her? Why?
She couldn’t hold it back, “Wait!”
Kaden froze, not turning back.
Mia stuttered, saying the first thing that came to mind, “I-I kept the drawing… the one with the stick figures and—” She hesitated, unsure, “And the heart.”
Kaden stayed silent, before a soft chuckle broke out. He turned around, a smile, more genuine than anything she’d seen all day, greeted her, “You still have that?”
Mia nodded, “Yeah. It’s tucked in my dresser. My mom tried to throw it away once, but I took it out of the trash.”
He stepped forward, almost like a question. He smiled teasingly, “Did you now?”
She laughed softly, rubbing the back of her neck, “I just, I just couldn’t let it go.”
He stepped forward again, standing right in front of her, “Me neither.”
The silence came back, thick with the same tension, though they seemed to find a meeting point.
After a few minutes she sat down in the grass, “But why?”
Kaden tilted his head while he sat down, the expression asking all the questions he had.
“Why now? After all these years you could’ve talked to me… Why now?”
Kaden sighed, lying down, “I was… I was scared.” Mia opened her mouth to say something but he continued, “I was scared if you forgot me. If you forgot this place.”
Mia chuckled, “If only you knew.”
He shrugged, “I thought that you wouldn’t like me, or you would be mad. So I just—”
“Ignored my existence for five years?”
Kaden looked at her confused, “Ignored?” He rolled over to face her, “I never ignored you.”
Mia rolled her eyes, “Don’t even act innocent.”
Kaden chuckled, “No, I mean it.” A small blush colored his cheeks, “I can’t count how many times I went up to talk to you, to ask how you’ve been, before I chickened out at least.”
Mia stared at him in shock. All the years of doubt, fear and waiting, only to learn that he was doing the same exact thing.
Kaden’s smile faltered, “Did I say something wrong?”
“No! It’s just,” Mia laughed, “I was doing the same exact thing.”
“You’re kidding me.”
“I’m not.”
Kaden was silent before he shook his head with silent laughter. He rolled back onto his back, “How ironic.”
They both laughed, the tension disappearing by the minute, though it now was replaced by the shared secret between them.
Mia lay down in the grass next to him, “So, you’re still into me?”
Kaden blushed softly, “I guess the butterflies never really left.”
Mia blushed, the butterflies kept on fluttering, “Yeah.”
Another silence fell, this one peaceful, perfect. Mia could feel her chest tighten with feelings. Hope, maybe a bit of giddiness, and one last feeling she wasn’t sure she was ready to admit yet.
Kaden finally sat up, “I want to start fresh.”
Mia smirked, “What do you mean?”
He looked at her, “The start of our little reunion was… Rough.” Mia laughed as he continued, “So we should start over. Keep it simple.”
Mia now sat up, “And how will we do that?”
Kaden pondered before picking a yellow dandelion and offering it to Mia. He smiled, far too similar to his gaped tooth smile from long ago, “Hi.”
Mia blushed as she took the flower, “Hi.”
They smiled at each other as the butterflies flew through both of them, and for the first time in a long time…
Mia didn’t feel so alone.
You must sign up or log in to submit a comment.
Based very loosely on true events :)
Reply