All In On Rock

Contemporary Drama Friendship

Written in response to: "Your character finds a photograph, letter, or keepsake they'd forgotten." as part of A Trip Down Memory Lane.

The thing about being successful is that everybody wants a piece of you. Everybody wants to be in the room, wants to shake your hand, wants to tell people they know you. But when things get tough, when the chips are down, you find out pretty quickly who’s really on your team.

Andrew never understood that.

“You need to talk to Dom,” he said.

We were sitting at a bar on the Las Vegas Strip, drinking eighteen-dollar bourbon after the second day of a federal jury trial. Behind Andrew, a woman in a silver dress was having her picture taken beside a floral arrangement considerably taller than she was. Every time her boyfriend lowered the phone, she made him take another.

“I’ll talk to him.”

“You need to talk to him tonight.”

“You’ve said that.”

“Because you keep saying you’ll do it.”

I moved my glass so the bartender could wipe underneath it. Andrew hadn’t loosened his tie. He had the same expression he’d worn through law school when somebody suggested going out before an exam: personally disappointed that other people could enjoy themselves under the circumstances.

“The jury’s still out,” I said.

“I know where the jury is.”

“So let’s see what happens.”

“Josh, I’m a trial lawyer. I’m telling you what’s going to happen.”

He wanted me to call Dom and tell him to settle. After two days of testimony, after Andrew had torn their witnesses apart, after we’d put the law in front of the judge in language a reasonably intelligent fifth grader could understand, he wanted me to announce that we’d lost our nerve.

“You were there,” I said. “Their main guy changed his story three times.”

“And they liked him better than our guy.”

“Our guy was right.”

“Our guy couldn’t be bothered to come back for the second day of his own trial.”

Dom “The Rock” Bugle had other obligations. You didn’t become one of the biggest names in hip-hop, then turn yourself into a television personality, by clearing your calendar every time somebody wanted your money.

“He’s got a lot going on.”

“So do the jurors. They showed up.”

I took a drink. Andrew watched me swallow it.

“You’ve got to have the killer instinct when everybody’s coming for the throne,” I said.

“What throne? We’re in federal court.”

“You know what I mean.”

“I do. That’s the problem.”

He leaned toward me, lowering his voice as though we were discussing something embarrassing.

“He thumbs his nose at everybody. The judge, the jury, the other lawyer. You think that makes him look powerful. It makes him look like a guy who thinks the rules are for everybody else.”

“That’s his brand.”

“Then his brand is going to cost him six figures.”

The bartender asked whether we wanted another. I pointed to my glass. Andrew put his hand over his.

Here we were in Las Vegas, representing one of the top performers in the game, and he couldn’t take five minutes to appreciate it. There were lawyers who spent their entire careers fighting over somebody’s retaining wall. I’d brought him into something people actually cared about.

“We’re on the map now,” I said.

He looked at me for a moment.

“I’m begging you to go talk to Dom before this gets worse. I already know what’s going to happen.”

“You did a good job.”

“Then listen to me.”

“I am listening.”

My phone lit up beside my drink. Dom had sent a picture from a restaurant: himself between two women, an enormous seafood tower in front of them.

Andrew looked at the screen.

“Call him.”

“I’m not doing this while he’s at dinner.”

“Then when?”

“When there’s something to tell him.”

***

The next afternoon I was in the courthouse bathroom when Andrew texted that the jury had a verdict.

There was blood on the toilet paper again. I folded it over, checked, and dropped it into the bowl. Something I’d eaten, probably. Between the food, the drinking, and the amount of coffee required to function around Andrew, my stomach hadn’t stood a chance.

I rinsed my mouth, straightened my tie, and finished the Red Bull I’d left beside the sink.

Andrew was already at counsel table. He looked as though he’d slept eight hours and spent the morning doing something wholesome with his cardiovascular system.

“Where’s Dom?” he asked.

“Outside.”

“Outside where?”

“In the hallway.”

“Get him.”

“He knows we’re going in.”

Andrew closed his eyes briefly. I sat down before he could give me another assignment.

When the jurors filed in, I tried to read their faces. One of the women looked at Andrew and then lowered her eyes. I decided that didn’t mean anything. People were strange about eye contact.

The foreperson stood.

There were questions, answers, the little formalities that seemed designed to make something take longer precisely when you needed it over with. Then the clerk read the number.

Six hundred fifty thousand dollars.

I looked at Andrew. He was writing it down.

The judge asked whether the verdict was unanimous. It was. At our request, the jurors were polled, and each one confirmed it individually, so we got to lose the case several more times before anybody could leave.

I coughed into my fist. Andrew put his pen away.

Dom was leaning against the wall outside with his videographer.

“Well?” he said.

I began with the distinction between the jury’s decision and our legal position. Dom interrupted.

“How much?”

“Six-fifty.”

“Thousand?”

I nodded.

He stared at me, then turned toward the camera.

“Get this.”

“Dom,” Andrew said.

But the videographer was already backing up.

Dom launched into a speech about people who couldn’t create anything trying to take from people who could. The media had made him a target. Once you reached a certain level, everybody thought they deserved a piece. He pointed toward the courtroom doors, then directly into the lens.

I stood beside him. Somebody needed to.

Andrew walked away.

By the time we reached the Escalade, Dom had watched part of the recording and ordered the videographer to cut the beginning.

“We got to have a little talk when we get back to New York,” he told me.

“Absolutely. There are things we can do.”

He ducked into the car without answering.

My phone vibrated.

Andrew: Same bar. Come over when you’re finished.

***

He had chosen the same stools. I couldn’t tell whether that was deliberate.

“I told you that you needed to talk to him,” he said.

I hadn’t even sat down.

“Can I get a drink first?”

“You had an opportunity to settle this.”

“You don’t know what they would’ve taken.”

“Because you wouldn’t find out.”

I eased onto the stool. My stomach cramped, and I rested a hand against it until the pain passed.

Andrew had a glass of water in front of him. He’d apparently decided we were approaching this from different moral elevations.

“It’s not my fault you lost the trial,” I said.

His face changed.

“I lost the trial?”

“You tried the case.”

“And you handled the client. You were supposed to get him there. You were supposed to get me the witnesses I asked for.”

“I can’t physically drag people onto a plane.”

“You could have told me they weren’t coming.”

“I thought they were.”

“Until when?”

The bartender approached. I ordered bourbon. Andrew waited until she moved away.

“I told you what I needed. You kept telling me it was handled.”

“I did everything I could.”

“No. You told everybody what they wanted to hear, and then you left me standing there.”

That was an ugly way of putting it, considering how he’d gotten involved in the first place.

“I guess I was wrong about you,” I said.

“About what?”

“I thought you knew how to win one of these.”

He looked down at his water.

“You don’t know shit,” I said.

For a moment I thought he might get up. Instead, he reached into his jacket pocket and placed something on the bar.

The gold rock.

It made a small, heavy sound against the wood.

I’d given it to him before the trial. We’d been upstairs going through the exhibits, and I’d taken it out of my bag and dropped it beside his legal pad.

Picked the right bulldog for this one, I’d told him. Little good-luck charm for my favorite Rock Boy.

He’d laughed. Picked it up, turned it over. For a few minutes we’d talked about school.

Now there was a fresh chip in the paint near the bottom.

“What’s this?”

“You tell me.”

“It was a gift.”

“All that talk about your confidence in me. That was all just bullshit?”

“Oh, come on.”

“You believed in me until believing in me cost you something.”

“I put you on this case.”

“And I worked it.”

“You think I bring just anybody around Dom?”

“There it is.”

“What?”

“The thing I’m supposed to owe you forever.”

My drink arrived. I took too much of it, and it burned all the way down.

Andrew pushed the rock closer.

“Our friendship ends when it stops being convenient. That’s what I’m finding out.”

I wanted him away from me. I was sick, I’d just had a catastrophic day, and now I was supposed to comfort the person who’d stood up in court and lost six hundred fifty thousand dollars.

“We’ll have a little talk when we get back to New York,” I said.

He gave a short laugh.

After he left, I sat with the rock beside my glass. I should have called Dom. I knew that. I should have pushed harder about the witnesses, too. There had been time, and I’d spent it telling Andrew not to worry.

I turned the rock over so the chipped side faced down.

Once we were home, I could smooth things over.

***

The rock had come from Coney Island when I was a kid. An ordinary gray stone, smooth on one side, that I’d brought home in a pocket full of sand. Years later I found it in a box, sprayed it gold, and made it the trophy for the Rock Boy Invitational.

By our third year at NYU, the tournament had become an institution, at least among the eight people I invited.

I arranged the table in my apartment, picked up the liquor, made the playlist. The bottles were better than anybody could afford. My credit card was nearly maxed, but nobody needed to know that. There was a difference between having money and making people feel they were somewhere worth being.

Andrew arrived with cash folded in his wallet and asked whether the buy-in was still what I’d said it was.

“Yes, Dad.”

“I’m asking.”

“And I’m answering.”

He smiled and took his seat.

I wore a gold chain over my shirt. Jay-Z was playing. The rock sat at the end of the table on a folded black napkin, looking considerably more valuable than it was.

Andrew was a good poker player in the way he was good at most things. He paid attention. He remembered what people had done. He could explain afterward why a decision made sense, which I always thought was a limited consolation if you’d lost.

With four of us left, he pushed his chips into the middle.

“All in.”

The guy across from him called.

Andrew turned over a good hand. The other guy turned over a better one, and a few minutes later Andrew was on my couch with a drink while I was still at the table.

That was the difference between us. He knew the percentages. I knew the people.

I let the other two go after each other. When one finally knocked the other out, I had enough chips to make the last stretch unpleasant for the survivor.

Nothing dramatic. Small bets, pressure where it belonged, a few pots I was happy to let go. By the time he pushed what remained of his stack forward, I could afford to call him.

I won.

I stood up with the rock in my hand while somebody turned the music louder.

“Rock Boy!”

They laughed. Andrew raised his glass from the couch.

For years, that was how I remembered him: smiling, toasting me, part of the whole thing. Whenever we told the story, I got to the part where he shoved his chips in, and he’d shake his head before I even finished.

“You went all in,” I’d say.

“That’s generally how you get eliminated.”

“Meanwhile, who walked away with the hardware?”

“You never actually put yourself on the line.”

“I know how to win.”

It always got a laugh.

Once, much later, he told me he’d stayed after everybody left and helped carry the table back against the wall. I didn’t remember that. I remembered the music, the bottles, the weight of the rock in my hand.

“You remember that night differently than I do,” he said.

“I remember winning.”

“Yeah,” he said. “I know.”

***

Back in New York, Dom kept me waiting forty minutes before telling me we were finished.

I had prepared several ways to explain the verdict. None of them turned out to be necessary.

“We had a run,” he said. “It’s over.”

“We’ve got options.”

“You had options before.”

“Andrew should have—”

“Andrew told you.”

I stopped.

Dom sat behind his desk, scrolling through his phone. He didn’t look angry. I would have preferred angry. Angry meant there was still something to work with.

“You weren’t there,” I said carefully. “That made it harder.”

He put the phone down.

“This was your deal to handle. It wasn’t mine.”

“I understand that.”

“Do you? Because now I’m hearing all the things I should’ve done. If I got to do everything, what do I need you for?”

There were ways to answer that. Years of calls taken, problems absorbed, things handled without him even knowing there had been a problem. I could have sat there all afternoon listing them.

“I’ve always looked out for you.”

“I can’t be looking after my lawyer, too.”

He picked up the phone again.

“What about Andrew?”

“He told you what was coming. You didn’t listen.”

“You’re going to keep him?”

“I’m going with the winning horse.”

I almost laughed. Six hundred fifty thousand dollars, and somehow Andrew was the winning horse.

Outside, I stood on the sidewalk with my coat open until somebody bumped my shoulder. Nobody appreciates what I do for them. It was a fact I kept having to learn.

Andrew’s office was within walking distance.

He let me in himself. There were files spread across his desk and a sandwich still in its wrapper beside the keyboard.

“Have a seat.”

I sat. He moved a stack of papers off the chair opposite me, then seemed to think better of sitting down.

“Did Dom send the trial money?”

So that was where we were starting.

“I just came from him.”

“Okay. Because I still haven’t been paid.”

“I’m aware.”

“I paid for the flights, Josh. The room. I took time away from other cases.”

“You said you wanted to win big cases.”

“I do.”

“You said if you didn’t come back with a win, you didn’t deserve to be paid.”

He looked at me.

“I said that when you were telling me the witnesses were coming and the client was going to cooperate.”

“So now there are qualifications.”

“There were always qualifications. You just didn’t listen to them.”

He pulled out his chair and sat down.

“I told you what was going to happen. I asked you to help me prevent it. Now I’m asking you to get me paid for the work I actually did.”

I looked at the sandwich. He had probably ordered it intending to eat at his desk, the way he always did, as though working through lunch was something to be proud of.

“I guess you were really all about the money after all,” I said. “Not about winning the big cases.”

“That’s not true, bro.”

“Well, you’re not getting your money anyway.”

The words came out harder than I’d intended.

He went still.

I couldn’t get it for him. That was the truth. Dom had fired me. I couldn’t call him and demand a check, couldn’t promise Andrew another matter, couldn’t even say when I’d be in a position to fix this. But I wasn’t going to sit there and explain all that while he looked at me like I was another problem on his desk.

“I guess you just weren’t what I thought you were,” I said. “I guess this concludes our business.”

“Our business?”

I stood.

“I thought we were friends.”

“We were.”

He leaned back, looking up at me.

“I guess I was wrong when you said we were the Rock Boys.”

“That was law school, Andrew.”

“You brought the rock to Vegas.”

I adjusted the cuff of my coat.

He waited, then nodded as though I’d answered.

“As long as you controlled the game,” he said. “As long as you could win.”

I left before we said something we couldn’t take back.

On the sidewalk, I felt worse than when I’d gone in. My stomach hurt, and I had a headache starting behind one eye. I reached into my coat for my phone and found the rock.

For a moment I held it there, inside the pocket.

We had been friends a long time. That had to count for something. But people changed. What worked when you were twenty-five didn’t necessarily work forever, and eventually you had to admit when you no longer shared the same values.

I put the rock back and opened my contacts.

There were other lawyers. Somebody would know what to do about the verdict. I could bring Dom a solution, remind him why he’d wanted me around in the first place.

I needed somebody hungry. Somebody who understood the opportunity.

Someone willing to go all in.

Posted Nov 14, 2026
Share:

You must sign up or log in to submit a comment.

10 likes 1 comment

Jane Davidson
November 18, 2026 23:58

Oof. Fake it till you make it, right? I really tried to like Josh, given he was sick and all, but some people just don't ever come through. I expect he repainted the rock after that.

Reply

Reedsy | Default — Editors with Marker | 2024-05

Bring your publishing dreams to life

The world's best editors, designers, and marketers are on Reedsy. Come meet them.