Vinny was following me through the mall, stepping over the dark floor tiles because he had decided they were lava. Every few feet he landed with both sneakers together and made a noise like somebody had punched him in the stomach.
“Walk regular,” I told him.
“This is regular.”
“Then walk irregular. Just stay close.”
Linda had made me promise I wouldn’t work, but Dennis had called three times. Ignoring somebody becomes its own kind of work.
“Tell him Monday,” I said.
“He says you told him Thursday.”
“It was Thursday when I told him. I didn’t say this Thursday.”
Dennis let that sit there. He left a space where a normal person would answer, hoping I’d climb into it and hang myself.
“Tony, he wants to know where his money is.”
“And I want to know why you’re calling me on a Saturday like somebody died.”
We passed a coffee stand. A woman behind the counter was fitting cardboard sleeves onto cups, stacking them into a tower. Vinny jumped another tile and clipped my heel.
“Sorry.”
“Watch where you’re going.”
“You stopped.”
He had me there. Five years old and already everything had to go before a jury.
Dennis said, “Look, I know you can be a little ruthless—”
“Ruthless? That’s a nice thing to say.”
“I’m trying to explain how he sees it.”
“Then explain how I see it.”
Everybody thought I was some kind of stone-cold savage. Because I raised my voice. I’m five-five with a forty-four-inch chest. Put a jacket on me and I look like somebody squeezed a nightclub bouncer into a carry-on. People find that funny. Talking Tony. Tough little guy. They’ll say it right in front of you, then act surprised when you’ve got something to say back.
I have a heart. This ruthless business bothered me more than I wanted Dennis to know.
Behind me, Vinny was pulling his sleeve over his fist. Dark curls, fat cheeks, my mother’s eyebrows. Built like me, unfortunately for his future tailor. He caught me looking and made a face.
I made one back.
“Daddy, is that it?”
Ahead, above the crowd, I could see Elmo waving from a sign.
“Almost.”
“Is Cookie Monster there?”
“I’ll ask Dennis. Apparently Dennis knows everything.”
“What?” Dennis said.
“Nothing. Listen, I’m with my kid. We’ll straighten this out Monday.”
“You need to call him yourself.”
“I said I would.”
I hadn’t, but I would.
A score notification dropped across the screen. Oregon was down seven. Plenty of game left. I cleared it and put the phone away.
“All right, pal. Let’s go see—”
The boy behind me stopped.
He was thin. Straight, sandy hair hung across a narrow forehead. His eyes were a pale gray, and one of his front teeth overlapped the other. He was wearing Vinny’s green sweatshirt, the one with the orange dinosaur.
I looked past him.
A woman pushed a double stroller between us. I stepped around it and checked the other side of a bench.
“Vin?”
“Daddy?”
The sandy-haired boy was looking at me.
“Hang on, buddy.”
I walked back toward the coffee stand, past a sporting-goods store and a kiosk selling phone cases.
“Vinny!”
The boy followed me.
I crouched so we were level.
“Did you see a little boy? About your size. Same shirt.”
He looked down at the dinosaur.
“Where’s your dad?”
His mouth opened a little.
“Who’d you come here with?”
“You.”
“No, before. Who were you walking with?”
“You, Daddy.”
Somewhere a machine was making an electronic winning noise. It went on for a ridiculous amount of time.
“Vincent!”
The boy flinched.
***
I checked inside the sporting-goods store first. Vinny liked to pick up the little dumbbells and announce the weights incorrectly. There was nobody in that aisle except a woman comparing yoga mats.
At the coffee stand, I leaned across the counter.
“You see a little boy come through here?”
The woman stopped stacking cups.
“Lost?”
“My son. Curly dark hair. Green shirt, dinosaur. He was right behind me.”
She looked down.
The other boy had caught up. He stood beside my leg, breathing through his mouth.
“Another little boy?” she asked.
“Yes.”
“How old?”
“Five.”
“And how old is this one?”
“I don’t know.”
The boy looked up at me.
“I’m five.”
“Could you call security?” I asked.
“Of course.”
She picked up a handset. While she spoke into it, I looked along the concourse again. A man in a black coat was walking away with a dark-haired child. I went after them, caught the man’s sleeve, and got a look at the girl beside him.
“Sorry. Thought you were somebody else.”
He pulled his arm away.
Back at the counter, the sandy-haired boy had started crying without making any noise. Tears ran down both sides of his nose.
“Hey,” I said. “We’re going to figure this out.”
He wiped his face with the dinosaur sleeve.
“Why are you doing that?”
“Doing what?”
He wouldn’t answer.
The woman handed him a napkin.
“You want some water, honey?”
He nodded.
“Give me a coffee,” I said. My mouth had gone dry, and ordering something was an action I understood.
“What size?”
“Whatever. Large.”
“You sure you want coffee?”
“Yes. I’m sure about the coffee.”
She filled a cup. I put a twenty down and told her to keep it, then remembered I didn’t have to tip fourteen dollars to get somebody to help me find my son.
“Actually, give me the change.”
The boy drank his water with both hands around the cup.
“What’s your name?”
“Vinny.”
“Your whole name.”
“Vincent Anthony Caruso.”
The woman set my change on the counter. I left it there.
“Who told you to say that?”
The boy’s face crumpled.
“Okay,” I said quickly. “Okay. What’s your mommy’s name?”
“Mommy.”
“Her other name.”
“Linda.”
I had said Dennis. I had said Monday. I hadn’t said Linda.
The woman was watching me over the espresso machine.
“Have you called his mother?”
“I’m going to.”
“Maybe do that now.”
I didn’t care for her tone, but it was a reasonable suggestion.
***
Linda answered with running water in the background.
“What?”
“Listen carefully. Vinny was walking behind me—”
“Did you lose him?”
“Let me finish.”
“Tony.”
“There’s another kid here. He thinks I’m his father.”
“Where’s Vinny?”
“That’s what I’m telling you.”
The water stopped.
I explained it again. I told her where we were and described the boy. She asked me to put the camera on.
I turned it toward him.
“Vin?”
“Mommy.”
“What happened, sweetheart?”
“Daddy’s mad at me.”
“I’m not mad at him,” I said.
“Tony, turn the phone around.”
I did.
“Why are you telling me you lost him?”
For a moment I couldn’t get enough air to answer. I loosened my collar, although I was wearing a T-shirt.
“Linda. Look at his face.”
“I am looking at him.”
“That is not our son.”
She said my name differently that time. Softly, with a little space between the two syllables.
A security guard arrived while she was telling me to stay where I was. He was heavy through the middle, with a white mustache. His name tag said WALTER. I was relieved to see somebody old enough to have dealt with things.
“Which child are we looking for?” he asked.
I gave him the description. He repeated it into his radio, then asked when I had last seen Vinny.
“Five minutes ago. Ten. I was on the phone.”
“Did you see which direction he went?”
“If I saw which direction he went, I would’ve gone in that direction.”
Walter waited.
“I’m sorry,” I said. “No.”
“And this young man?”
“He started following me.”
The boy shook his head.
Walter bent a little.
“You know this gentleman?”
“That’s my daddy.”
Walter straightened.
“Could I see some identification?”
“Mine?”
“Yes, sir.”
I handed it over. Cooperation would speed this up.
He asked whether I had a photograph.
Three kids, two phones’ worth of photographs. Activities I was paying for while missing. I opened the camera roll and found Halloween.
Lucy was a witch. Michael had insisted on being a refrigerator, for reasons that remained between him and God. Between them stood a boy in a firefighter’s coat.
Straight sandy hair under the plastic helmet.
I enlarged the picture until his face filled the screen.
“That’s me,” the boy said.
I swiped backward. There he was at the kitchen table. There he was beside Linda on the beach. In a photograph from Oregon, he stood under the cedar tree in our old yard, holding a hose.
He had sprayed me through the kitchen window. I remembered putting my hand over the nozzle and turning it back on him.
The boy who had laughed so hard he fell down had black curls plastered to his head.
“Sir?” Walter said.
I locked the phone.
“What’s wrong?” Linda asked. She was still on the call.
“Nothing. I’m looking.”
I opened the photographs again.
***
Walter took us to a bench near a service corridor. Another guard went to check the stores. I asked about cameras, and Walter said somebody was reviewing them. He radioed somebody to check the garage doors.
I gave him my phone and asked him to call his mother.
He tapped Linda’s photograph.
When I asked where he lived, he gave our address in New Jersey. When I asked where he used to live, he said the house with the tree.
“What tree?”
“The one you said we couldn’t bring.”
We’d had that conversation standing beside the moving truck. Vinny had thought we could put the tree in with the furniture. I’d told him we’d need a bigger truck.
I walked a few feet away.
Maybe somebody had put him up to it. People put kids up to things. There were videos all over the internet. But you needed a reason, and you needed access to my photographs, and you needed Linda to—
I stopped there.
My phone rang. Eddie.
Eddie had known me before Oregon, before Linda, before anybody entrusted me with anything more valuable than car keys.
“Eddie. Something’s happened.”
“Yeah, I’ve been trying you.”
“I’m at the mall. My kid’s missing.”
He went quiet.
“Which kid?”
“Vinny.”
“Jesus. You call the cops?”
“Security’s looking. There’s another kid here. He’s saying he’s Vinny.”
“What do you mean?”
“I mean exactly what I said.”
Walter smiled at something the boy said.
“Listen to me,” I said. “You know anybody who’d do something like that?”
“Like what?”
“Send a kid. Scare somebody.”
“Tony, what the fuck are you talking about?”
“I’m asking.”
“Are you asking me if I took your son?”
“No.”
“Because if this is about settling up—”
“My son is missing.”
“I heard you. Don’t put that on me.”
I gripped the phone so hard the case creaked.
“Tell me I sound normal.”
“What?”
“Do I sound like myself?”
“You sound like you need to let the cops handle it.”
I hung up.
There was a message from Dennis underneath Eddie’s missed calls. Call me before you speak to him.
That meant the client. Obviously it meant the client.
I read it twice anyway.
***
I checked the date on my phone. Saturday. I read the coffee receipt. I remembered the garage level, the last four digits of my Social Security number, the starting lineup of a basketball team I hadn’t watched in twenty years.
I could picture Lucy. Michael. Linda.
I could picture Vinny perfectly.
My mind was working. I could follow a thought from beginning to end. I knew that people having some kind of episode probably believed that too, but knowing that had to count for something.
Walter came over.
“No matching reports of another missing child,” he said.
“There wouldn’t have to be. His father might not have noticed yet.”
“We’ve got people checking.”
“The cameras?”
“They can see you coming up the escalator with one child.”
“Which child?”
“The green shirt.”
“Show me his face.”
“They’re still looking at the footage.”
He studied me.
“Have you eaten today?”
“What does that have to do with anything?”
“Just asking.”
“Eggs. Toast. I had breakfast.”
I had made eggs for the kids. I couldn’t remember whether I’d eaten mine. That wasn’t important enough to correct.
The boy slid off the bench.
“I need the bathroom.”
I looked at Walter. He pointed toward the corridor.
Inside, I checked every stall before letting the boy use one. Vinny wouldn’t have gone into a bathroom we hadn’t passed. I checked anyway.
The boy called for help with his button.
I knelt in front of him. The waistband had folded over, trapping the button at an angle. I straightened it.
“You always pull too hard,” I said.
He stood still while I fixed it.
I couldn’t remember deciding to say that.
At the sink, he put his hands under the water and waited for me to push up his sleeves. I did. His wrists were thin. Vinny still had little creases around his wrists.
I held one in my hand.
“Daddy, it’s hot.”
I let go.
In the mirror I looked like myself. Red face, heavy shoulders, the vein above my temple. The boy beside me looked like somebody I might never have seen if I’d gone to a different mall.
I washed my hands until he asked whether we could leave.
***
Linda came in a cab. By then I had walked the route twice more with Walter, checked the play area, and shown Vinny’s photograph to a woman with a dark-haired boy before realizing which photograph I was holding.
Linda knelt and the stranger ran into her arms.
I watched her kiss his hair.
“Are you okay?” she asked him.
He nodded against her shoulder.
She looked at me.
“We’re going home.”
“I can’t leave.”
“My dad’s coming over. We’ll work it out there.”
“There’s nothing to work out there. It happened here.”
Walter gave her a card. I couldn’t hear everything he said. She nodded several times.
I wanted to pull her aside and explain it properly, without the boy listening, without Walter standing there deciding whether I’d eaten breakfast. But she asked for my keys, and when I reached into my pocket she took them from my hand.
I went because there were pictures at home that weren’t on my phone. School photographs. The one on the stairs from when Vinny was three. There had to be something that hadn’t changed.
In the garage, the boy climbed into Vinny’s seat.
“You have to do the bottom first,” he told Linda.
“I know, honey.”
He said it exactly the way Vinny said it. Impatient, like the whole world was making him late.
I stood outside the car until Linda asked me to get in.
***
Michael opened the front door before we reached it.
“Did you bring pretzels?”
Nobody answered.
He looked at the boy.
“Did you go on the slide?”
“No.”
“Told you.”
The boy pushed past him into the house.
I went straight to the stairs.
Linda was saying something behind me, but I had the frame off the wall before she finished. Vinny’s school picture. Blue background. A little wooden stool I remembered him complaining about.
The sandy-haired boy smiled out from behind the glass.
I turned it over and bent back the metal tabs. The cardboard caught under my fingernail. I pulled everything out: backing, order slip, photograph. His name was written on the envelope in Linda’s handwriting.
There was no other picture underneath.
“Tony.”
I showed her the photograph.
“Tell me what I’m supposed to do with this.”
“Put it down.”
“I know my own son.”
“I know you do.”
“You keep saying that like you agree with me.”
She looked toward the kitchen. A drawer opened. One of the kids complained that there weren’t any clean spoons.
“I want you to see someone,” she said.
“Who?”
“Come outside with me.”
I put the pieces of the frame on the stairs because I couldn’t get them back together. My hands wouldn’t manage the little metal tabs.
Outside, her father’s car was running at the curb.
Frank got out. He wore his work jacket, although he hadn’t worked in six years. He looked at Linda first.
I stopped on the bottom step.
“What’s this?”
“Come on, Tony.”
“Where are we going?”
He opened the passenger door.
“Get in.”
I knew places in New Jersey now. Linda had shown me where she went to school, where her mother was buried, which hospital to use if something happened to the kids. Frank had shown me other places when we first moved back. Buildings he used to own. A road you took to avoid the traffic. I wished he would name one.
“Linda, tell him.”
She was holding my jacket.
I could have gone back into the house. The door was still open. I looked through it and saw the boy at the end of the hall, watching us.
If I stayed, I would have to explain again. If I went, there would be nobody left looking.
Frank put his hand on the open car door.
“Anthony.”
I walked down the path. My legs felt loose and unreliable under all that chest. I wanted to tell him I hadn’t done anything, but I didn’t know which thing he would think I meant.
“Just take me back to the mall,” I said. “We can start there. I’ll show you where we were.”
He waited while I got in.
“It was by the coffee place. I was on the phone, but I looked. Frank, I looked right at him.”
He closed my door and went around to the driver’s side.
I kept explaining while he backed out. I told him about the green shirt, the dark curls, the way my son had been jumping over the tiles. At the corner I told him to turn left for the mall.
He turned right.
You must sign up or log in to submit a comment.