The Neurotic Imperative

Fiction Funny

Written in response to: "Write a story that includes the line “I can’t sleep.”" as part of What Lingers.

The clock on the nightstand read 3:14 AM, blinking red with the cold, unfeeling precision of an executioner’s stopwatch. Beside me, Sarah was breathing with the deep, effortless rhythm of someone whose conscience wasn't currently being audited by the Universe. She had folded her pillow in half, drifted off in three minutes flat, and was no doubt dreaming of something blissfully uncomplicated, like Scandinavian kitchen design or a world where my mother didn't have my speed-dial on voice command.

I stared at the ceiling. The plaster had a water stain shaped remarkably like Soren Kierkegaard. I stared at Kierkegaard; Kierkegaard stared back, unimpressed by my life choices.

I rolled toward Sarah, cleared my throat with the subtlety of a foghorn, and whispered, "I can't sleep."

Sarah didn't stir. She made a soft, purring noise that suggested total peace with the cosmos.

I nudged her shoulder. "Sarah. Sarah, awake. I’m having a existential crisis. It’s a bad one. It’s got footnotes."

She groaned, her eyes remaining squeezed shut. "Seymour... it is three in the morning. Did the radiator make a noise again?"

"The radiator is the least of my problems, though now that you mention it, its clanking does resemble a poorly executed performance art piece about the decline of Western civilization," I said, sitting up and pulling the duvet to my chin. "No, it’s my hyperactive ego. It won't turn off. I was lying here, attempting the progressive muscle relaxation technique my therapist, Dr. Fastbinder, recommended—the one where you pretend your feet are made of warm sand—and suddenly I realized: what if the sand is symbolic of the inevitable erosion of my youth?"

Sarah finally opened one eye. It was bloodshot and filled with a terrifying, homicidal exhaustion. "Seymour. You are forty-two. Your youth didn't erode; it took a bus out of town ten years ago. Go to sleep."

"How can I sleep when the entire concept of linear time is pressing down on my chest?" I demanded, swing my legs over the side of the bed. "I read an article in The New Yorker today about entropy. Do you realize that eventually the sun is going to expand and incinerate the entire solar system? All of it. The Louvre, the New York Philharmonic, that deli on 72nd Street that makes the good pastrami—poof. Carbonized. And here I am, worrying about whether I should have opted for the extended warranty on the toaster."

"The toaster is fine, Seymour," she muttered into her pillow. "Take a Melatonin."

"Melatonin is a cop-out! It’s a chemical surrender to the farce of human biology," I said, putting on my thick-rimmed glasses so I could at least view my insomnia in high definition. "Besides, I took two at midnight. All they did was give me a vivid dream where I was forced to defend my seventh-grade geometry final in front of a jury made entirely of my ex-girlfriends. Sybil was the forewoman. She cited my lack of spatial awareness as grounds for my emotional inadequacy."

Sarah let out a long, theatrical sigh, rolled over, and pulled the blanket completely off me. "If you are going to pace, go pace in the kitchen. And don't eat the leftover brisket. That’s for lunch tomorrow."

I shuffled into the living room, barefoot, shivering in my flannel pajamas. The apartment was dead quiet, save for the rhythmic humming of the refrigerator, which sounded suspiciously like a low C-minor chord designed to induce clinical depression.

I turned on the desk lamp and sat down at my typewriter. Yes, a typewriter. A 1958 Underwood. Sarah said it was an insufferable hipster cliché, but I maintained that computers possessed no soul. A computer doesn't judge you when you type a bad sentence; it just sits there, glowing with cold, digital indifference. A typewriter, on the other hand, hits back. Every strike of the key is a permanent record of your intellectual failure.

I hit the carriage return. CLACK-CHUNK.

"Seymour!" Sarah shouted from the bedroom. "If I hear one more mechanical keystroke, I am calling your analyst and telling him you've relapsed into your experimental playwriting phase!"

"I'm not writing a play!" I called back. "I'm drafting an essay on the neurotic imperative of the modern urban male! It’s cathartic!"

I abandoned the typewriter and went into the kitchen. I opened the refrigerator door and bathed in its fluorescent, clinical light. I stared at the contents: a jar of capers, half a carton of almond milk, a suspicious plastic container of cream cheese that had developed its own ecosystem, and the brisket.

I picked up a fork, hovered over the brisket, and hesitated. Guilt instantly metastasized in my gut. Eating brisket at 3:20 AM felt like a moral failing, the kind of greasy, nocturnal indulgence that leads directly to a mid-life crisis, buying a convertible, and trying to explain French New Wave cinema to a twenty-two-year-old barista named Chloe.

I closed the fridge.

I walked over to the window and looked down at Eighth Avenue. A solitary yellow cab sped past through the rain, its tires sloshing over the wet asphalt. Where was it going? Who was inside? Probably a couple returning from a late-night jazz club, radiant with youth and unburdened by the knowledge that their mortgages were tied to volatile interest rates. Or maybe a killer. New York is wonderful that way; the line between romance and violent felony is entirely dependent on the lighting.

My phone on the counter buzzed.

I jumped. A text message at 3:25 AM is never good news. It’s either a family emergency, a wrong number from a drunk teenager, or my cousin Morty letting me know he found a loophole in the tax code regarding home office deductions for amateur taxidermists.

I picked it up. It was from Bernie.

Bernie was my best friend, a man whose baseline anxiety made me look like a Zen monk on tranquilizers. Bernie had spent the last three years convinced that his landlord was slowly poisoning his apartment air supply with trace amounts of radon to force him out of a rent-controlled two-bedroom on the Upper West Side.

Bernie: Are you awake?

Seymour: Of course I'm awake. My mind is a roaring furnace of self-doubt and cosmic dread. Why are you awake?

Bernie: I think my liver is vibrating.

I dialed his number immediately. He picked up on the first ring.

"Bernie, what do you mean your liver is vibrating?" I asked, pacing the narrow strip of hardwood between the counter and the trash can. "The liver doesn't vibrate. The liver is a silent organ. It suffers in stoic, physiological dignity until you eat too much duck fat, at which point it quietly throws in the towel."

"I'm telling you, Seymour, it’s buzzing," Bernie said, his voice a tight, breathy whisper. "Like an electric toothbrush. I was reading a medical blog—which I know Dr. Wallach told me never to do after 10 PM—and there’s a rare tropical parasite transmitted through unwashed arugula. You remember that salad I had at the bistro on Tuesday?"

"Bernie, you ordered the chicken parm. You haven't eaten a leaf of arugula since the Carter administration."

"Well, what if there was cross-contamination?" Bernie pleaded. "What if the chef used the same tongs for the arugula and the chicken? Seymour, I can't die tonight. I haven't finished organizing my jazz records. If I die, my sister is going to give my Miles Davis vinyl to her son, the one who listens to dubstep. It’s a sacrilege!"

"Calm down," I said, though my own pulse was beginning to race in sympathetic panic. "Look, if your liver is vibrating, it’s not a parasite. It’s functional dyspepsia brought on by your repressed hostility toward your father."

"My father has been dead for twelve years!"

"Which makes the hostility even more potent, Bernie! It has nowhere to go! It’s trapped in your digestive tract, humming at forty hertz!"

There was a long silence on the line. I could hear Bernie taking short, shallow breaths.

"Seymour?" he said softly.

"Yeah?"

"Do you ever feel like... we’re approaching this whole life thing from the wrong angle? Like everyone else got an instruction manual at birth, and we were out in the lobby getting pretzels?"

"Bernie," I said, leaning against the sink, "the instruction manual is an illusion created by the greeting card industry to sell anniversary cards. Nobody knows what they're doing. The President doesn't know. The Pope doesn't know. The guy driving the late-night street sweeper is out there right now wondering if his mother was right about him dropping out of dental school."

"That’s deeply comforting," Bernie said. "In a profoundly depressing, Kafkaesque sort of way."

"That’s my specialty. Now go to sleep. Drink a glass of warm water and refrain from searching your symptoms on the internet. If your liver is still humming at breakfast, we'll go to the urgent care on 14th Street and let a physician's assistant tell you you're a hypocondriac."

"Okay," Bernie sighed. "Thanks, Seymour. Give my best to Sarah."

"She hates us both right now, Bernie. Goodnight."

I hung up. The apartment felt even quieter now. The rain outside had settled into a steady, gloomy drizzle.

I walked into the bathroom, turned on the light, and recoiled. The man staring back at me in the mirror looked like a casualty of a middle-management civil war. My hair was sticking up in three different directions, resembling a frantic bird's nest, and the dark circles under my eyes were so pronounced they looked like they had been applied with theatrical charcoal.

"Look at you," I muttered to my reflection. "You’re forty-two years old. You write column entries about local zoning laws for a neighborhood weekly that gets used primarily to line birdcages. You have a mild intolerance to lactose and an acute fear of automatic car washes. Is this the summit of your human potential?"

My reflection offered no counterargument. It just looked tired.

I opened the medicine cabinet. Row upon row of small orange bottles stared back at me. It was a museum of modern neurosis: Antacids, antihistamines, multi-vitamins, prescribed sleep aids I was too afraid to take because the side-effect pamphlet listed "unusual dreams involving farm equipment," and a bottle of eye drops from 2019.

I closed the cabinet door and leaned over the sink, splashing cold water on my face.

Why couldn't I sleep? It wasn't just the entropy of the universe or Bernie's vibrating liver. It was the crushing, undeniable weight of being aware. Sleep requires a surrender of control. It requires you to trust that the world will keep spinning on its axis without your direct supervision for seven to eight hours. And I simply didn't trust the world. The world was run by amateurs.

I walked back out to the living room, retrieved a throw blanket from the sofa, and dragged a chair over to the window. If I couldn't sleep, I would watch the city.

New York at 3:45 AM is a strange, translucent space. It’s the hour when the performers step off the stage and the stagehands take over. Steam rose from the manhole covers in thick, ghostly plumes. A street sweeper ambled down the avenue, its big circular brushes churning up the wet trash, making a sound like a giant cat washing itself. Across the street, in the apartment building opposite ours, a single window on the fifth floor was illuminated.

I looked closer. A figure was standing by the glass, holding a mug, looking out into the rain just like me.

It was a woman, wearing what appeared to be a oversized flannel shirt. She raised her mug slightly toward the street, an unconscious gesture of nocturnal solidarity.

I raised my hand in a tiny, awkward half-wave.

She didn't wave back—she probably couldn't see me through the reflection—but for a brief moment, the overwhelming loneliness of the city dissolved into something shared. We were two members of the same secret, insomniac society, bound together by overactive minds, late-night doubts, and an absolute inability to shut off the noise of existing.

I sat back in my chair, wrapping the blanket tight around my shoulders.

I thought about my life. It wasn't glorious. I hadn't written the Great American Novel. I hadn't decoded the human genome. I was a man who spent twenty minutes every morning debating the moral implications of buying organic versus non-organic blueberries.

But as I sat there, watching the rain smudge the amber streetlights into soft, glowing watercolors, a strange and unfamiliar sensation washed over me. It wasn't peace—peace is for people who do yoga and drink green tea without complaining about the taste—but it was a kind of truce. An armistice with my own brain.

The sun wouldn't explode for another five billion years. Bernie’s liver was almost certainly fine. Sarah loved me, even if she currently wanted to smother me with a feather pillow. And the rain was falling on the city, washing away the grime of yesterday, making room for whatever brand of chaos tomorrow had in store.

My eyelids, heavy with the weight of four hours of relentless overthinking, finally began to droop. My breathing slowed. The hum of the refrigerator retreated into the background, softening until it sounded less like a existential threat and more like a lullaby written by a very tired engineer.

I didn't make it back to the bed. I just let my chin sink into my chest, right there in the armchair by the window, while the city kept turning beneath the rainy dark.

And finally, mercifully, the theater went quiet.

Posted Oct 31, 2026
Share:

You must sign up or log in to submit a comment.

0 likes 0 comments

Reedsy | Default — Editors with Marker | 2024-05

Bring your publishing dreams to life

The world's best editors, designers, and marketers are on Reedsy. Come meet them.